| Course | BUS 317 Financial Decision Making |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 5 |
| Paper type | Relevant cost discussion post |
| Length | About 400 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Discussion post, APA 7 citations |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Business Management |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for BUS 317 Topic 5
Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post and Reply
Keep the Assembly Service: The Report Shows a $5,000 Loss, but Dropping It Would Cut Store Profit by About $32,000
Initial Post
My position: keep the furniture assembly service, because dropping it would lower the store's total profit.
The service's own report shows revenue of $90,000 against costs of $95,000, a $5,000 loss. But the question is not whether the service's report shows a profit; it is what happens to the store's profit if the service ends. That means sorting the costs by whether they would disappear (Garrison et al., 2021).
Costs that disappear: technician wages of $54,000, van fuel of $6,000 and parts of $4,000. If the service ends, all $64,000 stops. Against $90,000 of revenue, the service contributes $26,000 to the store.
Costs that do not disappear: the $28,000 of store rent and administration charged to the service. The store pays its rent and its office manager whether or not it offers assembly; the charge would simply move to other departments. It does not belong in the comparison. The $3,000 of depreciation on the tool kit bought last year is also out: the money was spent last year and cannot be recovered by stopping now. It is a sunk cost.
Two effects outside the service's report also matter. Store staff estimate that about $40,000 of furniture sales a year come from customers who buy partly because assembly is offered; at the store's 35 percent margin, that is about $14,000 of profit at risk. On the other side, if the service ended, the van and one technician's time could run deliveries the store now pays a courier about $8,000 a year to make. Net of that, keeping the service adds about $32,000 a year to store profit.
The furniture link is an estimate, and it is the figure I would test first, perhaps by asking customers at checkout. But even if it were zero, the service would still add $18,000.
Reply to Jordan
Jordan, you counted the $28,000 of allocated overhead and concluded the service loses money. The allocation is useful for knowing what the service would need to earn to carry its share of the building over time, but the building costs the same if assembly stops, so the store would lose the $26,000 contribution and still pay the $28,000. Would the allocation change if the store rented out the space the service uses (Datar & Rajan, 2021)?
References
Datar, S. M., & Rajan, M. V. (2021). Horngren's cost accounting: A managerial emphasis (17th ed.). Pearson.
Garrison, R. H., Noreen, E. W., & Brewer, P. C. (2021). Managerial accounting (17th ed.). McGraw Hill.
What the BUS 317 Topic 5 instructions ask for
BUS-317 Topic 5 asks students to discuss relevant costs in a keep-or-drop decision. Many posts accept a department report's loss. Posts that score well state a position, sort each cost by whether it would disappear, remove allocated costs that continue and name sunk costs explicitly. Students should consider effects outside the department's own report, such as linked sales and alternative uses of resources, quantify them where possible, note which estimate matters most and reply to a classmate by explaining why an allocation does not change the decision.
How the BUS-317 Topic 5 example is put together
The finished post leads with a position: keep the service, because dropping it would lower total profit. The sorting follows. Technician wages, van fuel and parts disappear if the service ends, so they count. The share of store rent and administration charged to the service does not disappear, since the store pays it regardless, and the post removes it from the comparison with a sentence explaining why. The tool kit bought last year is named as sunk. Two effects outside the service's own report are then raised: customers who buy furniture partly because assembly is offered, and the van time that could otherwise run deliveries. A reply to a classmate who counted the allocated overhead follows, showing courteously how the conclusion reverses once it is removed.
Reading the BUS 317 Topic 5 rubric
GCU's rubric for this discussion rewards costs sorted by what the decision changes. Excellent posts remove allocated rent and name the tool kit as sunk with a sentence of reasoning each. Credit goes to counting linked furniture sales and the alternative use of the van. The rubric values identifying which estimate to test first and showing the answer holds without it. The strongest replies explain what an overhead allocation is useful for and why it does not apply here. Posts that drop the service on the report's loss, or leave the sunk tool kit in the comparison, usually land in a middle band.
BUS 317 Topic 5 help before you submit
Allocated overhead is the trap in this discussion, and posts that count it recommend dropping a service that is contributing toward costs the store will carry anyway. Counting last year's equipment purchase repeats the mistake from the other direction, weighing money that no present choice can recover. A post that states the principle correctly and never applies it to the case figures demonstrates reading without analysis. Ignoring the furniture sales linked to assembly treats the service as independent when the case suggests it is not, and that omission can change the verdict. Opportunity costs are missed often, since no invoice ever records them. Replies that only agree with a classmate add nothing to the thread, and faculty tend to read them as participation without engagement.
Get a BUS-317 Topic 5 example written to your instructions
Send the BUS-317 Topic 5 discussion question and the rubric from your classroom, with the case or scenario your section is using. We write a custom example to those instructions and that rubric, with every cost marked avoidable, continuing or sunk, linked effects raised and a peer reply that recalculates, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More BUS 317 papers and BS in Business Management samples
- BUS 317 Topic 1: Financial Statement Limits Paper
- BUS 317 Topic 2: Statement Reading Memo
- BUS 317 Topic 3: Cost Behavior Impact Memo
- BUS 317 Topic 4: Break-even Sensitivity Analysis
- BUS 317 Topic 6: Budget Commitment Review
- BUS 317 Topic 7: Investment Timing Comparison
- BUS 317 Topic 8: Funding Request Memo
- BUS 332 Topic 5: Loyalty Program Dq Response
- MGT 475 Topic 5: Recommendation Ownership Dq Post
- BUS 340 Topic 5: Law and Ethics Divergence Dq
- MGT 470 Topic 5: Local Legitimacy Dq Post
BUS 317 Topic 5 questions, answered
Is allocated overhead ever relevant to a keep or drop decision?
Only the part that would actually disappear. If closing the service lets the store sublet the space or cut an administrative role, those savings are avoidable and belong in the comparison. The allocation itself is a bookkeeping share of costs the business keeps paying, and removing a service simply spreads that share across whatever remains. The test is whether total spending would fall.
What counts as an opportunity cost in this discussion?
The value of the best alternative use the resources would have if the service ended. Here that is chiefly the van and technician time, which could run paid deliveries. Nobody records an opportunity cost in the accounts, which is why posts leave it out, and it is legitimately part of what keeping the service costs the business.
Why do non-financial effects belong in a cost post?
Because the service does not operate alone. If some customers choose this retailer because assembly is available, dropping it risks furniture sales that never appear in the service's own figures. The post estimates that effect where the case allows and names it as a risk where it does not. A decision resting only on the service's report assumes an independence the business may not have.
Where can I find a free BUS 317 Topic 5 sample paper?
The discussion post and its reply to Jordan both appear above, covering the position, costs that disappear, costs that stay, sunk costs and effects outside the report. Share the keep-or-drop question you were given and a worked sample post comes back free.
Why keep a service that shows a loss in BUS 317 Topic 5?
Its avoidable costs are $64,000 against $90,000 of revenue, and the $28,000 of allocated overhead continues whether or not the service does.