| Course | DBA 835 The Sustainable Future |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 1 |
| Paper type | Sustainability definition paper |
| Length | About 1,000 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | DBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for DBA 835 Topic 1
What the Distributor Promised: Testing Three Definitions of Sustainable Against Trucks, Cold Storage and Food That Expires
[Author Name]
College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University
DBA-835: The Sustainable Future
Topic 1 Sustainability Definition Paper
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
What the Distributor Promised: Testing Three Definitions of Sustainable Against Trucks, Cold Storage and Food That Expires
The Promise and the Board's Question
A composite food-service distributor, which delivers to about 6,000 restaurants, schools and hospitals from five refrigerated warehouses with a fleet of 310 trucks, announced last year that it would become a sustainable company by 2030. The statement drew praise from customers and no objection from anyone, which is a sign it committed the company to little anyone could check. The board has now asked what, exactly, it has promised. This paper tests three definitions of sustainability against the distributor's actual operations and keeps the one that can be measured and reported honestly. The operations that matter are refrigerated trucks burning diesel, warehouses kept at or below freezing around the clock, refrigerant that leaks from cooling systems, food that expires in storage, and drivers working long routes that begin before dawn. Figures are illustrative.
The Brundtland Definition: A Purpose Without a Measure
The most widely quoted definition comes from the World Commission on Environment and Development (1987), which described sustainable development as development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs. The definition states a purpose that almost everyone accepts, and its emphasis on future generations rightly directs attention to impacts that outlast the people causing them. But it was written for nations, and it gives a firm nothing to count. It does not say which needs, how compromise would be recognized or what share of a global problem belongs to one distributor. A board asked to report against it could claim compliance with almost any record.
The Triple Bottom Line: Wider, but Without a Common Unit
Elkington (1994) proposed that firms account for social and environmental performance alongside financial performance, a framing later known as the triple bottom line. Its contribution was to widen the question beyond profit and to insist that impacts be accounted for, not just intended. For the distributor it would mean reporting emissions, safety and community effects beside earnings.
Its weakness is measurement. Tonnes of carbon dioxide, hours of driver fatigue, kilograms of wasted food and dollars of profit share no common unit. Any attempt to combine them into a net score requires exchange rates between them, how many tonnes of emissions offset one serious injury, and those rates are value judgments disguised as arithmetic. A single figure hides what was traded away. Elkington (2018) himself later called for the concept to be rethought, arguing that it had become an accounting and reporting exercise rather than the push for systemic change Elkington had intended.
An Operational Definition
The paper keeps a third definition: the distributor is becoming more sustainable to the extent that it reduces a named set of its own impacts, each measured in its own unit, reported side by side without a combined score, and each marked as aligned with cost savings, opposed to them or uncertain. Five impacts are named, chosen because they are the largest the distributor causes and because it controls them. Fleet emissions are measured as tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent from diesel, drawn from fuel cards. Refrigerant emissions are measured from the quantities purchased to recharge systems, converted at each refrigerant's warming potential. Warehouse energy comes from utility bills. Food loss is measured as tonnes written off as expired or damaged, from inventory records. Driver safety is measured as preventable collisions and hours-of-service violations per million miles, from telematics and compliance logs.
The definition deliberately leaves out the emissions of the farms and processors that supply the food, even though they are larger than the distributor's own. The distributor cannot measure them with any precision and has little control over them, and including them now would make the headline figures depend on estimates rather than records. They are named as a later addition, once supplier data can support them.
Where Savings and Impacts Align, and Where They Part
The definition's value is that it shows where the distributor's interests point in the same direction as its impacts and where they do not. Several actions pay for themselves, and the distributor should take them regardless of its promise. Others cost money, and the definition makes that visible.
Table 1
Sustainability Actions by Alignment With Cost, Illustrative
| Action | Impact reduced | Effect on cost | Alignment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Route optimization and idle limits | Fleet emissions, driver hours | Lower fuel and overtime | Aligned |
| Refrigerant leak detection and repair | Refrigerant emissions | Lower recharge purchases | Aligned |
| Warehouse lighting and door seals | Warehouse energy | Lower utility bills | Aligned |
| Electric refrigerated trucks | Fleet emissions | Higher capital cost; payback uncertain | Uncertain |
| Donating near-expiry food | Food loss | Added handling and transport | Opposed, modestly |
Electric refrigerated trucks illustrate the uncertain case. Each costs well over twice as much as a diesel truck, its range limits it to shorter urban routes, and its payback depends on electricity prices, maintenance savings and incentives that change from year to year. Food donation illustrates the opposed case. Writing off expired food costs the distributor its purchase price either way; donating it before expiry reduces loss but adds sorting, handling and delivery to food banks, a modest net cost the distributor would not incur for financial reasons alone.
What the Definition Obliges the Board to Report
Adopting this definition obliges the board to report each of the five impacts every year in its own unit, with the method and data source stated, and to report the actions taken and their cost. It obliges the board to report impacts that cost money to improve, including the ones where it decides not to spend. It forbids describing the company as sustainable on the strength of aligned actions alone, since those would have been taken for financial reasons anyway. And it requires the board to say, when it declines an action such as electric trucks, why it declined and what would change its decision. That is a narrower promise than the one announced, but it is one the board can keep and others can check.
