| Course | BUS 340 Ethical and Legal Issues in Business |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 2 |
| Paper type | Contract formation analysis |
| Length | About 950 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Business Management |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for BUS 340 Topic 2
Was There a Contract for 20,000 Boxes? Five Emails, One Offer, an Acceptance With an Added Term and a Price Increase That Comes Too Late
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
BUS-340: Ethical and Legal Issues in Business
Topic 2 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Was There a Contract for 20,000 Boxes? Five Emails, One Offer, an Acceptance With an Added Term and a Price Increase That Comes Too Late
The Correspondence
The analysis rests on the exact words exchanged, so the five messages are set out first, in order.
Table 1
The Five Messages
| Date | From | Message |
|---|---|---|
| March 2 | Keller Box Co., supplier | Spring price list attached: 12-inch corrugated shipping boxes, $1.20 each, minimum order 5,000. Prices subject to change. |
| March 5 | Riverside Candle Co., buyer | Please ship 20,000 of the 12-inch boxes at $1.20 each, delivered to our Dayton plant by March 20. Thanks, Tom Alvarez, Purchasing. |
| March 6 | Keller Box Co. | Confirmed: 20,000 boxes at $1.20, delivery March 20. Payment due within 15 days of delivery. Regards, Lisa Chen, Sales. |
| March 7 | Riverside Candle Co. | Thanks, Lisa. Tom |
| March 14 | Keller Box Co. | Due to resin costs we must adjust your order to $1.35 per box. Please confirm. Lisa |
The Governing Law
The transaction is a sale of goods between two merchants, so the state's version of the Uniform Commercial Code sales article governs it, not by the general common law of contracts (Cheeseman, 2019). The Code applies the same basic questions, offer, acceptance and consideration, but relaxes some common law rules to fit how businesses actually trade.
Which Message Was the Offer
The March 2 price list was not an offer. A price list sent to many customers, stating that prices are subject to change, is generally treated as an invitation to make offers, because a reasonable reader would not think the sender meant to be bound to supply any quantity to anyone who replied (American Law Institute, 1981). The March 5 email was the offer. It stated a specific quantity, price, product and delivery date, and it came from someone with authority to buy. It invited a response that would conclude the deal.
Acceptance, With an Added Term
Keller's March 6 reply accepted the quantity, price and delivery date, but it added a term: payment within 15 days of delivery. Under the common law mirror image rule, an acceptance that changes the offer's terms is a counteroffer, not an acceptance. The Code rejects that rule for sales of goods. A reply that clearly accepts still counts as acceptance when it adds new terms, unless the reply makes the deal expressly depend on the other side agreeing to them (Uniform Commercial Code, 2022). Keller's reply begins with the word confirmed and is plainly an acceptance.
Between merchants, the additional term becomes part of the contract unless the offer expressly limited acceptance to its terms, the term materially alters the contract, or the offeror objects within a reasonable time. Riverside's offer did not limit acceptance, and Riverside did not object; its March 7 reply simply said thanks. Whether 15-day payment is a material alteration depends on the trade. If Riverside's customary terms with suppliers are 30 days, halving the payment period could be material, and the term would drop out, leaving the Code's default that payment is due on delivery. If 15 days is ordinary in the packaging trade, the term is part of the contract. On the facts available, the payment term is uncertain, but the contract itself is not.
Consideration
Consideration is found in the exchanged promises: Keller promised to deliver boxes, and Riverside promised to pay $1.20 each. No payment or delivery was needed for a binding contract to form on March 6.
The Writing Requirement
Sales of goods for $500 or more generally need a written record showing that a deal was made, signed by whichever party is being held to it. At $24,000, this contract needs one. The emails are writings, and the typed names at the end of each, Tom Alvarez and Lisa Chen, can serve as signatures: federal law provides that a signature or contract may not be denied legal effect solely because it is in electronic form (Electronic Signatures in Global and National Commerce Act, 2018). The requirement is met against both parties.
The March 14 Price Increase
By March 14, a contract at $1.20 had existed for eight days. Keller's message was not a new offer but a request to modify the contract. Under the Code, a modification needs no new consideration but does require agreement, made in good faith (Clarkson et al., 2021). Riverside has not agreed and need not. If it declines, Keller remains bound to deliver at $1.20. The rise in resin costs does not excuse performance unless it made delivery commercially impracticable, a high standard that an increase of about 12 percent does not meet.
Conclusion
A contract was formed on March 6 for 20,000 boxes at $1.20, delivered March 20. The 15-day payment term is part of it unless it materially alters Riverside's position, which depends on trade practice. The emails satisfy the writing requirement. Keller's attempted increase to $1.35 is an unaccepted modification, and Riverside may insist on the original price, saving $3,000.
What Each Side Should Do Now
Riverside should reply to the March 14 message in writing, stating that it relies on the contract formed on March 6 at $1.20 and expects delivery on March 20. If the 15-day payment term matters to its cash planning, it should also say whether it accepts that term, which would remove any question of materiality. Keller, for its part, should recognize that it cannot impose the increase; if resin costs make the order unprofitable, its options are to ask for a negotiated compromise, perhaps offering faster delivery or a larger future order in exchange, or to perform at a loss. Both companies would benefit from using written purchase orders and acknowledgments with standard terms, which would settle payment and price-change questions before they arise.
