| Course | DNP 820 Translational Research and Evidence-Based Practice |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 6 |
| Paper type | Evidence synthesis paper |
| Length | About 1,170 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | DNP |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for DNP 820 Topic 6
Three Findings, One Dispute and a Gap of the Third Kind: A Synthesis of the Evidence on Paired Awakening and Breathing Trials
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
DNP-820: Translational Research and Evidence-Based Practice
Topic 6 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
July 5, 2027
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Three Findings, One Dispute and a Gap of the Third Kind: A Synthesis of the Evidence on Paired Awakening and Breathing Trials
The Body of Literature
The synthesis draws on the evidence assembled through the Topic 2 search and its reference-list check, narrowed to studies that report ventilation, safety or adherence outcomes for awakening trials, breathing trials or the two paired. Eight sources carry the weight. Three are randomized trials: an early single-center trial of daily sedative interruption (Kress et al., 2000), the multicenter Awakening and Breathing Controlled trial (Girard et al., 2008) and a multicenter trial of daily interruption added to protocolized sedation (Mehta et al., 2012). One is a Cochrane review pooling nine trials with 1,282 patients (Burry et al., 2014). Two are implementation studies with before-and-after designs at single institutions (Balas et al., 2014; Kher et al., 2013), one is a large collaborative cohort (Pun et al., 2019) and one is a statewide practice survey (Miller et al., 2015). The range of designs matters, because the trials answer whether the practice works under controlled conditions and the implementation studies answer what happens when units try to adopt it.
Findings the Evidence Supports Consistently
Finding 1: pairing an awakening trial with a breathing trial shortens mechanical ventilation when the comparison is sedation managed without a protocol. Two randomized trials support it directly (Girard et al., 2008; Kress et al., 2000), and a before-and-after implementation study found the same direction and similar size in routine care: patients after bundle implementation spent three more days breathing without assistance, a median of 24 versus 21 ventilator-free days (Balas et al., 2014). The effect is consistent in direction and in magnitude, about three days, across these three sources.
Finding 2: the practice does not increase reintubation. In the Awakening and Breathing Controlled trial, self-extubation was more frequent with paired trials, but reintubation was similar, 13.8 versus 12.5 percent (Girard et al., 2008). The Cochrane review found no difference in accidental endotracheal tube removal (risk ratio 1.07), and neither the bundle implementation study nor the protocolized-sedation trial found a difference in unplanned extubation (Balas et al., 2014; Burry et al., 2014; Mehta et al., 2012). Four sources, two designs, one conclusion.
Finding 3: outcomes improve in step with how completely the practice and its companion elements are performed. In the ICU Liberation Collaborative, patients whose eligible elements were performed more completely were less likely to still need the ventilator the following day, to be delirious or to be restrained (Pun et al., 2019), and units that combined mobility with sedation interruption and delirium screening reported reaching higher mobility levels than units attempting mobility alone (Miller et al., 2015). Both sources are observational, so this finding rests on association, but the dose-response pattern is consistent across them.
The Contested Finding
Whether daily sedation interruption itself shortens ventilation is disputed. The Cochrane review found a 13 percent reduction in the geometric mean duration of ventilation, with a confidence interval running from a 26 percent reduction to a 2 percent increase, which it judged as no strong evidence of an effect (Burry et al., 2014). The largest trial in that review found no difference at all: median time to extubation was 7 days in both groups, and nurse workload was higher with daily interruption (Mehta et al., 2012).
The disagreement tracks a difference in the comparator. In the positive trials, the control patients received sedation without a structured protocol (Girard et al., 2008; Kress et al., 2000). In the null trial, both groups were already managed with a nurse-directed sedation protocol, and daily interruption was added on top of it (Mehta et al., 2012). The review's own post hoc analysis adds a hint that setting matters: pooling only the five North American studies produced a 21 percent reduction (Burry et al., 2014). The most coherent reading is that interruption helps when there is sedation to interrupt and adds little where protocolized light sedation is already in place. That reading is an inference from how the trials differ, not a tested finding, and I treat it as such.
Characterizing the Gap
A gap can be one of three kinds: a population never studied, a population studied with null results, or a population studied under conditions that do not transfer. The gap that matters for this project is of the third kind. Strategies for raising adherence have been studied, but mainly in academic centers with resources a typical unit lacks. Balas et al. (2014) implemented the bundle across seven units of a 624-bed tertiary center with an interprofessional team built for the project, and the collaborative sites in Pun et al. (2019) received structured coaching. The one single-unit project most like ours shows what happens without that support: after a protocol tailored to local preferences, with education and reminders, compliance with the awakening component reached only 44 percent while the breathing trial reached 84 percent, and duration of ventilation did not change (Kher et al., 2013).
That pattern is the gap. It is not that nobody has tried to raise adherence, and it is not that attempts have failed everywhere. It is that the successful attempts ran under conditions this ICU cannot reproduce, and the one attempt under similar conditions stalled on the nursing half of the pair. What would address it is a unit-level implementation that targets the awakening component specifically, with coordination built into the schedule rather than into education, measured and reported in enough detail that other units without project teams can judge whether it transfers.
