BUS 340 Topic 8 position defense paper example

Ethical and Legal Issues in Business Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This BUS 340 Topic 8 sample paper defends voluntary notice to 14,000 customers after an encrypted laptop was stolen. It belongs to GCU BUS 340, Ethical and Legal Issues in Business, the course listed as BUS-340 in the Grand Canyon University BS in Business Management. The state statute exempts encrypted data when the key was not taken, and the paper says so plainly. The general counsel's case appears at full strength: notice invites claims, alarms customers over negligible risk and sets a precedent. The paper concedes the second point in part, answers the others with customer trust and the company's own privacy promise, drafts the letter and prices it.

CourseBUS 340 Ethical and Legal Issues in Business
TopicTopic 8
Paper typePosition defense paper
LengthAbout 970 words, 2 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramBS in Business Management
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for BUS 340 Topic 8

1

Notify Anyway: Defending Voluntary Notice of an Encrypted Laptop Theft Against a General Counsel's Strongest Case

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

BUS-340: Ethical and Legal Issues in Business

Topic 8 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the position and the opposition it is tested against. The company, people and figures are illustrative composites; the sources are real.
2

Notify Anyway: Defending Voluntary Notice of an Encrypted Laptop Theft Against a General Counsel's Strongest Case

The Position and the Legal Ground

A laptop belonging to a customer service analyst at Brightwell Insurance Agency, a composite firm, was stolen from a car. It held a spreadsheet of about 14,000 customers' names, addresses, dates of birth and policy numbers. The laptop's drive was encrypted, and the password was not written down or stored with it. The state's breach notification statute exempts data that is encrypted when the encryption key was not also acquired. Brightwell is therefore not legally required to notify anyone, and this paper says so without softening it (Cheeseman, 2019). The position defended here is that Brightwell should notify the affected customers anyway, briefly and plainly.

The General Counsel's Case

The general counsel opposes voluntary notice, and the case deserves to be stated at its strongest.

First, voluntary notice invites claims the company would otherwise never face. A letter telling 14,000 people their information was on a stolen laptop is an invitation to plaintiffs' firms, and even weak claims cost money to defend.

Second, notice alarms customers over a risk that is close to negligible. Modern full-disk encryption, properly configured, is extremely unlikely to be broken by a car thief, and a letter will cause worry out of proportion to the danger.

Third, it sets a precedent. If Brightwell notifies when the law does not require it, it will be expected to do so for every future incident, including trivial ones, and its own restraint will become the standard it is judged by.

Answering the Second Point, in Part

The second point is largely right about the risk. The chance that the data will be read is very small, and a notice that implied otherwise would mislead. The concession shapes the notice: it should say plainly that the device was encrypted, that the company has no evidence anyone has accessed the data and that the risk is low, and it should not offer credit monitoring as though a serious exposure had occurred. Research on data breach harms notes that the anxiety a breach causes is itself a harm people experience, which a calm, accurate notice can reduce as well as increase (Solove & Citron, 2018). A notice written this way informs without alarming.

Answering the First Point

The litigation risk is smaller than it appears. Claims after breaches of encrypted data rarely succeed, because plaintiffs struggle to show that their information was actually exposed or that they suffered harm; a notice that states the encryption plainly supports that defense rather than undermining it. Against that small risk sits a larger one: if the laptop is ever recovered and found to have been accessed, or if the theft becomes public through a police report or a former employee, customers will learn that Brightwell knew and said nothing. The damage to trust then would exceed any cost of notice now. Breaches that customers learn about from others, rather than the company, tend to cost more in lost business (IBM Security, 2023).

Answering the Third Point

The precedent concern is answered by Brightwell's own words. Its privacy statement, on its website and in every policy packet, promises customers that it will tell them promptly if their personal information is lost or stolen. It makes no exception for encrypted data. A company that makes that promise and then relies on a statutory exemption to avoid keeping it sets a worse precedent than one that keeps its word. If the company believes its promise is too broad, the right response is to revise the statement for the future, openly, not to read it narrowly after an incident.

What Would Change the Position

The position would change if notice could cause real harm, for example if law enforcement asked Brightwell to delay notice to protect an investigation. It would also change if the privacy statement had never made a promise, in which case the decision would rest on the balance of trust and cost alone, and reasonable people could decide either way. Neither applies here.

What the Letter Would Say

A draft shows that notice need not alarm. "On March 3, a company laptop was stolen from an employee's car. It contained a file with your name, address, date of birth and policy number. The laptop was protected by full-disk encryption, and the password was not with it, so we believe the risk that anyone can read the file is very low. We have no evidence that it has been accessed. We are telling you because our privacy statement promises to let you know when your information is lost or stolen, and we intend to keep that promise. We have also changed our rules so customer files are no longer kept on laptops. If you have questions, please call our customer care line." The letter is under 130 words, states the facts and the risk accurately and explains why it was sent.

