| Course | BUS 340 Ethical and Legal Issues in Business |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 4 |
| Paper type | Vicarious liability analysis |
| Length | About 960 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Business Management |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for BUS 340 Topic 4
Three Incidents, Three Answers: When a Retailer Answers for Its Driver, Its Installer and Its Salesperson
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
BUS-340: Ethical and Legal Issues in Business
Topic 4 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Three Incidents, Three Answers: When a Retailer Answers for Its Driver, Its Installer and Its Salesperson
Three Incidents That Look Alike
Crestline Appliance, a composite retailer, faces three claims from the same month. In each, a person working for Crestline caused a loss to a customer or a member of the public, and the injured party wants Crestline to pay. They look alike. Under the law of agency, they resolve differently, because the answer depends on the relationship between Crestline and the person who acted and on what that person was doing at the time.
The Delivery Driver
A Crestline delivery driver, a full-time employee, finished a morning delivery, left the assigned route to drive four miles to a restaurant for lunch, and on the way rear-ended another car. The other driver claims against Crestline.
An employer is liable for torts its employees commit while acting within the scope of their employment (American Law Institute, 2006). Conduct is within scope when it is part of the work assigned or a course of conduct the employer controls. The question is whether the lunch trip was a minor detour, still within the job, or a frolic, a departure far enough from the employer's business to take the conduct outside it. Courts weigh the distance and time of the departure, whether the employee was still serving the employer in any way and whether the employer permitted such stops. Crestline's drivers are allowed a meal break during their routes and routinely stop near their routes to eat. A four-mile trip to lunch in the company van, during a permitted break, is likely a detour. Crestline is probably liable.
A separate claim is available whatever the scope answer. Crestline knew when it hired the driver of two reckless driving citations in the preceding three years and assigned the driver to a delivery route anyway. An employer can be liable directly for negligently hiring or retaining an employee it knew or should have known posed a risk to others in the work assigned (Clarkson et al., 2021). That claim rests on Crestline's own conduct, not the driver's.
The Installer
An installer fitting a built-in oven cut into a water line behind a customer's cabinet, flooding the kitchen. The installer works under a written agreement with Crestline that calls the installer an independent contractor, and the customer claims against Crestline.
An employer is generally not liable for the torts of an independent contractor. The label in the agreement does not decide the question; what matters most is whether Crestline controls how the work is done. Here the evidence points both ways. The installer uses the installer's own tools and van, sets working hours and installs for two other retailers. But Crestline schedules each job, requires the installer to wear a Crestline shirt, sets the installation price and issues a detailed installation checklist the installer must follow. If the checklist governs how installations are performed, not just what result is expected, a court could find enough control to treat the installer as an employee, or find that Crestline's customers reasonably believed the installer was Crestline's own staff. On balance, the contractor label is weaker than it looks, and Crestline faces real exposure.
The Salesperson
A salesperson promised a customer a 25 percent discount on a refrigerator and range package, although salespeople are authorized to discount only 10 percent without a manager's approval. The customer, holding a written quote on Crestline letterhead, wants the discount honored.
A principal is bound by an agent's act if the agent had actual authority or if the principal's conduct led a third party reasonably to believe the agent had authority, called apparent authority (American Law Institute, 2006). The salesperson lacked actual authority for 25 percent. But Crestline placed the salesperson on the floor to negotiate prices, supplied the letterhead and gave customers no indication of any limit. A customer who received a written quote from a salesperson on the floor could reasonably believe it was the company's. Crestline is probably bound, though it may recover its loss from the salesperson under the employment agreement.
Why the Same Facts Can Cut Both Ways
The three incidents show that the question is never simply whether a worker caused harm. It is what relationship the worker had with Crestline, what Crestline let customers believe and what the worker was doing at the time. A small change in facts would change the answers. If the driver had driven forty miles to visit family during the break, the trip would look like a frolic and the vicarious claim would weaken, though the negligent hiring claim would remain. If the installer set their own methods and wore their own company's clothing, the contractor label would likely hold. If Crestline's quotes had stated the discount limit, the customer could not reasonably have relied on a higher figure. Knowing which facts matter tells Crestline where to change its practices.
The Three Answers
Crestline is probably liable for the driver's collision, both vicariously and for negligent hiring. It faces real risk on the installer's flood, depending on how much control its checklist exerts. And it is probably bound to the salesperson's discount through apparent authority (Cheeseman, 2019).
What Crestline Should Change
Each answer suggests a change. For drivers, review motor vehicle records before hiring and annually, and do not assign drivers with recent reckless driving citations to routes. For installers, decide whether they are contractors or employees and act consistently: if contractors, specify results rather than methods, remove the uniform requirement and require installers to carry their own liability insurance naming Crestline as an additional insured. For salespeople, print discount limits on quotes and require a manager's signature above them, so customers are on notice of the limit.
References
American Law Institute. (2006). Restatement (third) of agency. ALI.
Cheeseman, H. R. (2019). Business law: Legal environment, online commerce, business ethics, and international issues (10th ed.). Pearson.
