| Course | BUS 332 Customer Engagement |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 6 |
| Paper type | Service recovery evaluation |
| Length | About 960 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Business Management |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for BUS 332 Topic 6
Evaluating the Recovery From an Overnight Outage: A Credit for Everyone, a Call for Some, and What Cancellations Say About Each
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
BUS-332: Customer Engagement
Topic 6 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Evaluating the Recovery From an Overnight Outage: A Credit for Everyone, a Call for Some, and What Cancellations Say About Each
What Happened
On a Tuesday night in February, a fiber cut left 8,000 customers of Northshore Broadband, a composite internet provider, without service for eight hours, from late evening until the next morning. At 8 a.m. every affected customer received a text message explaining the cause and confirming service was restored. Two days later, each account received a $10 credit, about a week's service. The customer care team also began calling affected customers, with a manager speaking to each one to apologize and answer questions. The calls ran out before the list did: in the two days set aside, managers reached about 3,000 customers. The other 5,000 received only the text and the credit.
The Comparison Available
Because only some customers received a call, the company can compare cancellations between those who were called and those who were not. The comparison is imperfect. The calling list was worked in order of account age, oldest first, so the called group is made up of longer-standing customers, who cancel less often anyway. Any difference between the groups mixes the effect of the call with the effect of tenure. To reduce that problem, cancellations in both groups are compared with those of unaffected customers of similar tenure over the same period.
Table 1
Cancellations After the Outage
| Group | Customers | Cancellations within three months | Rate | Unaffected customers of similar tenure |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Called by a manager | 3,000 | 63 | 2.1% | 1.8% |
| Text and credit only | 5,000 | 170 | 3.4% | 2.4% |
Reading the Comparison
Measured against similar unaffected customers, the outage raised cancellations by about 0.3 percentage points among customers who received a call, and by about 1.0 point among those who received only the text and credit. Some of the difference between the groups remains unexplained by tenure, but the pattern suggests the call reduced the outage's effect on cancellations by roughly two-thirds. Applied to the 5,000 customers who were not called, a call might have saved about 35 accounts, worth more in lifetime margin than the cost of the managers' time, as the cost section below shows.
What the Recovery Cost and Returned
The credit cost $80,000: $10 for each of 8,000 accounts. The calls took about six minutes each, so the 3,000 completed calls used about 300 manager hours, roughly $15,000 at a loaded rate of $50 an hour. On the estimate above, the calls kept about 21 customers who would otherwise have left, and each Northshore customer is worth about $1,200 in lifetime margin, so the calls returned about $25,000. Calling the other 5,000 would have cost about $25,000 more and might have kept about 35 more customers, worth about $42,000. The credit's return cannot be measured from these data, since everyone received it, but its cost was more than three times that of the calls.
Through the Lens of Perceived Justice
Service recovery research describes three kinds of fairness that shape how customers rate a recovery: the outcome they receive, the process by which it is delivered and the way they are treated by the people involved (Tax et al., 1998). The evaluation takes each in turn.
Outcome. The $10 credit was modest but proportionate to an overnight outage, and it went to everyone. Customers who canceled rarely mentioned the credit in exit surveys, which suggests it neither offended nor impressed.
Process. The morning text was prompt and explained the cause. Several customers in exit surveys said they had learned of the outage only when they woke to find no service, which the text could not prevent, and some asked why no alert came overnight.
Treatment. The manager's call is the only element that addressed interpersonal fairness directly: a named person, an apology and a chance to ask questions. Studies of failure and recovery find that apology and personal attention have a strong effect on satisfaction, especially after failures that inconvenience the customer (Smith et al., 1999). The cancellation data are consistent with that finding.
What the Exit Surveys Added
Of the 233 affected customers who canceled within three months, 96 completed the exit survey. The most common reason given was not the outage itself but a sense that the company had not taken it seriously; several wrote that a text and a small credit felt automatic. Customers who had received a call rarely gave that reason. Exit surveys reflect only those who respond, but the comments point the same way as the cancellation figures: what customers valued was being treated as individuals.
The Recovery Paradox
Some managers believe that a well-recovered customer ends up more loyal than one who never experienced a failure, the so-called recovery paradox. The research gives little reason to count on it. A meta-analysis of studies on the paradox found that recovered customers reported higher satisfaction, yet their stated intention to buy again and their loyalty showed no such gain (de Matos et al., 2007). Northshore's own data fit that caution: even the called customers canceled at a slightly higher rate than similar unaffected customers. The recovery limited the damage; it did not turn the outage into an advantage.
Judgment and Recommendations
The recovery was partly successful. The text and credit were reasonable and cheap, but on their own they left cancellations about one point above normal. The personal call was the most effective element and the one the company ran short of. Three changes follow. Plan calling capacity in advance for large outages, using supervisors from other departments, so every affected customer can be reached within two days. Send an overnight alert when an outage begins, not only when it ends. And for the next outage, randomize the calling order so the company can measure the call's effect cleanly instead of estimating it around a tenure difference.
