DBA 835 Topic 2 materiality assessment example

The Sustainable Future Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This DBA 835 Topic 2 sample paper narrows a composite regional trucking company's survey of twenty-two sustainability issues, nearly all rated important, to five. It belongs to GCU DBA 835, The Sustainable Future, listed as DBA-835, a requirement of the Grand Canyon University DBA. Financial and impact materiality are applied separately. The SASB road transportation standard supplies emissions, air quality, driver conditions and safety, Khan, Serafeim and Yoon explain why narrowing matters, and data security is added. A table rates each survivor on both tests. Depot exhaust near homes and a school scores low financially but high on impact, and the company owes it attention anyway.

CourseDBA 835 The Sustainable Future
TopicTopic 2
Paper typeMateriality assessment
LengthAbout 1,000 words, 2 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramDBA
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for DBA 835 Topic 2

1

From Twenty-Two Issues to Five: A Materiality Assessment for a Regional Trucking Company, and the Depot Exhaust the Tests Disagree On

[Author Name]

College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University

DBA-835: The Sustainable Future

Topic 2 Materiality Assessment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states what the assessment narrows and the issue it ends on. The company and every figure are a composite, labeled illustrative; the sources are real.
2

From Twenty-Two Issues to Five: A Materiality Assessment for a Regional Trucking Company, and the Depot Exhaust the Tests Disagree On

A Survey in Which Everything Mattered

A composite regional trucking company runs 850 tractors from eleven depots, hauling dry and refrigerated freight within about 500 miles of its base. Last year it surveyed employees and customers on a generic list of twenty-two sustainability issues, each rated from one to five for importance. Twenty of the twenty-two scored above 3.5, and the spread between the highest and lowest was under a point. The results cannot guide a board. Respondents asked whether an issue is important will rarely say no, and rating unlike issues, such as biodiversity and driver fatigue, on one scale invites them to rate everything highly. The survey measured goodwill toward the idea of sustainability, not which issues bear on this business. This assessment narrows the list by applying two tests.

Two Tests

Financial materiality asks which issues could reasonably affect the company's cash flows, cost of capital or access to finance over the short, medium or long term. Impact materiality asks which of the company's effects on people and the environment are significant, whatever their financial consequence. The two tests answer different questions, and an issue may pass one and fail the other. The reporting standard most used for sustainability reports is organized around the second (Global Reporting Initiative, 2021); investor-oriented standards are built around the first. Disclosure regimes differ on which they require and have changed in recent years, so this assessment applies both without asserting what any regime currently demands of the company.

The Industry Standard as a Starting List

The Sustainability Accounting Standards Board's standard for road transportation identifies the issues most likely to be financially material across the industry: greenhouse gas emissions, air quality, driver working conditions, and accident and safety management (Sustainability Accounting Standards Board, 2018). Each was tested against the company's own operations.

Greenhouse gas emissions pass both tests. Diesel is the company's second-largest cost, so fuel efficiency affects margins directly, and large shippers increasingly ask carriers for emissions data per load. Air quality passes the impact test clearly, since diesel exhaust contains particulates and nitrogen oxides, and passes the financial test where rules or neighbors press on depots. Driver working conditions pass both: annual driver turnover runs near 70 percent, each replacement costs several thousand dollars to recruit and train, and fatigue affects safety. Accident and safety management passes both decisively, since a single serious crash can cost millions and harms people outside the company.

The narrowing matters for performance, not just reporting. Khan et al. (2016) found that firms with strong performance on the sustainability issues material to their industry earned better future stock returns than firms with weak performance on those issues, while performance on immaterial issues showed no such association. Spending attention evenly across twenty-two issues dilutes effort on the four that are likely to matter.

The Survey's Other Issues

The survey's remaining issues were tested the same way, and most drop away. Water use is minor for a trucking company, limited to truck washing. Biodiversity has no meaningful connection to its operations beyond the road network it shares with everyone. Packaging waste belongs mainly to shippers. One addition survives: data security, since the company holds shippers' load and pricing data and drivers' personal records, and a breach would carry financial and personal harm. The survey also raised community relations, which is folded into the depot issue below.

Placing the Surviving Issues

Each surviving issue is placed by financial significance and impact significance, each rated high, medium or low from the evidence above.

Table 1

Surviving Issues by Financial and Impact Significance, Illustrative

IssueFinancial significanceImpact significanceBasis
Accident and safety managementHighHighCrash costs; harm to the public
Driver working conditionsHighHigh70 percent turnover; fatigue
Greenhouse gas emissionsMedium to highHighFuel cost; shipper requests
Data securityMediumMediumShipper and driver records
Depot air qualityLow to mediumHighExhaust on residential streets

Depot Exhaust: Where the Tests Disagree

Three of the company's depots sit on the edges of residential neighborhoods, where trucks idle while being loaded early in the morning and queue along streets with homes and a primary school. The impact is high: the residents bear diesel exhaust in their homes and the children at school. The financial pressure is low today and depends on others. It would rise if the city restricted idling or truck routes, if neighbors organized complaints that slowed permits for the planned depot expansion, or if a shipper with a public commitment asked about it. None of these has happened.

On the financial test alone, depot exhaust would sit near the bottom of the list. On the impact test it sits near the top. The assessment's position is that the company owes the issue attention anyway, because it is a significant harm the company causes and can reduce at modest cost: enforcing idle limits at the three depots, moving queues inside the depot fences and scheduling the earliest departures from the depot farthest from homes. The board should report the issue, the measures taken and the residents' complaints each year, whatever the regulators do.

