| Course | ACC 685 BAR Discipline Capstone |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 6 |
| Paper type | Supplier comparability review |
| Length | About 980 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 685 Topic 6
Choosing a Five-Year Sole Supplier: How Three Judgments in Supplier A's Notes Erase Most of Its Advantage Over Supplier B
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
ACC-685: BAR Discipline Capstone
Topic 6 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Choosing a Five-Year Sole Supplier: How Three Judgments in Supplier A's Notes Erase Most of Its Advantage Over Supplier B
The Decision and the Measures That Matter
The procurement committee of Northgate Health, a composite hospital group, must choose one supplier of surgical instruments and sterilization services for the next five years. A sole supplier that fails midway would disrupt surgery schedules across eleven hospitals, so the measures that matter most are the supplier's ability to generate cash from its own operations and its dependence on outside financing. Profitability matters, but mainly as a source of cash. Two finalists remain, and on the reported figures Supplier A looks clearly stronger.
The Reported Comparison
Three years of reported figures from each supplier's annual report are set side by side.
Table 1
Reported Figures
| Measure | Supplier A, year 1 | A, year 2 | A, year 3 | Supplier B, year 1 | B, year 2 | B, year 3 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue, $ millions | 372 | 395 | 420 | 388 | 402 | 415 |
| Operating margin | 10.1% | 10.6% | 11.2% | 9.2% | 9.0% | 8.9% |
| Days sales outstanding | 47 | 43 | 38 | 60 | 62 | 61 |
| Operating cash flow, $ millions | 39 | 44 | 52 | 30 | 31 | 33 |
Reading Supplier A's Notes
Useful lives. In year three, Supplier A lengthened the estimated useful lives of its sterilization equipment from seven to ten years. A change in estimate is applied prospectively (Financial Accounting Standards Board, 2005), and the note discloses its effect: depreciation fell by $6.3 million. Without the change, A's operating margin would have been about 9.7 percent, not 11.2. The change may be justified by the equipment's service record, but it is a judgment, not an improvement in operations, and it will not recur as a source of margin growth.
Receivables sold. A's receivables note discloses that $29 million of customer receivables had been sold to a bank without recourse at year end, $12 million more than a year earlier. The sold receivables are off A's balance sheet, which shortens its reported collection period and adds their proceeds to operating cash flow. Adding them back, A's days sales outstanding are about 63, not 38, and the $12 million increase is financing, not operating cash.
Supplier finance. A's supplier finance disclosure shows $41 million of payables in a program under which a bank pays A's vendors early and A repays the bank later, up $9 million in the year (Financial Accounting Standards Board, 2022). The growth delayed A's cash outflows by $9 million, raising operating cash flow by the same amount.
Other Items Checked and Left Alone
Not every judgment in A's notes warranted an adjustment. A's revenue recognition policy for sterilization services, recognized as services are performed, matches B's. Its inventory reserve moved in line with slow-moving stock, and its warranty reserve with claims. A also capitalized $2.1 million of software development costs in year three, but the amount is small, the policy is unchanged from prior years and B follows a similar policy, so it does not affect comparability. The review adjusts only for items that differ between the suppliers, are material to the measures that matter and are disclosed well enough to quantify. Adjusting for everything that could be debated would replace the suppliers' judgments with the reviewer's own.
The Adjusted Comparison
Adjusting A for the three items places both suppliers on a common basis.
Table 2
Adjusted Comparison
| Measure | Supplier A, reported | Supplier A, adjusted | Supplier B |
|---|---|---|---|
| Operating margin | 11.2% | 9.7% | 8.9% |
| Days sales outstanding | 38 | about 63 | 61 |
| Operating cash flow, $ millions | 52 | 31 | 33 |
Reading the Adjusted Comparison
On a common basis, Supplier A's margin is still slightly higher, but its collection period is about the same as B's, and its operating cash flow of about $31 million is slightly below B's $33 million. More important for a five-year commitment, a significant share of A's reported cash depends on a bank continuing to buy its receivables and to finance its payables. If either program were withdrawn, A would need to find about $70 million of cash quickly. A's reported advantage came largely from accounting judgments and financing arrangements, not from operations (Penman, 2013).
Questions for Both Suppliers
Before the committee decides, the same questions should go to both suppliers in writing, so the answers can be compared. What are the terms and renewal dates of any receivables sale or supplier finance program, and what would the company do if a program ended? What are the planned capital expenditures for sterilization equipment over the contract term, and how will they be funded? How concentrated is revenue among the largest customers, since the loss of one could strain a supplier that Northgate depends on? The answers will not change the figures above, but they will show how each supplier would respond to the kind of pressure a five-year contract is likely to meet at some point.
Supplier B's Notes
The same notes were read for Supplier B. Its useful lives have not changed in three years, it discloses no sale of receivables and it reports no supplier finance program. Its revenue recognition and inventory notes describe the same policies as A's. The absence of adjustments for B is therefore a finding from the notes, not an omission in the review. B's figures can be taken largely as reported.
Recommendation
The review recommends Supplier B. Its cash generation is comparable to A's on a common basis and does not depend on bank programs that could be withdrawn during the contract. Supplier A could be reconsidered if it provided three things: evidence supporting the longer equipment lives, such as service and replacement records; a commitment from its bank to maintain the receivables and supplier finance programs for the contract term; or operating cash flow, excluding program growth, that exceeds B's over the next two years. The committee should also build a financial covenant into whichever contract it signs, requiring annual delivery of audited statements with the program disclosures.
