| Course | DBA 820 Emerging Issues in Financial Management |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 2 |
| Paper type | Crypto treasury policy analysis |
| Length | About 1,000 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | DBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for DBA 820 Topic 2
Clause by Clause: Testing a Proposal to Hold Bitcoin Against the Treasury Policy a Board Already Approved
[Author Name]
College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University
DBA-820: Emerging Issues in Financial Management
Topic 2 Crypto Treasury Policy Analysis
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Clause by Clause: Testing a Proposal to Hold Bitcoin Against the Treasury Policy a Board Already Approved
The Policy as Approved
A composite specialty manufacturer holds about 80 million dollars of cash beyond its operating needs. Its board-approved investment policy ranks three objectives in order: safety of principal first, liquidity second and yield third. It implements them with limits: investments must be issued by entities rated at least A by two rating agencies, or be U.S. Treasury or agency securities; no investment may mature in more than two years; and no more than 10 percent may be held with any single issuer other than the U.S. government. The chief financial officer proposes moving 2 percent of excess cash, about 1.6 million dollars, into bitcoin. This analysis states the proposal's case as its advocate would and then tests it against each clause of the policy the board approved.
The Case for the Proposal
The chief financial officer's case has two parts. First, bitcoin's fixed long-run supply offers protection against the debasement of currencies through monetary expansion, which erodes the purchasing power of cash and short-term bonds. Second, bitcoin's returns have historically shown low correlation with stocks and bonds, so a small holding could diversify the company's financial assets. Research supports part of the second claim: Liu and Tsyvinski (2021) found that cryptocurrency returns had little exposure to the factors that explain stock and currency returns. Whether bitcoin protects against debasement over any horizon relevant to a corporate treasury is less established, since its price has moved far more than any measure of inflation over the same periods.
Testing the Clauses
The rating limit has nothing to attach to. Bitcoin has no issuer and no credit rating; the clause was written for claims on borrowers, and an asset that is not anyone's obligation falls outside it entirely. The maturity limit cannot apply to an instrument that never matures. The concentration limit, likewise written for issuers, does not fit. Liquidity holds in ordinary markets, where large amounts trade continuously, but is uncertain under stress, when exchanges have halted withdrawals and prices have gapped. Safety of principal fails outright. Bitcoin's price fell by roughly three quarters from its late 2021 peak to its low a year later, and its volatility has been many times that of the short-term instruments the policy permits. Yermack (2015) argued that this volatility makes bitcoin behave more like a speculative investment than a currency, which is the relevant point for a treasury whose first objective is preserving principal.
Table 1
The Proposal Tested Against Each Policy Clause
| Policy clause | Applies to bitcoin? | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Safety of principal first | Yes | Fails: large price declines and high volatility |
| Liquidity second | Yes | Holds in normal markets; uncertain under stress |
| Yield third | Partly | No income; any return is price change |
| Issuer rated A or better | No issuer | Cannot be applied |
| Maturity two years or less | No maturity | Cannot be applied |
| Single-issuer limit of 10 percent | No issuer | Cannot be applied |
Risks the Policy Never Contemplated
The policy also says nothing about risks peculiar to the asset. Holding bitcoin requires custody of the private keys that control it; keys lost or stolen mean the asset is gone, with no issuer or insurer to restore it. The company would need either to hold keys itself, with security procedures its treasury staff do not have, or to use a third-party custodian, whose own solvency becomes a risk. The policy's controls, such as dual authorization of wire transfers, have no direct equivalent for moving digital assets.
Accounting Has Changed
The accounting treatment has itself changed recently. Until recently, companies holding bitcoin generally accounted for it as an intangible asset, recording declines in value as impairments but not recognizing increases until sale. A 2023 update from the Financial Accounting Standards Board requires such crypto assets to be carried at fair value, and each period's gains and losses to flow through net income, effective for fiscal years beginning after December 15, 2024 (Financial Accounting Standards Board, 2023). Under the new standard, a bitcoin holding would move the company's reported earnings every quarter, which the board and investors would need to understand before approving it.
Verdict
The proposal cannot be approved under the current policy. Three of its six clauses cannot even be applied to the asset, and the policy's first objective, safety of principal, fails outright. If the board wants to consider the proposal, the correct path is not to stretch the existing policy but to decide whether the company's treasury should hold a speculative asset at all, and if so, to write a separate policy for it with its own size limit, custody requirements, valuation rules and reporting.
What a Separate Policy Would Need
If the board chose to allow a holding, a separate policy would need at least five provisions. A size limit expressed as a share of excess cash that the company could lose entirely without affecting operations or covenants, perhaps 1 to 2 percent. A custody requirement naming acceptable custodians, with segregated accounts, insurance and audited controls. A rule for when the holding is reviewed or sold, set in advance so that decisions are not made in the middle of a price swing. A valuation and reporting procedure under the new accounting standard, including how quarterly gains and losses will be explained to investors. And board approval for any change in the limit. Writing those provisions would force the board to decide explicitly what the holding is for and how much loss it is prepared to accept.
Conclusion
Tested clause by clause, the proposal fails the policy's first objective and falls outside three of its limits, which were written for instruments with issuers and maturities. Custody risk and a change in accounting treatment add considerations the policy never contemplated. The board should not approve the proposal by reinterpreting the existing policy; if it wishes to consider bitcoin at all, it should do so as a separate decision about speculative assets, with a separate policy and a size limit set by how much the company could afford to lose.
