| Course | FIN 355 Retirement Planning and Employee Benefits |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 6 |
| Paper type | Offer valuation paper |
| Length | About 1,000 words, 4 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Finance and Economics |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for FIN 355 Topic 6
A Higher Salary or a Richer Package? Valuing Two Job Offers at Employer Cost and at What the Benefits Are Worth to One Employee
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
FIN-355: Retirement Planning and Employee Benefits
Topic 6 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
A Higher Salary or a Richer Package? Valuing Two Job Offers at Employer Cost and at What the Benefits Are Worth to One Employee
The Two Offers
Mei Tanaka, a composite financial analyst, has two job offers. Offer A, from a regional hospital system, pays 72,000 dollars. Offer B, from a software firm, pays 78,000 dollars. Comparing salaries alone, B is better by 6,000 dollars. But salary is only part of compensation: the Bureau of Labor Statistics regularly reports that benefits make up roughly 30 percent of what private employers spend on compensation (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, n.d.). This paper values both offers twice, first at what each costs the employer and then at what each is worth to Mei, because the two measures can point in different directions. All figures are illustrative and before tax.
The Benefits in Each Offer
Table 1
Compensation Components of the Two Offers, Illustrative
| Item | Offer A | Offer B |
|---|---|---|
| Salary | $72,000 | $78,000 |
| Employer share of family health premium | $14,400 (80%) | $7,200 (40%) |
| Retirement match | 100% of contributions up to 4% of pay, $2,880, three-year cliff vesting | None |
| Long-term disability insurance | Provided; costs employer about $500 | None |
Mei has a spouse and a young child, and family health coverage at both employers carries a total premium of about 18,000 dollars a year, in line with the average family premium reported in national surveys of employer plans (KFF, 2024).
Value at Employer Cost
Adding what each employer spends gives one comparison. Offer A costs the hospital 72,000 dollars in salary, 14,400 in health premiums, 2,880 in matching contributions if Mei takes the full match and about 500 for the disability policy, a total of 89,780 dollars. Offer B costs the software firm 78,000 in salary and 7,200 in premiums, a total of 85,200. At employer cost, Offer A leads by 4,580 dollars. This is how an employer sees the offers, but it is not necessarily what each is worth to Mei.
Value to This Employee
Table 2
Offer A Compared With Offer B at Value to the Employee, Illustrative
| Component | Needs coverage, stays three years | Spouse's plan covers family |
|---|---|---|
| Salary difference (A minus B) | -$6,000 | -$6,000 |
| Premium support difference | +$7,200 | $0 |
| Retirement match | +$2,880 | +$2,880 |
| Disability coverage, at individual price | +$900 | +$900 |
| Net advantage of Offer A | +$4,980 | -$2,220 |
What a benefit is worth to Mei depends on whether she would buy it herself, at what price, and whether she will stay long enough to keep it. If she needs family coverage and expects to stay at least three years, Offer A gives her 7,200 dollars more in premium support than B, 2,880 dollars a year of match once vested, and disability coverage that an individual policy would cost her about 900 dollars a year to buy, more than the employer pays because group coverage is cheaper. Against these she gives up 6,000 dollars of salary. Offer A leads by 4,980 dollars a year.
If Mei's spouse already has family coverage through his own employer, the picture changes. The premium support in both offers is worth nothing to her, because she would decline the coverage. The comparison becomes 6,000 dollars more salary in B against 2,880 of match and 900 of disability value in A, and Offer B leads by 2,220 dollars.
What the Calculation Leaves Out
Three adjustments would refine the comparison. Taxes matter: salary is taxed, while employer health premiums are generally excluded from income and the match is tax-deferred, so a dollar of these benefits is worth somewhat more than a dollar of salary. Vesting matters: if Mei left Offer A within three years, she would forfeit every dollar of match, so the 2,880 is worth something only if she stays. And the match is worth its full amount only if she contributes the 4 percent needed to earn it; Choi et al. (2011) found that many employees fail to contribute enough to receive their full match, leaving free money on the table. Mei should count the match only if she will in fact contribute.
If She Leaves Early
The three-year cliff deserves its own calculation. If Mei took Offer A and left after two years, she would forfeit both years of match, 5,760 dollars in total. Over those two years, Offer A would still have given her 7,200 dollars a year more in premium support and about 900 a year of disability value, against 6,000 a year less salary, a net gain of about 2,100 a year, or 4,200 over the two years. Even without the match, then, Offer A would still lead for a family that needs coverage. The match is what widens the gap, and it does so only for an employee who stays. For a candidate who expects to move on quickly, the vesting schedule turns part of a generous package into a promise that never pays.
What Is Not Priced
Some differences resist a dollar figure. The software firm offers more remote work, which would save Mei about an hour of commuting a day, and its salary may grow faster if the firm does well. The hospital system offers more predictable employment and a pension-like culture of long tenure. These considerations could reasonably tip a close decision either way, and the paper does not pretend to value them. What the calculation does is make the priced part of the choice clear, so that Mei knows how much the unpriced differences would need to be worth to her to change the answer: about 4,980 dollars a year in favor of the software firm.
Decision
Mei's spouse works for a small firm that does not offer family coverage, and she expects to stay at least five years in either job. On those facts, Offer A is worth about 4,980 dollars a year more than Offer B, before the tax advantages of the benefits, which widen the gap further. She should accept Offer A, contribute at least 4 percent of pay from her first paycheck and confirm the disability policy's terms. Had her spouse's plan covered the family, Offer B would have been the better choice by about 2,220 dollars.
