ECN 601 Topic 8 trade and exchange rate analysis example

Economics Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This ECN 601 Topic 8 sample paper demonstrates comparative advantage on numbers, distributes the cost of the 2018 washing machine tariffs and traces a currency move through a composite appliance parts supplier. It was prepared for GCU ECN 601, Economics, catalog code ECN-601, a course in Grand Canyon University's MBA. With the United States better at both goods, specialization still lifts output from 50 washers and 20 parts to 52 and 24, and trade leaves both countries ahead. Flaaen and colleagues find washer prices rose nearly 12 percent, at roughly 815,000 dollars per job. A 10 percent dollar fall costs the supplier 444,000 on peso inputs and gains 247,000 on Canadian sales. The recommendation pairs open trade with worker adjustment.

CourseECN 601 Economics
TopicTopic 8
Paper typeTrade and exchange rate analysis
LengthAbout 1,050 words, 2 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMBA
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for ECN 601 Topic 8

1

Who Gains and Who Pays: Comparative Advantage on the Numbers, the 2018 Washing Machine Tariffs and a Peso Move in an Appliance Supplier's Accounts

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

ECN-601: Economics

Topic 8 Trade and Exchange Rate Analysis

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title separates the gain from its distribution, which is the topic's point. The tariff evidence is real; the countries' hours and the supplier are illustrative.
2

Who Gains and Who Pays: Comparative Advantage on the Numbers, the 2018 Washing Machine Tariffs and a Peso Move in an Appliance Supplier's Accounts

Two Questions

Trade policy raises two questions that are often run together: does trade make a country better off in total, and who gains and who loses within it? This analysis answers the first by demonstrating comparative advantage on numbers, the second by examining the 2018 US tariffs on imported washing machines, and then traces a currency movement into the accounts of a composite appliance parts supplier that both imports and exports. It closes with a recommendation that weighs the total against the distribution.

Comparative Advantage on the Numbers

Take two illustrative economies, the United States and Mexico, each with 600 hours of labor, producing washing machines and aircraft parts. A US worker needs 10 hours for a washer and 20 for a part; a Mexican worker needs 15 hours for a washer and 60 for a part. The United States is better at both, which is absolute advantage in both goods. What matters for trade is opportunity cost (Ricardo, 1817). In the United States, one part costs the 2 washers that the same 20 hours could have made; in Mexico, one part costs 4 washers. So the United States gives up less to make parts, and Mexico gives up less to make washers: a washer costs Mexico a quarter of a part and the United States half a part. Each has a comparative advantage in a different good, even though one country is better at everything.

Table 1

Output and Consumption Before and After Specialization, Illustrative

AllocationUS washersUS partsMexico washersMexico partsTotal washersTotal parts
Each splits its hours equally, no trade30152055020
Mexico specializes in washers; US makes mostly parts12244005224
After trading 18 washers for 6 parts30182265224

Where the Gains Come From

Without trade, each country splits its hours equally, and together they produce 50 washers and 20 parts. If Mexico makes only washers and the United States puts 480 of its hours into parts and 120 into washers, total output rises to 52 washers and 24 parts from the same labor. Trading at 3 washers per part, between the two countries' opportunity costs of 2 and 4, Mexico sends 18 washers for 6 parts. The United States ends with 30 washers and 18 parts, 3 more parts than before; Mexico ends with 22 washers and 6 parts, more of both. The gains come from each country producing what it gives up least to make, which is why confusing absolute with comparative advantage reverses the conclusion: by absolute advantage, the United States should make everything.

A Trade Restriction and Its Distribution

In 2018 the United States imposed safeguard tariffs on imported washing machines. Flaaen et al. (2020) found that washer prices rose nearly 12 percent and that dryer prices, which were not tariffed, rose by a similar amount, because they are usually bought together and sellers raised both. The authors estimate that consumers paid about 1.5 billion dollars a year more, while foreign manufacturers opened or expanded US plants that added about 1,800 jobs, a cost to consumers of roughly 815,000 dollars per job. The distribution is the central finding. Domestic washer producers and their workers gained, in higher prices and more jobs. The government collected tariff revenue, though far less than consumers paid, since most of the price increase on domestic and untariffed products went to producers rather than the Treasury. Consumers lost, and in total they lost more than producers and the government together gained (Mankiw, 2021).

Why the Politics Differ From the Arithmetic

If consumers lose more than producers gain, why do such tariffs pass? Because the gains are concentrated and the losses diffuse. A few manufacturers and the workers in their plants gain a great deal each, so they have strong reasons to organize, lobby and vote on the issue. Each consumer loses perhaps 80 or 90 dollars on a washer bought once every several years, too little to notice or to organize around. Olson (1965) explained that small groups with large individual stakes organize more effectively than large groups with small individual stakes, which is why trade policy often favors producers even when the total is negative.

A Currency Movement in a Firm's Accounts

A composite US appliance parts supplier buys components from Mexico priced at 72 million pesos a year and sells finished assemblies to a Canadian manufacturer for 3 million Canadian dollars a year. At 18 pesos per dollar, its components cost 4.0 million dollars. If the dollar depreciates by 10 percent against the peso, to 16.2 pesos, the same components cost about 4.44 million dollars, about 444,000 more. The same depreciation against the Canadian dollar, from 1.35 to 1.215 Canadian dollars per US dollar, raises the US-dollar value of its Canadian sales from about 2.22 million to about 2.47 million, about 247,000 more. A weaker dollar helped the supplier as an exporter and hurt it as an importer; taken together it loses about 197,000 dollars a year, because its peso costs are larger than its Canadian revenue. The supplier should treat the export revenue as a partial natural hedge and use forward contracts to cover the remaining peso exposure.

