FIN 210 Topic 3 debt repayment order comparison example

Personal Finance Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This FIN 210 Topic 3 sample paper compares two ways a composite couple could direct the same 500 dollars a month at three debts: highest rate first and smallest balance first. It was prepared for GCU FIN 210, Personal Finance, catalog code FIN-210, a course in the Grand Canyon University BS in Finance and Economics. The debts are a 4,500-dollar card at 24 percent, a 1,100-dollar card at 17 percent and a 2,600-dollar loan at 11 percent. Highest rate first finishes in 19 months with about 1,229 dollars of interest; smallest balance first takes 20 months and about 1,529, but closes an account in month 5 instead of 14. The couple chooses a priced hybrid.

CourseFIN 210 Personal Finance
TopicTopic 3
Paper typeDebt repayment comparison
LengthAbout 1,000 words, 4 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramBS in Finance and Economics
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for FIN 210 Topic 3

1

Highest Rate First or Smallest Balance First: What the Same 500 Dollars a Month Costs Under Each Payoff Order for a Household With Three Debts

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

FIN-210: Personal Finance

Topic 3 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title names both orders and the fixed budget they share, which is what makes the comparison fair. The Whitaker household and every figure are an illustrative composite; the sources are real.
2

Highest Rate First or Smallest Balance First: What the Same 500 Dollars a Month Costs Under Each Payoff Order for a Household With Three Debts

The Household and Its Debts

Table 1

The Whitakers' Debts, Illustrative

DebtBalanceAnnual rateMinimum payment
Card A$4,50024%$135
Card B$1,10017%$35
Personal loan$2,60011%$85
Total$8,200| $255

Jordan and Casey Whitaker, a composite couple, owe money on three accounts and have committed 500 dollars a month to paying them off. They have tried twice before and given up both times, once after four months and once after six. This paper compares two common orders for directing the money and states what each costs.

The Rules Both Schedules Follow

Both schedules use the same money and the same rules, so any difference comes from the order alone. Each month, interest is added to each balance at one twelfth of its annual rate. The minimum payment is then made on every account, which uses 255 of the 500 dollars. The remaining 245 dollars goes to one target debt chosen by the order being tested. When a debt is paid off, its former minimum payment is not spent elsewhere; it joins the extra payment on the next target, so the full 500 dollars keeps working until all three debts are gone. This rollover is what allows both plans to finish in under two years.

What this page is doingEvery account receives its required payment first, and only the remainder of the 500 is directed by the payoff order under test.
3

Schedule One: Highest Rate First

Under this order, sometimes called the avalanche, the extra money goes first to Card A at 24 percent, then to Card B at 17 percent, then to the personal loan at 11 percent. Card A is paid off in month 14. Its 135-dollar minimum and the extra payment then go to Card B, which closes in month 16, and finally everything goes to the loan, which is paid off in month 19. Total interest over the whole period is about 1,229 dollars.

Schedule Two: Smallest Balance First

Under this order, sometimes called the snowball, the extra money goes first to Card B, the smallest balance at 1,100 dollars, then to the personal loan, then to Card A. Card B is paid off in month 5. The loan closes in month 11. Card A, which has been accruing 24 percent interest with only its minimum payment for most of the period, is paid off last, in month 20. Total interest is about 1,529 dollars.

The Two Orders Side by Side

Table 2

Two Payoff Orders With the Same 500 Dollars a Month, Illustrative

MeasureHighest rate firstSmallest balance first
Total interestAbout $1,229About $1,529
Months to debt-free1920
Month the first account closes145
Interest paid on Card A aloneAbout $688About $1,312

Table 2 puts the results together.

What this page is doingThe two orders differ by about 300 of interest in the case figures, a dollar amount the household can set against its own experience.
4

Interpreting the 300 Dollars

On arithmetic alone, the highest-rate order wins: it saves about 300 dollars and finishes one month sooner. The reason is visible in the last row of Table 2. Under the smallest-balance order, the most expensive debt sits nearly untouched for most of the period, and its interest almost doubles.

The arithmetic is not the whole decision, because a plan only saves money if the household completes it. The smallest-balance order closes an account in month 5; the highest-rate order does not close one until month 14. For a couple who abandoned two earlier plans within six months, that difference matters. Research supports taking it seriously. Gal and McShane (2012) analyzed data from a debt settlement program and found that closing individual debt accounts predicted eventually eliminating all debt, even after controlling for the dollar amount paid. Amar et al. (2011) found in experiments that people tend to pay off small debts first even when it costs them more, a pattern they called debt account aversion. Kettle et al. (2016) found that concentrating repayments on one account increased people's sense of progress and their motivation to continue. The research does not show that the smallest-balance order is always better, but it does show that early wins can affect whether people keep going.

The Household's Choice

The Whitakers choose a hybrid with a clear rule. They will pay off Card B first, closing it in month 5 and getting the early win their history suggests they need, and then send everything to Card A before the loan. Run under the same rules, the hybrid finishes in 20 months with about 1,309 dollars of interest, about 80 dollars more than the pure highest-rate order and about 220 dollars less than the pure smallest-balance order. Most of the snowball's extra cost came from leaving Card A until last, and the hybrid avoids that while keeping the early closed account.

Eighty dollars is the price of the detour, and the couple judges it worth paying given two abandoned plans. They have written down the condition that would change their minds: if a rate changes, for example if Card A's promotional terms end or the loan is refinanced, they will recompute both schedules before the next payment rather than assume the order still holds.

