FIN 355 Topic 7 decumulation stress projection example

Retirement Planning and Employee Benefits Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This FIN 355 Topic 7 sample paper shows how the order of returns decides whether a composite retiree's 800,000 dollars lasts from 65 to 95. It sits in GCU FIN 355, Retirement Planning and Employee Benefits, catalog code FIN-355, within the Grand Canyon University BS in Finance and Economics. Withdrawals start at 36,000 dollars and rise 2.5 percent a year. Three paths compound to the same 5 percent over thirty years: steady growth leaves about 94,000 at 95, losses of 15 and 8 percent in the first two years run the account dry at 87, and the same losses at the end leave about 579,000. A first withdrawal near 29,800 survives the worst path.

CourseFIN 355 Retirement Planning and Employee Benefits
TopicTopic 7
Paper typeWithdrawal projection
LengthAbout 960 words, 5 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramBS in Finance and Economics
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for FIN 355 Topic 7

1

Same Average, Different Retirement: How the Order of Returns Decides Whether 800,000 Dollars Lasts From 65 to 95

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

FIN-355: Retirement Planning and Employee Benefits

Topic 7 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the finding, that identical average growth can end very differently depending on when losses arrive. The retiree and every figure are an illustrative composite; the sources are real.
2

Same Average, Different Retirement: How the Order of Returns Decides Whether 800,000 Dollars Lasts From 65 to 95

The Question

Harold Ostrowski, a composite retiree, has 800,000 dollars in savings at 65 and wants to know whether withdrawing 36,000 dollars a year, rising with inflation, will last until he is 95. A projection using a single average return would give him one answer. This paper shows why that answer can mislead: three return paths with exactly the same compound growth over thirty years produce outcomes that range from running out of money at 87 to leaving more than half a million dollars at 95. The difference comes entirely from the order of returns.

Assumptions

Table 1

Projection Assumptions, Illustrative

InputValue
Starting balance at 65$800,000
First withdrawal$36,000, taken at the start of each year
Withdrawal growth2.5% a year for inflation
HorizonTo age 95 (30 withdrawals)
Compound growth over 30 years5% a year on every path

Every input is stated before any result.

What this page is doingThe assumptions sit apart from the results so any one can be challenged, and all three paths share the same compound growth.
3

Three Paths With the Same Growth

Table 2

Three Return Paths With Identical 30-Year Growth, Illustrative

PathFirst three yearsRemaining yearsResult
Steady5%, 5%, 5%5%Every withdrawal funded; about $94,000 left at 95
Poor years first-15%, -8%, +2%About 6.46%Money runs out at 87
Poor years lastAbout 6.46%Ends with -15%, -8%, +2%Every withdrawal funded; about $579,000 left at 95

The first path earns a steady 5 percent every year. The second has losses of 15 percent and 8 percent in the first two years and a gain of 2 percent in the third, followed by about 6.46 percent a year for the remaining 27 years; those figures were chosen so that the thirty-year compound growth is exactly 5 percent a year, the same as the steady path. The third path has the same returns as the second, but with the three poor years moved to the end, at ages 92 to 94.

What this page is doingThe three paths compound to the same 5 percent, so the eight-year difference in outcomes is due to order alone.
4

Why Order Matters

Without withdrawals, the order of returns would not matter at all: an account that falls 15 percent and then rises ends in the same place as one that rises and then falls. Withdrawals change that. When losses come early, Harold is selling investments at low prices to fund his spending, and the money he withdraws is gone before the recovery. The account that must earn the later high returns is smaller, so those returns add fewer dollars. When losses come late, the account has already grown large, and Harold's withdrawals by then are a smaller share of it, so the same percentage losses do less lasting damage. This is sequence-of-returns risk: for a retiree drawing income, the years just before and after retirement carry the most weight.

The effect is large here. Identical average growth produces an eight-year difference in how long the money lasts, and a gap of more than half a million dollars at 95, decided by order alone. A projection showing only the steady path would have told Harold his plan worked, with a modest cushion; it would not have shown him that a bad start could leave him without savings at 87.

Tracing the Damage Year by Year

The poor-years-first path shows how quickly the problem compounds. Harold withdraws 36,000 dollars at 65, leaving 764,000, which then falls 15 percent to about 649,400. At 66 he withdraws about 36,900, leaving roughly 612,500, which falls another 8 percent to about 563,500. At 67 he withdraws about 37,800 and the remainder grows only 2 percent. Within three years the account has lost nearly a third of its value, while the withdrawals, rising with inflation, now take a larger share of a smaller balance each year. The strong returns that follow are applied to a base that never recovers. From 68 onward, each year's withdrawal exceeds what the account earns, so the balance shrinks every year, slowly at first and then faster, until it cannot fund the withdrawal at 87. On the poor-years-last path, by contrast, the account has grown well above 800,000 dollars before the losses arrive, so the same three bad years only trim a large balance.

What Withdrawal Survives the Worst Path

Holding the poor-years-first path fixed, the first withdrawal can be reduced until the account just lasts to 95. On these assumptions, a starting withdrawal of about 29,800 dollars, rising 2.5 percent a year, survives that path. That is about 3.7 percent of the starting balance, compared with the 4.5 percent Harold planned. Bengen (1994), using historical United States returns, found that a starting withdrawal of about 4 percent, adjusted for inflation, survived every thirty-year period he tested for a portfolio of stocks and bonds, while higher rates failed in some periods, mainly those that began with poor returns. Cooley et al. (1998) reached a similar conclusion, estimating the probability that various withdrawal rates would last over different horizons. Both studies rely on historical returns, and long-run international evidence (Dimson et al., 2002) shows that returns in other countries and periods have sometimes been lower, so any safe rate is an estimate rather than a guarantee.

