| Course | ECN 601 Economics |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 3 |
| Paper type | Cost and output analysis |
| Length | About 1,080 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for ECN 601 Topic 3
Six Batches a Week at a Loss: Marginal Cost, the Shape of Average Cost and the Shutdown Test at a Craft Brewery
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
ECN-601: Economics
Topic 3 Cost and Output Analysis
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Six Batches a Week at a Loss: Marginal Cost, the Shape of Average Cost and the Shutdown Test at a Craft Brewery
The Decision
A composite craft brewery sells beer to distributors in batches of 100 cases. Wholesale prices in its region have fallen to 1,900 dollars a batch, and at that price the brewery is losing money. Its owners are asking two questions: how many batches a week should it brew, and should it keep brewing at all? This analysis separates the brewery's fixed and variable costs, computes average and marginal cost across its output range, explains the shape of the average cost curve, chooses output at the margin and works the shutdown test. Figures are illustrative.
Fixed and Variable Costs
The brewery's fixed costs are about 4,000 dollars a week: the lease on its building, loan payments on its fermentation tanks and the salary of its head brewer. These are paid whether it brews no batches or seven. Its variable costs, malt, hops, packaging, energy and hourly labor, rise with every batch. Because fixed costs do not change with output, they cannot change which output is best, a point Clark (1923) developed in a study of overhead costs; they affect whether the brewery makes a profit, not how much it should produce. This is the point the analysis returns to below, because it is the one most often missed.
Average and Marginal Cost
Marginal cost is the change in total cost from producing one more batch (Mankiw, 2021). It is computed from the difference between successive totals, not by dividing total cost by output, which gives average cost and answers a different question. The first batch adds 1,500 dollars of variable cost, the second 1,100 and the third 900, as the brewing crew settles into a rhythm and the equipment is used more fully. After that the cost of each additional batch rises, 1,100, 1,400, 1,800 and then 2,400 for the seventh, as the tanks are crowded, overtime begins and cleaning cycles cut into brewing time.
Table 1
Weekly Costs by Output, Dollars, With Fixed Cost of 4,000
| Batches | Variable cost | Total cost | Marginal cost | Average variable cost | Average total cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1,500 | 5,500 | 1,500 | 1,500 | 5,500 |
| 2 | 2,600 | 6,600 | 1,100 | 1,300 | 3,300 |
| 3 | 3,500 | 7,500 | 900 | 1,167 | 2,500 |
| 4 | 4,600 | 8,600 | 1,100 | 1,150 | 2,150 |
| 5 | 6,000 | 10,000 | 1,400 | 1,200 | 2,000 |
| 6 | 7,800 | 11,800 | 1,800 | 1,300 | 1,967 |
| 7 | 10,200 | 14,200 | 2,400 | 1,457 | 2,029 |
Why Average Cost Has Its Shape
The U shape of average cost is not assumed here; it follows from marginal cost. An average falls whenever the next unit costs less than the current average and rises whenever it costs more, just as a student's grade average falls when the next test score is below it. Average variable cost falls from 1,500 to 1,150 over the first four batches because each added batch costs less than the average so far; the fourth batch, at 1,100, is still below the average of 1,167 it joins. The fifth batch costs 1,400, above the average of 1,150, so the average turns up. Average total cost falls longer, to 1,967 at six batches, because spreading the 4,000 dollars of fixed cost over more batches keeps pulling it down; it turns up at the seventh, whose marginal cost of 2,400 exceeds the average of 1,967. In each case marginal cost crosses the average at its lowest point (Viner, 1932).
Output Chosen at the Margin
In a market with many breweries selling similar beer to distributors, the brewery takes the wholesale price as given, so each extra batch adds 1,900 dollars of revenue: its marginal revenue equals the price. It should brew another batch whenever that batch adds more to revenue than to cost. The sixth batch costs 1,800 and earns 1,900, so it is worth brewing. The seventh costs 2,400 and earns 1,900, so it is not. The brewery should produce six batches a week. At six batches, revenue is 11,400 dollars and total cost 11,800, a loss of 400 dollars a week. Every other output loses more: five batches lose 500 and seven lose 900.
The Shutdown Test
A firm that is losing money may still be right to keep producing in the short run. If the brewery stopped brewing, its revenue and variable costs would fall to zero, but it would still owe the 4,000 dollars of fixed cost, so it would lose 4,000 a week. By brewing six batches it loses only 400, because revenue of 11,400 covers the variable cost of 7,800 and contributes 3,600 toward the fixed costs. The rule is to keep producing as long as price covers average variable cost, which at 1,900 against a minimum of about 1,150 it comfortably does. If the price fell to 1,100, below the lowest average variable cost, the best output would lose 4,200 dollars a week, more than the 4,000 lost by shutting down, and the brewery should stop brewing until prices recover.
Fixed Costs and the Decision
Suppose the landlord raises the rent and fixed costs rise to 6,000 dollars a week. The marginal cost of each batch is unchanged, because rent does not depend on how much beer is brewed, so the best output is still six batches; the weekly loss simply grows to 2,400 dollars. A manager who reacted to the higher rent by brewing more to spread it, or less to save on it, would make the loss larger. That is what it means to say fixed costs are irrelevant to the output decision.
The Long Run
The short-run decision is not the end of the analysis. At 1,900 dollars a batch, the price is below the brewery's lowest average total cost of about 1,967, so it cannot cover all its costs at any output. If prices stay there, the brewery should plan to leave the market when its lease and loans come up for renewal, because in the long run every cost becomes variable and must be covered. If enough breweries leave, supply falls and the price rises, which is how a competitive market brings losses back toward zero.
