| Course | DBA 965 Dissertation III |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 8 |
| Paper type | Final defense question bank |
| Length | About 960 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | DBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for DBA 965 Topic 8
Ranked by the Damage a Weak Answer Would Do: A Final Defense Question Bank for a Study of Branch Discount Discretion
[Author Name]
College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University
DBA-965: Dissertation III
Topic 8 Final Defense Question Bank
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Ranked by the Damage a Weak Answer Would Do: A Final Defense Question Bank for a Study of Branch Discount Discretion
The Study and How the Bank Is Built
A doctoral candidate who serves as pricing director at a composite building materials distributor, with 38 branches, studied how branch managers use discount discretion after a policy gave them authority to discount up to 8 percent without approval. The study combined two years of transaction records, before and after the policy, with interviews of 14 branch managers. It found that average realized prices fell about 2.3 percent after the policy, concentrated among contractors buying in volume, and that managers described discounting mainly to protect relationships with large accounts. The final defense is approaching. This question bank is a set of cards, one per question, ranked by how much damage a weak answer would do. Each card gives a short answer, the page where the dissertation supports it and the concession the candidate is prepared to make.
Card One: The Rival Explanation
Question: A regional construction price index shifted during the same months the discretion policy began. Did you examine it, and how do you know the price decline came from the policy rather than the market?
Answer: The dissertation did not examine the index, and that is a gap. The transaction data can say something about timing. Prices began falling in the second month after the policy, while the index turned three months later, and prices on products sold mainly to homeowners, who rarely receive discretionary discounts, did not fall. Those patterns point toward the policy. But they do not rule out the market, since contractor demand may have softened before the index recorded it. Shadish et al. (2002) identified history, an external event coinciding with the treatment, as a basic threat to validity in designs without a comparison group, and this is that threat.
Page: discussion, pages 142 to 145, and the homeowner product comparison in the findings, page 118.
Concession: The conclusion that discretion lowered prices must be held more loosely. The conclusions about how managers use discretion, from the interviews, survive intact.
Card Two: The Dropped Variable
Question: Your approved analysis included customer segment as a control. Why was it dropped?
Answer: Branch codes for customer segment proved unreliable. In a check of 200 transactions against account records, about a quarter were miscoded, and coding practice differed by branch. Keeping the variable would have introduced error correlated with branch, which could bias the estimates. The decision was made before the main analysis, recorded and approved by the chair. A substitute, order size, was used as a proxy, and results with and without it are reported.
Page: method, page 74, and the appendix on data quality.
Concession: Order size is an imperfect proxy for segment, and the finding that discounts concentrated among contractors rests partly on account names rather than coded segments.
Card Three: Managers Who Report to the Candidate's Function
Question: The branch managers you interviewed report to the pricing function you lead. How candid could they be about discounting?
Answer: Less candid than with an outsider, and the dissertation says so. Managers were interviewed by the candidate, with assurances that nothing would affect their evaluations, and transcripts were anonymized before analysis. Insider status is defensible when the researcher accounts for it (Brannick & Coghlan, 2007), and the method chapter does. Managers' accounts were also checked against the transaction records: where a manager said discounts went mainly to large accounts, the records were examined to see whether they did.
Page: method, pages 68 to 71; positionality, page 62.
Concession: Managers may have understated discounts given for reasons they expected the pricing function to disapprove of, such as personal relationships.
Card Four: The Excluded Branches
Question: Two branches declined interviews. Are they different?
Answer: Their transaction data are included in the quantitative analysis, so the price findings cover all 38 branches. They are absent only from the interviews. Both are high-volume branches in competitive metropolitan markets, where discounting may be more aggressive, and the findings chapter notes that the interview account may underrepresent such settings.
Page: findings, page 101.
Concession: The explanation of why managers discount may not reflect the most competitive branches.
The Bank at a Glance
The cards are summarized below for a final review the night before the defense. Each row is a reminder, not a script; the candidate will answer in their own words.
Table 1
Defense Question Bank Ranked by Damage
| Card | Question | Damage if weak | Core concession |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Construction price index as rival explanation | High | Price conclusion held more loosely |
| 2 | Dropped customer segment variable | Moderate | Order size is an imperfect proxy |
| 3 | Managers reporting to the candidate's function | Moderate | Some discounting reasons understated |
| 4 | Two branches declined interviews | Low | Most competitive branches underrepresented |
| 5 and 6 | Contribution | Low if method holds | Descriptive, not causal, contribution |
Rehearsal follows the ranking. The candidate will practice card one most, with the chair asking the question in several forms, because a hesitant answer on the rival explanation would invite the committee to doubt every causal statement in the dissertation, while a clear concession would show that the candidate understands the design's limits.
Cards Five and Six: Contribution
The final two cards address contribution, placed last because method questions do the most damage if answered weakly. The prepared answers state that the study adds evidence on how delegated pricing authority is used in business-to-business distribution, a setting the pricing literature has studied less than retail, and that it offers the practical finding that discretion tends to flow to the largest accounts. Antonakis et al. (2010) warned against causal language that observational designs cannot support, and the contribution answers are worded accordingly: they describe what the study found, not what discretion causes.
