DBA 815 Topic 1 decision sorting memo example

Economics for Business Decisions Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This DBA 815 Topic 1 sample paper is a memo sorting five decisions facing a composite fourteen-club fitness chain by what economics can contribute to each. It was written for GCU DBA 815, Economics for Business Decisions, catalog code DBA-815, a seminar in Grand Canyon University's DBA. A price cut near a rival waits on the chain's own-price elasticity, and a club closure on avoidable cost with the renovation set aside as sunk. A member growth target is recast as contribution, an annual contract is priced with DellaVigna and Malmendier's finding on overestimated attendance in view, and a youth sponsorship can be costed but not valued.

CourseDBA 815 Economics for Business Decisions
TopicTopic 1
Paper typeDecision sorting memo
LengthAbout 830 words, 1 pages
FormatMemo with APA 7 references
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramDBA
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for DBA 815 Topic 1

1

Memorandum

To: Leadership Team

From: Director of Strategy and Analytics

Date: [Date]

Re: Sorting this quarter's five decisions by what economics can settle

 

Purpose

The leadership team has five decisions on its agenda this quarter. This memo sorts them by what economics can contribute: which it can settle once a specific number is known, which it can inform but not settle, and which it can cost but not value. The chain runs fourteen clubs and charges 49 dollars a month; figures in this memo are illustrative.

Two Decisions Economics Can Settle

The proposal to cut the price to 39 dollars at the club nearest the new regional rival turns on one number the chain has not yet estimated: its own-price elasticity of demand at that club, meaning how many members it gains or keeps for each percentage point the price falls. If demand there is elastic enough, the lower price raises contribution; if not, it gives away margin. Once the elasticity is measured, the arithmetic decides. The markup rule also offers a check: a seller pricing to maximize profit sets its markup so that the share of price above marginal cost equals one over the absolute value of its elasticity (Lerner, 1934), so the chain's current margin implies what elasticity it has been assuming. The proposal to close the weakest club turns on a different number: the costs that would actually disappear if it closed, compared with the contribution it earns, and the date its lease can be ended. The club's renovation last year is sunk; it cannot be recovered by staying open or by closing, so it belongs on neither side of the comparison (Frank, 2014). Both decisions become calculations once the relevant figure is in hand.

Two Decisions Economics Can Inform

The board's growth target, ten percent more members by year end, cannot be settled by economics because it is stated in the wrong unit. Members added through discounts at a lower margin can raise membership and lower profit at the same time. Economics can recast the target as a contribution question, how much more contribution the chain should earn, and show which ways of adding members serve it; the choice of target remains the board's. The proposed annual contract, twelve months prepaid at a discount, can be priced, but its revenue rests partly on a predictable mistake. DellaVigna and Malmendier (2006) found that gym members choosing flat monthly fees overestimated how often they would attend and would have paid less by paying per visit. An annual contract would earn part of its revenue from members who overestimate their own attendance and later regret it. Economics can estimate how much revenue depends on that, but whether the chain wants to earn it is a judgment about its relationship with members, not a calculation.

Table 1

Five Decisions Sorted by What Economics Can Settle

DecisionWhat economics contributesNumber or judgment still needed
Price cut to 39 dollars near the rivalSettles it once elasticity is knownOwn-price elasticity at that club
Close the weakest clubSettles it once avoidable cost is knownAvoidable cost and lease end date; renovation excluded as sunk
Ten percent member growth targetInforms: recasts as contributionBoard's choice of contribution target
Annual prepaid contractInforms: prices it and sizes the revenue from overestimated attendanceWhether to earn revenue from members' mistakes
Youth sports sponsorshipCosts it onlyWhether community value is worth the cost

One Decision Economics Can Only Cost

The proposal to sponsor a youth sports league stands alone. Economics can state its cost, about 40,000 dollars a year, and can estimate any measurable return, such as memberships from parents who attend league events. But the sponsorship's main purpose, the chain's standing in its communities, has no market price, and no calculation can say whether it is worth 40,000 dollars. That decision belongs to the leadership's judgment about what kind of company the chain wants to be.

What Happens Next

For the two decisions economics can settle, the next step is to produce the missing numbers: a price test to estimate elasticity at the contested club, and a schedule of avoidable costs with the lease terms for the weakest one. For the two it can inform, the board should restate the growth target in contribution terms and decide its view on the annual contract before pricing it. For the sponsorship, the leadership team should decide on its merits, with the cost in view. Sorting the decisions this way also prevents a common error: treating a calculation as if it settled a question of values, or treating a question that a number could settle as a matter of opinion.

Recommendation

Do not decide the price cut or the closure until the elasticity estimate and avoidable-cost schedule are ready, which finance and operations can deliver within six weeks. Replace the member growth target with a contribution target at the next board meeting. Take a position on the annual contract's reliance on overestimated attendance before any pricing work begins. Decide the sponsorship separately, as a values decision with its cost stated.