Conclusion
Comparing marginal cost with marginal revenue tells the brewery to brew six batches a week, and comparing price with average variable cost tells it that six batches at a loss of 400 beat shutting down at a loss of 4,000. Fixed costs settle whether the brewery profits, not how much it brews. The analysis turns its cost table into both decisions and states the price, 1,150 dollars a batch, below which the answer changes.
References
Clark, J. M. (1923). Studies in the economics of overhead costs. University of Chicago Press.
Mankiw, N. G. (2021). Principles of economics (9th ed.). Cengage.
Viner, J. (1932). Cost curves and supply curves. Zeitschrift für Nationalökonomie, 3(1), 23-46. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01316299
The ECN-601 Topic 3 assignment instructions
In Topic 3, ECN-601 asks MBA students to analyze costs and choose output at the margin. Strong analyses separate fixed from variable costs, compute marginal cost from changes in total cost, explain the shape of average cost through marginal cost and choose the output where marginal cost meets marginal revenue. Students should work the shutdown test against average variable cost and treat the long run separately. The paper should also show that fixed costs leave the best output unchanged by recomputing the decision after a fixed cost rises. A short treatment of the long run, when every cost becomes variable, completes the analysis.
How the ECN-601 Topic 3 example is put together
The finished example decides one unit at a time. Fixed and variable costs are separated, and the example is explicit that fixed costs are irrelevant to the output decision, which is the point students most resist. Marginal cost is computed from the change in total cost rather than from an average, and the output choice follows from comparing it against marginal revenue. The relationship between marginal and average cost is explained rather than drawn, since the average falls whenever the next unit costs less than the current average and rises when it costs more. The short run shutdown decision is worked, and the example shows why a firm losing money may rationally keep producing.
ECN 601 Topic 3 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Faculty reward marginal reasoning applied one batch at a time. An Excellent paper tables total, marginal and average costs for seven batches. Credit goes to explaining the U shape as marginal cost crossing the average at its minimum, with Viner on cost curves. The rubric values a loss of 400 compared against 4,000 from shutting down and a price of 1,100 that reverses the answer. Strong papers show higher rent leaving output at six batches. Top marks go to the long run exit plan. Papers that state the price at which the answer changes, here the minimum of average variable cost, give the owners a rule they can use when prices move. Faculty also reward explaining the U shape rather than asserting it.
ECN 601 Topic 3 help: mistakes that cost marks
Including fixed costs in the output decision is the error the topic exists to remove, since they are paid regardless and cannot change what quantity is optimal. A second failure is computing marginal cost by dividing total cost by output, which produces the average and answers a different question entirely. Papers lose marks for asserting the U shape of average cost without explaining it, because the explanation through marginal cost is the assessed content. Treating any loss as a reason to shut down misses the short run analysis, where covering variable costs and contributing something toward fixed costs is better than producing nothing. Confusing the short run with the long run leads to recommendations that assume inputs the firm cannot change this year.
Get an ECN-601 Topic 3 example written to your instructions
Send the ECN-601 Topic 3 problems and the rubric your classroom posts, with the cost data your section supplied. We write a custom example to those criteria, with fixed costs excluded from the decision, marginal cost computed from the change in total, the average shape explained and the shutdown case worked, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More ECN 601 papers and MBA samples
- ECN 601 Topic 1: Market Equilibrium Analysis
- ECN 601 Topic 2: Elasticity and Pricing Analysis
- ECN 601 Topic 4: Market Structure Comparison
- ECN 601 Topic 5: Macroeconomic Indicator Analysis
- ECN 601 Topic 6: Business Cycle Position Analysis
- ECN 601 Topic 7: Policy Transmission Analysis
- ECN 601 Topic 8: Trade and Exchange Rate Analysis
- BUS 660 Topic 3: Forecasting Method Comparison
- BUS 655 Topic 3: Price Elasticity Estimate
- HRM 635 Topic 3: Build Versus Buy Cost Case
- BUS 635 Topic 3: Sponsorship Valuation Proposal
ECN 601 Topic 3 questions, answered
Why are fixed costs irrelevant to the output decision?
Because they do not change with the quantity produced. Rent is owed whether you make one unit or a thousand, so it cannot make one quantity better than another. The decision is entirely about whether the next unit earns more than it costs to make, and only variable costs enter that comparison. Fixed costs matter for whether to be in the business at all, which is a different question.
Why does average cost fall and then rise?
Because of what the next unit costs relative to the current average. Early on, spreading fixed costs over more units and gains from specialization make each additional unit cheap, so the average falls. Eventually capacity constraints make each additional unit more expensive than the current average, and the average rises. The average follows the marginal, which is why explaining the relationship beats describing the shape.
When should a firm shut down in the short run?
When the price does not cover average variable cost. If a firm can cover its variable costs and contribute anything toward fixed costs, it loses less by producing than by stopping, since the fixed costs are owed either way. That is why loss making firms rationally keep operating. Once price falls below average variable cost, every unit adds to the loss and shutting down is better.
Where can I find a free ECN 601 Topic 3 sample paper?
The cost and output analysis is shown here complete: the decision, fixed and variable costs, average and marginal cost, the curve's shape, output at the margin, the shutdown test, fixed costs and the decision, the long run and the conclusion. Send your cost data and we will work it free.
Why keep brewing at a loss in ECN 601 Topic 3?
At 1,900 dollars a batch, revenue covers the variable cost and contributes 3,600 dollars toward fixed costs. Shutting down would lose the full 4,000 of fixed cost instead of 400.