BUS 332 Topic 1 retention economics comparison example

Customer Engagement Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This BUS 332 Topic 1 sample paper compares what it costs an internet provider to win a subscriber with what it costs to keep one. It was written for GCU BUS 332, Customer Engagement, catalog code BUS-332, in the Grand Canyon University BS in Business Management. Winning a subscriber costs about $300 and each contributes $25 a month, so payback takes a year; a save attempt costs about $60 and succeeds 40 percent of the time. With 2 percent monthly churn, half of acquisition spending replaces lost customers. Declining the popular multiple, the paper derives this business's own ratio, about 2.9 to 1, and names a test to confirm it.

CourseBUS 332 Customer Engagement
TopicTopic 1
Paper typeRetention economics comparison
LengthAbout 990 words, 2 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramBS in Business Management
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for BUS 332 Topic 1

1

Winning Versus Keeping a Subscriber: A $300 Acquisition, a $60 Save and the Ratio This Internet Provider Can Actually Defend

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

BUS-332: Customer Engagement

Topic 1 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the two costs the comparison sets against each other and its refusal to borrow a generic multiple. The provider and figures are illustrative composites; the sources are real.
2

Winning Versus Keeping a Subscriber: A $300 Acquisition, a $60 Save and the Ratio This Internet Provider Can Actually Defend

The Provider's Numbers

Lakeview Fiber, a composite regional internet provider with 50,000 subscribers, spends heavily to win new customers. Counting promotional pricing, free installation and advertising, winning one subscriber costs about $300. Each subscriber contributes a margin of about $25 a month after network and support costs. A new subscriber therefore repays the cost of acquisition only after twelve months; anyone who leaves before then was a loss to the company. The figures used here are illustrative but built from the kind of records any provider holds: marketing budgets, installation logs and billing data.

What It Costs to Keep One

When a subscriber calls to cancel, or when the provider's systems flag an account as at risk, Lakeview's retention team can offer a service visit to fix a speed problem and a modest bill credit. Including the technician's time and the credit, a save attempt costs about $60. Not every attempt succeeds; over the last year, about 40 percent of subscribers who received the offer stayed at least another year. The cost of each subscriber actually kept is therefore about $60 divided by 0.4, or $150.

How the Figures Were Built

Each figure comes from a record the provider already keeps. The $300 acquisition cost divides last year's marketing spending, installation labor and the revenue given up on promotional pricing by the number of new subscribers. The $25 monthly margin takes average revenue per subscriber and subtracts the network, support and billing costs that vary with the number of subscribers, leaving out head-office costs that would not change if one more customer joined. The $60 save cost adds the technician's time for a service visit to the average credit offered. Building the figures this way lets a manager check each one and see how the comparison would change if any of them were wrong.

Churn and What Acquisition Spending Really Buys

Lakeview loses about 2 percent of its subscribers each month, about 1,000 customers. It wins about 2,000 new subscribers a month, spending about $600,000. Half of that spending, about $300,000 a month, does nothing more than replace customers who walked out. Only the other half grows the business. Seen this way, some of Lakeview's acquisition budget is really a cost of churn, paid to stand still. Every subscriber kept is one the marketing team does not have to replace (Reichheld & Sasser, 1990).

Not Borrowing the Popular Multiple

Managers often hear that acquiring a customer costs five to twenty-five times as much as keeping one. Figures like that circulate widely, but they come from other industries, other decades and other definitions of cost, and a manager who repeats them cannot say what they mean for this business. The only defensible ratio is the one derived from Lakeview's own records.

The Ratio for This Business

On the surface, the ratio is $300 against $60, five to one. But both figures need the same adjustment for outcomes. Not every new subscriber stays long enough to repay acquisition: about 30 percent of new customers leave within their first year, often when promotional pricing ends. The cost of acquiring a subscriber who stays past the twelve-month payback is therefore about $300 divided by 0.7, or $429. The cost of a subscriber kept through a save attempt, as shown above, is about $150.

Table 1

Acquisition and Retention on the Same Basis

AcquisitionRetention save
Direct cost$300$60
Success rate70% stay past one year40% stay another year
Cost per lasting customer$429$150
Ratio2.9 to 1

Compared on the same basis, winning a lasting subscriber costs about 2.9 times as much as keeping one. That is far below the popular multiple, but it is Lakeview's own figure, built from its records, and it still says clearly that a dollar spent keeping a wavering subscriber goes further than a dollar spent winning a new one.

What the Comparison Implies

The comparison does not mean Lakeview should stop acquiring customers; a provider that only retained would shrink as customers moved away or switched for reasons no offer can address. It means the balance between the two budgets is worth revisiting. Three implications follow. First, the retention team is probably underfunded relative to marketing: each additional successful save is worth about $279 of acquisition spending avoided. Second, the high first-year churn among new subscribers suggests that some acquisition spending buys customers who were never likely to stay, and the promotional offers that attract them deserve scrutiny. Third, because customer value depends on how long customers stay, retention improvements raise the value of every customer the company acquires (Gupta et al., 2004; Kotler & Keller, 2016).

Limits of the Comparison

Two limits should be stated. The 40 percent save rate may overstate what retention achieves, because some subscribers who accepted a credit would have stayed anyway; a small test in which some at-risk subscribers receive no offer would show how many saves are real. And the costs used here are averages; the cost of acquiring a subscriber in a new neighborhood, where the network has just been built, may be quite different from the average. Both limits argue for refining the figures, not for abandoning them in favor of a borrowed multiple.

