FIN 355 Topic 8 lump sum election review example

Retirement Planning and Employee Benefits Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This FIN 355 Topic 8 sample paper tests a composite retiree's three reasons for taking a 420,000-dollar lump sum instead of a 2,400-dollar monthly joint and survivor pension. It answers the final prompt of GCU FIN 355, Retirement Planning and Employee Benefits, catalog code FIN-355, in the university's BS in Finance and Economics. The bequest reason holds. The fear of company failure is weak because the benefit sits inside the federal guarantee. The 7 percent return reason gets the arithmetic: the lump sum must earn about 6.0 percent every year to match the pension, and one 20 percent loss in year one leaves it unable to fund year twenty.

CourseFIN 355 Retirement Planning and Employee Benefits
TopicTopic 8
Paper typeLump sum decision review
LengthAbout 1,070 words, 4 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramBS in Finance and Economics
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for FIN 355 Topic 8

1

Testing Three Reasons for Taking the Lump Sum: A Review of One Retiree's Choice Between 420,000 Dollars and a 2,400-Dollar Monthly Pension

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

FIN-355: Retirement Planning and Employee Benefits

Topic 8 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the method, taking the retiree's own reasons one at a time, and the two amounts being compared. The retiree, his pension and every figure are an illustrative composite; the sources are real.
2

Testing Three Reasons for Taking the Lump Sum: A Review of One Retiree's Choice Between 420,000 Dollars and a 2,400-Dollar Monthly Pension

The Choice and His Reasons

Frank Delgado, a composite 65-year-old retiring from a manufacturing company, must choose between two forms of his pension. One option is a joint and survivor pension paying 2,400 each month, or 28,800 in a year, for as long as he or his wife, Rosa, 62, is alive. Or he can take a lump sum of 420,000 dollars now. Apart from the pension, the couple has about 150,000 dollars in Frank's 401(k) and will receive Social Security. Frank is inclined to take the lump sum and gives three reasons in his own words: "I want something to leave my kids," "I'm worried the company could go under," and "I can earn 7 percent on my own." This review tests each reason in turn. One plan rule frames the decision: because the pension's default form for a married participant is a joint and survivor annuity, Frank cannot take the lump sum without Rosa's written, witnessed consent, and she is the person who gives up the most if the money runs out. All figures are illustrative.

Reason One: A Bequest

The bequest reason holds. The pension ends at the second death; if Frank and Rosa both die in their eighties, nothing passes to their children. Money left in the lump sum account would pass to heirs. If leaving money to his children is a real goal, the lump sum serves it and the pension does not. The question is how much the goal is worth relative to the security the pension provides, which depends on the other two reasons.

What this page is doingEach reason is stated in the retiree's own words and judged on its merits, starting with the one that holds.
3

Reason Two: The Company Could Fail

This reason is weak. Frank's pension is a private-sector defined benefit plan insured by the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation. If the plan ended without enough money to pay benefits, the PBGC would pay his benefit up to the maximum guaranteed amount set by law, which depends on age at retirement and the form of benefit (Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation, n.d.). A 2,400-dollar monthly joint and survivor benefit at 65 falls well inside the guarantee. The company's failure would not, on these facts, reduce his pension.

Reason Three: Earning 7 Percent

Table 1

The Lump Sum Against the Pension Under Three Return Paths, Illustrative

ScenarioReturn pathResult after 30 years of 28,800 withdrawals
PensionNot market-dependent28,800 a year for both lives, however long
Lump sum, steady 7%7% every yearAll withdrawals funded; about $286,000 left
Lump sum, early loss-20% in year 1, then 7%Cannot fund year 20
Lump sum, break-evenAbout 6.0% every yearAll withdrawals funded; nothing left

The return reason deserves the arithmetic. To pay himself 28,800 dollars at the start of each year for thirty years, until Rosa is 92, the 420,000 dollars must earn about 6.0 percent a year after fees, every year. That is the return implied by the pension's price. If Frank can reliably earn more, the lump sum could replicate the pension and leave something over; if not, it cannot.

At a steady 7 percent after fees, the lump sum would fund all thirty withdrawals and still hold about 286,000 dollars at the end, the strongest case for Frank's view. But returns are not steady. If the account lost 20 percent in the first year and then earned a steady 7 percent, it would fail to fund the withdrawal in year twenty, leaving Frank, then 84, and Rosa, 81, with only Social Security for the remaining years. One bad year at the start turns a comfortable surplus into a shortfall.

What this page is doingThe break-even return and the early-loss path together show what Frank's 7 percent expectation must survive.
4

What the Pension Also Insures

The comparison so far assumes Rosa lives to 92. The pension pays for as long as either spouse lives, which may be longer. A lump sum sized for thirty years would leave Rosa without that income if she lived to 97; the pension would keep paying. This is longevity insurance, and Brown (2001) estimated that for retirees without much other lifetime income, its value can be substantial. Benartzi et al. (2011) note that many retirees nonetheless prefer lump sums, often for reasons, such as a sense of control or the appeal of a large balance, that do not hold up when the insurance value is counted.

The Strongest Case Against the Pension: Inflation

The pension has one real weakness the review must weigh: its 2,400 dollars a month is fixed. If prices rise 2.5 percent a year, the payment will buy about as much as 1,465 dollars does today after twenty years, when Frank is 85, and less after that. A lump sum invested in stocks and bonds could, in principle, keep pace with inflation. This is the best argument for Frank's position, and it is stronger than any of the three he gave. But it does not change the conclusion, for two reasons. Social Security, which will make up a large share of the couple's income, rises with inflation each year, so their total income is partly protected. And the 401(k) can be invested for growth precisely because the pension covers a base of spending. The better response to inflation risk is to keep the guaranteed income and let the couple's other savings carry the growth assets, rather than to give up the guarantee and take on both investment and longevity risk at once.

