DBA 835 Topic 8 transition risk position paper example

The Sustainable Future Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This DBA 835 Topic 8 sample paper takes a side on carbon capture at a composite family cement producer's largest kiln, which emits about 1.1 million tonnes a year. It was prepared for GCU DBA 835, The Sustainable Future, catalog code DBA-835, a core course of Grand Canyon University's DBA. Process emissions from clinker, which Andrew estimated globally, resist cleaner fuels. Rules, carbon prices, public buyers and lenders, with Bolton and Kacperczyk's carbon premium and Carney's tragedy of the horizon, make the case for acting. The case for waiting cites shifting tax credits. The paper funds a 35 million dollar study and pilot now and full capture on triggers.

CourseDBA 835 The Sustainable Future
TopicTopic 8
Paper typeTransition risk position paper
LengthAbout 970 words, 2 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramDBA
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for DBA 835 Topic 8

1

Study and Pilot Now, Build on Triggers: A Position on Carbon Capture at a Family Cement Producer's Largest Kiln

[Author Name]

College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University

DBA-835: The Sustainable Future

Topic 8 Transition Risk Position Paper

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the position. The producer, its board and every figure are a composite, labeled illustrative; the sources are real.
2

Study and Pilot Now, Build on Triggers: A Position on Carbon Capture at a Family Cement Producer's Largest Kiln

The Position

A composite family-controlled cement producer operates three plants, the largest of which runs a kiln producing about 1.4 million tonnes of clinker a year and emitting about 1.1 million tonnes of carbon dioxide. The board is divided over whether to fund carbon capture at that kiln before any rule requires it. This paper's position is to fund an engineering study and a capture pilot now, at about 35 million dollars over three years, and to commit to full-scale capture, estimated at 600 to 800 million dollars, only when policy, buyer demand or tax credits make its cost recoverable. The money spent now is a purchase of readiness, and it may never be returned.

Why Cement Is a Hard Case

Most industries can cut emissions by changing their energy source. Cement can do so only in part. About 40 percent of a kiln's emissions come from burning fuel to heat it, which cleaner fuels and electricity can reduce. The other 60 percent come from chemistry: when limestone is heated to make clinker, the calcium carbonate releases carbon dioxide regardless of the fuel used. Andrew (2018) estimated global process emissions from cement production at roughly 1.5 billion tonnes of carbon dioxide in 2016, before any fuel is counted. Reducing the clinker content of cement by blending in other materials helps, and the International Energy Agency's roadmap counts on it, but its own pathways still rely heavily on carbon capture for the deep cuts that remain (International Energy Agency & Cement Sustainability Initiative, 2018). For this kiln, there is no cheap route to large reductions.

The Transition Risks

The case for acting early rests on transition risk, the financial risk from changes in policy, technology and markets as economies decarbonize. Four apply here. Rules could tighten, through emissions limits on kilns or permitting conditions for expansions. Carbon prices could arrive, directly or through border adjustments on imported cement that domestic policy may mirror. Public buyers, which account for about half of the producer's sales through highways and public works, could require lower-carbon concrete in procurement, as some states have begun to do. And lenders and investors could price carbon exposure into the company's cost of capital. Bolton and Kacperczyk (2021) found that US firms with higher emissions earned higher stock returns, consistent with investors demanding compensation for carbon risk. Any of these could leave an unabated kiln, with decades of physical life remaining, worth far less than its book value.

Carney (2015) described climate change as a tragedy of the horizon: its costs fall beyond the horizon of most business and policy decisions, so the people best placed to act have little reason to. A family company should be better placed than most to look past that horizon, since its owners expect to hold the kiln for another generation.

The Case for Waiting

The case for waiting deserves the same care, and the board members who make it are not wrong about the facts. Federal tax credits for captured carbon exist (Credit for carbon oxide sequestration, 2022), but their value and terms have changed through legislation, and a credit that could make capture pay today could be reduced before a plant is built. No buyer currently pays more for low-carbon cement in the producer's markets. Capture technology for cement is still early, and a better or cheaper approach could arrive within a decade, rewarding the firm that waited. Storage requires a pipeline and a geological site the producer does not control. And the family's capital has other uses, including a debt-funded plant expansion and dividends on which several family members depend.

The Staged Commitment

The position answers the case for waiting by spending little now while keeping the option to move quickly. The engineering study, about 5 million dollars, would design capture for the kiln, identify storage partners and estimate cost per tonne. The pilot, about 30 million dollars, would capture a slipstream of the kiln's exhaust, about 3 percent, for two years, giving the producer operating data and staff experience. Full-scale capture would be committed when any one of three triggers is met: a binding rule or carbon price above the producer's cost per tonne captured; long-term contracts from public or private buyers paying a premium for low-carbon cement covering at least a third of the kiln's output; or tax credits secured for the project's life at a value that covers its cost.

Table 1

Staged Commitment to Carbon Capture, Illustrative

StageCost, millions of dollarsTimingMoves forward when
Engineering studyAbout 5Year 1Funded now
Capture pilotAbout 30Years 1 to 3Funded now
Full-scale capture600 to 800Year 4 or laterA rule, buyer contracts or secured credits cover the cost

What Is Traded Away

The position is not free. The 35 million dollars will reduce dividends for three years and use borrowing capacity the expansion may need. If no trigger is ever met, the money buys only knowledge. The board should accept those costs knowingly rather than describe them as an investment certain to pay. There is a quieter cost as well: once a pilot exists, staff and some board members may push to scale it up whether or not a trigger has been met, so the triggers should be written into the board minutes now, while the decision is still abstract.