A Test Worth Running

The most useful next step is a controlled test. For three months, Lakeview could flag at-risk subscribers as it does now but randomly withhold the save offer from one in five of them. Comparing cancellation rates between the two groups would show how many saves the offer truly produces, rather than how many subscribers who received it happened to stay. If the true save rate proved lower than 40 percent, the cost per kept customer would rise and the ratio would narrow; if it held, the case for shifting budget toward retention would be much stronger. Either way, the provider would be deciding on its own evidence rather than a slogan.

References

Gupta, S., Lehmann, D. R., & Stuart, J. A. (2004). Valuing customers. Journal of Marketing Research, 41(1), 7-18. https://doi.org/10.1509/jmkr.41.1.7.25084

Kotler, P., & Keller, K. L. (2016). Marketing management (15th ed.). Pearson.

Reichheld, F. F., & Sasser, W. E., Jr. (1990). Zero defections: Quality comes to services. Harvard Business Review, 68(5), 105-111.

BUS 332 Topic 1 instructions, in plain terms

BUS-332 opens with Topic 1, where students compare the economics of acquiring and retaining customers. Many papers quote a general multiple from another industry. The assignment rewards comparisons built from the case company's own figures, stating how each was derived, and setting acquisition cost, margin, payback and the cost of a retention save side by side. Students should show how churn turns part of acquisition spending into replacement, put both costs on the same basis by adjusting for success rates, derive a ratio the manager could defend, state what the comparison implies for budgets and name its limits and how to test them.

How this BUS 332 Topic 1 example is built

The finished comparison works in the provider's own numbers, labeled as illustrative. Winning a subscriber costs about 300 once promotions, installation and advertising are counted, and each subscriber contributes a margin of 25 a month, so a new customer only repays the cost of acquiring them after a year. Anyone who leaves before then was a loss. Keeping a wavering subscriber through a service call and a modest credit costs closer to 60. The example sets these against each other and against the provider's churn, showing that acquisition spending partly just replaces customers who walked out. It declines to repeat the popular multiple comparing the two costs, and instead derives the ratio for this business, which is the only version a manager could defend.

Where the marks sit in the BUS 332 Topic 1 rubric

Faculty grading the retention comparison reward figures a manager could check line by line. Excellent comparisons compute payback in months and show that part of acquisition spending only replaces customers who left. Credit goes to adjusting both costs for their success rates before forming a ratio, rather than dividing one list price by another. The rubric values declining a borrowed multiple with a stated reason. The highest level proposes a controlled test to confirm the save rate and explains how the result would change the ratio. Comparisons that repeat the five-to-twenty-five multiple usually lose marks with graders.

BUS 332 Topic 1 help: mistakes that cost marks

Borrowed statistics are the quickest way to lose credit here: a paper asserting that acquisition costs some fixed multiple of retention, with no source and no connection to the case, rests its argument on folklore. Leaving installation or promotional credits out of acquisition cost understates it and tilts the central comparison in acquisition's favor. Treating revenue as though it were margin inflates the value of every customer on both sides of the ledger. A comparison with no payback period misses why early departures are so expensive. Papers arguing for abandoning acquisition entirely overlook that every base loses customers and must replace some. Ignoring churn leaves acquisition spending looking like growth when much of it only refills the base.

Get a BUS-332 Topic 1 example written to your instructions

Send the BUS-332 Topic 1 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with the company or data your section assigned. We write a custom example to those instructions and that rubric, with acquisition and retention costs built from the case, payback in months, churn converted into replacement demand and the ratio derived instead of quoted, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More BUS 332 papers and BS in Business Management samples

BUS 332 Topic 1 questions, answered

Is keeping a customer always cheaper than finding a new one?

Usually, not always. Keeping one is cheaper in most subscription and repeat-purchase businesses because the acquisition cost has already been paid and the relationship requires less persuasion. It can run the other way where customers are cheap to win and expensive to serve, or where a customer is unprofitable. The example computes the comparison for its own case instead of assuming the answer.

Why does payback period matter in retention economics?

Because a customer who leaves before repaying their acquisition cost was a loss, however pleasant the relationship. In the illustrative case, a subscriber must stay a full year before the provider recovers what it spent winning them. That makes early departures disproportionately expensive and explains why the first months of a relationship deserve more attention than a flat average churn figure suggests.

Should a business stop spending on acquisition?

No. Every customer base loses members to relocation, changing needs and competitors, so some acquisition is needed simply to hold steady. The argument is about balance: many businesses spend most of their budget winning customers and comparatively little keeping them, and the comparison shows where the next dollar would earn more. That usually shifts spending toward retention without eliminating acquisition.

Where can I find a free BUS 332 Topic 1 sample paper?

The whole paper is above: the provider's numbers, how the figures were built, what it costs to keep one, churn and acquisition, the borrowed multiple, the ratio for this business, implications, limits and a test worth running. Share your company's customer data for a free worked paper.

What ratio does the provider derive in BUS 332 Topic 1?

About 2.9 to 1: a lasting new subscriber costs about $429 after first-year churn, and a kept subscriber about $150 after the save rate.