FIN 350 Topic 7 project criteria comparison example

Fundamentals of Business Finance Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This FIN 350 Topic 7 sample paper ranks two mutually exclusive 40,000-dollar projects at a composite frozen meal producer on payback, IRR and NPV and explains why the three disagree. It sits in GCU FIN 350, Fundamentals of Business Finance, catalog code FIN-350, within the Grand Canyon University BS in Finance and Economics. Project E pays back in about 1.2 years with an IRR near 22.8 percent; Project L takes 2.6 years and yields about 17.5. At a 10 percent cost of capital, though, L's NPV of about 7,814 beats E's 5,965. An NPV profile locates the crossover at about 13.1 percent, and a modified IRR check also favors L.

CourseFIN 350 Fundamentals of Business Finance
TopicTopic 7
Paper typeCapital budgeting comparison
LengthAbout 970 words, 4 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramBS in Finance and Economics
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for FIN 350 Topic 7

1

Payback, NPV and IRR Disagree: Ranking Two Mutually Exclusive Projects and Finding the Rate Where They Trade Places

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

FIN-350: Fundamentals of Business Finance

Topic 7 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the conflict the paper must explain and the tool it uses to resolve it. The firm, its projects and every figure are an illustrative composite; the sources are real.
2

Payback, NPV and IRR Disagree: Ranking Two Mutually Exclusive Projects and Finding the Rate Where They Trade Places

Two Projects, One Choice

Table 1

Cash Flows of the Two Projects, Illustrative

YearProject EProject L
0-$40,000-$40,000
1$38,000$4,000
2$12,000$8,000
3$2,000$50,000

Brannock Foods, a composite regional producer of frozen meals, has 40,000 dollars to spend on improving one production line and two proposals, of which it can accept only one. Project E, an early-payoff option, upgrades the existing packaging equipment and produces most of its savings at once. Project L, a late-payoff option, installs a new automated portioning system whose savings build as staff are retrained and the system is tuned. Brannock's cost of capital is 10 percent. The projects' cash flows are illustrative.

Three Criteria, Three Answers

Payback measures how long a project takes to recover its cost. Project E recovers 38,000 dollars in year one and the remaining 2,000 early in year two, a payback of about 1.2 years. Project L recovers only 12,000 in two years and needs 28,000 of its 50,000-dollar third-year flow, a payback of about 2.6 years. Payback favors E.

IRR is the rate at which a project's discounted inflows exactly repay its cost. For E it is about 22.8 percent; for L, about 17.5 percent. The IRR also favors E, and both exceed the 10 percent cost of capital.

Net present value discounts each cash flow at the cost of capital and subtracts the investment. At 10 percent, E's NPV is about 5,965 dollars and L's about 7,814. NPV favors L, by about 1,849 dollars.

What this page is doingEach criterion is applied in turn and its verdict stated, which sets up the conflict the paper must explain.
3

Why the Criteria Disagree

The disagreement comes from timing. E's money arrives early and L's arrives late. Payback ignores everything after the cost is recovered, so it never sees L's large third-year flow, and it ignores the time value of money within the payback period. The IRR summarizes each project as a single rate, and in effect assumes that early cash flows can be reinvested at that project's own IRR, a high rate for E. NPV discounts every cash flow at the rate Brannock can actually earn on its capital, 10 percent, and so values L's large late flow more generously than the IRR comparison suggests.

The Crossover Rate

Table 2

NPV Profiles of the Two Projects, Illustrative

Discount rateNPV of ENPV of LHigher NPV
0%$12,000$22,000L
5%$8,803$14,258L
10%$5,965$7,814L
13.1%About $4,360About $4,360Equal
15%$3,432$2,403E
20%$1,157-$2,176E

An NPV profile shows how each project's value changes with the discount rate, and it locates the conflict precisely.

What this page is doingThe profile shows the two lines crossing near 13.1 percent, which explains every disagreement above.
4

Reading the Profile

L's NPV falls faster as the rate rises, because its value depends on a cash flow three years away, which a higher rate discounts heavily. E's NPV falls more slowly because most of its cash arrives in year one. The two lines cross at about 13.1 percent, the crossover rate, which can be found as the IRR of the difference between the two projects' cash flows: L minus E is 0, negative 34,000, negative 4,000 and 48,000 dollars, and the rate that makes that stream worth zero is about 13.1 percent. Below that rate, L adds more value; above it, E does. Because Brannock's cost of capital, 10 percent, is below the crossover, L is the better project for Brannock, even though E has the higher IRR.

The IRR ranking would be right only if Brannock's opportunity cost were above 13.1 percent, or if it could reinvest E's early cash at E's own 22.8 percent. Neither holds here: Brannock's best alternative earns about 10 percent.

A Reinvestment Check

One way to see the reinvestment issue is to recompute each project's rate of return assuming its cash flows are reinvested at Brannock's 10 percent cost of capital rather than at the project's own IRR. This modified internal rate of return compounds each inflow forward to year three at 10 percent and finds the rate that grows the 40,000-dollar investment to that total. For E, the inflows grow to about 61,180 dollars, a modified rate of about 15.2 percent. For L, they grow to about 63,640 dollars, a modified rate of about 16.7 percent. Once both projects are judged at the rate Brannock can actually earn on reinvested cash, L comes out ahead, agreeing with NPV. The original IRR comparison favored E largely because it credited E's large first-year flow with earning 22.8 percent for two more years.

Which Criterion to Follow

When projects exclude each other, the standard texts side with net present value (Brealey et al., 2020; Ross et al., 2022), since it states in dollars how much richer the owners become at the return they could have earned elsewhere. The IRR remains a useful summary, and payback a useful check on how long capital is exposed, but neither should decide between exclusive projects when they conflict with NPV. Practice is broadly consistent: Graham and Harvey (2001) found that net present value and the internal rate of return were the methods chief financial officers used most, with payback still common, especially at smaller firms.

