| Course | FIN 355 Retirement Planning and Employee Benefits |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 4 |
| Paper type | Distribution options comparison |
| Length | About 970 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Finance and Economics |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for FIN 355 Topic 4
Cash Out, Roll Over, Stay or Annuitize: Comparing the Distribution Options for a 600,000-Dollar Workplace Account at Retirement
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
FIN-355: Retirement Planning and Employee Benefits
Topic 4 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Cash Out, Roll Over, Stay or Annuitize: Comparing the Distribution Options for a 600,000-Dollar Workplace Account at Retirement
The Retiree and the Account
Gordon Mbeki, a composite 65-year-old retiring after thirty years with a regional utility, has 600,000 dollars in his workplace 401(k): 520,000 in pre-tax contributions and earnings, and 80,000 in a designated Roth account he began funding eight years ago. He will also receive Social Security, and his wife, Ada, 62, has a small pension of her own. The couple's essential expenses, housing, food, insurance and utilities, run about 4,000 dollars a month, which matters because it sets how much guaranteed income they need before deciding what to do with the rest. His employer's plan allows him to take the money as a lump sum, roll it over to an IRA, leave it in the plan or use part of it to buy a lifetime annuity through the plan's provider. This paper compares the options. All figures are illustrative; tax rules are described generally and change over time.
The Options Side by Side
Table 1
Distribution Options for the Pre-Tax Balance, Illustrative
| Option | Tax at the time of the move | Flexibility afterward | Main risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cash out the full pre-tax balance | All 520,000 taxed as income this year | Complete | Large tax bill; money spent too soon |
| Direct rollover to an IRA | None | High: wide investment choice, withdrawals when wanted | Investment and longevity risk stay with Gordon |
| Indirect rollover | 20% withheld (104,000 on the full balance); taxable unless replaced within 60 days | High once complete | Missing the 60-day deadline or the withheld share |
| Leave in the plan | None | Limited to plan's menu and rules | Plan fees and rules may change |
| Annuitize 200,000 | Income taxed as received | None on that portion | Money cannot be recovered; inflation erodes fixed payments |
Table 1 sets out what each option does to Gordon's taxes, flexibility and income.
Cashing Out
Taking the full 520,000 dollars of pre-tax money as cash would add it to a single year's taxable income. Under a progressive tax system, much of it would be taxed at rates Gordon would never otherwise face, since his income in retirement would normally be spread across many years in lower brackets. A large share of his savings would go to taxes in one year, and the rest would no longer grow tax-deferred. Because he is over 59½, he would owe no early-withdrawal penalty, but the tax cost alone makes a full cash-out the weakest option for anyone who does not need the money at once.
Rolling Over
A direct rollover moves the money from the plan to an IRA in Gordon's name without passing through his hands, so no tax is withheld or owed at the time of the transfer (Internal Revenue Service, 2025). He gains a wide choice of investments and control over the timing of withdrawals, which remain taxable when taken.
An indirect rollover is riskier. The plan sends Gordon a check for the balance, but it must withhold 20 percent for federal tax, so on the full pre-tax balance he would receive 416,000 dollars and 104,000 would be withheld. To roll over the full 520,000 tax-free, he must deposit the entire amount into an IRA within 60 days, which means replacing the withheld 104,000 from other savings. Any amount not deposited in time is treated as a taxable distribution. He would recover the withholding as a credit when he files his tax return, but only after the deadline has passed. There is no reason to choose an indirect rollover when a direct one is available.
Staying in the Plan
Leaving the money in the plan keeps it tax-deferred and may give access to low-cost institutional funds that are not available in an IRA. Some plans, however, restrict how often retirees can withdraw or limit them to all-or-nothing distributions, and the plan's fees and menu can change. Gordon's plan allows partial withdrawals and charges low fees, so staying is a reasonable option for at least part of the balance.
Annuitizing Part of the Balance
The plan's provider quotes a lifetime annuity paying 1,200 dollars a month, 14,400 dollars a year, for a 200,000-dollar premium. The annuity turns part of the account into income that cannot run out, however long Gordon lives, which addresses the risk an account cannot: outliving it. Brown (2001) estimated that for a typical retiree without other annuitized income, the ability to convert savings into a lifetime income stream has substantial value, because it insures against longevity. The cost is irreversibility. Once payments begin, the 200,000 dollars cannot be recovered, and if Gordon dies early, payments stop unless he chose a survivor or guarantee option. Fixed payments also lose purchasing power over time. Benartzi et al. (2011) note that despite the insurance value of annuities, few retirees choose them voluntarily, partly because people dislike giving up a lump sum and fear losing it by dying early.
The Roth Balance
The 80,000 dollars in the designated Roth account is treated differently. Gordon has held it for more than five years and is over 59½, so his withdrawals are qualified and come out tax-free. It can be rolled into a Roth IRA, where it is not subject to required minimum distributions during his life, preserving tax-free growth.
A Recommended Combination
Gordon should not choose one option for all his money. A reasonable plan is to use 200,000 dollars of the pre-tax balance to buy the annuity, which, together with Social Security, covers his essential expenses for life; directly roll the remaining 320,000 dollars to an IRA for flexibility and growth; and roll the 80,000-dollar Roth balance directly to a Roth IRA, to be used last. He should avoid both a full cash-out and an indirect rollover. Before buying the annuity he should compare quotes from several insurers and consider whether a survivor benefit is needed for his wife.
