| Course | DBA 815 Economics for Business Decisions |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 3 |
| Paper type | Rival cost structure comparison |
| Length | About 1,010 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | DBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for DBA 815 Topic 3
Twelve Dollars Now, Forty-Six Later: Comparing a Fitness Chain's Cost Structure With a Fifteen-Dollar Entrant's and What the Time Horizon Decides
[Author Name]
College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University
DBA-815: Economics for Business Decisions
Topic 3 Rival Cost Structure Comparison
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Twelve Dollars Now, Forty-Six Later: Comparing a Fitness Chain's Cost Structure With a Fifteen-Dollar Entrant's and What the Time Horizon Decides
The Question
A low-price fitness entrant has opened three clubs in the region charging 15 dollars a month, against the composite chain's 49. The chain's board wants to know whether it can compete on price if it must. The answer depends on two cost structures and, above all, on the time horizon. This comparison builds both cost structures, separates costs the chain can avoid from those it cannot over different periods and draws a verdict. Figures are illustrative.
Two Cost Builds
A typical chain club carries about 91,000 dollars a month in fixed costs: the lease, a staffed front desk and fitness floor for long opening hours, utilities, equipment leases and its share of the chain's central marketing and administration. It serves about 2,700 members, so fixed cost runs near 34 dollars per member each month. Variable cost, the cost that rises with each member-month covering cleaning, laundry, equipment wear and card fees, comes to about 12 dollars. Average cost per member is therefore about 46 dollars. The entrant's clubs are larger, open around the clock with minimal staff and no towels or classes, and carry about 55,000 dollars a month in fixed costs with a variable cost near 4 dollars. At 5,000 members, its fixed cost is 11 dollars per member and its average cost 15 dollars, which is its price: it breaks even once it reaches that size.
Table 1
Monthly Cost Structures per Club, Illustrative
| Item | Chain club | Entrant club |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed cost per month | About 91,000 dollars | About 55,000 dollars |
| Members | About 2,700 | About 5,000 at maturity |
| Fixed cost per member | About 34 dollars | About 11 dollars |
| Variable cost per member | About 12 dollars | About 4 dollars |
| Average cost per member | About 46 dollars | About 15 dollars |
| Price | 49 dollars | 15 dollars |
Why the Entrant's Costs Are Lower
The entrant's cost advantage comes from design, not efficiency in running the same model. It offers fewer services, needs far fewer staff per member and spreads a lower fixed cost over almost twice as many members. Porter (1980) described cost leadership as built on such structural choices, which an established firm cannot copy quickly without changing what it sells. The chain's higher costs buy classes, staffed hours and amenities its members value; they are not waste. But they mean the chain cannot match 15 dollars and cover its costs under its current model.
The Horizon Does the Work
Whether the chain can fight on price depends on which of its costs it can avoid over the period in question (Frank, 2014). Over the next twelve months, its leases are signed and its core staff are committed; those costs will be paid whether it keeps members or loses them. The only cost it avoids by losing a member is the 12 dollars of variable cost. In the short run, then, the chain's price floor is about 12 dollars: any price above that adds to contribution toward costs it must pay anyway, and it could match almost any rival price for months without making its losses worse than standing still. Over three years, the picture changes. Leases come up for renewal, staffing levels can be cut, central costs can be reduced, and nearly everything becomes avoidable. The long-run floor rises toward the full average cost of about 46 dollars, below which the chain cannot keep its clubs open indefinitely.
What Each Firm Can Sustain
The entrant faces the same logic with lower numbers. Its short-run floor is 4 dollars and its long-run floor about 15. A price war at, say, 25 dollars would be painful but sustainable for the chain in the short run, since 25 dollars more than covers its 12 dollars of avoidable cost, and comfortable for the entrant, which covers its full costs at that price. Over three years, a war at 25 dollars would leave the chain unable to cover its long-run costs while the entrant profits. Tirole (1988) noted that price wars are won by the firm whose costs allow it to sustain low prices longest, and here that is the entrant.
The Entrant's Vulnerable Period
The entrant's cost advantage depends on reaching about 5,000 members per club. Before it does, its fixed cost per member is higher: at 2,500 members, about 22 dollars, so its average cost is about 26 dollars against a 15 dollar price. In its first year, then, the entrant is losing money on every club and relies on its backers' patience. A chain price response during that period would hurt the entrant more than at maturity. That is the strongest economic case for a short, targeted response now, and it carries a risk: if the entrant's backers expect losses in year one anyway, a price war may not change their plans, and the chain will have spent contribution without effect.
Verdict
The chain can fight a short price war and cannot survive a long one. A temporary match or discount near contested clubs could slow the entrant's growth during its first year, when it has not yet reached the membership it needs to break even, but committing to sustained prices near the entrant's would erode the chain's ability to cover its costs as leases renew. The chain's sustainable response is to compete on what its higher costs buy, classes, staffing and service, and to aim its price defense where the entrant's members are most likely to come from, rather than across all fourteen clubs.
Conclusion
The chain's average cost of about 46 dollars per member reflects a staffed, amenity-rich model; the entrant's 15 dollars reflects a lean model at scale. Over the next year, with leases and core staff committed, the chain can price down to its 12 dollars of avoidable cost and still add contribution, so a short fight is affordable. Over three years nearly every cost becomes avoidable and the floor rises toward 46 dollars, so a long fight is not. The horizon, not the size of the gap, decides what the chain can do.
