| Course | BUS 317 Financial Decision Making |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 7 |
| Paper type | Investment timing comparison |
| Length | About 970 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Business Management |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for BUS 317 Topic 7
Two Upgrades That Each Save $120,000: Why Timing Makes One Worth $103,100 Today and the Other $98,500
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
BUS-317: Financial Decision Making
Topic 7 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Two Upgrades That Each Save $120,000: Why Timing Makes One Worth $103,100 Today and the Other $98,500
The Puzzle
Keystone Print Works, a composite commercial printer, has budget for one of two upgrades, each costing $100,000. Option A replaces the drying units on the main press and is expected to save $40,000 a year in energy and spoilage for three years. Option B installs automated plate handling, which the vendor expects to save $10,000 in the first year, while staff learn the new process, then $30,000, then $80,000 once it is fully settled. Both save $120,000 over three years, and a simple sum says they are equal. The production manager asked whether it matters which one the company chooses.
Why Timing Matters
It matters, because a dollar saved next year is worth more than a dollar saved in three years. A dollar received sooner can be used sooner, to pay down debt, fund other projects or earn a return, and a dollar promised later carries more uncertainty (Brealey et al., 2020). To compare savings that arrive at different times, each year's savings are converted to their value today by discounting at the company's required rate of return. The finance team sets that rate at 8 percent, reflecting what Keystone pays to borrow and what it expects to earn on other uses of its money.
Where the 8 Percent Comes From
The discount rate is not arbitrary. Keystone borrows from its bank at about 6.5 percent and has other uses for cash, such as paying down that loan early or buying stock ahead of price increases, that return more than that. The finance team adds a small allowance for the ordinary uncertainty of equipment savings estimates and arrives at 8 percent. A different rate would change the figures but, as shown below, not the ranking. What matters for the decision is that the same rate is applied to both options, so they are compared on the same terms.
The Calculation
Each year's savings are multiplied by a discount factor, 1 divided by 1.08 raised to the number of years, and the results added.
Table 1
Present Value of Each Option's Savings
| Year | Option A savings | Discount factor at 8% | Present value | Option B savings | Present value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $40,000 | 0.9259 | $37,037 | $10,000 | $9,259 |
| 2 | $40,000 | 0.8573 | $34,294 | $30,000 | $25,720 |
| 3 | $40,000 | 0.7938 | $31,753 | $80,000 | $63,507 |
| Total | $120,000 | $103,084 | $120,000 | $98,486 |
Reading the Result
Option A's savings are worth about $103,084 today, more than its $100,000 cost, so it adds about $3,100 of value. Option B's are worth about $98,486, less than its cost, so on these figures it would lose about $1,500 of value. The reason is visible in the table: B's largest saving, $80,000, arrives in year three, when each dollar is worth only about 79 cents today, while A's savings arrive evenly, starting next year. Equal totals hide a real difference in value (Garrison et al., 2021).
What the Simple Sum Gets Right
The simple sum is not useless. It correctly shows that both upgrades save more than they cost in total, and that neither is a bad idea in principle. What it cannot show is how long the company waits for its money. For projects whose savings arrive evenly and quickly, the sum and the present value tell similar stories. For projects whose benefits are back-loaded, as Option B's are, the sum overstates their value, and the longer the wait, the larger the overstatement.
Other Measures Point the Same Way
Two other common measures agree. Option A recovers its cost in two and a half years; Option B takes about two and three-quarter years. The return each option earns on its $100,000, the discount rate at which its savings would exactly equal its cost, is about 9.7 percent for A and 7.4 percent for B. Only A clears the 8 percent the company requires. The ranking also holds across a range of rates: at 5 percent both options are worth more than their cost but A still leads, and at 12 percent both fall short, with A closer to breaking even.
Explaining It Without Formulas
For the production manager, the result can be put in one sentence: if Keystone chose Option B, it would wait longer for most of its savings, and money that arrives later is worth less because the company could have used it in the meantime. Another way to see it: if Keystone chose A and put each year's $40,000 toward its bank loan, it would save interest from the first year; with B, most of that benefit would not begin until the third year.
The Second Concern: Risk
The production manager raised a second point: the savings promised for Option B's third year are less certain than Option A's steady savings. That is true for two reasons. B's savings depend on staff mastering a new process, and the vendor's estimate of $80,000 in year three is based on other printers' experience, not Keystone's. A's savings come from replacing worn drying units, a change whose effect on energy use can be measured from the old units' meters. If B's third-year savings were $65,000 rather than $80,000, its present value would fall to about $86,600. B therefore carries more risk as well as less value, and a cautious manager would demand a higher rate of return for it, which would only widen the gap (Datar & Rajan, 2021).
Recommendation
Choose Option A. It is worth more today at the company's required rate, pays back sooner and rests on savings that are easier to verify. Option B may be worth reconsidering in two years, when Keystone has more experience with automation and the vendor can offer references from printers of similar size, or if the vendor offers a price reduction of more than about $1,500, which would bring its value to break-even at 8 percent.
