| Course | DBA 815 Economics for Business Decisions |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 8 |
| Paper type | Executive pricing brief |
| Length | About 840 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | DBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for DBA 815 Topic 8
Memorandum
To: Executive Committee
From: Director of Strategy and Analytics
Date: [Date]
Re: New-member pricing at the six uncontested clubs
Decision Requested
Approve a monthly rate of 54 dollars for new members at the six clubs that face no nearby rival, hold 49 dollars at the other eight clubs and leave every existing member's rate unchanged. Every supporting claim below is labeled measured, inferred or assumed, so the committee can see which parts rest on the test and which on judgment. Figures are illustrative.
The Trade-Off at a Typical Uncontested Club
The table shows both sides of the decision in one place, so that neither the lost joiners nor the added margin carries the argument alone.
Table 1
One Uncontested Club's Monthly Cohort at Each Price, Illustrative
| Measure | At 49 dollars | At 54 dollars | Label |
|---|---|---|---|
| New members joining per month | About 110 | About 104 | Measured in the price test |
| Still paying after six months | About 83 percent | About 81 percent | Measured |
| Contribution per member per month | About 37 dollars | About 42 dollars | Measured from costs |
| Six-month cohort contribution | Baseline | About 5 percent higher | Inferred from the rows above |
Why the Higher Price Earns More
Measured: about six fewer people join each month at the higher price, and slightly more of them cancel within six months. Measured: each member who stays contributes about 5 dollars more per month. Inferred: the extra margin on those who stay outweighs the members lost, so each monthly cohort contributes about 5 percent more over six months. Across six clubs, that is a meaningful gain without changing any existing member's price. Inferred: because each month brings a new cohort, the gain accumulates as more members join at the new rate, while the members already paying 49 dollars continue unchanged. The full effect therefore arrives gradually over the next year rather than in the first month.
What This Decision Does Not Include
The brief does not propose raising existing members' rates; the test measured only new members, and an increase for current members would be a different decision with different risks. It does not propose any change at the eight contested clubs. And it does not commit the chain to a further increase, though a separate test of 59 dollars at two uncontested pairs is planned and will come back to this committee with its own results.
Question One: Why Not Every Club?
Measured: at the two test pairs near the regional rival, joins fell by about a quarter at the higher price, enough that contribution fell. Measured: at the one pair near the 15 dollar entrant, joins fell about 12 percent; one pair is too few to decide on, so that setting is held at 49 dollars until it is tested again. Inferred: a single price across all fourteen clubs would lose members where substitutes are close and leave money unearned where they are not. Pricing to each club's competitive setting is what the evidence supports (Nagle & Müller, 2018).
Question Two: What If Members Leave Later?
Measured: cancellations were tracked for six months, not longer. Assumed: the gap in cancellation between the two prices does not widen sharply after six months. If it did, the gain would shrink. The brief therefore commits finance to follow the cohorts for a full year and to report quarterly, so the assumption is tested rather than relied upon.
Question Three: What Will the Regional Rival Do?
Measured: the rival copied the chain's joining-fee waiver two years ago, within three weeks of its launch. Inferred: the rival watches the chain's prices at clubs it competes with and responds quickly. That is why the recommendation leaves prices unchanged at the five clubs the rival overlaps; the six uncontested clubs sit outside the rival's catchment, where a change gives it little reason to react (Tirole, 1988). The answer rests on the rival's past behavior, not on a model.
Timing and Cost of Implementation
Assumed: the new rate can be introduced at the start of next month, outside the January joining season, with changes to the website, the joining forms at six front desks and the scripts staff use when prospects ask about price. Measured: marketing estimates the cost of these changes at under 5,000 dollars. Inferred: at the expected gain per cohort, that cost is recovered within the first month. Staff at the six clubs will receive a short explanation of local pricing so they can answer members who notice that other clubs charge less.
Signals That Would Reverse the Decision
Each signal has an owner. If new-member joins at the six clubs fall more than 10 percent below the same months last year, the chief financial officer will recommend returning to 49 dollars. If six-month cancellations exceed 22 percent, the head of member services will review the rate. If a rival opens within twelve minutes of one of the six clubs, the director of strategy will move that club into the contested group and test again. Results will be reviewed with this group monthly for the first two quarters, following practice for monitoring a change after a controlled test (Kohavi et al., 2020).
References
Kohavi, R., Tang, D., & Xu, Y. (2020). Trustworthy online controlled experiments: A practical guide to A/B testing. Cambridge University Press.
Nagle, T. T., & Müller, G. (2018). The strategy and tactics of pricing: A guide to growing more profitably (6th ed.). Routledge.
Tirole, J. (1988). The theory of industrial organization. MIT Press.
