ACC 685 Topic 7 failed sale-leaseback position memo example

BAR Discipline Capstone Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This ACC 685 Topic 7 sample paper concludes that a plant sale and leaseback fails as a sale. It was prepared for GCU ACC 685, BAR Discipline Capstone, catalog code ACC-685, in the Grand Canyon University MS in Accounting program. A processor sold its plant, carried at $22 million, for $40 million and leased it back for 15 years at $3.0 million a year with a year-ten repurchase option at a fixed $44 million. Under ASC 842-40, the option blocks sale accounting because its price is not fair value and no similar plants are readily available. The $40 million is a financial liability, and management's view is answered.

CourseACC 685 BAR Discipline Capstone
TopicTopic 7
Paper typeFailed sale-leaseback position memo
LengthAbout 880 words, 1 pages
FormatMemo with APA 7 references
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMS in Accounting
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for ACC 685 Topic 7

1

Memorandum

To: Chief Financial Officer, Marlow Food Processing

From: [Author Name], technical accounting

Date: [Date]

Re: Accounting for the sale and leaseback of the Fremont plant

 

Conclusion

The transfer of the Fremont plant does not qualify as a sale. The $40 million received from Ridgeway Realty Partners is a financial liability, the plant remains on Marlow's balance sheet at its $22 million carrying amount and continues to be depreciated, and no gain is recognized. The $18 million gain management expected to report this year will not appear.

The Terms

The purchase agreement transfers title to the plant to Ridgeway for $40 million in cash. The lease, signed the same day, leases the plant back to Marlow for 15 years at $3.0 million a year, fixed. Section 18 of the lease grants Marlow an option to repurchase the plant at the end of year ten for $44 million. The plant is a specialized food processing facility with refrigerated production lines built for Marlow's products; the appraisal commissioned for the transaction describes the market for comparable facilities in the region as thin.

The Analysis, in the Order the Guidance Sets

A seller-lessee accounts for the transfer as a sale only if it meets the requirements for a sale in the revenue standard, meaning control of the asset passes to the buyer (Financial Accounting Standards Board, 2016; Financial Accounting Standards Board, 2014). The steps are taken in order.

Is there a contract? Yes. The purchase agreement and lease are enforceable, approved by both parties and have commercial substance.

Would the leaseback be a finance lease? If so, control would not pass and no sale could be recognized. The 15-year term is not a major part of the plant's remaining 30-year economic life, the present value of the payments is below substantially all of the plant's fair value, and there is no transfer of ownership at the end. The leaseback would be an operating lease, so this test does not by itself prevent a sale.

Does the repurchase option prevent control from passing? An option for the seller-lessee to repurchase the asset precludes sale accounting unless two conditions are both met: the exercise price is the asset's fair value at the time of exercise, and alternative assets substantially the same as the transferred asset are readily available in the marketplace. The exercise price is a fixed $44 million, not fair value at exercise. And a specialized processing plant in a thin market has no readily available substitutes. Neither condition is met. Because Marlow can take the plant back at a fixed price, Ridgeway cannot direct its use and obtain substantially all its benefits, and control has not passed.

Management's View at Full Strength

Management's position is that the transaction is a sale because Marlow has no intention of exercising the option, which it describes as a formality included at Ridgeway's suggestion, and because the option price exceeds the sale price, making exercise unattractive. The intention is sincere, and a price above the sale price does reduce the option's value. But the guidance turns on the option's terms, not on management's intention, since intentions can change and the option gives Marlow a right it can exercise if the plant becomes more valuable. A fixed price below the plant's future value would make exercise attractive, and no one can know today what the plant will be worth in ten years. The option's existence, on these terms, is decisive.

Accounting for the Failed Sale

The transaction is accounted for as a financing. Marlow keeps the plant at $22 million and continues depreciating it over its remaining 20-year useful life, about $1.1 million a year. The $40 million received is a financial liability. The effective interest rate on the liability, computed so the payments and the $44 million repurchase price at year ten equal the $40 million received, is about 8.2 percent. Each year's $3.0 million payment is less than the interest on the liability, about $3.27 million in year one, so the liability grows toward $44 million over ten years. If the option is not exercised, the liability is adjusted so that no gain arises before the lease ends.

The Two Presentations Compared

The failed sale changes both statements; operating cash flow also differs, because payments on a financing obligation are split between interest and principal.