Clarkson, K. W., Miller, R. L., & Cross, F. B. (2021). Business law: Text and cases (15th ed.). Cengage Learning.
Reading the GCU BUS 340 Topic 4 instructions
The Topic 4 instructions in BUS-340 ask students to analyze when a business is liable for the conduct of those who work for it. Weak submissions assume a business is always liable. The assignment rewards analyses that identify the relationship in each incident, apply scope of employment to employees, test contractor status by control rather than label, and apply actual and apparent authority to promises made to customers. Students should raise direct claims such as negligent hiring where the facts support them, explain which facts would change each answer and recommend practical changes.
Inside the BUS 340 Topic 4 example
The finished analysis handles three incidents that look alike on the surface and resolve differently. The delivery driver was an employee who left the assigned route to collect lunch, so the example asks whether that was a minor detour still inside the job or a departure far enough to take the conduct outside it. The installer worked under a written agreement, so the question becomes whether the retailer controlled how the work was done, which largely decides contractor status. The salesperson promised a discount beyond any authority actually granted, and the example tests whether the customer could reasonably have believed the promise was the company's. A separate paragraph raises negligent hiring, since the driver's record was known. Each incident ends with a one-line verdict and the fact that would most change it.
Reading the BUS 340 Topic 4 rubric
Faculty grading the liability analysis reward three incidents resolved by different rules. Excellent analyses weigh distance, time and permission in deciding between a detour and a frolic. Credit goes to looking past the contractor label to the control the retailer exercises. The rubric values applying apparent authority from the customer's reasonable view of the quote. The highest level adds negligent hiring as a separate claim and shows which facts would flip each answer. Analyses that treat all three incidents the same way usually land in a middle band.
BUS 340 Topic 4 help before you submit
The costliest error is assuming the organization always pays, which erases the distinctions the topic is testing. An employee acting within the job exposes the employer; a genuine independent contractor usually does not; an agent can bind the principal in contract through authority that was never actually given. Papers that apply respondeat superior to all three incidents in one paragraph have not analyzed any of them. Contractor status decided by what the agreement calls the worker, rather than by who controlled the work, is a frequent and specific loss. Apparent authority is often confused with actual authority, or argued from the salesperson's belief instead of the customer's reasonable reliance on the retailer's conduct. Leaving negligent hiring out forfeits the one theory that survives a finding that the driver's errand fell outside the job.
Get a BUS-340 Topic 4 example written to your instructions
Send the BUS-340 Topic 4 instructions and your classroom rubric, along with the incidents or case facts your section provided. We write a custom example to those criteria, with each relationship classified, the right liability doctrine applied to each incident and direct negligence handled separately, in 24 to 48 hours. First one free.
More BUS 340 papers and BS in Business Management samples
- BUS 340 Topic 1: Legal Exposure Map
- BUS 340 Topic 2: Contract Formation Analysis
- BUS 340 Topic 3: Employment Exposure Memo
- BUS 340 Topic 5: Law and Ethics Divergence Dq
- BUS 340 Topic 6: Intellectual Property Analysis
- BUS 340 Topic 7: Permitted Conduct Decision Paper
- BUS 340 Topic 8: Position Defense Paper
- BUS 352 Topic 4: Interval Estimate Memo
- BUS 332 Topic 4: Service Failure Analysis
- BUS 390 Topic 4: Transaction Exposure Analysis
- BUS 317 Topic 4: Break-even Sensitivity Analysis
BUS 340 Topic 4 questions, answered
What does scope of employment actually cover?
Conduct of the kind the employee was hired to perform, occurring substantially within authorized time and place, and motivated at least partly by serving the employer. Doing assigned work carelessly, or in a way a supervisor had forbidden, can still count, since the question is whose business was being done. A personal errand far from the job usually falls outside it, and the example measures the driver's lunch stop against that line.
Is a company ever liable for an independent contractor?
Sometimes. The general rule shields the hiring party from a genuine contractor's negligence, but exceptions exist for inherently dangerous work, duties the law treats as non-delegable, and the hiring party's own carelessness in selecting or supervising the contractor. Misclassification is the other route: if the retailer in fact controlled the work, the installer may be treated as an employee whatever the agreement says.
How is apparent authority different from actual authority?
Actual authority is what the principal has in fact granted the agent, expressly or by implication from the role. Apparent authority arises from the principal's own conduct toward the third party, a title, a desk on the sales floor, a history of honoring similar deals, which leads that party reasonably to believe the agent could act. The belief must trace back to the principal, not merely to the agent's claims.
Where can I find a free BUS 340 Topic 4 sample paper?
You can read the whole analysis here: three incidents, the delivery driver, the installer, the salesperson, the three answers, why facts cut both ways and what to change. Share your incidents for a free worked analysis.
Why is the retailer bound to the discount in BUS 340 Topic 4?
It put the salesperson on the floor to negotiate, supplied letterhead and gave no notice of limits, so the customer could reasonably believe the quote was the company's.