DBA 839 Topic 3 definition arbitration memo example

Enterprise Data Complexity Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This DBA 839 Topic 3 sample paper is a memo deciding which of three correct active customer counts governs a composite freight company's board figure. It forms part of GCU DBA 839, Enterprise Data Complexity, catalog code DBA-839, a doctoral seminar in Grand Canyon University's DBA. Sales counts about 11,400 ordering accounts, finance about 8,900 billed customers and service about 9,700 contracted accounts. The gaps reveal credit problems and dormant contracts. Criteria are declared first, decision use, auditability and resistance to gaming, and finance wins. Kerr's warning about rewards frames the sales commission problem, and the CFO owns the definition, as Abraham and colleagues describe.

CourseDBA 839 Enterprise Data Complexity
TopicTopic 3
Paper typeDefinition arbitration memo
LengthAbout 780 words, 1 pages
FormatMemo with APA 7 references
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramDBA
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for DBA 839 Topic 3

1

Memorandum

To: Board Secretary

From: Director of Enterprise Data

Date: [Date]

Re: Active customer definition for the board figure

 

Recommendation

The board figure for customers should adopt the finance definition, renamed billed customers: accounts invoiced in the past twelve months and not referred to collections. On the current data that figure is about 8,900. The sales and customer service counts should continue under their own qualified names, ordering accounts and contracted accounts, and should not be presented to the board as the number of customers. The chief financial officer should own the enterprise definition, and any change to it should require the audit committee's approval.

The Three Definitions

The board of a composite less-than-truckload freight company asked how many active customers it has and received three numbers, each computed correctly from the same data warehouse.

Sales counts any account that placed a shipment order in the past twelve months, about 11,400. The question it serves is how many accounts are using the company, which drives territory planning and sales capacity.

Finance counts accounts invoiced in the past twelve months and not referred to collections, about 8,900. The question it serves is how many accounts are paying for service, which drives revenue forecasts and credit policy.

Customer service counts accounts holding an open service contract, whether or not they shipped anything, about 9,700. The question it serves is how many accounts the company is obliged to serve, which drives staffing of the service desk and account management.

Table 1

Three Active Customer Counts, Illustrative

CountDefinition in plain termsAccountsQuestion it answers
Ordering accounts, salesPlaced an order in past 12 monthsAbout 11,400How many accounts use us
Billed customers, financeInvoiced in past 12 months, not in collectionsAbout 8,900How many accounts pay us
Contracted accounts, serviceHold an open service contractAbout 9,700How many accounts we must serve

What the Gaps Reveal

The differences between the counts are not noise; each tells the company something. About 1,900 accounts placed orders but were not billed in good standing: most were referred to collections, and some placed orders that were canceled before pickup. That gap measures credit and order quality. About 1,600 accounts hold service contracts but shipped nothing in a year. Some are seasonal shippers; many are dormant contracts that the company is still staffing and that may be quietly lost to competitors. That gap is a retention warning. Wang and Strong (1996) argued that data quality is judged by fitness for the consumer's purpose; each count is fit for its owner's purpose, and the gaps between them are useful only if all three remain visible.

Criteria, Declared Before Applying Them

Three criteria govern the choice, stated here so the decision can be challenged on its reasons. First, the decision the board uses the figure for: the board uses the customer count to judge revenue concentration, growth and the average revenue per customer behind its pricing strategy. Second, auditability: whether an outside reviewer can verify the figure from source records. Third, resistance to gaming: whether anyone whose pay or standing depends on the figure can easily inflate it.

Finance's definition meets all three. It matches the board's revenue questions, since every billed customer generated revenue. Invoices are audited records. And inflating it requires billing someone, which is hard to do without real shipments. Sales' definition is the broadest and the easiest to inflate, since any order counts, including one canceled the next day. Customer service's definition depends on contracts, which can stay open long after a customer has left.

The Incentive Problem

One further fact bears on the arbitration. Sales commissions currently include a bonus tied to growth in ordering accounts, so the owner of the broadest count has a financial stake in its use. Kerr (1975) showed how reward systems can pay for conduct other than what an organization says it wants; a board figure based on ordering accounts would reward orders whether or not they are paid for. This memo does not question the good faith of the sales team. It notes that a figure used to judge the business should not be one its reporters are paid to raise, and it recommends that the commission plan be reviewed alongside this decision.

Ownership and Change Control

Abraham et al. (2019) found that data governance frameworks commonly assign each critical data element an accountable owner and a defined process for changes. The chief financial officer should own the enterprise definition of billed customers, publish its query logic, and report any change with its effect on prior periods restated. Changes require the audit committee's approval. The sales and customer service counts remain with their current owners, published under their qualified names on the same dashboard, so that the board sees the gaps each quarter.

