| Course | DBA 835 The Sustainable Future |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 7 |
| Paper type | Circularity claim test |
| Length | About 950 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | DBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for DBA 835 Topic 7
Does Trading In Make a Phone Circular? Testing an Electronics Seller's Claim Against What Happens to Returned Devices
[Author Name]
College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University
DBA-835: The Sustainable Future
Topic 7 Circularity Claim Test
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Does Trading In Make a Phone Circular? Testing an Electronics Seller's Claim Against What Happens to Returned Devices
The Claim as Marketed
A composite consumer-electronics seller, which sells its own brand of smartphones online and through carriers, advertises its trade-in program with one sentence: trade in your old phone and help make our phones circular. Product pages repeat it beside a looping arrow, and the annual report describes the product line as part of a circular economy. The seller sells about 2.4 million phones a year. This paper tests the sentence against the company's own records of what happens to returned devices. Figures are illustrative.
What Circular Means
To test the claim against a standard rather than against preference, circular is defined by a published framework, which describes a circular economy as one that is restorative by design (Ellen MacArthur Foundation, 2013), keeping products, components and materials at their highest value for as long as possible, with an order of preference: maintaining and reusing products first, then refurbishing and remanufacturing, and recycling materials last, since recycling recovers the least value. A circular product line, on this definition, is one in which most products return and are kept in use, and the materials of those that cannot be are recovered.
Three Assertions and the Evidence Each Needs
The claim contains three assertions. The first is that traded-in phones are kept in use, which needs records of what happens to each returned device. The second is that their materials are recovered, which needs recycler records of what was extracted. The third, that the program makes the product line circular, needs evidence that a large share of the phones the company sells come back through the program.
Following the Evidence
Trade-in volumes come first. Last year the program received about 310,000 phones, of all brands, against 2.4 million of the seller's own phones sold. The seller does not know what share of its own phones sold in earlier years eventually return, because it does not track phones that customers keep, sell privately or put in drawers. A rough comparison suggests that a minority do.
The volume figure also overstates the program's link to the seller's own product line. About 40 percent of returned phones were other brands, accepted to win customers from competitors. Their reuse is welcome, but it says nothing about whether the seller's phones are circular. Counting only the seller's own phones, about 186,000 came back last year, under one in twelve of the number sold in that year, and the share of phones from any earlier year that eventually return cannot be calculated from the records the seller keeps.
Refurbisher reports come next. About 78 percent of returned phones were graded as refurbishable and sold to two refurbishers, which resold them, many in markets abroad. That counts as reuse, the highest-value loop, though the seller's records end at the sale to the refurbisher, and what happens to those phones at the end of their second life is unknown.
Table 1
Each Part of the Claim Set Against the Evidence, Illustrative
| Assertion | Evidence found | Where the trail ends | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Traded-in phones are kept in use | About 78 percent refurbished and resold | At sale to refurbishers | Supported for returned phones |
| Materials are recovered | Certified recycler processed the rest | Tonnes in, not materials out | Partly supported |
| The product line is circular | 310,000 returns against 2.4 million sold | Unknown return share | Not supported |
Recycler certificates come last. The remaining 22 percent, about 68,000 phones, went to a certified recycler, which shredded them and recovered metals. Recovery of copper, gold and other precious metals is high in such processes, while recovery of lithium, rare earth elements and plastics is much lower or absent. The certificates state tonnes processed, not what was extracted from them.
The Rebound Question
A further question concerns the program's overall effect. Zink and Geyer (2017) warned that circular economy activities can increase total production if reused or recycled products do not substitute for new ones, or if they lower prices and so raise consumption. Here the concern is specific: trade-in credits, advertised at each new launch, may encourage customers to replace phones sooner, raising the number of phones manufactured. If so, the program could increase total environmental impact while making each individual phone's end of life more circular. The seller has no data on whether customers who trade in replace phones sooner than those who do not, so the rebound is plausible but unmeasured in this case.
Is the Claim Greenwashing?
Delmas and Burbano (2011) described greenwashing as the combination of poor environmental performance with positive communication about it. The seller's performance is not poor at the level of returned phones, most of which are reused. The problem is that the communication describes the whole product line, and the evidence supports a claim only about the minority of phones that come back. Environmental marketing claims in the United States fall under Federal Trade Commission guidance, which cautions against broad, unqualified environmental benefit claims and requires that claims be substantiated (Guides for the use of environmental marketing claims, 2012); that guidance has been under review, and the paper does not state how a revision would treat this claim.
A Claim the Records Could Support
The records could support a narrower sentence: phones traded in through our program are refurbished for reuse where possible, about three in four last year, and the rest are recycled by a certified recycler. That claim is specific, measurable and true, and every figure in it can be traced to a record the seller already holds. To support anything broader, the seller would need to estimate the return share of its own phones, obtain refurbisher and recycler records of what happens downstream, and study whether trade-in credits shorten how long customers keep their phones.
References
Delmas, M. A., & Burbano, V. C. (2011). The drivers of greenwashing. California Management Review, 54(1), 64-87. https://doi.org/10.1525/cmr.2011.54.1.64
Ellen MacArthur Foundation. (2013). Towards the circular economy: Economic and business rationale for an accelerated transition (Vol. 1). https://www.ellenmacarthurfoundation.org/towards-the-circular-economy-vol-1-an-economic-and-business-rationale-for-an
Guides for the use of environmental marketing claims, 16 C.F.R. pt. 260 (2012).
