| Course | FIN 355 Retirement Planning and Employee Benefits |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 1 |
| Paper type | Plan comparison paper |
| Length | About 990 words, 4 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Finance and Economics |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for FIN 355 Topic 1
Who Carries the Risk of a Long Life? Comparing a Final-Salary Pension With an Account Plan Over One Twenty-Five-Year Career
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
FIN-355: Retirement Planning and Employee Benefits
Topic 1 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Who Carries the Risk of a Long Life? Comparing a Final-Salary Pension With an Account Plan Over One Twenty-Five-Year Career
The Career and the Two Plans
Renee Castillo, a composite engineer, is choosing between two employers whose retirement plans differ in kind. One offers a traditional defined benefit pension; the other offers a defined contribution account plan, the kind most private employers now provide. To compare them fairly, this paper follows one illustrative career: twenty-five years of service, retiring at 65, with a final average salary of 80,000 dollars. The question is not only which plan pays more, but who carries each risk that stands between a paycheck and a secure retirement.
What the Pension Promises
The pension pays 1.5 percent of final average salary for each year of service. After twenty-five years that is 37.5 percent of 80,000 dollars, or 30,000 dollars a year, paid for life. The promise does not depend on how markets perform, how well Renee invests or how long she lives. If she lives to 100, the pension pays for 35 years. The employer, not Renee, must fund that promise, invest the plan's assets and make up any shortfall. In exchange, Renee gives up control: she cannot choose the investments, and if she leaves early, her benefit is based on her salary at that time, which often makes a pension worth much less to someone who changes jobs.
What the Account Plan Promises
Table 1
Balance Needed to Replace a 30,000-Dollar Pension, Illustrative
| Years of payments | Ends at age | Balance needed at 65 (4% return) |
|---|---|---|
| 25 | 90 | About $469,000 |
| 30 | 95 | About $519,000 |
| Difference | | About $50,000 |
The account plan promises only contributions. The employer and Renee each put money into an account in her name; the balance at retirement depends on how much went in, how the investments performed and the fees charged. At retirement she must turn that balance into income herself. To compare the two plans, the question becomes: what balance would she need at 65 to replace the pension's 30,000 dollars a year?
The answer depends on how long the payments must last. Assuming the account earns 4 percent a year during retirement and pays 30,000 dollars at the end of each year, a balance of about 469,000 dollars would fund twenty-five years of payments, to age 90. Stretching the payments to thirty years, to age 95, requires about 519,000 dollars.
Could the Account Plan Get There?
Whether the account plan can reach that balance depends on contributions and returns. Suppose Renee and her employer together contribute 10 percent of her pay each year, and her pay averages about 65,000 dollars over the career, so 6,500 dollars goes in each year. At an assumed 6 percent return, twenty-five years of contributions grow to about 357,000 dollars; at 7 percent, to about 411,000. Both fall short of the 469,000 needed for a 25-year retirement, let alone the 519,000 for thirty years. To reach 469,000 at 6 percent, the combined contribution would have to be about 8,550 dollars a year, roughly 13 percent of average pay. The comparison shows that an account plan can replace a pension of this size only with higher saving or stronger returns than many workers achieve.
Longevity Risk in Dollars
The gap of about 50,000 dollars is longevity risk expressed in money: the extra savings needed because Renee cannot know whether she will live to 90 or to 95. Under the pension, that risk belongs to the employer, which pools it across many retirees, some of whom will die early and some late. Under the account plan, it belongs to Renee alone. If she plans for 25 years and lives 30, she runs out of money at 90. If she plans for 30 to be safe, she may die with savings she could have spent. Pooling is what allows a pension, or an annuity bought with an account balance, to pay a lifetime income more efficiently than an individual can self-insure. Rejda et al. (2020) describe this pooling of mortality risk as the basic principle of life annuities.
Who Owns Each Risk
Table 2
Ownership of Retirement Risks Under the Two Plans
| Risk | Defined benefit pension | Account plan |
|---|---|---|
| Investment returns | Employer | Employee |
| Longevity | Employer, pooled | Employee, unless she buys an annuity |
| Inflation after retirement | Employee, unless benefits are indexed | Employee |
| Employer insolvency | Largely insured up to legal limits | Account assets held in trust, protected |
| Job change before retirement | Employee: benefit frozen at early salary | Small: balance is portable once vested |
| Fees and investment choices | Employer | Employee |
Table 2 assigns each risk to its owner under the two plans.
The Remaining Protections
Two protections deserve note. If a private employer with a pension goes bankrupt and the plan is underfunded, the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation, a federal agency, pays guaranteed benefits up to maximum amounts set by law and adjusted each year; a benefit of 30,000 dollars at 65 falls well within those limits (Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation, n.d.). Account plan assets, by contrast, are held in trust and are not the employer's to lose, though they can lose value in markets. Neither plan protects fully against inflation unless the pension includes cost-of-living increases, which most private pensions do not.
Which Plan Suits This Employee
The right plan depends on tenure. If Renee expects to stay twenty-five years, the pension's guaranteed lifetime income and transfer of investment and longevity risk are worth a great deal, and she would need roughly half a million dollars in an account to match them. If she expects to change jobs within ten years, as many engineers do, the pension's backloaded formula would leave her with a small frozen benefit, and the portable account plan is likely to be worth more. Research comparing the two has found that, under plausible assumptions, account plans can produce comparable or greater wealth for many workers, though with much more risk borne by the worker (Poterba et al., 2007). Renee plans to stay, values certainty and has no strong interest in managing investments, so the pension suits her better.
