| Course | DBA 815 Economics for Business Decisions |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 5 |
| Paper type | Elasticity estimation discussion post |
| Length | About 450 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Discussion post, APA 7 citations |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | DBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for DBA 815 Topic 5
Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post and Reply
Buy the Estimate With a Test: Why the Fitness Chain's Own Data Cannot Reveal Its Price Elasticity
Initial Post
My position: the chain should buy its elasticity estimate with a price test, because the data it already holds cannot supply one.
The obstacle is timing. Every price increase the chain has made took effect in January, alongside its heaviest advertising and the year's surge of new joiners. Any change in joins after an increase therefore mixes the effect of price with the effect of the season and the advertising, and there is no year in which price changed without them. Comparing clubs that charge the same price but sit in areas with different incomes fails for a similar reason: income affects demand directly, so differences in joins across those clubs cannot be attributed to price. Angrist and Pischke (2009) describe this as the core problem of observational data: the variation that would identify the effect is entangled with other causes.
A test separates them. I propose six pairs of clubs, matched on size and competitive setting, running for eight weeks outside January. At one club in each pair, new members are offered 54 dollars a month; at the other, 49, with figures illustrative. Existing members keep their current rate, which avoids provoking cancellations among people who joined at a different price. Joins are compared within each pair, so season, advertising and local conditions affect both arms equally. Kohavi et al. (2020) stress that tests should fix their success measure and duration in advance, so the measure here is set now: new members per week, and the contribution each cohort produces.
The concession: eight weeks measures how many people join at each price, not how long they stay. A higher price may attract fewer but more committed members, or more who cancel early. So the test must follow the 54 dollar cohort for six months before any conclusion about contribution is drawn. My question for the class: would you randomize at the level of clubs, as I propose, or at the level of individual prospects, and what would each choice cost?
Reply to Taylor
Taylor, you suggest skipping the test and estimating elasticity from the chain's five past January increases with a regression controlling for season. I agree a model is cheaper. But every increase coincided with January, so the model has no variation in timing to separate price from season; any control for January absorbs the price effect along with it. The regression would report a number with a standard error, and the number would be wrong in a way the output cannot show. Would you accept a smaller test, perhaps three pairs instead of six, if cost is the concern?
References
Angrist, J. D., & Pischke, J.-S. (2009). Mostly harmless econometrics: An empiricist's companion. Princeton University Press.
Kohavi, R., Tang, D., & Xu, Y. (2020). Trustworthy online controlled experiments: A practical guide to A/B testing. Cambridge University Press.
The DBA-815 Topic 5 assignment instructions
Topic 5 in DBA-815 asks doctoral students to propose in a discussion post how to estimate demand elasticity. Strong posts state a position early, explain why existing data cannot identify the effect by naming the specific confounds, and propose a design that removes them with its unit of comparison, duration and outcome stated in advance. Students should concede what the design cannot measure, commit to following up, pose a question about design choices to classmates and answer a peer's alternative with a concrete reason.
How the DBA-815 Topic 5 example is put together
A position opens the post: the chain should buy its elasticity estimate with a test, because the data it already holds cannot supply one. Each of the chain's past increases took effect in January, alongside its heaviest advertising and the year's surge of new joiners, so any change in joins mixes the price with the season. Comparing clubs with different local incomes fails for a similar reason. The proposal follows. Six pairs of clubs, matched on size and competitive setting, run for eight weeks with new members at one club of each pair offered $54 and at the other $49, figures illustrative, while existing members keep their rate. Joins are compared within pairs. The post concedes that eight weeks measures the join response rather than year-long retention, and commits to following the $54 cohort for six months.
Where the marks sit in the DBA 815 Topic 5 rubric
Faculty reward a design matched to the confound. An Excellent post shows that every past increase coincided with January, with Angrist and Pischke on identification. Credit goes to six matched pairs testing new members only, outside January, with outcomes fixed in advance as Kohavi and colleagues recommend. The rubric values conceding that eight weeks measures joins, not retention, and committing to six months of follow-up. Strong posts ask peers about randomizing clubs or prospects. Top marks go to a reply explaining why a seasonal control absorbs the price effect.
DBA 815 Topic 5 help: mistakes that cost marks
Answers that list estimation methods, surveys, regressions, experiments, without choosing one for this firm treat the prompt as a request for a menu. Regressing joins on the chain's own past prices is the answer that loses the most, because the January timing means the estimate measures the season as much as the price. Posts that propose a test and apply it to existing members invite churn the test was never meant to cause. Some designs compare different clubs without matching them, so local income and competition contaminate the result the pairing exists to protect. A post that claims the test yields long-run elasticity overstates eight weeks of join data. Stated-preference surveys offered as the whole answer rely on what people say they would pay, which pricing research has long treated as a weaker guide than what they actually do.
Get a DBA-815 Topic 5 example written to your instructions
Send the DBA-815 Topic 5 discussion question as your classroom words it, with the participation rubric and any firm or data the prompt supplies. We write a custom example to those requirements, with a method chosen and defended, the confounds in existing data named, the test designed and its limits conceded, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More DBA 815 papers and DBA samples
- DBA 815 Topic 1: Decision Sorting Memo
- DBA 815 Topic 2: Own-price Elasticity Analysis
- DBA 815 Topic 3: Rival Cost Structure Comparison
- DBA 815 Topic 4: Local Pricing Power Analysis
- DBA 815 Topic 6: Repeated Pricing Game Analysis
- DBA 815 Topic 7: Tested Price Recommendation
- DBA 815 Topic 8: Executive Pricing Brief
- DBA 805 Topic 5: Weak Theory Persistence Dq Post
- MKT 838 Topic 5: Contribution Claim Dq Post
- MKT 834 Topic 5: Test Abandonment Dq Post
DBA 815 Topic 5 questions, answered
Why can't the chain use its own price history?
Because nothing about its past increases was random. Each took effect in January, when advertising peaks and new joiners arrive in large numbers for reasons unrelated to price. Any movement in joins after an increase therefore blends the price effect with the season and the promotion. Economists call this an identification problem: the data exist, but they cannot separate the one cause the chain needs to measure from the others that moved with it.
Why match clubs in pairs?
So that whatever differs between locations, local income, nearby rivals, club size, is held roughly equal within each comparison. Both clubs in a pair face the same season and similar competition, so a gap in joins between them can be attributed to the price difference. Which club in each pair receives the higher price is assigned at random, so the chain's own hunches about location cannot steer the result.
Is charging new members different prices fair?
The objection deserves an answer rather than dismissal. Members do judge prices by fairness as well as amount, and a visible difference at the front desk can cost goodwill. The post limits the test to new members, keeps it to eight weeks, and notes that prices commonly vary by location across the fitness industry. Existing members pay what they paid before, which is where fairness complaints are most likely to arise.
Where can I find a free DBA 815 Topic 5 sample paper?
Both the opening post and the response appear in full: the position, why existing data fail, the test design, the concession, a question for peers and the reply on regression. Paste the discussion prompt your seminar posted and a post follows free.
Why can the chain's past increases not reveal elasticity in DBA 815 Topic 5?
Every increase took effect in January with heavy advertising and peak joining, so price and season cannot be separated in the data.