References
Financial Accounting Standards Board. (2005). Accounting changes and error corrections (Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 154). FASB.
Financial Accounting Standards Board. (2022). Liabilities, supplier finance programs (Subtopic 405-50): Disclosure of supplier finance program obligations (Accounting Standards Update No. 2022-04). FASB.
Penman, S. H. (2013). Financial statement analysis and security valuation (5th ed.). McGraw-Hill.
ACC 685 Topic 6 instructions, in plain terms
The Topic 6 instructions in ACC-685 ask students to compare companies whose accounting judgments differ. Weak submissions compare reported ratios as though the two companies used the same judgments. The assignment rewards reviews that name the decision and the measures it needs, present the reported comparison over several years and read each judgment in the notes that permits an adjustment. Students should recompute the ratios on a common basis, confirm the absence of adjustments for the other company, explain items left alone and make a recommendation with the conditions under which the rejected supplier would be reconsidered.
How this ACC 685 Topic 6 example is built
The finished review opens with the decision, a hospital group's procurement committee choosing one supplier for five years, and with the reported figures that seemed to settle it, all illustrative. Supplier A shows an 11.2 percent operating margin on $420 million of revenue, 38 days of sales outstanding and $52 million of operating cash flow; Supplier B shows 8.9 percent, 61 days and $33 million. The review then reads A's notes. A change in estimate lengthened equipment lives and cut depreciation by $6.3 million, $29 million of receivables had been sold without recourse by year end, $12 million more than a year earlier, and its supplier finance obligations grew by $9 million. Adjusted, A's margin is 9.7 percent, its collection period about 63 days and its operating cash flow $31 million. The advantage largely disappears.
Reading the ACC 685 Topic 6 rubric
Faculty grading the comparability review reward each adjustment sourced to a note. Excellent reviews treat receivables sold as financing and restore them to collection days. Credit goes to removing supplier finance growth from operating cash flow. The rubric values confirming that the other supplier's notes show no comparable items. The highest level states what the rejected supplier would need to show. Reviews that choose the supplier with the higher reported margin, or adjust for items the notes cannot quantify, usually lose marks with graders.
ACC 685 Topic 6 help before you submit
Ranking the suppliers on reported ratios loses the most, because every advantage A showed traces to a judgment or an arrangement its notes disclose. Papers that spot the useful-life change and call it manipulation go beyond the evidence, since a change in estimate can be legitimate and the review's task is comparability, not accusation. Adding back factored receivables to the collection period while leaving operating cash flow untouched adjusts one ratio and not the figure it depends on. Supplier finance is often missed entirely, although the disclosures now required make it visible. An analysis that adjusts A and never examines B's notes assumes B is clean. Recommendations that never say what would change them leave the committee holding a verdict with no way to revisit it.
Get an ACC-685 Topic 6 example written to your instructions
Send your ACC-685 Topic 6 instructions, the rubric and the statements or companies your section assigned. A custom example comes back written to them, with the decision named, reported figures tabled, each judgment traced to its note, ratios recomputed on a common basis and a recommendation defended, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More ACC 685 papers and MS in Accounting samples
- ACC 685 Topic 1: Hosting Arrangement Characterization Memo
- ACC 685 Topic 2: Retirement Obligation Sensitivity Schedule
- ACC 685 Topic 3: Principal Agent Presentation Analysis
- ACC 685 Topic 4: Going Concern Note Draft
- ACC 685 Topic 5: Lease-adjusted Debt Multiple Dq Post
- ACC 685 Topic 7: Failed Sale-leaseback Position Memo
- ACC 685 Topic 8: Earnout Integration Report
- ACC 653 Topic 6: Value Chain Linkage Analysis
- ACC 683 Topic 6: Installment Plan Stress Test
- ACC 656 Topic 6: Noncontrolling Interest Measurement Problem
- ACC 682 Topic 6: Known Trend Chart Memo
ACC 685 Topic 6 questions, answered
Is a change in useful life a red flag?
Not by itself. Useful lives are estimates, and a company that finds its equipment lasting longer should revise them prospectively, disclosing the effect when it is material. The analytic issue is comparability: a reader comparing two companies needs their depreciation on a similar basis, so the review removes the effect of the change to compare like with like and draws no conclusion about motive.
Why does factoring change operating cash flow?
When receivables are sold without recourse and derecognized, the company collects cash from the factor sooner than its customers would have paid, and those proceeds are generally presented in operating activities. Growth in the factored balance therefore raises operating cash flow for the year without any change in customer behavior. Removing the year's increase shows what collections alone would have produced.
What do supplier finance disclosures reveal?
US GAAP now requires buyers in supplier finance programs to disclose the key program terms, the amount outstanding at period end and how that amount changed during the year. Those figures show how much of a company's payables sits in a bank-facilitated program, which matters because a program can be withdrawn. The review uses A's disclosed increase to estimate how much operating cash flow the program supplied.
Where can I find a free ACC 685 Topic 6 sample paper?
The complete review appears above: the decision and measures, the reported comparison, Supplier A's notes, items left alone, the adjusted comparison, reading it, questions for both, Supplier B's notes and the recommendation. Describe your two suppliers for a free worked review.
How does Supplier A's cash flow fall in ACC 685 Topic 6?
Removing $12 million of growth in receivables sold and $9 million of supplier finance growth cuts operating cash flow from $52 million to $31 million.