What Would Reverse the Position

The position would move toward full commitment now if a binding rule were adopted in the producer's main state or a large public buyer offered long-term premium contracts. It would move toward waiting entirely if tax credits were withdrawn, if storage proved unavailable in the region or if the pilot showed costs far above estimates. Each development should be reviewed annually by the board.

References

Andrew, R. M. (2018). Global CO2 emissions from cement production. Earth System Science Data, 10(1), 195-217. https://doi.org/10.5194/essd-10-195-2018

Bolton, P., & Kacperczyk, M. (2021). Do investors care about carbon risk? Journal of Financial Economics, 142(2), 517-549. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfineco.2021.05.008

Carney, M. (2015, September 29). Breaking the tragedy of the horizon: Climate change and financial stability [Speech]. Bank of England. https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/speech/2015/breaking-the-tragedy-of-the-horizon-climate-change-and-financial-stability

Credit for carbon oxide sequestration, 26 U.S.C. ยง 45Q (2022).

International Energy Agency & Cement Sustainability Initiative. (2018). Technology roadmap: Low-carbon transition in the cement industry. https://www.iea.org/reports/technology-roadmap-low-carbon-transition-in-the-cement-industry

DBA 835 Topic 8 instructions, in plain terms

Topic 8 in DBA-835 asks doctoral students to take a committed position on a sustainability conflict that cannot be resolved cheaply. Strong papers state the position at once, explain why the case is technically hard and set out the transition risks with evidence. Students should present the case for waiting as its best advocate would, then answer it with a staged commitment whose triggers are specific and measurable. The paper should name what is traded away, including dividends and borrowing capacity, and close by stating the developments that would reverse the position in either direction.

Inside the DBA 835 Topic 8 example

The finished paper commits at once: fund the engineering study and a capture pilot now, and commit to full-scale capture only when policy, buyer demand or tax credits make its cost recoverable. It explains why cement is a hard case. Much of the industry's emissions come from the chemistry of turning limestone into clinker, not from fuel, so cleaner energy alone cannot remove them. The case for acting early rests on transition risk: rules, carbon prices or public buyers' low-carbon requirements could leave an unabated kiln stranded. Carney's description of climate change as a tragedy of the horizon frames why that risk is easy to discount. The case for waiting receives the same care: federal credits for captured carbon exist, but their terms have changed through legislation, and a family's capital has other uses.

DBA 835 Topic 8 rubric: what Excellent looks like

Faculty reward a stance taken with its costs named. An Excellent paper separates fuel emissions from clinker process emissions, citing Andrew and the IEA cement roadmap. Credit goes to four transition risks, with Bolton and Kacperczyk on carbon risk and Carney's tragedy of the horizon. The rubric values the case for waiting at full strength, including tax credits whose terms have changed. Strong papers tabulate a staged study, pilot and triggered full-scale build. Top marks go to naming dividends deferred and the developments that would reverse the position.

Common DBA 835 Topic 8 mistakes, and how to avoid them

The weakest position papers here argue that decarbonizing the kiln will pay for itself, because the case is built so that it may not. Asserting alignment where the costs are front-loaded and the returns depend on policy declines the trade-off the prompt asks about. The opposite paper, recommending that the producer wait for certainty, never prices the risk of a kiln stranded by rules or buyers. Treating cement like any other emitter, as if clean electricity solved it, misses the process emissions that make the case hard. Papers that give the waiting case a single dismissive sentence have not faced their strongest objection. Tax credit terms, carbon prices or procurement rules stated as fixed date the paper, since each has shifted, and a position without reversal conditions cannot be tested.

Get a DBA-835 Topic 8 example written to your instructions

Send the DBA-835 Topic 8 instructions and the rubric shown in your classroom, with the company or industry case your section assigned. We write a custom example to them, with a stated position, the transition risks named, the case for waiting given fairly, a staged commitment with triggers and the cost to owners named, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More DBA 835 papers and DBA samples

DBA 835 Topic 8 questions, answered

What is transition risk?

The risk that a firm's assets or business model lose value as the economy moves toward lower emissions, through new regulation, carbon pricing, shifts in customer demand, technology change or changes in the cost of finance. It differs from physical risk, which concerns damage from climate effects themselves. For a cement producer, the central transition risk is a kiln that becomes costly to run or hard to sell into public projects.

What did Carney mean by the tragedy of the horizon?

In a 2015 speech as Governor of the Bank of England, Mark Carney argued that the most serious effects of climate change would fall beyond the horizons that most businesses, investors and policymakers plan for, so the incentive to act today is weak. The paper borrows the idea to show why transition risk is easy to discount, and asks whether a family owner with a longer view is better placed.

Should a real cement company invest in carbon capture now?

Nothing in the example settles that for an actual producer. The kiln, the family board and their deliberations were invented to show a committed stance on a genuine conflict, whereas a real investment would depend on engineering studies, access to storage, current tax and regulatory terms and the owners' finances. It is DBA-835 coursework and gives no investment or engineering advice.

Where can I find a free DBA 835 Topic 8 sample paper?

The whole cement position paper appears on this page: the position, why cement is hard, the transition risks, the case for waiting, the staged commitment, what is traded away and what would reverse it. Share your DBA 835 Topic 8 prompt for a free position paper.

Why not commit to full-scale capture now in DBA 835 Topic 8?

No rule, buyer premium or secured credit yet covers its 600 to 800 million dollar cost. A study and pilot buy readiness for 35 million, and full capture waits for one of three named triggers.