References

DellaVigna, S., & Malmendier, U. (2006). Paying not to go to the gym. American Economic Review, 96(3), 694-719. https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.96.3.694

Frank, R. H. (2014). Microeconomics and behavior (9th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.

Lerner, A. P. (1934). The concept of monopoly and the measurement of monopoly power. Review of Economic Studies, 1(3), 157-175. https://doi.org/10.2307/2967480

Reading the GCU DBA 815 Topic 1 instructions

Topic 1 in DBA-815 asks doctoral students to sort business decisions by what economic analysis can settle. Strong memos identify the specific number each settleable decision turns on, exclude sunk costs from both sides of a comparison and recast goals stated in the wrong unit. Students should separate decisions economics can inform from those it can only cost, recognize where revenue depends on customers' predictable mistakes and leave value judgments to the people who own them, ending with the next step for each decision. Each recommendation should say who must supply the missing number and by when.

How this DBA 815 Topic 1 example is built

Five decisions reach the memo, all from a composite chain charging $49 a month. Two can be decided by economics once one number is known: a proposed cut to $39 near a rival turns on the chain's own-price elasticity, still unestimated, and closing the weakest club turns on avoidable cost and a lease date, with the recent renovation kept out of both sides. Two can only be informed. A growth target of more members is recast as a contribution question, since members bought at a lower margin can shrink profit. An annual contract can be priced, but DellaVigna and Malmendier's finding that gym members on flat fees overestimate their attendance means part of its revenue rests on a predictable mistake, which the chain must judge. A youth sports sponsorship stands alone: economics can cost it but not value it.

DBA 815 Topic 1 rubric: what Excellent looks like

Faculty reward decisions sorted by what a number can settle. An Excellent memo names elasticity and avoidable cost as the missing figures, with Lerner's markup rule as a check and Frank on sunk costs. Credit goes to recasting a membership target as contribution. The rubric values pricing an annual contract while naming the revenue that rests on overestimated attendance, as DellaVigna and Malmendier found. Strong memos table all five decisions. Top marks go to separating what economics can cost from what it can value.

Common DBA 815 Topic 1 mistakes, and how to avoid them

A memo that applies economics to everything, sponsorship included, shows enthusiasm for the tools and no judgment about their reach, which is what this topic assesses. The opposite error, treating the price cut as a matter of executive instinct, surrenders a decision economics can actually settle. Letting the renovation cost into the closure discussion is typically marked wrong outright, since money already spent cannot change which option leaves the chain better off. Papers that accept a membership growth target at face value miss that volume bought with margin can lower profit. Citing behavioral findings to dismiss standard reasoning overshoots, because DellaVigna and Malmendier's result shows where one assumption fails, not that pricing analysis is useless. Memos that name no missing quantity leave the team with categories and nothing to go and find.

Get a DBA-815 Topic 1 example written to your instructions

Send the DBA-815 Topic 1 instructions, your classroom rubric and the firm, case or decisions the assignment describes. The custom example is written to those requirements, with a sorting rule stated, each decision placed and its deciding quantity named, sunk spending kept out and the limits of the standard model marked, returned in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More DBA 815 papers and DBA samples

DBA 815 Topic 1 questions, answered

What did DellaVigna and Malmendier find about gym contracts?

Stefano DellaVigna and Ulrike Malmendier studied health club members and found that many who chose flat monthly fees attended too rarely for the fee to beat paying per visit, and that members tended to overestimate how often they would go. They read this as overconfidence about future self-control. The example uses the finding to mark where a standard assumption, accurate self-prediction, stops holding for this firm.

Why can't the renovation cost count in the closure decision?

Because it has already been paid and nothing the board decides now can recover it. Keeping the club open does not earn the renovation back, and closing it does not waste the money a second time. What differs between the options is future revenue and future cost, including the lease until its break date. The example keeps the renovation visible in the memo precisely so the team can see it being set aside.

Is a youth sponsorship really outside economics?

Its cost is inside economics and the memo states it in full. Its value is harder. The chain could try to measure brand or referral effects, but the executives proposing it describe it as something the company should do regardless of return. Economic reasoning can tell them what that commitment costs and what it displaces. Whether it is worth that price is a judgment the memo returns to them rather than pretending to settle.

Where can I find a free DBA 815 Topic 1 sample paper?

The sorting memo is shown here complete: purpose, two decisions economics can settle, two it can inform, one it can only cost, what happens next and the recommendation. List the decisions your seminar case presents and a sorting memo follows free.

Why exclude the renovation in DBA 815 Topic 1?

It has been spent whether the club stays open or closes, so it cannot change which choice is better. Only costs that differ between the options belong in the comparison.