References
Benartzi, S., Previtero, A., & Thaler, R. H. (2011). Annuitization puzzles. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 25(4), 143-164. https://doi.org/10.1257/jep.25.4.143
Brown, J. R. (2001). Private pensions, mortality risk, and the decision to annuitize. Journal of Public Economics, 82(1), 29-62. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0047-2727(00)00152-3
Internal Revenue Service. (2025). Publication 575: Pension and annuity income. https://www.irs.gov/publications/p575
The FIN-355 Topic 4 assignment instructions
In Topic 4, FIN-355 asks students to compare distribution options from a workplace retirement plan. Good work lays the options out side by side and weighs each on tax, flexibility and risk. Students should explain why a full cash-out is costly under progressive taxation, distinguish direct from indirect rollovers including the withholding and the 60-day rule, discuss the trade-offs of leaving money in the plan, and treat an annuity as longevity insurance that cannot be undone. Roth balances should be handled separately with their qualifying conditions. Tax rules should be described generally, and the paper should end with a recommended combination rather than a single option.
How the FIN-355 Topic 4 example is put together
The finished comparison is one table and the reasoning beneath it, every figure illustrative. Cashing out the full balance adds 520,000 of pre-tax money to a single year's taxable income, pushing much of it into brackets the retiree would never otherwise reach. A direct rollover to an IRA moves the money with no tax at transfer. An indirect rollover sends a check with 20 percent withheld, and unless the retiree replaces that share from other savings within 60 days, it is taxed as a distribution. Leaving the balance in the plan keeps its fees and rules. Spending 200,000 on a lifetime annuity quoted in the case at 1,200 a month creates income that cannot fail and money that cannot come back. The Roth 80,000 is shown as tax-free when withdrawn, provided the qualifying conditions are met.
Where the marks sit in the FIN 355 Topic 4 rubric
Graders award an Excellent comparison for weighing every option on the same terms. The rubric rewards a table that sets tax at the time of the move, later flexibility and main risk side by side. Credit goes to explaining the indirect rollover's 20 percent withholding and 60-day deadline precisely, and to treating the annuity as insurance against outliving savings with its irreversibility stated. Faculty look for the Roth balance handled on its own terms. Strong papers cite research on why retirees undervalue annuities. Top marks go to a combined recommendation tied to the couple's essential expenses, with steps such as comparing annuity quotes.
FIN 355 Topic 4 help: mistakes that cost marks
The reversibility column is where comparisons most often fall short: ranking payout options by tax alone can recommend an annuity purchase or a cash-out without ever saying that neither can be taken back. Papers that treat an indirect rollover as equivalent to a direct one miss the withholding and the 60-day window, which is where retirees lose money. Cash-out tax computed at one flat rate understates what a year of concentrated income costs. Roth money taxed as if it were pre-tax, or pre-tax money described as tax-free, confuses the two sources the case keeps apart. Stating a required distribution age as fixed dates the paper, since Congress has moved it more than once and may again. An annuity recommended for its income, with no word on the access and legacy it gives up, is described from one side only.
Get a FIN-355 Topic 4 example written to your instructions
Send the FIN-355 Topic 4 instructions and your classroom rubric, with the retiree case or balances your section assigns. We write a custom example to them, with each payout option scored for tax, flexibility and reversibility, the rollover rules shown in dollars and the permanent parts of the recommendation named, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More FIN 355 papers and BS in Finance and Economics samples
- FIN 355 Topic 1: Plan Risk Bearer Comparison
- FIN 355 Topic 2: Employer Plan Design Memo
- FIN 355 Topic 3: Contribution Rules Worksheet
- FIN 355 Topic 5: Irreversible Election Dq Post
- FIN 355 Topic 6: Total Reward Valuation
- FIN 355 Topic 7: Decumulation Stress Projection
- FIN 355 Topic 8: Lump Sum Election Review
- FIN 375 Topic 4: Two-method Equity Valuation
- FIN 350 Topic 4: Bond and Share Pricing
- FIN 431 Topic 4: Commercial Property Policy Reading
- FIN 210 Topic 4: Credit Score Factor Analysis
FIN 355 Topic 4 questions, answered
Why is a direct rollover safer than taking a check?
Because the money moves from plan to IRA without passing through the retiree's hands, so nothing is withheld and no deadline applies. A check payable to the retiree carries mandatory withholding, and completing the rollover means depositing the full original amount within 60 days, including the withheld share from other funds. Missing either step turns part of the balance into taxable income that cannot be reversed afterward.
Can an annuity purchase be undone?
Generally not once payments begin under an immediate life annuity. The premium buys income for life and, under a life-only contract, nothing is refunded if the owner dies early. Some contracts add a period certain or a refund feature in exchange for a smaller payment, and a short free-look period may apply just after purchase. The example treats the purchase as permanent and prices it that way.
Can this comparison guide my own rollover decision?
No. The retiree, the balances and the annuity quote are composites, and the tax treatment is described in general terms from rules that change. Your options depend on your plan's terms, your other income, your state and the law in force when you act. The example shows how FIN-355 wants payout options compared; a qualified adviser should look at your actual accounts.
Where can I find a free FIN 355 Topic 4 sample paper?
This page holds the complete distribution options comparison: the retiree, the options table, cashing out, rollovers, staying in the plan, the annuity, the Roth balance and the recommended combination. Balances and annuity quotes vary by case, so send yours and the options will be weighed again in a no-cost sample.
What does an indirect rollover risk in FIN 355 Topic 4?
The plan withholds 20 percent, 104,000 dollars on the full pre-tax balance, and only the amount deposited in an IRA within 60 days escapes tax, so the retiree must replace the withheld share from other savings or pay tax on it.