References
Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation. (n.d.). Maximum monthly guarantee tables. Retrieved October 4, 2026, from https://www.pbgc.gov/wr/benefits/guaranteed-benefits/maximum-guarantee
Poterba, J., Rauh, J., Venti, S., & Wise, D. (2007). Defined contribution plans, defined benefit plans, and the accumulation of retirement wealth. Journal of Public Economics, 91(10), 2062-2086. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpubeco.2007.08.004
Rejda, G. E., McNamara, M. J., & Rabel, W. H. (2020). Principles of risk management and insurance (14th ed.). Pearson.
FIN 355 Topic 1 instructions, in plain terms
Topic 1 in FIN-355 asks students to compare defined benefit and defined contribution plans. A list of features is not the goal; the course wants students to see who bears each risk. Strong submissions follow one realistic career, compute the pension benefit from its formula, estimate the account balance needed to replace it and show how that balance depends on how long retirement lasts. Students should assign investment, longevity, inflation, insolvency and job-change risks to their owners under each plan, describe the federal pension insurance accurately, test whether realistic contributions could reach the needed balance and finish with a judgment about which plan suits the employee described.
Inside the FIN 355 Topic 1 example
The finished comparison follows one illustrative career: twenty-five years of service ending on a final average salary of 80,000. The pension pays 1.5 percent of that salary for each year served, 30,000 a year for life, whatever markets do and however long the retiree lives. The account plan promises only contributions, so the example asks what balance would replace the pension. At an assumed 4 percent return, paying 30,000 a year for twenty-five years takes about 469,000; stretching the payments to thirty years takes about 519,000. That gap of about 50,000 is longevity risk in dollars, and under the account plan it belongs to the employee. A risk table then gives each exposure an owner, noting that a federal insurer backs private pensions up to limits set by law. Its final paragraph judges which plan suits this employee's tenure.
Reading the FIN 355 Topic 1 rubric
Instructors reward a comparison grounded in one career with its numbers shown. An Excellent paper computes the pension from its formula and the replacement balance at a stated rate for more than one horizon, turning longevity risk into dollars. Credit goes to a risk table that names an owner for each exposure and to an accurate description of the PBGC guarantee. The rubric values testing whether the account plan's contributions could plausibly reach the needed balance. Strong papers recognize that pensions favor long tenure while account plans favor mobility. Top marks go to a verdict tied to the employee's expected tenure and preferences.
FIN 355 Topic 1 help: mistakes that cost marks
Comparisons built as feature lists, vesting in one paragraph and loans in the next, lose the most, because they describe two accounts without ever saying who absorbs a bad outcome. A paper that calls the pension safe without noting that its fixed payment erodes with prices has removed one risk from the table by not looking at it. Treating an account balance as equal to the pension, dollar for dollar, ignores that a lump sum has to be stretched across a lifetime of unknown length. Employer failure left out, or stated as though benefits vanish with the sponsor, misreads federal pension insurance even at a descriptive level. Replacement arithmetic run at a single horizon hides longevity risk inside one figure. A verdict that never mentions the employee's likely tenure applies a general preference to a particular person.
Get a FIN-355 Topic 1 example written to your instructions
Send the FIN-355 Topic 1 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with the plan descriptions or case your section provides. We write a custom example to them, with each risk assigned to the party that bears it, the pension converted into an equivalent balance at two horizons and the verdict tied to tenure, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More FIN 355 papers and BS in Finance and Economics samples
- FIN 355 Topic 2: Employer Plan Design Memo
- FIN 355 Topic 3: Contribution Rules Worksheet
- FIN 355 Topic 4: Payout Option Comparison
- FIN 355 Topic 5: Irreversible Election Dq Post
- FIN 355 Topic 6: Total Reward Valuation
- FIN 355 Topic 7: Decumulation Stress Projection
- FIN 355 Topic 8: Lump Sum Election Review
- FIN 375 Topic 1: Trade Execution Walkthrough
- FIN 350 Topic 1: Finance Function Paper
- FIN 431 Topic 1: Loss Exposure Identification
- FIN 210 Topic 1: Household Spending Budget
FIN 355 Topic 1 questions, answered
Is a pension always safer than an account plan?
Safer against some risks and not others. A pension lifts investment and longevity risk off the retiree, which is a large advantage, but a fixed payment loses purchasing power whenever prices rise, and a benefit based on final salary shrinks for anyone who leaves early. The example rates the two plans risk by risk, since a single safety verdict hides exactly the trade the topic is about.
What happens to a private pension if the employer fails?
Plan assets are held in trust apart from the employer, and a federal insurer, the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation, guarantees benefits up to limits set by law and adjusted over time. Many modest benefits sit inside the guarantee, while larger ones can be cut back. The example describes that protection in general terms and does not quote a guarantee figure, since the ceiling changes and depends on age and payment form.
Does the example recommend a plan for my own job?
No. The employee is a composite, the salary and multiplier are illustrative, and the verdict follows from the tenure the case assumes. Real plan choices depend on the actual plan documents, your expected career, other savings and a spouse's benefits, none of which a coursework example can see. It demonstrates the risk-by-risk reasoning FIN-355 asks for and is not retirement advice.
Where can I find a free FIN 355 Topic 1 sample paper?
Read the whole pension and account plan comparison here: the career, both plans, the balance needed, whether contributions could reach it, longevity risk, the risk ownership table, the protections and the verdict. Got a different multiplier or tenure in your prompt? Send it, and the comparison will be rerun on your plan terms at no charge.
What does longevity risk cost in FIN 355 Topic 1?
About 50,000 dollars. Replacing a 30,000-dollar pension at 4 percent takes about 469,000 for twenty-five years of payments and about 519,000 for thirty, and under the account plan the employee carries that difference.