What the Synthesis Supports Here, and Where It Stops
In the composite 22-bed medical ICU, more than a third of ventilated days at baseline involved a continuous benzodiazepine drip, and there is no nurse-directed sedation protocol. That places this unit closer to the control arms of the positive trials than to the null trial, so the synthesis supports expecting a benefit in ventilation duration from reliably paired trials, and it supports reassuring staff that reintubation is unlikely to rise. It does not support a specific expected effect size for this unit, because the three-day estimates come from different case mixes and baseline practices. And it does not support any particular adherence strategy as proven, since the only comparable single-unit attempt did not reach high awakening-trial compliance.
What the Project Can Proceed On and What It Must Establish Locally
The project can proceed on three things: that paired trials shorten ventilation in settings with this unit's sedation practice, that they are safe with respect to reintubation, and that fuller performance of the bundle is associated with better outcomes. It will have to establish two things locally. The first is whether scheduling the awakening trial to finish before the respiratory therapist's breathing-trial window, rather than relying on education and reminders, raises awakening-trial completion beyond the level Kher et al. (2013) reached. The second is whether ventilator days fall once pairing is reliable, measured against this unit's own baseline and adjusted for severity, since the published estimates cannot be imported as a target.
References
Balas, M. C., Vasilevskis, E. E., Olsen, K. M., Schmid, K. K., Shostrom, V., Cohen, M. Z., Peitz, G., Gannon, D. E., Sisson, J., Sullivan, J., Stothert, J. C., Lazure, J., Nuss, S. L., Jawa, R. S., Freihaut, F., Ely, E. W., & Burke, W. J. (2014). Effectiveness and safety of the awakening and breathing coordination, delirium monitoring/management, and early exercise/mobility bundle. Critical Care Medicine, 42(5), 1024-1036. https://doi.org/10.1097/CCM.0000000000000129
Burry, L., Rose, L., McCullagh, I. J., Fergusson, D. A., Ferguson, N. D., & Mehta, S. (2014). Daily sedation interruption versus no daily sedation interruption for critically ill adult patients requiring invasive mechanical ventilation. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2014(7), Article CD009176. https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD009176.pub2
Girard, T. D., Kress, J. P., Fuchs, B. D., Thomason, J. W. W., Schweickert, W. D., Pun, B. T., Taichman, D. B., Dunn, J. G., Pohlman, A. S., Kinniry, P. A., Jackson, J. C., Canonico, A. E., Light, R. W., Shintani, A. K., Thompson, J. L., Gordon, S. M., Hall, J. B., Dittus, R. S., Bernard, G. R., & Ely, E. W. (2008). Efficacy and safety of a paired sedation and ventilator weaning protocol for mechanically ventilated patients in intensive care (Awakening and Breathing Controlled trial): A randomised controlled trial. The Lancet, 371(9607), 126-134. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(08)60105-1
Kher, S., Roberts, R. J., Garpestad, E., Kunkel, C., Howard, W., Didominico, D., Fergusson, A., & Devlin, J. W. (2013). Development, implementation, and evaluation of an institutional daily awakening and spontaneous breathing trial protocol: A quality improvement project. Journal of Intensive Care Medicine, 28(3), 189-197. https://doi.org/10.1177/0885066612444255
Kress, J. P., Pohlman, A. S., O'Connor, M. F., & Hall, J. B. (2000). Daily interruption of sedative infusions in critically ill patients undergoing mechanical ventilation. New England Journal of Medicine, 342(20), 1471-1477. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJM200005183422002
Mehta, S., Burry, L., Cook, D., Fergusson, D., Steinberg, M., Granton, J., Herridge, M., Ferguson, N., Devlin, J., Tanios, M., Dodek, P., Fowler, R., Burns, K., Jacka, M., Olafson, K., Skrobik, Y., Hébert, P., Sabri, E., Meade, M., SLEAP Investigators, & Canadian Critical Care Trials Group. (2012). Daily sedation interruption in mechanically ventilated critically ill patients cared for with a sedation protocol: A randomized controlled trial. JAMA, 308(19), 1985-1992. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2012.13872
Miller, M. A., Govindan, S., Watson, S. R., Hyzy, R. C., & Iwashyna, T. J. (2015). ABCDE, but in that order? A cross-sectional survey of Michigan intensive care unit sedation, delirium, and early mobility practices. Annals of the American Thoracic Society, 12(7), 1066-1071. https://doi.org/10.1513/AnnalsATS.201501-066OC
Pun, B. T., Balas, M. C., Barnes-Daly, M. A., Thompson, J. L., Aldrich, J. M., Barr, J., Byrum, D., Carson, S. S., Devlin, J. W., Engel, H. J., Esbrook, C. L., Hargett, K. D., Harmon, L., Hielsberg, C., Jackson, J. C., Kelly, T. L., Kumar, V., Millner, L., Morse, A., . . . Ely, E. W. (2019). Caring for critically ill patients with the ABCDEF bundle: Results of the ICU Liberation Collaborative in over 15,000 adults. Critical Care Medicine, 47(1), 3-14. https://doi.org/10.1097/CCM.0000000000003482
DNP 820 Topic 6 instructions, in plain terms
Topic 6 in DNP-820 asks students to synthesize the evidence for their project. Strong syntheses are organized by finding rather than by study, stating what the evidence supports consistently, what is contested and why. Students should look for what separates contradictory studies, such as differences in comparison groups or sedation practice, rather than simply listing them. The gap should be characterized precisely, distinguishing a population never studied, one studied with null results and one studied under conditions that may not transfer. The synthesis should state what the project can proceed on and what it must establish locally. A table of findings with the studies behind each helps faculty see the structure.