The Cost of Notice

Mailing and handling 14,000 letters costs about $12,000, and preparing the customer care team for questions adds perhaps $5,000 in staff time. Those figures are small against the value of the customer relationships at stake, and against the cost of explaining later why the company chose silence. They also assume no credit monitoring, which the low risk does not justify.

The Recommendation

Brightwell should send a short, plain letter to the 14,000 affected customers within two weeks, describing what happened, the encryption, the low risk and the steps taken, including a review of the policy that allowed customer data on laptops. It should also revise its internal rules so that customer spreadsheets are not stored on portable devices at all. Keeping a promise that costs little and protects the relationship with every customer is the right course, and also the prudent one.

References

Cheeseman, H. R. (2019). Business law: Legal environment, online commerce, business ethics, and international issues (10th ed.). Pearson.

IBM Security. (2023). Cost of a data breach report 2023. IBM.

Solove, D. J., & Citron, D. K. (2018). Risk and anxiety: A theory of data-breach harms. Texas Law Review, 96(4), 737-786.

What the BUS 340 Topic 8 instructions ask for

The Topic 8 instructions in BUS-340 ask students to defend a position against serious opposition. Weak submissions present only their own side. The assignment rewards papers that state the position at once, settle the legal ground honestly and present the opposing case in its strongest form, point by point. Students should concede where the opposition is right and show how the concession shapes the recommendation, answer the remaining points with reasons tied to the facts and the company's own commitments, and state what would change the position.

Inside the BUS 340 Topic 8 example

The finished paper puts its position on the table at once and spends most of its length under pressure. The legal ground is settled early: the composite state's notification statute exempts encrypted data when the key was not taken, so disclosure is not required, and the paper says so without softening it. The general counsel's case then appears in its strongest form, in three parts: voluntary notice invites claims the company would otherwise never face, it alarms customers over a risk that is close to negligible, and it sets a precedent for every future incident. The paper concedes the second point in part and answers the other two with reasons tied to customer trust and to what the company has promised in its own privacy statement. It ends with a narrower position than it began with, and says why.

Where the marks sit in the BUS 340 Topic 8 rubric

Faculty grading the position paper reward a view that survives its strongest critic. Excellent papers admit there is no legal duty to notify. Credit goes to conceding the low risk and writing a notice that informs without alarming. The rubric values answering the precedent concern with the company's own privacy promise. The highest level drafts the letter, prices the notice and names what would reverse the position. Papers that dismiss the general counsel's concerns, or claim a legal duty that does not exist, usually lose marks with graders.

BUS 340 Topic 8 help before you submit

Weak versions of this paper argue against an opponent nobody would recognize. When the counsel is written as indifferent to customers, the position wins easily and demonstrates nothing, and faculty grading the defense against reasonable disagreement notice at once. A related loss is the refusal to concede anything, which reads as advocacy rather than analysis; a defended position usually comes out slightly narrower than it went in. Some papers skip the legal ground, and their argument for disclosure then sounds like a claim that the law requires it, which it does not. Others overcorrect and rest the whole case on reputation, turning an ethical position into a public relations calculation. The conclusion loses marks when it restates the opening word for word, as though the objections had never been raised.

Get a BUS-340 Topic 8 example written to your instructions

Send the BUS-340 Topic 8 instructions and the rubric your section posts, along with the position or case you were asked to argue. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the legal ground settled, the opposing view stated fairly and a position defended that survives it, delivered in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More BUS 340 papers and BS in Business Management samples

BUS 340 Topic 8 questions, answered

What makes a disagreement reasonable?

A reasonable opponent shares most of your facts and values and weighs them differently. The general counsel in the example cares about customers too; the disagreement is about whether voluntary notice actually serves them and what it costs the company. Choosing an opponent like that forces the paper to argue about the weighing, which is where the real question sits, rather than about whether customers matter at all.

Is it a weakness to concede a point?

Usually the opposite. Conceding something true shows the position was tested rather than assembled to win, and it lets the argument concentrate on the ground it can actually hold. The risk is conceding the central point without noticing. The example grants that individual risk is small but keeps its claim that customers are owed the information, and it explains why those two statements are compatible.

Does the paper tell companies what breach law requires?

No. Breach notification rules differ by state and by type of data, and the example uses a composite statute with a simplified encryption exemption to create a clean legal floor for the ethical argument. Anyone handling a real incident needs counsel licensed where the affected customers live. The paper's value is in how it holds a position against pressure, not in any statement of current law.

Where can I find a free BUS 340 Topic 8 sample paper?

The paper is here in full: the position and legal ground, the general counsel's case, answers to each point, what the letter would say, the cost of notice, what would change the position and the recommendation. Describe the incident and the opposing view for a free worked paper.

Why notify when the law does not require it in BUS 340 Topic 8?

The company's privacy statement promises to tell customers when their information is lost or stolen, with no exception for encrypted data.