Conclusion

Of Frank's three reasons, only the bequest holds. The fear of company failure is largely answered by the federal guarantee, and the 7 percent expectation, while possible, must be earned every year after fees and survive the risk of an early loss, a risk the pension removes entirely. Frank should take the pension, which secures income for both lives and leaves the couple's other savings free to grow, to cover emergencies and, eventually, to pass to their children. If leaving money to his children matters to him, he can meet that goal more cheaply by keeping his separate 401(k) savings invested for that purpose or by buying a modest life insurance policy, rather than by giving up the guaranteed income he and Rosa will rely on. If, after this review, the couple still prefers the lump sum, two steps would make that choice safer: holding the first five years of withdrawals in short-term bonds so an early loss does not force sales, and spending at a rate tied to the account's value rather than a fixed 28,800 dollars.

References

Benartzi, S., Previtero, A., & Thaler, R. H. (2011). Annuitization puzzles. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 25(4), 143-164. https://doi.org/10.1257/jep.25.4.143

Brown, J. R. (2001). Private pensions, mortality risk, and the decision to annuitize. Journal of Public Economics, 82(1), 29-62. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0047-2727(00)00152-3

Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation. (n.d.). Maximum monthly guarantee tables. Retrieved October 4, 2026, from https://www.pbgc.gov/wr/benefits/guaranteed-benefits/maximum-guarantee

The FIN-355 Topic 8 assignment instructions

FIN-355 closes with Topic 8, where students review a client's retirement decision instead of making it for them. The brief asks for each of the client's reasons to be stated in his own words and tested on its merits. Students should compute the return the lump sum must earn to match the pension, test the client's expected return on more than one path, address the federal guarantee when insolvency is the concern and recognize the spousal consent rule that applies to married participants. A strong review credits any reason that holds, weighs the pension's inflation weakness fairly, gives a verdict and names steps that would make the client's preferred choice safer.

How this FIN 355 Topic 8 example is built

The review opens with the two options and the retiree's three reasons quoted, along with the rule that his wife must consent to a lump sum. Each reason is then tested in its own section. The bequest reason is found sound. The fear of company failure is answered with the federal guarantee. The return reason is tested by computing the break-even return of about 6.0 percent and running the lump sum at a steady 7 percent and with an early 20 percent loss, summarized in a table. A section on longevity insurance and another on inflation, the pension's real weakness, follow before a conclusion that recommends the pension and names safer steps if the couple still prefers the lump sum.

Reading the FIN 355 Topic 8 rubric

Graders award an Excellent review for testing reasons rather than endorsing or dismissing the client. The rubric rewards quoting each reason, judging it on evidence and saying plainly which ones hold. Credit goes to the break-even return calculation and to testing the 7 percent assumption on an early-loss path, not just a steady one. Faculty look for the federal guarantee raised against the insolvency fear and for the spousal consent requirement. Strong reviews weigh the pension's lack of inflation protection honestly. Top marks go to a verdict that names what would make the client's preferred choice safer, such as a bond reserve and flexible spending.

FIN 355 Topic 8 help: mistakes that cost marks

Reviews lose the most when they simply endorse the client's choice because he has already made it, since agreement is not a test. The opposite error writes the review to talk him out of it and ignores that one of his reasons is sound. Testing his 7 percent only on a steady path accepts the very assumption under review. Raising the fear of employer failure without mentioning the federal guarantee leaves the weakest reason standing. Leaving out the spousal consent rule misstates the plan and forgets the person who gives up the most. A verdict that never says which reasons held, or what would make the decision safer, leaves the file with an opinion instead of a finding.

Get a FIN-355 Topic 8 example written to your instructions

Send the FIN-355 Topic 8 instructions and your classroom rubric, with the client case and the decision your section's scenario has already settled. We write a custom example to them, with each of the client's reasons tested separately, the required return computed, an early-loss path run and the spousal consent rules applied, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More FIN 355 papers and BS in Finance and Economics samples

FIN 355 Topic 8 questions, answered

Why does the wife have to consent to a lump sum?

Because federal pension law protects a married participant's spouse by making a survivor annuity the default form of payment. Choosing a lump sum or a single-life payment waives that protection, so the plan requires the spouse's written consent, witnessed by a notary or a plan representative. The review treats her signature as a decision in its own right, since the survivor income she gives up is hers.

Where can I find a free FIN 355 Topic 8 sample paper?

The lump sum review is printed here in full, from the three reasons and the consent rule through the bequest, the guarantee, the break-even return, the early-loss path, longevity insurance and inflation to the verdict. When your case client has other reasons, list them and we will test each one in a complimentary review.

What return must the lump sum earn in FIN 355 Topic 8?

About 6.0 percent a year after fees, every year, to pay 28,800 dollars at the start of each year for thirty years from 420,000 dollars. A steady 7 percent would leave about 286,000, but an early 20 percent loss would run it out in year twenty.

Does the review tell the client he is wrong?

Not on every point. It finds his bequest reason sound, his insolvency fear largely answered by the federal guarantee and his return expectation fragile to an early loss, then recommends the pension while naming steps that would make a lump sum safer.

Is this review advice about my own pension?

No. The couple, the pension and the lump sum are composites, and the rules are summarized generally for a FIN-355 assignment. Your own choice depends on your plan's terms, your health, your other income and current law.