| Course | DBA 815 Economics for Business Decisions |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 2 |
| Paper type | Own-price elasticity analysis |
| Length | About 1,010 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | DBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for DBA 815 Topic 2
Category Elasticity Is Not the Chain's Elasticity: Why a Consultant's -0.4 Cannot Justify a Fitness Chain's Price Increase
[Author Name]
College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University
DBA-815: Economics for Business Decisions
Topic 2 Own-Price Elasticity Analysis
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Category Elasticity Is Not the Chain's Elasticity: Why a Consultant's -0.4 Cannot Justify a Fitness Chain's Price Increase
The Consultant's Recommendation
A consultant has advised a composite fourteen-club fitness chain to raise its monthly dues from 49 to about 54 dollars, a 10 percent increase. The report rests on an estimated price elasticity of demand of minus 0.4: a 10 percent price rise would lose about 4 percent of members, so revenue would rise by roughly 5.6 percent. The arithmetic is reproduced here and is internally correct. If demand at the chain's clubs really responds with an elasticity of minus 0.4, a price increase raises revenue and, with costs per member unchanged, raises contribution further. The question this analysis asks is what the minus 0.4 actually measures. Figures are illustrative.
What the Estimate Measures
The report estimated the elasticity from national survey data on how much households spend on gym memberships as prices change across regions. That is the elasticity of category demand: how much the total quantity of gym membership falls when the price of gym membership in general rises. The chain's question is different: whether its own members stay when it raises its price while a nearby club does not. That is own-price elasticity for one seller. Whenever buyers can switch between sellers, a single seller's demand is more elastic than the category's, because a seller that raises its price alone loses members not only to giving up the gym but to rivals (Frank, 2014). Applying category elasticity to one seller's price decision mistakes the market's response for the firm's.
A Consistency Check From the Markup Rule
The chain's own pricing offers a check. The markup rule states that a firm pricing to maximize profit sets the share of price above marginal cost equal to one over the absolute value of its own-price elasticity (Lerner, 1934). The chain's marginal cost, the cost that rises with each additional member-month for towels, cleaning, wear on equipment and payment processing, is about 12 dollars. At 49 dollars, the markup share is 37 divided by 49, about 0.76. If the chain has been pricing sensibly, its own elasticity is about one over 0.76, roughly minus 1.3.
Table 1
Checking the Elasticity Against the Chain's Own Markup
| Quantity | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Price per member-month | 49 dollars | Current dues |
| Marginal cost per member-month | About 12 dollars | Operating records |
| Markup share (price minus cost, over price) | About 0.76 | Calculation |
| Implied own-price elasticity | About -1.3 | Markup rule |
| Consultant's elasticity | -0.4 | Category survey data |
| Markup implied by -0.4 | 2.5, above 100 percent | Impossible: no price produces it |
Why -0.4 Cannot Be the Chain's Elasticity
An own-price elasticity of minus 0.4 would imply that the profit-maximizing markup share is one over 0.4, or 2.5: price would have to exceed marginal cost by 250 percent of price itself, which is impossible, since the markup share cannot exceed 1. A firm facing inelastic demand for its own product, with an elasticity smaller than 1 in absolute value, can always raise profit by raising price, so a profit-seeking firm never stays where its own demand is inelastic (Tirole, 1988). If the chain's own elasticity were minus 0.4, it would have been leaving money on the table at every price it has ever charged. The more plausible reading is that minus 0.4 describes the category, and the chain's own elasticity is near minus 1.3.
The Increase at the Implied Elasticity
At an own elasticity of minus 1.3, a 10 percent price rise loses about 13 percent of members. Contribution per member rises from 37 dollars to about 42, about 13 percent, while members fall by about 13 percent, so monthly contribution falls by roughly 1.5 to 2 percent. The increase that looked like a gain at minus 0.4 is a small loss at the elasticity the chain's own pricing implies.
Why the Error Is Easy to Make
The confusion is common because both numbers are called price elasticity and both are legitimate. Category elasticity is the right figure for questions about the whole market, such as how an industry-wide tax on memberships would change total gym use. It is the wrong figure for a single firm's price, because the firm's members can leave for a rival without leaving the category. Consultants often have category estimates on hand from industry studies, while own-price estimates require the firm's own data or a test. Using the available number in place of the relevant one is understandable and costly.
Elasticity Will Differ Across the Chain's Clubs
The markup check yields one number for the chain, but own-price elasticity almost certainly varies by club. A club with a close rival two minutes away faces members who can switch easily, so its demand is likely more elastic than minus 1.3. A club with no rival nearby faces members whose alternative is the next town or no gym at all, so its demand is likely less elastic. A single chain-wide price increase would therefore lose most members where rivals are close and least where they are absent. Any test should be designed to measure elasticity separately in each competitive setting.
What the Analysis Does Not Show
The consistency check assumes the chain has been pricing to maximize profit, which may not be true; firms often set prices by habit or by matching rivals. It also treats elasticity as the same at every club, while clubs facing close rivals likely have more elastic demand than clubs with none nearby. The check does not prove the chain's elasticity is minus 1.3. It shows that minus 0.4 cannot be right for a single seller and that the consultant's recommendation rests on the wrong number.
Recommendation
The chain should not adopt the increase on the strength of the consultant's estimate. It should estimate its own-price elasticity directly, with a controlled price test among new members at matched clubs, and should expect the answer to differ by competitive setting. Until then, the evidence points to an elasticity near minus 1.3 and a price close to the level that maximizes contribution already. A test costs a few weeks; a mispriced increase across fourteen clubs would cost far more.