References
de Matos, C. A., Henrique, J. L., & Rossi, C. A. V. (2007). Service recovery paradox: A meta-analysis. Journal of Service Research, 10(1), 60-77. https://doi.org/10.1177/1094670507303012
Smith, A. K., Bolton, R. N., & Wagner, J. (1999). A model of customer satisfaction with service encounters involving failure and recovery. Journal of Marketing Research, 36(3), 356-372. https://doi.org/10.1177/002224379903600305
Tax, S. S., Brown, S. W., & Chandrashekaran, M. (1998). Customer evaluations of service complaint experiences: Implications for relationship marketing. Journal of Marketing, 62(2), 60-76. https://doi.org/10.1177/002224299806200205
What the BUS 332 Topic 6 instructions ask for
The Topic 6 instructions in BUS-332 ask students to evaluate a service recovery. Weak submissions describe the recovery and assume it worked. The assignment rewards evaluations that set out what actually happened, use any natural comparison available while stating its flaws, and judge the recovery by later behavior such as cancellations. Students should examine outcome, process and interpersonal fairness, weigh the recovery's cost against what it returned, address the recovery paradox with the research evidence rather than assuming it, and recommend changes that would improve both the next recovery and the company's ability to measure it.
Inside the BUS 332 Topic 6 example
The finished evaluation begins with the failure and the recovery as they actually happened: an overnight outage, a text alert the next morning, an account credit for everyone affected and a personal call from a manager to the customers the team reached within two days. Because the calls ran out before the list did, the example can compare affected customers who received a call with those who received only the credit, while noting that the comparison is imperfect. Recovery is examined through the perceived justice framework, covering outcome, process and treatment, and then judged by cancellations over the following months. The example addresses the recovery paradox directly, treating the claim that recovered customers end up more loyal as something the research supports only inconsistently.
Where the marks sit in the BUS 332 Topic 6 rubric
Faculty grading the recovery evaluation reward a comparison used honestly. Excellent evaluations adjust for the tenure difference created by the calling order and say how much remains uncertain. Credit goes to judging each fairness dimension against specific evidence from cancellations and exit surveys. The rubric values costing the credit and the calls against the customers they kept. The highest level rejects the recovery paradox as a planning assumption and recommends randomizing the next calling order. Evaluations that praise the recovery without behavioral evidence, or that assume the recovery paradox, usually lose marks with graders.
Common BUS 332 Topic 6 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Recoveries judged only by a satisfaction survey sent after the apology lose marks, because a customer can rate a courteous call highly and still cancel a month later. Assuming the recovery paradox, that a failure handled well leaves customers more loyal than before, overstates what the evidence supports and flatters the recovery. Evaluations that stop at the credit ignore process and treatment, which customers weigh at least as heavily as compensation. Comparing called and uncalled customers without acknowledging how the two groups might differ presents a rough comparison as a controlled one. Omitting the cost of the recovery leaves no way to say whether it was worth repeating. Papers that never mention the outage's cause, or the risk that it happens again, overlook what a second failure would do.
Get a BUS-332 Topic 6 example written to your instructions
Send the BUS-332 Topic 6 instructions and the rubric listed in your classroom, with the failure case your section assigned. We write a custom example to those instructions and that rubric, with the recovery described as delivered, outcome, process and treatment weighed, cancellations used as the verdict and the cost set against value kept, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More BUS 332 papers and BS in Business Management samples
- BUS 332 Topic 1: Retention Economics Comparison
- BUS 332 Topic 2: Customer Lifetime Value Calculation
- BUS 332 Topic 3: Value Segmentation Analysis
- BUS 332 Topic 4: Service Failure Analysis
- BUS 332 Topic 5: Loyalty Program Dq Response
- BUS 332 Topic 7: Engagement Measurement Proposal
- BUS 332 Topic 8: Targeted Retention Plan
- BUS 340 Topic 6: Intellectual Property Analysis
- BUS 317 Topic 6: Budget Commitment Review
- BUS 352 Topic 6: Two Sample Test Report
- MGT 475 Topic 6: Employee Monitoring Assessment
BUS 332 Topic 6 questions, answered
Does a good recovery make customers more loyal than they were before?
Occasionally, and far less reliably than the popular version claims. Research on the so-called recovery paradox has produced mixed results, with effects appearing more often in satisfaction ratings than in later buying behavior, and seldom after a serious or repeated failure. The example treats the paradox as a hypothesis to test against the company's cancellation records, not a premise to build on.
Is compensation enough on its own?
Rarely. Customers judge a recovery on what they received, on how quickly and fairly the problem was handled and on how they were treated along the way. A generous credit delivered by an automated message can leave the second and third unmet. In the example, customers who received a personal explanation alongside the credit left less often, though that comparison carries caveats the paper states.
How does the example judge whether the recovery paid for itself?
By comparing what it cost with the value of the customers it appears to have kept. Credits and staff hours are totaled. Cancellations among called customers are compared with credit-only customers, and the difference is multiplied by lifetime value from the earlier topic. The result is an estimate with stated weaknesses, and it still gives the firm a basis for deciding whether to repeat the calls.
Where can I find a free BUS 332 Topic 6 sample paper?
The complete evaluation appears above: what happened, the comparison available, reading it, cost and return, perceived justice, exit surveys, the recovery paradox and the judgment. Describe your recovery for a free worked evaluation.
Which part of the recovery worked best in BUS 332 Topic 6?
The manager's call; called customers canceled about 0.3 points above similar unaffected customers, against about 1.0 point for credit-only customers.