References
Financial Accounting Standards Board. (2023). Accounting Standards Update No. 2023-08: Intangibles, goodwill and other, crypto assets (Subtopic 350-60). https://www.fasb.org
Liu, Y., & Tsyvinski, A. (2021). Risks and returns of cryptocurrency. Review of Financial Studies, 34(6), 2689-2727. https://doi.org/10.1093/rfs/hhaa113
Yermack, D. (2015). Is Bitcoin a real currency? An economic appraisal. In D. Lee Kuo Chuen (Ed.), Handbook of digital currency (pp. 31-43). Academic Press. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-802117-0.00002-3
Reading the GCU DBA 820 Topic 2 instructions
The Topic 2 assignment in DBA-820 asks doctoral students to analyze an emerging instrument against an existing financial policy. Strong analyses state the proposal's case as its advocate would, then test it against each clause the board approved rather than judging the instrument in general. Students should identify which clauses apply, which fail and which cannot be applied at all because the instrument lacks the features they assume. The paper should also name risks the policy never contemplated, describe how the accounting treatment has changed, and recommend whether the decision belongs inside the current policy or in a separate one.
How this DBA 820 Topic 2 example is built
The finished analysis starts from the document the board already approved: an investment policy ranking safety of principal first, liquidity second and yield third, with limits set by issuer credit rating and maturity. A composite CFO proposes moving a small share of excess cash into bitcoin, and the paper states her case as she would, as protection against currency debasement and a source of diversification. Each clause is then tested. The rating limit has nothing to attach to, because the asset has no issuer. The maturity limit cannot apply to an instrument that never matures. Liquidity holds in ordinary markets and is uncertain under stress. Safety of principal fails outright on price volatility. The paper also records custody and key-management risk, which the policy never contemplated, and notes that the accounting treatment has itself changed in recent years.
Where the marks sit in the DBA 820 Topic 2 rubric
Faculty reward a policy tested clause by clause. An Excellent paper gives the proposal its strongest case, including the low factor exposure Liu and Tsyvinski reported. Credit goes to a table showing safety failing, yield absent and three limits that cannot be applied to an asset with no issuer or maturity. The rubric values Yermack's doubts about bitcoin as currency, custody risk and the 2023 FASB move to fair value. Strong papers refuse to approve by reinterpretation. Top marks go to a separate policy sized by what the company could afford to lose.
DBA 820 Topic 2 help: mistakes that cost marks
Graders mark down first the paper that declares treasury policy outdated without saying which clause fails. The analysis this topic asks for is local: the rating limit, the maturity limit and the safety objective each break for a different reason, and a paper that cannot say why has not located anything. Advocacy is the second hazard. Stating the debasement argument without the volatility record, or the volatility record without the argument proponents actually make, argues one side of a live dispute. Papers that treat bitcoin's liquidity as settled, in either direction, skip the stress question entirely. Custody is frequently missing, although it is the risk with no precedent anywhere in the policy. Accounting and regulatory treatment described as permanent dates the paper, since both have shifted in recent years and continue to be revised.
Get a DBA-820 Topic 2 example written to your instructions
Send the DBA-820 Topic 2 instructions and your classroom rubric, with the instrument or company case your section assigns. We write a custom example to them, with the existing policy used as the test, each clause checked, custody and stressed liquidity addressed and both sides stated fairly, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More DBA 820 papers and DBA samples
- DBA 820 Topic 1: Esg Evidence Assessment
- DBA 820 Topic 3: Payments Startup Valuation
- DBA 820 Topic 4: Private Credit Risk Analysis
- DBA 820 Topic 5: Trading App Regulation Dq Post
- DBA 820 Topic 6: Climate Disclosure Proposal
- DBA 820 Topic 7: Buyback Position Paper
- DBA 820 Topic 8: Behavioral Finance Argument Paper
- DBA 815 Topic 2: Own-price Elasticity Analysis
- DBA 805 Topic 2: Theory Appraisal Criteria Paper
- MKT 838 Topic 2: Hit Attribution Post-mortem
DBA 820 Topic 2 questions, answered
Why test bitcoin against an existing treasury policy?
Because the policy is the framework the board has already approved, and the course asks where that framework fails. Testing clause by clause shows that most provisions still work for ordinary instruments and that a few break for this one. Naming those few tells a board what must be amended, which is more useful than a general claim that the policy is out of date.
How is bitcoin accounted for on a corporate balance sheet?
Treatment has changed in recent years. Under earlier US practice many companies carried it as an intangible asset subject to impairment, recording declines but not recoveries, and US standard setters have since moved certain crypto assets to fair value measurement. Because the rules continue to be revised and differ across jurisdictions, the example describes the direction of change rather than stating current requirements as fixed.
Should my company hold bitcoin in its treasury?
The example cannot answer that for any real company. The CFO, the policy and the proposal are composites built to show a framework under strain; any actual holding would turn on the company's cash needs, how much risk its board will accept, and its accounting, tax and custody arrangements. Those questions belong with qualified advisers. The analysis is DBA-820 coursework, not investment, accounting or legal advice.
Where can I find a free DBA 820 Topic 2 sample paper?
Every section of the policy analysis appears here: the policy as approved, the case for the proposal, the clause tests, risks the policy never contemplated, accounting, the verdict, what a separate policy would need and the conclusion. Share your company's policy and proposal and an analysis follows at no cost.
Why can some policy clauses not be applied in DBA 820 Topic 2?
Limits on issuer rating, maturity and single-issuer exposure assume a security issued by someone and repaid on a date. Bitcoin has neither, so those clauses neither pass nor fail it; they simply say nothing.