References
Frank, R. H. (2014). Microeconomics and behavior (9th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.
Porter, M. E. (1980). Competitive strategy: Techniques for analyzing industries and competitors. Free Press.
Tirole, J. (1988). The theory of industrial organization. MIT Press.
What the DBA 815 Topic 3 instructions ask for
In Topic 3, DBA-815 asks doctoral students to compare their firm's cost structure with a rival's and judge what price competition each can sustain. Strong comparisons build both cost structures with fixed and variable costs per customer, explain where the rival's advantage comes from and separate costs that are avoidable over different horizons. Students should state short-run and long-run price floors for each firm, consider the rival's vulnerable period before it reaches scale and reach a verdict on what kind of price competition the firm can afford.
How the DBA-815 Topic 3 example is put together
Two cost builds sit side by side in the finished comparison, figures illustrative. A typical chain club carries about $91,000 a month in lease, staff, utilities and its share of central costs, and serves some 2,700 members, so fixed cost runs near $34 per member, plus about $12 variable. The entrant's larger, lightly staffed club carries about $55,000 and a variable cost near $4, so it breaks even at $15 once it holds 5,000 members. Horizon does the work. Over the next year the chain's leases and core staff are committed, so its floor is the $12 it can avoid, and it could match almost any price for months. Over three years nearly everything becomes avoidable and the floor rises toward $46. The verdict: the chain can fight a short price war and cannot survive a long one.
Where the marks sit in the DBA 815 Topic 3 rubric
Faculty reward cost structures read through the time horizon. An Excellent paper tables both firms' fixed, variable and average costs per member. Credit goes to locating the entrant's advantage in design, following Porter on cost leadership. The rubric values a short-run floor at avoidable cost and a long-run floor near average cost, with Frank on avoidable cost and Tirole on who wins price wars. Strong papers examine the entrant before it reaches scale. Top marks go to a verdict distinguishing a short fight from a long one.
DBA 815 Topic 3 help: mistakes that cost marks
Cost comparisons that stop at the entrant's low price, without building its cost per member, cannot say whether $15 is a strategy or a promotion. Papers reasoning about the chain's costs without a horizon can prove anything, since a twelve-month view makes nearly every price look affordable and a three-year view makes most look ruinous. A frequent slip counts past equipment purchases in the price floor; that money is sunk and plays no part in what the chain can charge. Scale is often asserted rather than computed, when the 5,000-member breakeven is what reveals the entrant's dependence on volume. Treating classes and childcare as extra cost, rather than as scope economies that share fixed space, misreads where the chain's advantage lies. Recommendations to match the entrant's price ignore the three-year floor the paper itself derived.
Get a DBA-815 Topic 3 example written to your instructions
Send the DBA-815 Topic 3 instructions and the rubric your classroom posts, with any cost data or case the assignment names. A custom example is written to those criteria, with both firms' costs built line by line, floors stated at two horizons, scale and scope computed and each structure's permitted moves set out, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More DBA 815 papers and DBA samples
- DBA 815 Topic 1: Decision Sorting Memo
- DBA 815 Topic 2: Own-price Elasticity Analysis
- DBA 815 Topic 4: Local Pricing Power Analysis
- DBA 815 Topic 5: Elasticity Estimation Dq Post
- DBA 815 Topic 6: Repeated Pricing Game Analysis
- DBA 815 Topic 7: Tested Price Recommendation
- DBA 815 Topic 8: Executive Pricing Brief
- DBA 805 Topic 3: Construct Measurability Critique
- MKT 838 Topic 3: Peer Effects Literature Review
- MKT 834 Topic 3: Online Experiment Protocol
DBA 815 Topic 3 questions, answered
What is the difference between economies of scale and scope?
Economies of scale lower cost per unit as one activity grows, as when the entrant spreads a fixed club budget across more members. Economies of scope lower cost when different activities share inputs, as when the chain's classes, childcare and pool use the same building and front desk. The example uses scale to explain the entrant's price and scope to explain what the chain can offer that the entrant cannot cheaply add.
Why build costs at two horizons?
Because which costs are fixed depends on how far ahead the decision looks. Within a year the chain's leases and core staff are committed, so any price above variable cost covers everything it could avoid. Across three years those commitments expire and must be renewed or dropped, so the sustainable price has to cover them. A single horizon hides one of these two facts, and the example needs both to judge a price war.
Should the chain match the entrant's $15 price?
Not on these costs. It could hold such a price for months while its commitments run, but not beyond lease renewal, where its full cost per member sits near $46 and the entrant's near $13 at volume. A match the chain cannot sustain teaches members to expect a price it will later withdraw. The example points the response toward the bundle of classes and childcare that the entrant's structure excludes.
Where can I find a free DBA 815 Topic 3 sample paper?
The cost comparison is shown here complete: the question, two cost builds, why the entrant's costs are lower, the horizon, what each firm can sustain, the vulnerable period, the verdict and the conclusion. Share your firm's and a rival's cost figures and a comparison follows free.
Why is the chain's short-run floor only 12 dollars in DBA 815 Topic 3?
Its leases and core staff are committed for the year, so losing a member saves only the 12 dollars of variable cost. Any price above that adds contribution.