What Could Derail Either Plan

Both schedules assume nothing new is charged to the cards and the 500 dollars is paid every month. In the Whitakers' past attempts, the plans failed for two reasons: an unexpected car repair was put on a card, and the monthly amount was quietly reduced during a tight month. The arithmetic cannot protect against either. The couple is therefore taking two steps alongside the payoff order. They will stop using both cards for new purchases, keeping one in a drawer for emergencies only, and they will build a small buffer of 500 dollars in savings over the first two months by trimming other spending, so that a minor emergency does not go onto Card A. They will also set the 500-dollar payment as automatic transfers on the day after each paycheck. These steps matter more than the choice of order: a plan that is completed under either order saves far more than the 300-dollar difference between them, while a plan abandoned in month eight saves nothing.

References

Amar, M., Ariely, D., Ayal, S., Cryder, C. E., & Rick, S. I. (2011). Winning the battle but losing the war: The psychology of debt management. Journal of Marketing Research, 48(SPL), S38-S50. https://doi.org/10.1509/jmkr.48.SPL.S38

Gal, D., & McShane, B. B. (2012). Can small victories help win the war? Evidence from consumer debt management. Journal of Marketing Research, 49(4), 487-501. https://doi.org/10.1509/jmr.11.0272

Kettle, K. L., Trudel, R., Blanchard, S. J., & Häubl, G. (2016). Repayment concentration and consumer motivation to get out of debt. Journal of Consumer Research, 43(3), 460-477. https://doi.org/10.1093/jcr/ucw037

The FIN-210 Topic 3 assignment instructions

Topic 3 in FIN-210 asks students to compare debt repayment strategies for a household and to state the difference in money. Arguing for one order from principle does not answer the question. The comparison should run both schedules under the same rules, paying every minimum first and rolling each freed minimum into the next debt, and then report total interest, time to debt-free and the month the first account closes. Students should interpret the dollar difference against the household's circumstances, including any history of abandoned plans, cite research on motivation and debt repayment, and end with a chosen order and the condition that would make the household change it.

Inside the FIN 210 Topic 3 example

The finished comparison lists three illustrative debts: a card of 4,500 at 24 percent, a second card of 1,100 at 17 percent and a personal loan of 2,600 at 11 percent. The household can commit 500 a month in total, and minimums are paid on every account before any extra goes anywhere. Paying the highest rate first clears everything in 19 months with about 1,229 of interest. Paying the smallest balance first takes 20 months and about 1,529, so the gap is roughly 300. The example then sets that figure beside the other result the schedules produce: smallest first closes an account in month 5, highest rate first not until month 14. It weighs the two honestly and states which order the household adopts.

Where the marks sit in the FIN 210 Topic 3 rubric

Faculty marking the comparison reward two complete schedules built on the same money and rules. An Excellent paper pays minimums first, rolls freed minimums forward and reports the results side by side, including how much interest the most expensive debt accrues under each order. Credit goes to weighing the 300-dollar gap against the household's two abandoned plans and to citing research on early wins accurately. The rubric values pricing any compromise, such as a hybrid that clears the small card first at a cost of about 80 dollars. Strong papers address what could derail the plan, such as new charges on the cards. Top marks go to a conclusion with a stated switching condition.

Common FIN 210 Topic 3 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Declaring one order correct without running either schedule is where most comparisons lose ground, because the topic asks for the difference in money and an argument from principle never produces it. Schedules that forget to roll a freed minimum into the next debt overstate the time and interest for both orders. Comparing on interest alone is marked down as well, since a plan the household abandons in month eight saves nothing at all. The opposite error, praising early wins without pricing them, gives no way of deciding whether 300 is worth the motivation it buys. Minimum payments skipped in the arithmetic make one card appear to grow while another shrinks unrealistically. A conclusion with no condition for switching orders treats the plan as fixed when circumstances rarely are.

Get a FIN-210 Topic 3 example written to your instructions

Send the FIN-210 Topic 3 instructions and the rubric listed in your classroom, with the debts or case your section uses. We write a custom example to that rubric, with both payoff orders scheduled month by month, freed payments rolled forward, the interest gap priced in dollars and a reasoned choice made, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More FIN 210 papers and BS in Finance and Economics samples

FIN 210 Topic 3 questions, answered

Why roll a paid-off minimum into the next debt?

Because otherwise the money freed by closing an account drifts into general spending and the plan slows down. Keeping the total monthly commitment constant means each closed debt accelerates the next one, which is why both orders in the example finish in under two years. Without the roll-forward the schedules stretch considerably, and the comparison between orders becomes much less informative.

Is this advice about which debts to pay first?

No. The example answers a coursework question for a composite household with invented balances. Real repayment choices can involve hardship programs, balance transfer fees, secured debts with collateral at stake and credit counseling options that the assignment does not model. The comparison demonstrates how the choice is priced; it does not make that choice for anyone outside the case.

Where can I find a free FIN 210 Topic 3 sample paper?

The complete debt repayment comparison is here: the debts, the shared rules, both schedules, the side-by-side table, the interpretation, the household's hybrid choice and what could derail it. If your case lists different balances and rates, send them and we will run both orders on your figures in a free sample.

How much more does smallest balance first cost in FIN 210 Topic 3?

About 300 dollars more interest and one more month, because the 24 percent card sits with only its minimum for most of the period and its interest nearly doubles. A hybrid that clears the small card first costs only about 80 dollars more than highest rate first.

What does paying only the minimum cost?

Far more than most borrowers expect, because a minimum set near the month's interest barely reduces the balance. On an illustrative 3,000-dollar card at 22 percent, minimum payments can stretch repayment past a decade, which is why both schedules in the example add a fixed extra amount every month.