What the Board Should Do With the Short List

The short list changes how the company spends attention. Each of the five issues should have a named executive, one or two measures reported every year, such as preventable crashes per million miles, driver turnover, fuel used per loaded mile, security incidents and idling hours at the three depots, and a target where the company controls the outcome. The issues that dropped away should not disappear from view entirely; the assessment should be repeated every two years, or sooner if the company enters a new kind of freight, because materiality changes with the business and with what regulators and shippers expect. And the next survey should ask respondents to rank issues against one another rather than rate each alone, so that its results can show priorities instead of goodwill.

References

Global Reporting Initiative. (2021). GRI 3: Material topics 2021. https://www.globalreporting.org/standards/

Khan, M., Serafeim, G., & Yoon, A. (2016). Corporate sustainability: First evidence on materiality. The Accounting Review, 91(6), 1697-1724. https://doi.org/10.2308/accr-51383

Sustainability Accounting Standards Board. (2018). Road transportation: Sustainability accounting standard. IFRS Foundation. https://sasb.ifrs.org/standards/

The DBA-835 Topic 2 assignment instructions

The Topic 2 assignment in DBA-835 asks doctoral students to assess which sustainability issues are material to one business. Strong assessments explain why equal survey ratings cannot guide a board, define financial and impact materiality separately and note that disclosure regimes differ on which they require. Students should test an industry standard's list against the company's own operations, record why generic issues drop away and place survivors on both dimensions. The paper should examine an issue where the two tests disagree, state what the company owes it regardless and say how the short list should change the board's attention.

Inside the DBA 835 Topic 2 example

The finished assessment begins with the survey the company ran, in which employees and customers rated a generic list of issues and nearly everything scored as important. It then applies two tests. Financial materiality asks which issues could reasonably affect the company's cash flows, cost of capital or access to finance; impact materiality asks which of the company's effects on people and the environment are significant whatever their financial consequence. SASB's industry standard for road transportation supplies a starting list: greenhouse gas emissions, air quality, driver working conditions, and accident and safety management. Khan, Serafeim and Yoon's finding that performance on industry-material issues, not on immaterial ones, was associated with better returns explains why narrowing matters. The assessment ends on the issue where the two tests disagree: diesel exhaust from depots on residential streets.

Reading the DBA 835 Topic 2 rubric

Faculty reward a long list made short by tests. An Excellent assessment explains why a survey rating everything important cannot guide a board. Credit goes to separating financial from impact materiality, with GRI built around the second, and testing the SASB road transportation list against the company's routes. The rubric values Khan, Serafeim and Yoon's finding on material issues and a table rating each survivor on both tests. Strong papers drop water and biodiversity with reasons. Top marks go to depot exhaust, owed attention whatever regulators do.

DBA 835 Topic 2 help before you submit

Assessments that reproduce the survey's full list, every issue marked important, lose the most, because a materiality exercise that excludes nothing has not been done. Using a generic issue list instead of one fitted to trucking imports concerns that belong to other industries. Papers that never say whether a judgment rests on financial or impact materiality leave the reader unable to check any placement. Treating the two tests as always agreeing is the advocacy version of the topic, and the depot exhaust case exists to show where they part. Citing Khan, Serafeim and Yoon as proof that sustainability always pays stretches a finding about material issues into a claim about all of them. Disclosure requirements stated as fixed are a frequent slip, since their scope has changed and continues to be revised.

Get a DBA-835 Topic 2 example written to your instructions

Send the DBA-835 Topic 2 instructions and your classroom rubric, with the firm or industry case your section assigns. A custom example is written to those criteria, with both materiality tests defined, an industry standard applied, dropped issues explained and the case where the tests disagree addressed honestly, returned in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More DBA 835 papers and DBA samples

DBA 835 Topic 2 questions, answered

What is double materiality?

The view that a company should assess two things: how sustainability issues affect its own financial position, and how its activities affect people and the environment. Investor-focused standards concentrate on the first, while some regulators, notably in the European Union, have required both. The scope of those requirements has been revised in recent years, so the example describes the concept without treating any jurisdiction's current rules as settled.

What did Khan, Serafeim and Yoon find?

Using industry-specific classifications of which sustainability issues are material, they found that firms with strong ratings on material issues earned better subsequent stock returns than firms with weak ratings on those issues, while strength on immaterial issues showed no comparable advantage. The finding is often cited for the value of focus. The example uses it for that point only and not as evidence that every sustainability investment pays.

Can a trucking firm ignore issues that are not material?

It can give them lower priority in strategy and reporting, but ranking an issue lower is different from ignoring it. An issue that is immaterial today can become material through new regulation, a customer requirement or an incident. The example records why each dropped issue left the list and when it would be revisited. The company is invented for this DBA-835 exercise, and nothing in it is reporting or legal advice.

Where can I find a free DBA 835 Topic 2 sample paper?

The materiality assessment is printed here in full: the survey, two tests, the industry standard applied, the survey's other issues, the survivors placed on both tests, depot exhaust and what the board should do. Paste in your DBA 835 Topic 2 prompt and a free assessment follows.

Why does depot exhaust matter in DBA 835 Topic 2 if it costs little?

Residents and schoolchildren breathe the exhaust whatever the financial pressure, and the company can cut it cheaply with idle limits, queues inside fences and rescheduled departures. Impact alone justifies the attention.