What this page is doingFinding the withdrawal that survives the worst path turns the risk into a decision Harold can act on.
5

What Harold Can Do

Harold has several options besides simply spending less. He can begin at 36,000 dollars but agree in advance to cut withdrawals by a set share in any year after the account falls, which protects against a bad start without reducing spending if returns are good. He can hold two to three years of withdrawals in cash or short-term bonds, so that early losses do not force him to sell stocks at low prices. He can delay Social Security to increase his guaranteed income, reducing what the account must supply. Or he can use part of the balance to buy an annuity covering essential expenses. Each of these targets the specific risk this paper has measured: a poor sequence in the first years of retirement.

References

Bengen, W. P. (1994). Determining withdrawal rates using historical data. Journal of Financial Planning, 7(4), 171-180.

Cooley, P. L., Hubbard, C. M., & Walz, D. T. (1998). Retirement savings: Choosing a withdrawal rate that is sustainable. AAII Journal, 20(2), 16-21.

Dimson, E., Marsh, P., & Staunton, M. (2002). Triumph of the optimists: 101 years of global investment returns. Princeton University Press.

Reading the GCU FIN 355 Topic 7 instructions

Topic 7 in FIN-355 asks students to project retirement withdrawals in a way that exposes sequence-of-returns risk. A single average return hides the risk this topic is about. Students should state every assumption, including inflation-adjusted withdrawals and a horizon beyond life expectancy, build return paths that share the same compound growth but differ in order, and keep the withdrawal timing convention consistent across paths. The paper should explain why early losses do lasting damage when withdrawals are being taken, trace the mechanism year by year through actual balances, find the withdrawal level that survives the worst path, cite the research on sustainable withdrawal rates with its limits, and name practical responses such as spending rules, a cash reserve or partial annuitization.

Inside the FIN 355 Topic 7 example

The projection begins with an assumptions table, then defines three paths that all compound to 5 percent over thirty years: steady growth, losses at the start and the same losses at the end. A results table shows the account funding every withdrawal on two paths and running dry at 87 on the third. A section explains why withdrawals make order matter, followed by a year-by-year trace of the first three years on the poor-start path. The paper then solves for the starting withdrawal that survives that path, about 29,800 dollars, compares it with research on sustainable withdrawal rates and closes with responses such as spending rules and a cash reserve.

FIN 355 Topic 7 rubric: what Excellent looks like

The rubric rewards a projection that measures sequence risk rather than averaging it away. An Excellent paper builds paths with identical compound growth so that differences come from order alone, and uses one withdrawal convention throughout. Credit goes to withdrawals that rise with inflation and a horizon past life expectancy. Faculty look for the mechanism explained and traced through actual balances. Strong papers solve for the withdrawal that survives the poor path and set it beside Bengen's and the Trinity study's findings, noting that history is not a guarantee. Top marks go to responses aimed at the first years of retirement, such as a cash reserve or flexible spending.

Common FIN 355 Topic 7 mistakes, and how to avoid them

The most common failure here is a projection with one steady return, which makes any plan look sound and hides the risk the topic exists to measure. Lowering the average return to model volatility tests the level of returns, not their order. Fixed withdrawals that ignore inflation make every path look sturdier than it is. Stopping the projection at life expectancy reports success while ignoring the long-lived outcomes a plan must cover. Mixing start-of-year and end-of-year withdrawals across paths produces differences that come from the convention rather than the returns. A paper that finds the plan fragile but names no withdrawal level that would hold leaves the retiree with a warning instead of a decision.

Get a FIN-355 Topic 7 example written to your instructions

Send the FIN-355 Topic 7 instructions and the rubric attached in your classroom, with the retiree case or figures your section supplies. We write a custom example to them, with assumptions tabled apart, the same growth run in several orders, the horizon set past life expectancy and a sustainable withdrawal located, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More FIN 355 papers and BS in Finance and Economics samples

FIN 355 Topic 7 questions, answered

What is sequence-of-returns risk?

The risk that poor returns arrive early in retirement, when withdrawals are selling investments at low prices. Losses in the first years shrink the balance that later recoveries have to work on, so two retirees with identical average returns can end very differently. In the example, the same thirty-year growth ends with about 603,000 left or with the money gone at 87, depending only on when the losses fall.

Why project to 95 instead of to life expectancy?

Because life expectancy is an average, and a plan built to it fails for everyone who lives longer, which for a couple is more likely than not for at least one spouse. Projecting further costs little if the couple dies sooner and protects them if one of them does not. The example uses 95 as an illustrative horizon and says so, since mortality and health differ from household to household.

Where can I find a free FIN 355 Topic 7 sample paper?

The full sequence-of-returns projection is here: the assumptions, the three equal-growth paths, why order matters, the year-by-year trace, the withdrawal that survives the worst path and the responses. Share the balance and spending in your case and a free projection can be run on them.

How much can be withdrawn safely in FIN 355 Topic 7?

On its illustrative worst path, a first withdrawal of about 29,800 dollars, rising 2.5 percent a year, lasts to 95. That is about 3.7 percent of the 800,000 starting balance, not a universal safe rate.

Why do early losses matter more than late ones?

Because withdrawals sell investments at low prices after an early loss, leaving a smaller balance to benefit from later gains. Late losses hit an account that has already grown, so the same percentages do less lasting damage.