References
Brealey, R. A., Myers, S. C., & Marcus, A. J. (2020). Fundamentals of corporate finance (10th ed.). McGraw Hill.
Datar, S. M., & Rajan, M. V. (2021). Horngren's cost accounting: A managerial emphasis (17th ed.). Pearson.
Garrison, R. H., Noreen, E. W., & Brewer, P. C. (2021). Managerial accounting (17th ed.). McGraw Hill.
BUS 317 Topic 7 instructions, in plain terms
BUS-317 Topic 7 asks students to compare investments using the time value of money. Many papers simply add up the savings and call options with equal totals equivalent. The assignment rewards comparisons that explain why timing matters, state where the discount rate comes from and show the present value of each year's savings in a table. Students should confirm the ranking with other measures such as payback and rate of return, test whether it holds across discount rates, address the extra risk of savings that arrive later and explain the result to a non-specialist manager without formulas.
How the BUS-317 Topic 7 example is put together
The finished comparison opens with the puzzle that makes timing matter. In labeled illustrative figures, each upgrade costs 100,000 and saves 120,000 in total over three years, so a simple sum calls them equal. Option A saves 40,000 every year; Option B saves 10,000, then 30,000, then 80,000 as a new process settles. Discounted at the 8 percent rate the finance team supplies, A is worth about 103,100 today and clears its cost, while B is worth about 98,500 and falls short. The example explains the reversal in plain terms and adds the manager's second concern: savings promised for year three are less certain than savings arriving next year, so B carries more risk as well as less value.
BUS 317 Topic 7 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Faculty grading the timing comparison reward present values shown year by year. Excellent comparisons explain in plain terms why equal totals hide a real difference in value. Credit goes to checking that the ranking holds at other discount rates. The rubric values treating back-loaded savings as riskier as well as less valuable, with a lower-savings case priced. The highest level explains the result in one plain sentence for the production manager. Comparisons that call the options equal because their totals match, or that use an unexplained rate, usually land in a middle band.
BUS 317 Topic 7 help: mistakes that cost marks
Adding up the savings and stopping is the most expensive slip in this topic, because it declares two options equal when their timing makes them anything but. A rate chosen by the writer with no source attached draws the next deduction, since the conclusion moves with the rate and a reader needs to know whose number it is. Papers that discount correctly and never say which option to pick have done the finance and skipped the management. Ignoring the lower certainty of distant savings treats a forecast for year three as though it were as solid as next year. Relying on payback alone misses savings that arrive after recovery. Explanations written only in formulas lose the audience the course has in mind, a manager who has to repeat the argument to others.
Get a BUS-317 Topic 7 example written to your instructions
Send the BUS-317 Topic 7 instructions and the rubric listed in your classroom, with the options or case figures your section provided. We write a custom example to those instructions and that rubric, with each option's savings placed on a timeline, the discount rate attributed, the ranking explained in plain words and a recommendation made, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More BUS 317 papers and BS in Business Management samples
- BUS 317 Topic 1: Financial Statement Limits Paper
- BUS 317 Topic 2: Statement Reading Memo
- BUS 317 Topic 3: Cost Behavior Impact Memo
- BUS 317 Topic 4: Break-even Sensitivity Analysis
- BUS 317 Topic 5: Relevant Cost Dq Post
- BUS 317 Topic 6: Budget Commitment Review
- BUS 317 Topic 8: Funding Request Memo
- BUS 332 Topic 7: Engagement Measurement Proposal
- MGT 475 Topic 7: Hris Implementation Evaluation
- BUS 340 Topic 7: Permitted Conduct Decision Paper
- MGT 470 Topic 7: Two Country Incentive Redesign
BUS 317 Topic 7 questions, answered
Why does timing change the answer when the totals are equal?
Because money received sooner can be used sooner, whether to pay down a loan, fund another project or simply earn interest. A saving of 40,000 next year is therefore worth more today than the same amount three years out. When two options return the same total, the one returning it earlier creates more value, and discounting is the arithmetic that measures how much more.
Where does a manager get the discount rate?
Usually from the finance function, which sets a required return for projects of normal risk. A manager is not expected to derive it, and the example does not try. What the manager should do is ask whether the project is riskier than the business's usual work, because a riskier proposal deserves a higher rate, and state in the paper which rate was used.
What does payback add to the comparison?
A sense of how long the money is exposed, which matters when cash is tight. Option A recovers its cost in about two and a half years and Option B in nearly three, and a manager short of cash would weigh that gap. Payback says nothing about when savings arrive inside that period or what follows it, so the example reports it as context and decides on discounted value.
Where can I find a free BUS 317 Topic 7 sample paper?
Every part is above: the puzzle, why timing matters, where the rate comes from, the calculation, reading the result, what the simple sum gets right, other measures, the second concern, the plain explanation and the recommendation. Send your two options for a free worked comparison.
Why is Option A worth more in BUS 317 Topic 7?
Its savings arrive evenly from year one, while most of Option B's arrive in year three, when each dollar is worth only about 79 cents today.