DBA 835 Topic 5 profit divergence dq post example

The Sustainable Future Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This DBA 835 Topic 5 sample paper makes a case, across a main post and one reply, for raising a composite regional bottler's recycled content from 15 to 50 percent while admitting it costs money. It belongs to GCU DBA 835, The Sustainable Future, listed as DBA-835, required in Grand Canyon University's DBA. Recycled resin costs about a fifth more and retailers will not pay. Friedman's view is given its strongest form, then answered with state recycled-content minimums and Hart and Zingales on shareholder welfare, with shareholders asked. The cost, about two cents a bottle, is named, and the reply presses a classmate's shared value claim using Crane and colleagues.

CourseDBA 835 The Sustainable Future
TopicTopic 5
Paper typeProfit divergence DQ post
LengthAbout 390 words, 1 pages
FormatDiscussion post, APA 7 citations
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramDBA
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for DBA 835 Topic 5

1

Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post and Reply

Recycled Resin Costs More: Arguing a Sustainable Choice Without Pretending It Pays

Initial Post

In my composite case, a regional bottler is deciding whether to raise the recycled content of its plastic bottles from 15 to 50 percent. Food-grade recycled resin costs it about a fifth more than virgin resin, its retail customers have refused to pay more per case, and shoppers who tell surveys they value recycled content rarely choose a bottle for that reason at the shelf. On these facts, profit and sustainability diverge, and I will not pretend otherwise.

Friedman's position deserves its strongest form. Friedman (1970) argued that a manager is the shareholders' employee, whose duty is to earn as much for them as the law and common ethical custom permit, and that spending their money on an unpriced social benefit is in effect taxing them without their consent. Friedman did not object to sustainable spending that serves the firm; the objection was only to spending that does not, and the extra resin here does not.

Two grounds survive that concession. First, part of the switch is not voluntary: some states already set minimum recycled content for beverage bottles, rising over time, so a share of the cost is compliance, and building supply contracts early may cost less than buying scarce resin later. Second, for the voluntary part, Hart and Zingales (2017) argued that firms should maximize shareholder welfare, not market value, because shareholders also care about pollution and may prefer the firm to reduce it when the firm can do so more cheaply than they can. That argument needs consent, so I would put the voluntary part to shareholders as an explicit proposal.

The cost should be stated plainly: margin lost on every case sold, about two cents a bottle at 50 percent recycled content. I will not relabel that as a long-term investment without evidence that it returns anything.

Reply to Marcus

Marcus, you argue that shared value dissolves the conflict (Porter & Kramer, 2011). In some cases it may, but Crane et al. (2014) criticized the idea for passing over real tensions between business and social goals by focusing on the cases where they align. Here they do not align: who pays the two cents? If no one in the chain will, is the switch shared value or simply a cost someone has chosen to bear?

References

Crane, A., Palazzo, G., Spence, L. J., & Matten, D. (2014). Contesting the value of "creating shared value." California Management Review, 56(2), 130-153. https://doi.org/10.1525/cmr.2014.56.2.130

Friedman, M. (1970, September 13). A Friedman doctrine: The social responsibility of business is to increase its profits. The New York Times Magazine, 32-33, 122-126.

Hart, O., & Zingales, L. (2017). Companies should maximize shareholder welfare not market value. Journal of Law, Finance, and Accounting, 2(2), 247-274. https://doi.org/10.1561/108.00000022

Porter, M. E., & Kramer, M. R. (2011). Creating shared value. Harvard Business Review, 89(1/2), 62-77.

What the DBA 835 Topic 5 instructions ask for

The Topic 5 discussion in DBA-835 asks doctoral students to argue a sustainability decision where profit and impact diverge. Strong posts state the divergence plainly, present the shareholder-primacy view in its strongest form and concede what it gets right before arguing. Students should separate any part of the decision that law compels from the part that is voluntary, give a defensible ground for the voluntary part and name the cost without relabeling it as an investment. The reply should test a classmate's claim that the conflict dissolves, asking who in the chain actually bears the cost.