References
Choi, J. J., Laibson, D., & Madrian, B. C. (2011). $100 bills on the sidewalk: Suboptimal investment in 401(k) plans. Review of Economics and Statistics, 93(3), 748-763. https://doi.org/10.1162/REST_a_00100
KFF. (2024). 2024 employer health benefits survey. https://www.kff.org/health-costs/report/2024-employer-health-benefits-survey/
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. (n.d.). Employer costs for employee compensation. Retrieved October 4, 2026, from https://www.bls.gov/ecec/
What the FIN 355 Topic 6 instructions ask for
FIN-355 uses Topic 6 to show that compensation is more than salary. Students value two offers by listing every component, adding them at employer cost and then valuing each benefit at what it is worth to the specific employee. The paper should show how the answer changes with the employee's situation, such as access to coverage through a spouse, and should account for vesting, which makes a match worthless to someone who leaves early. Students should note tax differences between salary and benefits, cite sources for benefit costs, acknowledge factors that cannot be priced and finish with a decision tied to the facts given.
Inside the FIN 355 Topic 6 example
The finished valuation sets the two offers side by side with illustrative figures. Offer A pays 72,000, covers 14,400 of an 18,000 family health premium, matches retirement contributions up to 4 percent, 2,880, with a three-year cliff, and provides long-term disability cover. Offer B pays 78,000, covers 7,200 of a comparable premium and offers no match or disability cover. At employer cost, A leads by 4,580 once the disability policy's 500 is counted. At employee value the answer depends on her. If she needs family coverage and plans to stay, she gains 7,200 in premiums, 2,880 in match and disability cover an individual policy would price at 900, against 6,000 less salary, so A leads by 4,980. If a spouse's plan already covers the household, the premium gap is worth nothing to her, and B leads by 2,220.
Where the marks sit in the FIN 355 Topic 6 rubric
Faculty reward a valuation that shows why employer cost and employee value differ. An Excellent paper lists every component side by side, totals them at employer cost and then revalues each for the employee, using the price she would pay herself. Credit goes to showing the answer reverse when a spouse's plan covers the family, and to a vesting calculation for early departure. The rubric values noting the tax advantage of benefits and the need to contribute enough to earn a match. Strong papers name what cannot be priced and how much it would need to be worth. Top marks go to a decision tied to the stated facts.
FIN 355 Topic 6 help: mistakes that cost marks
Valuing benefits at employer cost and calling the result total reward loses the most here, because it states the package from the side that spends the money and assumes the employee values every dollar equally. Papers that compare salaries alone treat the 6,000 difference as decisive when the health premium gap by itself outweighs it. A match counted in full regardless of vesting overstates an offer to anyone likely to leave early. Health coverage valued identically for every employee ignores that a second family policy is worth little to someone already covered through a spouse. A comparison with no line for disability insurance omits the benefit whose absence would hurt most. Mixing pre-tax and after-tax figures without saying which is which makes the arithmetic impossible to check, and a single verdict with no scenarios hides the fact that decides it.
Get a FIN-355 Topic 6 example written to your instructions
Send the FIN-355 Topic 6 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with the offers, benefit summaries or case your section provides. We write a custom example to them, with every benefit valued at employer cost and at employee value, vesting applied to the match, scenarios run and the deciding fact named, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More FIN 355 papers and BS in Finance and Economics samples
- FIN 355 Topic 1: Plan Risk Bearer Comparison
- FIN 355 Topic 2: Employer Plan Design Memo
- FIN 355 Topic 3: Contribution Rules Worksheet
- FIN 355 Topic 4: Payout Option Comparison
- FIN 355 Topic 5: Irreversible Election Dq Post
- FIN 355 Topic 7: Decumulation Stress Projection
- FIN 355 Topic 8: Lump Sum Election Review
- FIN 375 Topic 6: Bond Duration Exercise
- FIN 350 Topic 6: Risk and Return Measurement
- FIN 431 Topic 6: Premium Loading Breakdown
- FIN 210 Topic 6: Household Insurance Review
FIN 355 Topic 6 questions, answered
Why not value benefits at what the employer pays?
Because employer cost measures spending, not worth to the person receiving it. A health contribution is valuable to an employee who needs the coverage and worth little to one already insured through a spouse, though it costs the employer the same in both cases. Coverage that is expensive to buy individually, such as disability insurance, can be worth more than its group cost. The example values each line from the employee's side.
How does vesting change the value of a match?
A match belongs to the employee only once it vests. Under a three-year cliff, someone leaving after two years forfeits the entire match, so for that person it is worth nothing, while someone staying five years keeps all of it. Graded schedules release part of the match each year instead. The example asks how long the employee expects to stay before counting any match as pay.
Can I use this to compare my own job offers?
Not directly. Both offers and the employee are composites with illustrative figures, and real benefit plans carry deductibles, networks, waiting periods and tax details the example simplifies. Your comparison depends on your household, your health needs and the actual plan documents. The example demonstrates the employee-value reasoning FIN-355 grades and is not advice about any particular offer.
Where can I find a free FIN 355 Topic 6 sample paper?
Here you can read every part of the two-offer valuation: the components table, employer cost, value to the employee in two situations, the early-departure case, what is not priced and the decision. Send the offers in your case and a free valuation can be built on their terms.
When does Offer B win in FIN 355 Topic 6?
When a spouse's plan already covers the family. The premium support is then worth nothing to her, and B's 6,000 dollars of extra salary beats A's 2,880 match and 900 of disability value by about 2,220 a year.