Zink, T., & Geyer, R. (2017). Circular economy rebound. Journal of Industrial Ecology, 21(3), 593-602. https://doi.org/10.1111/jiec.12545
The DBA-835 Topic 7 assignment instructions
The Topic 7 assignment in DBA-835 asks doctoral students to test a published sustainability claim against evidence. Strong papers reproduce the claim exactly, define its key term from a published framework rather than personal preference and divide it into assertions that each need specific evidence. Students should follow the records as far as they go and mark where the trail ends, weigh whether the program could raise total impact, and assess the claim against a recognized definition of greenwashing and the relevant marketing guidance. The paper should close with a narrower claim the existing records could support.
How this DBA 835 Topic 7 example is built
The finished test begins with the claim exactly as marketed and breaks it into testable parts: that traded-in phones are kept in use, that their materials are recovered, and that the program makes the product line circular. Each part is followed through the company's records. Trade-ins cover only the devices customers return, and the company does not know what share of phones sold that represents. Most returned phones are refurbished and resold, many abroad, which counts as reuse. Phones beyond repair are shredded, and recovery of some materials is far better than of others. The paper uses the Ellen MacArthur Foundation's principles to define circularity, Delmas and Burbano's framing of greenwashing as weak performance paired with favorable communication, and Zink and Geyer's warning that circular programs can raise total production.
Where the marks sit in the DBA 835 Topic 7 rubric
Faculty reward a claim traced to its evidence or its gap. An Excellent test defines circular from the Ellen MacArthur Foundation's order of loops. Credit goes to splitting the claim into reuse, recovery and a circular product line, and a table recording where each trail ends. The rubric values separating the seller's own returns from other brands and weighing Zink and Geyer's rebound as plausible but unmeasured. Strong papers apply Delmas and Burbano and the FTC guidance without stating how a revision would rule. Top marks go to a narrower, checkable claim.
Common DBA 835 Topic 7 mistakes, and how to avoid them
The costliest reading judges the claim by the program's intentions rather than by its records. A trade-in scheme that refurbishes returned phones does real good, and a paper that stops there never asks what share of phones return at all. Defining circularity loosely, so that any recycling qualifies, lets the test pass a claim a published framework would not. The mirror error calls the whole program greenwashing, which ignores the reuse the refurbisher reports document. Papers that miss the rebound argument treat each returned phone as a pure gain, although credits can shorten ownership. Citing Delmas and Burbano as proof of deliberate deception misreads a framing about the gap between performance and communication. Legal status stated as settled overstates guidance that is still being revised.
Get a DBA-835 Topic 7 example written to your instructions
Send the DBA-835 Topic 7 instructions and the rubric your classroom posts, with the company claim or case your section provides. A custom example gets written to those criteria, with the claim quoted, circularity defined by a published framework, each assertion traced to evidence, rebound weighed and a supportable claim proposed, returned within 24 to 48 hours. The first request is free.
More DBA 835 papers and DBA samples
- DBA 835 Topic 1: Sustainability Definition Paper
- DBA 835 Topic 2: Materiality Assessment
- DBA 835 Topic 3: Emissions Baseline Reconstruction
- DBA 835 Topic 4: Disclosure Obligation Map
- DBA 835 Topic 5: Profit Divergence Dq Post
- DBA 835 Topic 6: Supplier Influence Map
- DBA 835 Topic 8: Transition Risk Position Paper
- DBA 833 Topic 7: Out-of-sample Evaluation Report
- DBA 831 Topic 7: Rival Explanation Design Defense
- DBA 820 Topic 7: Buyback Position Paper
- MGT 805 Topic 7: Divisional Redesign Proposal
DBA 835 Topic 7 questions, answered
What is greenwashing, precisely?
Definitions vary, but a widely cited one from Delmas and Burbano describes it as the combination of poor environmental performance with positive communication about that performance. The definition matters because it separates greenwashing from ordinary error and from firms that perform well and say little. The example uses it to ask whether the trade-in claim communicates more than the records show, not whether the company intended to mislead.
What is the circular economy rebound effect?
Zink and Geyer argued that circular activities such as reuse and recycling can fail to reduce, or can even increase, total production if the secondary products do not displace new ones, or if lower prices raise overall consumption. For trade-in programs, the concern is that credits encourage customers to replace phones sooner. The example treats the effect as plausible and notes that the company lacks the data to measure it.
Can the narrower claim in the example be used in real marketing?
No. The electronics seller and its records are composites, and an actual marketing claim depends on the company's real data and on regulatory guidance that differs by jurisdiction and has been under revision. Such claims are for the company's own legal and compliance advisers to approve. What the example offers is a DBA-835 demonstration of testing a sustainability claim against records, and it is not legal advice.
Where can I find a free DBA 835 Topic 7 sample paper?
The claim test is shown here complete: the claim as marketed, what circular means, three assertions, the evidence followed, the rebound question, the greenwashing assessment and a claim the records could support. Forward the DBA 835 Topic 7 prompt you received for a free test.
Why count only the seller's own phones in DBA 835 Topic 7?
About 40 percent of returns were other brands, accepted to win customers. Their reuse is welcome but says nothing about whether the seller's own product line is circular.