Table 1

Balance Sheet and Income Statement Effects

As a sale, management's viewAs a financing
Plant on the balance sheetRemoved; right-of-use asset recognized$22 million, still depreciated
LiabilityOperating lease liabilityFinancial liability of $40 million
Gain this year$18 millionNone
Annual expenseLease cost of $3.0 millionDepreciation of about $1.1 million plus interest of about $3.3 million

Draft Disclosure

"In March, the Company transferred its Fremont plant to a third party for $40 million and leased it back for 15 years, with an option to repurchase the plant in year ten for $44 million. Because of the repurchase option, the transfer did not qualify as a sale, and the Company accounts for the transaction as a financing. The plant remains in property, plant and equipment, and the proceeds are presented as a financing obligation, which accrues interest at an effective rate of approximately 8.2 percent." Readers comparing Marlow with companies that completed ordinary sale-leasebacks can use this disclosure to see the difference in structure (Penman, 2013).

References

Financial Accounting Standards Board. (2014). Revenue from contracts with customers (Topic 606) (Accounting Standards Update No. 2014-09). FASB.

Financial Accounting Standards Board. (2016). Leases (Topic 842) (Accounting Standards Update No. 2016-02). FASB.

Penman, S. H. (2013). Financial statement analysis and security valuation (5th ed.). McGraw-Hill.

The ACC-685 Topic 7 assignment instructions

ACC-685 Topic 7 asks students to apply sale-leaseback guidance to a contested transaction. Many papers accept management's intention. The assignment rewards memos that state the conclusion first, quote the contract terms that decide it, and take the guidance's steps in order: contract, leaseback classification and repurchase option. Students should argue management's view at full strength and answer it, account for the failed sale with the asset kept and a financial liability recognized, compare both presentations and draft the disclosure.

How the ACC-685 Topic 7 example is put together

The memo's first line gives the conclusion: the transfer fails as a sale, so the $40 million received is a financial liability and no gain is recognized. Amounts are illustrative. The processor sold its plant, carried at $22 million, to a real estate investor for $40 million and leased it back for 15 years at $3.0 million a year, keeping an option to repurchase in year ten for $44 million. The memo then walks ASC 842-40 in order. Sale accounting needs control to pass under ASC 606, and a repurchase option blocks that unless the price is fair value at exercise and substantially similar assets are readily available. Neither condition holds for a fixed price on a specialized plant. Management's reading, a sale because the option will never be exercised, is stated in full and answered.

Reading the ACC 685 Topic 7 rubric

Faculty grading the sale-leaseback memo reward the steps taken in the guidance's order. Excellent memos test both conditions that could let a repurchase option coexist with a sale. Credit goes to keeping the plant depreciated and computing an effective rate on the liability. The rubric values answering management's intention with the option's terms. The highest level shows both statements side by side and drafts the disclosure. Memos that recognize the gain because exercise is unlikely, or remove the plant from the balance sheet, usually land in a middle band.

Common ACC 685 Topic 7 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Memos that announce a failed sale and stop lose the most, since the conclusion is worth little until each requirement has been matched to the clause that meets or fails it. The opposite weakness is a memo recognizing the $18 million gain because the option is unlikely to be exercised, applying a probability test the guidance does not contain for repurchase options. Papers that skip the finance lease question leave one route to the same conclusion unexamined. Treating the failed sale as a sale with a note attached, keeping the gain and disclosing the option, misstates the balance sheet and reported income alike. Some memos derecognize the plant in the failed case, removing an asset the processor still controls. Marks also go when the alternative is never stated, since a reviewer cannot tell whether it was considered.

Get an ACC-685 Topic 7 example written to your instructions

Send the ACC-685 Topic 7 instructions, your rubric and the transaction or technical accounting prompt your section assigned. We write a custom example to them, with the conclusion stated first, each requirement walked against the facts, the rejected alternative argued fairly, the accounting recorded and both presentations compared, returned in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More ACC 685 papers and MS in Accounting samples

ACC 685 Topic 7 questions, answered

Why does a repurchase option prevent a sale?

Because a seller that can buy the asset back has not given the buyer the ability to direct its use and obtain substantially all its remaining benefits, which is what control means under ASC 606. ASC 842-40 allows sale accounting despite a repurchase option only when the exercise price is the asset's fair value at exercise and alternative assets that are substantially the same are readily available in the marketplace.

Why does the processor's intention matter for one test and not the other?

Lease classification asks whether the lessee is reasonably certain to exercise a purchase option, so intention and economic incentive are evidence there. The sale test asks whether the seller holds a repurchase right at all, and the guidance does not weigh how likely exercise is. The memo keeps the two questions apart because management's argument depends on blending them.

Where can I find a free ACC 685 Topic 7 sample paper?

Every part is above: the conclusion, the terms, the analysis in order, management's view, accounting for the failed sale, both presentations and the draft disclosure. Send your transaction documents for a free worked memo.

Why does the repurchase option block a sale in ACC 685 Topic 7?

Its fixed $44 million price is not fair value at exercise and no similar plants are readily available, so control does not pass to the buyer.

How is the failed sale shown on the balance sheet in ACC 685 Topic 7?

The plant stays at $22 million and is still depreciated, and the $40 million received is a financial liability that accretes toward the $44 million option price.