References
Antonakis, J., Bendahan, S., Jacquart, P., & Lalive, R. (2010). On making causal claims: A review and recommendations. The Leadership Quarterly, 21(6), 1086-1120. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.leaqua.2010.10.010
Brannick, T., & Coghlan, D. (2007). In defense of being "native": The case for insider academic research. Organizational Research Methods, 10(1), 59-74. https://doi.org/10.1177/1094428106289253
Shadish, W. R., Cook, T. D., & Campbell, D. T. (2002). Experimental and quasi-experimental designs for generalized causal inference. Houghton Mifflin.
DBA 965 Topic 8 instructions, in plain terms
Topic 8 in DBA-965 asks doctoral students to prepare for the hardest questions at a final defense. Strong question banks rank questions by how much damage a weak answer would do and take the rival explanation the study never examined first. Students should prepare, for each question, a short answer, the page that supports it and the concession they are prepared to make. The bank should cover departures from the approved analysis, the candidate's relationship to participants and missing sites, place contribution questions last and describe how the candidate will rehearse the most damaging card.
How the DBA-965 Topic 8 example is put together
The finished bank is a set of cards, one per question, ranked by how much damage a weak answer would do. The first card concerns a rival explanation: a regional construction price index shifted during the same months the discretion policy began, and the dissertation never examined it. The prepared answer concedes the gap, shows what the transaction data can say about timing and states which conclusions survive and which must be held more loosely. Later cards cover the variable dropped from the approved analysis because branch codes were unreliable, the fact that the interviewed branch managers report to the candidate's function, and the branches excluded after two declined. Each card gives a short answer, the page where the dissertation supports it and the concession the candidate is prepared to make. Contribution questions sit on the final two cards.
Reading the DBA 965 Topic 8 rubric
Faculty reward the hardest question answered first. An Excellent bank ranks cards by damage and opens with the unexamined construction price index, conceding a history threat from Shadish, Cook and Campbell while showing what timing and homeowner products suggest. Credit goes to cards on the dropped segment variable and managers reporting to the candidate, after Brannick and Coghlan. The rubric values a page and a concession on every card and a summary table. Strong banks word contribution answers within Antonakis and colleagues' limits. Top marks go to rehearsing card one hardest.
Common DBA 965 Topic 8 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Final defenses go worst for candidates who prepare to present their contribution and meet a committee that wants to discuss method, particularly a rival explanation the dissertation left unexamined. Preparing answers that deny a real gap fails in a different way; a committee that has found the gap will press until the denial collapses, while a bounded concession ends the line of questioning. Candidates are also caught out by questions about departures from the approved analysis that were disclosed but never justified in the text. Insider defenses weaken when the answer to a question about reporting lines is a promise of objectivity rather than a description of what the design did about it. Answers that run long under pressure lose the committee. A question bank without follow-up questions prepares for a conversation that will not happen.
Get a DBA-965 Topic 8 example written to your instructions
Send the DBA-965 Topic 8 instructions and your classroom rubric. We write a custom structural example to them, showing method questions ranked, answered and conceded where necessary, in 24 to 48 hours, and the first one is free. Your dissertation is your own work: we never write chapters for a reader, and your IRB application, site permission letters, committee correspondence and signatures stay yours.
More DBA 965 papers and DBA samples
- DBA 965 Topic 1: Analysis Execution Chapter
- DBA 965 Topic 2: Findings Chapter Presentation
- DBA 965 Topic 3: Interpretation Boundary Memo
- DBA 965 Topic 4: Unsettled Questions Section
- DBA 965 Topic 5: Absent Effect Dq Post
- DBA 965 Topic 6: Pilot-scale Recommendation Set
- DBA 965 Topic 7: Chapter Reconciliation Audit
- MGT 805 Topic 8: Structural Choice Defense
- DBA 960 Topic 8: Achieved Sample Description
- MGT 820 Topic 8: Advantage Durability Assessment
- DBA 955 Topic 8: Proposal Method Defense Brief
DBA 965 Topic 8 questions, answered
What is the hardest question at a final dissertation defense?
Frequently it concerns a rival account of the results that the dissertation never examined, since pointing to completed work cannot answer it. Committees raise it to see whether the candidate understands the limits of the design. The example ranks that question first and prepares a concession that bounds the gap and states which conclusions still hold, rather than a denial.
Should I defend my contribution or my method?
Prepare for method first. By the final defense, committees generally accept that the question mattered and focus on whether the study answered it soundly, including departures from the approved plan and threats the design left open. The example gives contribution the last two cards and spends its preparation on analysis, sampling, reporting lines and rival explanations.
Will you prepare my defense answers?
No. The defense is an examination of your own work, and its answers have to come from your understanding of your study and your data. This page's composite distributor lays out the architecture of a question bank and nothing more. Your dissertation, your defense and all correspondence with your committee are yours to prepare.
Where can I find a free DBA 965 Topic 8 sample paper?
The question bank is printed here in full: the study, four method cards with answers, pages and concessions, a summary table, rehearsal and two contribution cards. Send your DBA 965 Topic 8 prompt and a paper follows free.
Why is the price index the first card in DBA 965 Topic 8?
A weak answer on an unexamined rival explanation would invite doubt about every causal statement. A clear concession, with what the timing evidence shows, limits the damage to one conclusion.