References
Frank, R. H. (2014). Microeconomics and behavior (9th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.
Lerner, A. P. (1934). The concept of monopoly and the measurement of monopoly power. Review of Economic Studies, 1(3), 157-175. https://doi.org/10.2307/2967480
Tirole, J. (1988). The theory of industrial organization. MIT Press.
What the DBA 815 Topic 2 instructions ask for
The Topic 2 assignment in DBA-815 asks doctoral students to analyze own-price elasticity for a pricing decision. Strong analyses reproduce the recommendation's arithmetic, ask what the elasticity actually measures and distinguish category demand from a single seller's demand. Students should check the estimate against the firm's own markup using the markup rule, show why an inelastic own-price estimate is inconsistent with profit-seeking pricing, recompute the decision at a plausible elasticity and state what the check does not prove. The paper should also say how elasticity is likely to vary across locations, since one figure for the whole firm hides that.
Inside the DBA 815 Topic 2 example
The consultant's arithmetic is reproduced first and found internally correct: at -0.4, a 10 percent rise loses about 4 percent of members and revenue climbs. The analysis then asks what the -0.4 measures. The report estimated it for gym membership as a whole, which is category demand, while the chain's question is whether its own members stay when a nearby club charges less. Own-price elasticity for one seller exceeds category elasticity whenever buyers can switch. A consistency check follows. With marginal cost near $12 per member-month and dues at $49, figures illustrative, the markup rule says a profit-seeking chain already pricing well faces an own elasticity near -1.3. An own elasticity of -0.4 would call for a markup above 100 percent, which no price can produce. At -1.3, the proposed rise lowers monthly contribution by roughly 2 percent.
Reading the DBA 815 Topic 2 rubric
Faculty reward an elasticity questioned before it is used. An Excellent paper separates category from own-price elasticity, citing Frank. Credit goes to a table deriving an implied elasticity near minus 1.3 from the chain's markup with Lerner's rule. The rubric values showing that minus 0.4 implies an impossible markup and that inelastic own demand is never where a profit-seeking firm stays, following Tirole. Strong papers recompute the increase at the implied elasticity. Top marks go to expecting elasticity to differ by club.
DBA 815 Topic 2 help: mistakes that cost marks
Borrowing an industry elasticity for a single firm's price costs the most here, and a paper that accepts the consultant's -0.4 has misread elasticity at exactly the level where it decides the answer. Papers that recompute the report's revenue gain without asking what the figure measures check the arithmetic and miss the input. Revenue is the wrong target in any case, since a rise that lifts revenue can still lower contribution once marginal cost is counted. The markup consistency check is often absent, although it is the quickest route from the chain's own margin to a plausible elasticity. Some analyses correctly reject the figure and then offer no alternative, which leaves the executives with a veto and no number. Treating the implied -1.3 as measured rather than inferred overstates what the check can show.
Get a DBA-815 Topic 2 example written to your instructions
Send the DBA-815 Topic 2 instructions, the rubric for your section and any demand data, report or pricing proposal the case supplies. We write a custom example to them, with the cited elasticity traced to what it measures, market and firm demand separated, the markup check run and the proposal recomputed on contribution, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More DBA 815 papers and DBA samples
- DBA 815 Topic 1: Decision Sorting Memo
- DBA 815 Topic 3: Rival Cost Structure Comparison
- DBA 815 Topic 4: Local Pricing Power Analysis
- DBA 815 Topic 5: Elasticity Estimation Dq Post
- DBA 815 Topic 6: Repeated Pricing Game Analysis
- DBA 815 Topic 7: Tested Price Recommendation
- DBA 815 Topic 8: Executive Pricing Brief
- DBA 805 Topic 2: Theory Appraisal Criteria Paper
- MKT 838 Topic 2: Hit Attribution Post-mortem
- MKT 834 Topic 2: Causal Identification Essay
DBA 815 Topic 2 questions, answered
What is the markup rule?
For a firm with some pricing power that sets price to maximize profit, the gap between price and marginal cost, as a share of price, equals one over the absolute value of its own-price elasticity. Economists know the left side as the Lerner index. Because that share cannot exceed one, a profit-maximizing firm never prices where its own demand is inelastic, which is why the example can reject -0.4 as the chain's figure.
Why is a single chain's demand more elastic than the market's?
Because buyers leaving one chain rarely leave the market. When one club raises its price, many members move to a nearby rival rather than giving up exercise, so the chain loses far more members than the industry does. Market elasticity measures the second loss and firm elasticity the first. A pricing decision by one seller depends on the first, and borrowing the second is a common misreading on this topic.
Does this mean the chain should never raise its price?
No. The implied elasticity is a chain-wide average, and clubs with no nearby rival may face much less responsive demand than clubs beside a competitor. A rise could pay in some locations and lose in others. The example argues only that the consultant's evidence cannot support a chain-wide increase, and that a firm-level estimate, ideally split by competitive setting, should come before any price moves.
Where can I find a free DBA 815 Topic 2 sample paper?
The elasticity analysis is printed here in full: the recommendation, what the estimate measures, the markup check, why minus 0.4 fails, the increase recomputed, why the error is easy, variation across clubs, limits and the recommendation. Send the elasticity your case relies on and an analysis follows at no cost.
Why can a single seller not have an elasticity of minus 0.4 in DBA 815 Topic 2?
A firm facing inelastic demand for its own product could always raise profit by raising price, so a profit-seeking firm never prices where its own demand is inelastic.