Recommendation

The analysis recommends against extending broad safeguard tariffs of the washing machine kind. The evidence shows a total loss, with consumers paying far more than the jobs gained are worth on any reasonable measure. The recommendation acknowledges who would bear the cost of removing them: the workers in the new plants, who would face real losses concentrated in a few communities. A better policy would pair open trade with adjustment assistance for those workers, such as retraining and wage insurance, funded from the gains that open trade spreads across consumers.

Conclusion

Comparative advantage shows on the numbers that both economies gain from trade even when one is better at everything. The washing machine tariffs show that a restriction can raise some producers' gains while costing consumers more in total, and that diffuse losses explain the politics. A currency movement helps a firm as an exporter and hurts it as an importer at the same time. Policy advice in trade should report the total and say who pays.

References

Flaaen, A., Hortaçsu, A., & Tintelnot, F. (2020). The production relocation and price effects of US trade policy: The case of washing machines. American Economic Review, 110(7), 2103-2127. https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.20190611

Mankiw, N. G. (2021). Principles of economics (9th ed.). Cengage.

Olson, M. (1965). The logic of collective action: Public goods and the theory of groups. Harvard University Press.

Ricardo, D. (1817). On the principles of political economy and taxation. John Murray.

The ECN-601 Topic 8 assignment instructions

The Topic 8 assignment in ECN-601 asks MBA students to analyze trade and exchange rates. Strong analyses demonstrate comparative advantage with numbers, show where the gains come from, and separate producers, consumers and government when a trade restriction is imposed. Students should explain why concentrated gains win politically, trace a currency move into a firm's revenue and costs, and make a recommendation that says who pays. The paper should also show where the gains from specializing come from and why confusing absolute with comparative advantage reverses the conclusion. A firm's exposure to a currency move should be netted across its revenue and costs.

How this ECN 601 Topic 8 example is built

The finished example counts the winners and the losers as two separate groups. Comparative advantage is demonstrated on numbers rather than asserted, showing that both parties can gain even when one is better at everything, which is the result that makes the whole subject counterintuitive. A trade restriction is then analyzed for its distribution: protected producers gain visibly and concentratedly, consumers lose more in total but invisibly and individually, which explains the politics as well as the economics. A currency movement is traced into a specific firm's position, since a depreciation helps an exporter and damages an importer and most firms are partly both. The recommendation weighs the total against the distribution honestly.

ECN 601 Topic 8 rubric: what Excellent looks like

Faculty reward gains demonstrated and then distributed. An Excellent paper tables output before and after specialization using Ricardo's opportunity cost reasoning. Credit goes to the washer and dryer price increases and the cost per job from Flaaen and colleagues. The rubric values Olson's account of concentrated gains and diffuse losses. Strong papers net a peso cost increase against a Canadian revenue gain for one supplier. Top marks go to advice that names the workers who would bear the change. Papers that recommend a hedge for the remaining currency exposure, after treating export revenue as a partial natural hedge, show the analysis carried to a business action. Faculty also credit tariff evidence drawn from a published study rather than assertion.

Common ECN 601 Topic 8 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Asserting comparative advantage rather than demonstrating it is the shortfall, since the counterintuitive result only convinces when the numbers are on the page. A second failure is reporting only the net effect of a trade restriction, which hides that the losses are spread thinly across many consumers while the gains concentrate on few producers, and that distribution is the interesting finding. Papers lose marks for treating a currency depreciation as simply good or bad for a country, when it helps exporters and harms importers simultaneously. Confusing absolute with comparative advantage is the classic conceptual error and it inverts the conclusion. Recommendations that ignore who bears the cost read as incomplete in a topic built around distribution.

Get an ECN-601 Topic 8 example written to your instructions

Send the ECN-601 Topic 8 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with the trade measure or currency situation your section assigned. We write a custom example to those criteria, with comparative advantage demonstrated on numbers, winners and losers counted separately and a currency movement traced into one firm, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.

More ECN 601 papers and MBA samples

ECN 601 Topic 8 questions, answered

What is the difference between absolute and comparative advantage?

Absolute advantage means producing something with fewer resources; comparative advantage means producing it at a lower opportunity cost. The second is what drives trade, and it explains why a country better at everything still gains from specializing. Confusing them produces the conclusion that a more productive country should make everything itself, which is exactly the error the topic exists to correct.

Why do trade restrictions persist if they reduce total welfare?

Because of how the effects are distributed. The gains go to a small identifiable group of producers who feel them strongly and will organize; the losses are spread across many consumers who each pay slightly more and mostly never notice. Concentrated benefit and diffuse cost is a reliable political arrangement, which is why the arithmetic rarely settles these questions on its own.

Is a weaker currency good for a business?

It depends which side of the business you look at. A depreciation makes exports cheaper abroad and helps anybody selling overseas, while making imported inputs more expensive and hurting anybody buying them. Most firms are both, so the net effect depends on the balance between export revenue and imported costs. Working that out for a specific firm is more useful than a general verdict.

Where can I find a free ECN 601 Topic 8 sample paper?

The trade and exchange rate analysis is printed here in full: two questions, comparative advantage on numbers, where gains come from, a restriction and its distribution, the politics, a currency move in a firm's accounts, the recommendation and the conclusion. Send your trade case and the analysis follows at no charge.

Why does a weaker dollar both help and hurt in ECN 601 Topic 8?

The supplier's Canadian sales are worth more in dollars, but its peso-priced components cost more. Because its peso costs are larger, the net effect is a loss of about 197,000 dollars a year.