How this DBA 835 Topic 5 example is built

The finished post opens by stating the divergence plainly: in the composite case, recycled resin costs the bottler more than virgin resin, retailers will not absorb the difference and shoppers who say they value recycled content rarely pay for it. The second paragraph gives Friedman's position its strongest form, that a manager's duty is to increase profits within the law, so spending shareholders' money on an unpriced benefit needs their consent. The third answers with two grounds that survive the concession: some states already set minimum recycled content for beverage bottles, which turns part of the cost into a compliance matter, and Hart and Zingales argue that firms should serve shareholders' welfare, which can include their preferences about pollution. The fourth names what is traded away. The reply questions a classmate's appeal to shared value.

Where the marks sit in the DBA 835 Topic 5 rubric

Faculty reward a divergence admitted, not wished away. An Excellent post sets out the resin cost gap, retailer refusal and the gap between what shoppers say and buy. Credit goes to Friedman's view in its strongest form, noting it permits spending that serves the firm. The rubric values separating state recycled-content rules from the voluntary part and grounding that part in Hart and Zingales on shareholder welfare, with consent. Strong posts name two cents a bottle. Top marks go to a reply using Crane and colleagues against Porter and Kramer's shared value.

DBA 835 Topic 5 help: mistakes that cost marks

Credit drains fastest from posts asserting that the switch will pay off through brand loyalty, which answers a question about divergence by denying that any exists. The prompt is about a real parting of profit and sustainability, and a post that finds them aligned after all has declined it. Dismissing Friedman as outdated, instead of engaging his consent argument, leaves the strongest objection standing. Papers that treat state recycled content rules as voluntary sustainability, or voluntary switching as compliance, confuse two different reasons to act. Citing Porter and Kramer as though shared value settles every conflict ignores the critique that the concept tends to assume tensions away. A reply that echoes a classmate's optimism without asking who pays adds little to a discussion about costs.

Get a DBA-835 Topic 5 example written to your instructions

Send the DBA-835 Topic 5 discussion question as your classroom shows it, with the rubric and any readings attached. We write a custom example to them, with the divergence conceded, the shareholder objection stated fairly, compelled and voluntary action separated, the cost named and a peer reply included, in 24 to 48 hours. Your first one is free.

More DBA 835 papers and DBA samples

DBA 835 Topic 5 questions, answered

What did Friedman argue about social responsibility?

In his 1970 essay, Milton Friedman argued that executives work for the owners, whose wish is usually to make as much money as possible while obeying the law and ethical custom, and that executives who spend company money on social goals are in effect taxing shareholders, customers or employees without their consent. The example treats the consent point as the strongest part of the argument and answers it rather than dismissing it.

What is shared value, and why is it criticized?

Porter and Kramer proposed that firms can create economic value by addressing social problems, so that profit and social benefit rise together. Crane and colleagues argued that the idea is attractive but tends to assume away cases where the two conflict, and says little about compliance with existing rules. The example accepts that shared value exists in some decisions and denies that it describes this one.

Should a company absorb sustainability costs its customers will not pay?

No verdict for a real firm is possible here. The example argues that such spending needs a stated ground, such as regulation, shareholders' expressed preferences or a risk the firm reasonably expects, and that its cost should be named rather than relabeled. The bottler exists only for this DBA-835 exercise, and the post offers no investment, legal or business advice.

Where can I find a free DBA 835 Topic 5 sample paper?

The complete forum entry appears above: a lead post stating the divergence, Friedman's view, two grounds that survive it and the cost, then a reply to one classmate. Your own DBA 835 Topic 5 prompt gets a free post.

Why put the voluntary part to shareholders in DBA 835 Topic 5?

The shareholder welfare argument rests on owners preferring less pollution even at some cost. Asking them turns an assumed preference into consent, which answers Friedman's objection to spending without it.