Recommendation and Its Conditions

Brannock should choose Project L. The recommendation has two conditions worth stating. If the company were short of cash and could not wait three years for L's savings, E's faster payback would deserve more weight, though that is a financing constraint rather than a reason to prefer lower value. And if L's third-year savings are less certain than E's first-year savings, which is plausible for a new system, the higher risk would justify a higher discount rate for L; a rate above 13.1 percent would reverse the ranking. Brannock's managers should therefore check how confident they are in the 50,000-dollar third-year figure before committing, for example by asking the system's vendor for results at comparable plants and by agreeing a retraining schedule that makes the year-three savings realistic.

References

Brealey, R. A., Myers, S. C., & Allen, F. (2020). Principles of corporate finance (13th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.

Graham, J. R., & Harvey, C. R. (2001). The theory and practice of corporate finance: Evidence from the field. Journal of Financial Economics, 60(2-3), 187-243. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0304-405X(01)00044-7

Ross, S. A., Westerfield, R. W., & Jordan, B. D. (2022). Fundamentals of corporate finance (13th ed.). McGraw Hill.

The FIN-350 Topic 7 assignment instructions

Topic 7 in FIN-350 asks students to apply several capital budgeting criteria to competing projects and to explain any conflict among them. Reporting three numbers is not enough. Students should compute payback, IRR and NPV with the work shown, identify which project each favors and explain the disagreement through the timing of cash flows. Strong work builds an NPV profile, finds the crossover rate from the difference in cash flows, compares it with the cost of capital and states which criterion governs a choice between mutually exclusive projects. Students should also note conditions that could reverse the ranking, such as a higher discount rate for a riskier, later-paying project.

How the FIN-350 Topic 7 example is put together

The finished comparison uses two labeled illustrative projects, each costing 40,000. Project E returns 38,000, 12,000 and 2,000 over three years; Project L returns 4,000, 8,000 and 50,000. Payback favors E at about 1.2 years against 2.6. The internal rate of return also favors E, about 22.8 percent against 17.5. At the firm's 10 percent cost of capital, though, net present value favors L, about 7,814 against 5,965. The example resolves the conflict by computing the crossover rate, about 13.1 percent, below which L adds more value and above which E does. It explains the disagreement through timing, since E's money arrives early and L's arrives late, and follows net present value because the firm's rate sits below the crossover.

Reading the FIN 350 Topic 7 rubric

Faculty reward a comparison that explains the conflict instead of only reporting it. An Excellent paper computes all three criteria correctly, shows that payback and IRR favor the early project while NPV favors the late one, and attributes the difference to timing. Credit goes to an NPV profile and a crossover rate computed from the incremental cash flows. The rubric values discussing the reinvestment assumption, for example with a modified IRR. Strong papers follow NPV for exclusive projects and cite evidence on how firms use these methods. Top marks go to a recommendation that names the conditions, such as a higher risk-adjusted rate, under which it would change.

FIN 350 Topic 7 help: mistakes that cost marks

Picking Project E for its higher rate when the criteria conflict, with no reason given, is marked wrong in FIN-350, since for mutually exclusive projects the criterion that measures value in dollars governs. Reporting the conflict without diagnosing its cause leaves out the part of the answer that carries the most weight. Discounting cash flows that already include interest on the project's financing, at a rate that also reflects that financing, counts the cost of borrowing twice. Payback treated as a deciding criterion ignores everything after recovery, including L's largest year. Net present value profiles drawn without the crossover marked miss the point the graph exists to show. A recommendation with no condition for reversal treats the discount rate as certain when it rarely is.

Get a FIN-350 Topic 7 example written to your instructions

Send the FIN-350 Topic 7 problems and the rubric attached in your classroom, with the projects or data your section provided. We write a custom example to them, with payback, IRR and NPV computed for each project, the conflict diagnosed through a crossover rate, the profiles drawn and the reversal condition stated, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More FIN 350 papers and BS in Finance and Economics samples

FIN 350 Topic 7 questions, answered

Why follow net present value when the rates conflict?

Because owners are made richer by dollars of value rather than by percentages, and net present value measures exactly that at the firm's own cost of capital. Internal rate of return also assumes interim cash flows can be reinvested at that same high rate, which is rarely realistic. When the two rank exclusive projects differently, the dollar measure answers the question the firm is actually asking.

What is a crossover rate?

The discount rate at which two projects have the same net present value. It is found by taking the difference between their cash flows year by year and solving for the rate that sets the present value of that difference to zero. In the example it is about 13.1 percent. Below it the late-paying project is worth more; above it, the early-paying one is.

Can a discount rate be applied to the wrong cash flows?

Yes, and FIN-350 marks it as an error. Project cash flows should exclude interest and loan repayments, because the cost of capital already charges for financing, so subtracting interest and then discounting at that rate charges twice. Likewise, discounting a cash flow that occurs today, such as the initial outlay, understates the true cost of starting the project.

Where can I find a free FIN 350 Topic 7 sample paper?

The project criteria comparison is shown in full here: the cash flows, payback, IRR and NPV, why they disagree, the NPV profile, the crossover rate, the reinvestment check and the recommendation. If your assignment gives two other projects, send their cash flows and a free ranking on all three criteria can follow.

What is the crossover rate in FIN 350 Topic 7?

About 13.1 percent, the IRR of the difference between the two projects' cash flows. Below it Project L has the higher NPV; above it Project E does. The firm's 10 percent cost of capital is below the crossover, so L is preferred.