Inside the DNP 820 Topic 6 example
The finished example never devotes a paragraph to a single study. Findings are the units: three claims the evidence supports consistently, each carrying the studies that support it and a note on how consistent the effect size is across them. One claim is contested, and the paper examines whether the disagreement tracks something, which it does, since the two null results come from settings without the staffing the positive studies had. The gap is then characterized rather than merely announced, and the distinction is important: this population has never been studied, as opposed to studied with null results or studied under conditions that do not transfer. The paper says which, and what would have to be done about it.
Where the marks sit in the DNP 820 Topic 6 rubric
Faculty reward a synthesis organized by finding. An Excellent paper states three consistent findings, including shorter ventilation from pairing per Girard and colleagues and safety on reintubation. Credit goes to treating sedation interruption as contested, setting Burry and colleagues' Cochrane estimate of 13 percent with its wide interval beside Mehta and colleagues' trial. The rubric values explaining that comparison groups differed in sedation practice. Strong papers characterize the gap as conditions that may not transfer. Top marks go to placing the unit, with its benzodiazepine drips, where the evidence applies.
Common DNP 820 Topic 6 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Synthesis written as a study by study march is the failure this topic reliably surfaces, recognizable from its first paragraph. A second failure is announcing a gap without characterizing it, since an unexamined population and a population studied with null findings call for entirely different projects. Marks also go for reporting only the direction of effects while ignoring how much they vary across studies. Papers that avoid contradictions in the literature leave the most informative material unused. Claims supported by a single study presented alongside claims supported by nine imply an equivalence that does not exist. Syntheses with no local application leave the project unconnected to the evidence. Gaps announced in a single closing sentence get none of the length the finding deserves.
Get a DNP-820 Topic 6 example written to your instructions
Send the DNP-820 Topic 6 instructions and the rubric your classroom posts, with your practice question and the studies your section requires. We write a custom example to those criteria, organized by finding, with consistency reported, disagreement traced and the gap characterized, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More DNP 820 papers and DNP samples
- DNP 820 Topic 1: Translation Science Orientation
- DNP 820 Topic 2: Searchable Question Construction
- DNP 820 Topic 3: Appraisal Tool Comparison
- DNP 820 Topic 4: DNP-820 Topic 4: Sample Paper, in Real Form
- DNP 820 Topic 5: Strength of Recommendation DQ Pair
- DNP 820 Topic 7: Translation Model Selection
- DNP 820 Topic 8: Dissemination Audience Plan
- DNP 825 Topic 6: Language and Culture in Program Design
- DNP 815A Topic 6: Translation Framework Application
- DNP 830 Topic 6: Relationships Between Variables DQ Pair
- DNP 810 Topic 6: Social Conditions Analysis
DNP 820 Topic 6 questions, answered
What makes a synthesis different from a review?
Organization. A review moves through studies; a synthesis moves through claims, and each claim carries whichever studies bear on it. The test is whether a single paper appears in three different sections because it contributes to three findings. If every study gets one paragraph and appears once, you have written a review whatever the heading says.
How do I handle studies that contradict each other?
Look for what separates them before concluding the evidence is mixed. Disagreements frequently track a difference in setting, staffing, population or how the outcome was measured. Finding that pattern is the most valuable thing a synthesis can produce, because it tells you which side of the literature applies to your site. Declaring the evidence inconsistent is where the work should start.
Why characterize the gap rather than name it?
Because different silences need different projects. A population nobody has studied might justify a straightforward implementation with local measurement. A population studied with null results demands an explanation before you proceed. A population studied only under conditions you cannot reproduce means the evidence does not transfer. Saying which one you face determines what you do next.
Where can I find a free DNP 820 Topic 6 sample paper?
All of the trial evidence synthesis is on this page: the body of literature, findings supported consistently, the contested finding, the gap characterized, what the synthesis supports here and what the project must establish locally. Your own DNP 820 Topic 6 prompt gets a free synthesis.
How are contradictory studies handled in DNP 820 Topic 6?
By finding what separates them. Interruption helped most where the comparison was heavy sedation without a protocol and little where a nurse-directed protocol already kept sedation light.