Reading the GCU DBA 815 Topic 8 instructions
Topic 8 of DBA-815 asks doctoral students to write an executive brief on a pricing decision. Strong briefs state the decision in one sentence, show the trade-off in a small table so neither side carries the vote alone, and label every claim as measured, inferred or assumed. Students should answer the questions executives have actually raised, rest predictions about rivals on their past behavior, say what the decision does not include and close with reversal signals, each with an owner. Implementation cost and timing belong in the brief, since executives will ask.
How this DBA 815 Topic 8 example is built
Two pages hold the whole argument. The first opens with the decision in one sentence, then a small table for a typical uncontested club, figures illustrative: about 110 joiners a month at $49 against 104 at $54, and a six-month cohort contribution about 5 percent higher at the higher price. Six fewer joiners and the extra margin appear in the same line, so neither framing carries the vote alone. Each supporting claim is labeled measured, inferred or assumed, in those words. The second page answers the three questions the executives raised in earlier meetings: why not every club, what happens if members leave later, and what the regional rival will do. That last answer cites the waiver the rival matched, not a model. Reversal signals close the brief, each with an owner.
Reading the DBA 815 Topic 8 rubric
Faculty reward a brief executives can act on and check. An Excellent brief opens with the decision and a table of joiners and cohort contribution at each price. Credit goes to labeling every claim measured, inferred or assumed. The rubric values answers to three executive questions, pricing by setting as Nagle and Müller advise and the rival's response inferred from its past behavior, with Tirole. Strong briefs state what is not being decided and the cost of implementation. Top marks go to reversal signals with named owners and monthly review.
Common DBA 815 Topic 8 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Executives handed an elasticity and a payoff matrix have received the analyst's working instead of a decision, and briefs built that way lose the most. The opposite failure strips out the uncertainty along with the vocabulary, presenting a six-month result as settled while twelve-month retention is still assumed. Briefs reporting only the members lost invite a no vote on framing alone, and briefs reporting only contribution gained look as though they hide the cost the head of membership will find. Answering the rival question with equilibrium reasoning, rather than with what the rival did after the joining-fee waiver, speaks past the person asking. A brief without reversal signals requests a permanent commitment to a change tested for six months. Some papers bury the recommendation beneath pages of background, inverting the order these readers need.
Get a DBA-815 Topic 8 example written to your instructions
Send the DBA-815 Topic 8 instructions and your classroom rubric, with the recommendation, audience or case the assignment names. The custom example is written to those requirements in 24 to 48 hours, with the decision stated first, consequences shown at each price, every claim graded by its evidence and the reversal signals assigned to owners. The first one is free.
More DBA 815 papers and DBA samples
- DBA 815 Topic 1: Decision Sorting Memo
- DBA 815 Topic 2: Own-price Elasticity Analysis
- DBA 815 Topic 3: Rival Cost Structure Comparison
- DBA 815 Topic 4: Local Pricing Power Analysis
- DBA 815 Topic 5: Elasticity Estimation Dq Post
- DBA 815 Topic 6: Repeated Pricing Game Analysis
- DBA 815 Topic 7: Tested Price Recommendation
- DBA 805 Topic 8: Theoretical Position Defense
- MKT 838 Topic 8: Interaction-aware Budget Recommendation
- MKT 834 Topic 8: Contrary Evidence Decision Defense
DBA 815 Topic 8 questions, answered
Why put the member loss and the contribution gain in one line?
Because the same outcome can win or lose a vote depending on how it is described. Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman showed that people choose differently between identical options when those options are framed as gains or as losses. A brief leading with six lost joiners invites a no, and one leading with higher contribution invites a yes. Stating both together leaves the executives deciding on the trade itself.
Where do the elasticities go if not in the brief?
Into a short technical note the analyst keeps for questions, holding the test design, the six-month elasticities by setting and the payoff matrix for the overlap clubs. The executives are not asked to evaluate a coefficient. They are asked to evaluate consequences and conditions, and every condition in the brief, such as the rival holding its price, traces back to a figure in that note.
What do the labels measured, inferred and assumed mean?
Measured claims come from the chain's own test, such as the drop in joins at $54. Inferred claims are derived from other numbers, such as the elasticity implied by current margins. Assumed claims have no evidence yet, such as twelve-month retention of the $54 cohort. The labels tell executives how much weight each claim can bear, which is the evidence standard a firm should apply before acting on an economic argument.
Where can I find a free DBA 815 Topic 8 sample paper?
Every part of the executive brief appears below: the decision, the trade-off, why the higher price earns more, what is not included, three executive questions, timing and cost, and reversal signals. Share the decision your seminar case requires and a brief follows at no charge.
Why label claims measured, inferred or assumed in DBA 815 Topic 8?
Executives can see which parts rest on the test and which on judgment, so they know where to press before approving.