References
American Law Institute. (1981). Restatement (second) of contracts. ALI.
Cheeseman, H. R. (2019). Business law: Legal environment, online commerce, business ethics, and international issues (10th ed.). Pearson.
Clarkson, K. W., Miller, R. L., & Cross, F. B. (2021). Business law: Text and cases (15th ed.). Cengage Learning.
Electronic Signatures in Global and National Commerce Act, 15 U.S.C. § 7001 (2018).
Uniform Commercial Code, U.C.C. § 2-207 (2022).
BUS 340 Topic 2 instructions, in plain terms
The Topic 2 instructions in BUS-340 ask students to analyze whether a contract was formed. Weak submissions state conclusions without the correspondence. The assignment rewards analyses that quote the messages in order before applying any law, identify the governing body of law, decide which message was the offer and test acceptance against the offer's terms. Students should apply the merchant rule on additional terms, find consideration, check the writing requirement for larger sales of goods, deal with any later attempt to change the deal and give each side practical next steps.
How the BUS-340 Topic 2 example is put together
The finished analysis quotes the correspondence before it says anything about law. Five messages appear in order, dated, with the sender marked, so each later claim can point at the exact line it depends on. The example then decides which message was the offer, and it explains why the supplier's original price sheet was only an invitation to deal. Acceptance is tested against the offer's terms, and the reply that added a payment deadline is examined under the Uniform Commercial Code rule for merchants who accept with additional terms. Consideration is found in the exchanged promises rather than in any payment. The example also checks whether the writing requirement for larger sales of goods is met by emails carrying typed names. It concludes that a contract exists, states its terms, and names the one term still open to dispute.
Where the marks sit in the BUS 340 Topic 2 rubric
Faculty grading the formation analysis reward every claim tied to a quoted line. Excellent analyses explain why a price list is an invitation rather than an offer. Credit goes to treating an acceptance with an added term under the Code rather than the mirror image rule. The rubric values testing typed names in emails against the writing requirement. The highest level treats the later price increase as a modification needing agreement and says what each company should do next. Analyses that call the reply a counteroffer usually land in a middle band.
BUS 340 Topic 2 help before you submit
Deductions here usually begin with the assumption that no signature means no contract. A paper that dismisses the email thread because nothing was formally signed has skipped the analysis the topic sets, since conduct and correspondence form agreements all the time. Calling the price quotation an offer is the second frequent loss, and it pulls every later conclusion out of position. Applying the common law mirror-image rule to a sale of goods between merchants misses the code provision written for exactly that exchange. Consideration is often asserted rather than located, as though any business deal must have it. The quieter loss is a conclusion with no terms, a paper that decides a contract exists and never says what the parties are now obliged to do, which is the part a manager would need.
Get a BUS-340 Topic 2 example written to your instructions
Send the BUS-340 Topic 2 instructions, the rubric posted in your classroom and the fact pattern or correspondence you were given. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the offer identified, acceptance tested and the binding terms listed, in 24 to 48 hours. Your first one is free.
More BUS 340 papers and BS in Business Management samples
- BUS 340 Topic 1: Legal Exposure Map
- BUS 340 Topic 3: Employment Exposure Memo
- BUS 340 Topic 4: Vicarious Liability Analysis
- BUS 340 Topic 5: Law and Ethics Divergence Dq
- BUS 340 Topic 6: Intellectual Property Analysis
- BUS 340 Topic 7: Permitted Conduct Decision Paper
- BUS 340 Topic 8: Position Defense Paper
- BUS 352 Topic 2: Distribution Shape Analysis
- BUS 332 Topic 2: Customer Lifetime Value Calculation
- BUS 390 Topic 2: Entry Mode Comparison
- BUS 317 Topic 2: Statement Reading Memo
BUS 340 Topic 2 questions, answered
Can an email exchange really create a binding contract?
It can, provided the messages show an offer, an acceptance and consideration, and nothing in the law of the relevant state requires a different form for that kind of deal. Federal and state electronic signature laws generally give electronic records and electronic signatures legal effect. The example treats that as a question to analyze on the facts rather than a rule to recite, and it is coursework, not advice on any real dispute.
Is a price quote an offer?
Usually not. Quotations, catalogs and price lists are generally read as invitations for the buyer to make an offer, because treating them as offers would bind a seller to every reader at once. A quote can become an offer when it is specific about quantity, terms and who may accept, and the example explains which features of the supplier's message did or did not cross that line.
What if one side never meant to be bound?
Contract law generally asks what a reasonable person reading the exchange would conclude, not what either party privately intended. A manager who writes that an order is confirmed has usually manifested assent, whatever reservations sat behind the message. The example makes that objective test explicit, because papers that argue from a party's hidden intention reach conclusions a court applying the standard would not.
Where can I find a free BUS 340 Topic 2 sample paper?
Everything is above: the correspondence, the governing law, which message was the offer, acceptance with an added term, consideration, the writing requirement, the price increase, the conclusion and next steps. Send your correspondence for a free worked analysis.
Can the supplier raise the price in BUS 340 Topic 2?
Not without the buyer's agreement; a contract at $1.20 formed on March 6, and the $1.35 request is a modification the buyer may refuse.