References
Elkington, J. (1994). Towards the sustainable corporation: Win-win-win business strategies for sustainable development. California Management Review, 36(2), 90-100. https://doi.org/10.2307/41165746
Elkington, J. (2018, June 25). 25 years ago I coined the phrase "triple bottom line." Here's why it's time to rethink it. Harvard Business Review. https://hbr.org/2018/06/25-years-ago-i-coined-the-phrase-triple-bottom-line-heres-why-im-giving-up-on-it
World Commission on Environment and Development. (1987). Our common future. Oxford University Press.
The DBA-835 Topic 1 assignment instructions
Topic 1 in DBA-835 asks doctoral students to turn a sustainability commitment into a definition that can be measured. Strong papers test well-known definitions against the organization's actual operations rather than in the abstract, crediting what each contributes and naming where it fails to supply a measure. Students should explain why combining unlike impacts into one score hides trade-offs, then build an operational definition from named impacts with units and data sources. The paper should show where savings and impacts align and where they part, and state what the definition obliges leaders to report, including the impacts that cost money to improve.
Inside the DBA 835 Topic 1 example
The finished paper tests three definitions against the distributor's actual operations: refrigerated trucks, cold warehouses, refrigerant, food that expires in storage and drivers on long routes. The Brundtland Commission's definition, meeting present needs without compromising those of future generations, sets the purpose but gives a firm nothing to count. Elkington's triple bottom line adds three accounts, and the paper notes that Elkington himself later called for the concept to be rethought because it had become a reporting exercise. Its measurement problem is that carbon, safety and profit share no common unit, so any single net score hides what was traded away. The paper keeps a third definition: named impacts measured in their own units, reported side by side, with each marked as aligned with cost savings, opposed to them or uncertain.
DBA 835 Topic 1 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Faculty reward a promise turned into measures. An Excellent paper credits the Brundtland Commission's purpose while showing it gives a firm nothing to count. Credit goes to Elkington's triple bottom line and its missing common unit, with Elkington's later call to rethink it. The rubric values five impacts with units and data sources and a table marking each action as aligned, uncertain or opposed to cost. Strong papers explain why supplier farm emissions wait for data. Top marks go to obliging the board to report costly impacts and declined actions.
Common DBA 835 Topic 1 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Papers on this opening topic lose the most by adopting a definition no one could ever measure and then proceeding as if it had been measured. Quoting the Brundtland definition and moving on leaves the distributor with a purpose and no test. Adopting the triple bottom line without facing the unit problem invites a net score that can rise while emissions climb, provided profit rises faster. The advocacy version, in which every sustainable choice is also the cheaper one, skips the electric truck decision that the case sets up precisely because its payback is uncertain. Definitions built from the issues the firm already performs well on quietly exclude the ones it does not. Attributing to Elkington a rejection of sustainability, rather than a critique of how his concept came to be used, misstates his argument.
Get a DBA-835 Topic 1 example written to your instructions
Send the DBA-835 Topic 1 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with the company or industry case your section assigned. We write a custom example to them, with competing definitions tested against measurement, the unit problem faced, impacts sorted by cost direction and the reporting duty stated, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More DBA 835 papers and DBA samples
- DBA 835 Topic 2: Materiality Assessment
- DBA 835 Topic 3: Emissions Baseline Reconstruction
- DBA 835 Topic 4: Disclosure Obligation Map
- DBA 835 Topic 5: Profit Divergence Dq Post
- DBA 835 Topic 6: Supplier Influence Map
- DBA 835 Topic 7: Circularity Claim Test
- DBA 835 Topic 8: Transition Risk Position Paper
- DBA 833 Topic 1: Prediction Goal Framing Paper
- DBA 831 Topic 1: Research Question Refinement Paper
- DBA 820 Topic 1: Esg Evidence Assessment
- MGT 805 Topic 1: Structural Trade-off Essay
DBA 835 Topic 1 questions, answered
What is the triple bottom line?
A framing introduced by John Elkington in the 1990s that asks firms to account for social and environmental performance alongside financial results, often summarized as people, planet and profit. It widened the question managers asked. Its weakness for measurement is that the three accounts have no common unit, and Elkington later argued that the idea had too often become a reporting routine rather than a prompt for change.
Why not combine sustainability measures into one score?
Because combining carbon, safety and financial figures requires weights, and the weights decide the result. A single score lets improvement in one area conceal deterioration in another, which is the trade-off the course wants made visible. The example reports each impact in its own unit and marks whether improving it saves or costs money, leaving the weighing to the board where it can be seen.
Can this definition be used for a real company's commitment?
Not directly. The distributor is a composite, and a real definition would rest on the company's actual operations, its data systems and the disclosure rules that apply where it operates. The example shows the reasoning DBA-835 expects, testing definitions against what can be measured and stating trade-offs openly, as coursework rather than sustainability reporting or legal advice.
Where can I find a free DBA 835 Topic 1 sample paper?
The definition paper is shown here complete: the promise and the board's question, the Brundtland test, the triple bottom line, an operational definition, where savings and impacts align and what the board must report. Share your DBA 835 Topic 1 prompt for a free paper.
Why are farm emissions left out at first in DBA 835 Topic 1?
The distributor cannot measure them precisely and controls them little, so including them would make headline figures rest on estimates. They are named as a later addition once supplier data can support them.