References

Abraham, R., Schneider, J., & vom Brocke, J. (2019). Data governance: A conceptual framework, structured review, and research agenda. International Journal of Information Management, 49, 424-438. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijinfomgt.2019.07.008

Kerr, S. (1975). On the folly of rewarding A, while hoping for B. Academy of Management Journal, 18(4), 769-783. https://doi.org/10.2307/255378

Wang, R. Y., & Strong, D. M. (1996). Beyond accuracy: What data quality means to data consumers. Journal of Management Information Systems, 12(4), 5-33. https://doi.org/10.1080/07421222.1996.11518099

The DBA-839 Topic 3 assignment instructions

In Topic 3, DBA-839 asks doctoral students to arbitrate between competing definitions of one business measure. Strong memos open with the decision, reproduce each definition in plain terms with the question it serves and quantify the gaps between counts, explaining what each gap reveals. Students should declare the arbitration criteria before applying them, so the choice can be challenged on its reasons, and address any incentive that gives a definition's owner a stake in the outcome. The memo should keep the other counts under qualified names and assign ownership and change control for the enterprise definition.

How the DBA-839 Topic 3 example is put together

The finished memo sets out the three definitions exactly as each business unit computes them. Sales counts any account that placed an order in the past twelve months. Finance counts accounts invoiced in that period and not referred to collections. Customer service counts accounts holding an open service contract, whether or not they shipped anything. The memo shows that each count answers a real question its owner needs answered, and that the gaps between them are informative: accounts under contract that never ship, accounts that order and never pay. It then states the criteria for the board figure, namely the decision the board uses it for, whether it can be audited and whether it resists gaming, and applies them in turn. The memo also records that sales commissions currently reward the broadest count.

Reading the DBA 839 Topic 3 rubric

Faculty reward a definition chosen on declared criteria. An Excellent memo opens with billed customers as the board figure and keeps ordering and contracted accounts under qualified names. Credit goes to a table of three counts and to reading their gaps as credit and retention signals, after Wang and Strong. The rubric values criteria stated before applying them and Kerr on rewards that pay for unwanted conduct, given commissions tied to the broadest count. Strong memos assign the CFO ownership, as Abraham and colleagues describe. Top marks go to audit committee change control.

Common DBA 839 Topic 3 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Memos on this topic usually lose ground when they declare two of the definitions wrong. All three are correct for the questions their owners ask, and a memo that says otherwise has confused a governance choice with an error hunt. A second loss comes from choosing the governing definition without stating criteria, which leaves the decision looking like a preference for whichever unit the writer trusts. Papers that reconcile the counts into one figure by adjusting each toward the others produce a number no unit computes and nobody can audit. The commission link is frequently ignored, although it explains the resistance any change will meet. Recommendations that pick a definition and assign no owner leave the next divergence with nowhere to go, and a doctoral grader reads that as the original problem reproduced in a tidier document.

Get a DBA-839 Topic 3 example written to your instructions

Send the DBA-839 Topic 3 instructions and your classroom rubric, together with the measure or case your section provides. We write a custom example to them, with each unit's definition reproduced, arbitration criteria stated before they are applied, the incentive question addressed and change authority assigned, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More DBA 839 papers and DBA samples

DBA 839 Topic 3 questions, answered

Which business unit's definition should win?

The one that best serves the purpose of the enterprise figure, judged on criteria stated in advance. In the example the board uses the count to follow the revenue base, so the audited finance definition governs that figure. A different board question, such as sales coverage, might favor another definition. The choice follows from the use, not from which unit is right.

Why keep the other definitions at all?

Because they answer real questions. Sales needs to know who is ordering and service needs to know who holds a contract, and deleting those counts would push each unit back to private spreadsheets. Renaming them with qualified labels ends the competition for one term while preserving the information, and the gaps between the counts become useful reporting in their own right.

Is this memo a template for a real company's metrics?

No. The freight company, its three definitions and the commission arrangement were built for DBA-839 coursework to show a definitional dispute arbitrated on stated criteria. A real organization's choice would depend on its own reporting obligations, its audit requirements and the decisions its board actually makes. The example shows the reasoning a doctoral paper is expected to display, not a recommendation for any business.

Where can I find a free DBA 839 Topic 3 sample paper?

The arbitration memo is shown here complete: the recommendation, three definitions, what the gaps reveal, declared criteria, the incentive problem and ownership with change control. Post your DBA 839 Topic 3 prompt and get a free memo.

What do the gaps between counts reveal in DBA 839 Topic 3?

About 1,900 accounts ordered but were not billed in good standing, a credit and order quality signal. About 1,600 hold contracts but shipped nothing, a warning that dormant customers may be drifting to competitors.