| Course | FIN 375 Introduction to Investments |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 4 |
| Paper type | Equity valuation paper |
| Length | About 960 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Finance and Economics |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for FIN 375 Topic 4
36.65 or 50.00? Valuing a Share With a Two-Stage Dividend Model and a Peer Multiple, and Reading What the Gap Assumes
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
FIN-375: Introduction to Investments
Topic 4 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
36.65 or 50.00? Valuing a Share With a Two-Stage Dividend Model and a Peer Multiple, and Reading What the Gap Assumes
The Company and the Question
Tamarack Water Systems, a composite maker of commercial water filtration equipment, has just paid an annual dividend of 1.50 dollars a share and earned 2.50 dollars a share over the past year. Its sales are growing quickly as new regulations take effect, but analysts expect growth to settle once the market matures. This paper values the share two ways, with a two-stage dividend discount model and with a price-earnings multiple taken from comparable companies, and then asks why the two answers differ. All figures are illustrative.
The Two-Stage Dividend Model
Table 1
Two-Stage Dividend Valuation, Illustrative
| Item | Amount | Discount factor at 9% | Present value |
|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 dividend | $1.65 | 1 / 1.09 | About $1.51 |
| Year 2 dividend | About $1.82 | 1 / 1.09^2 | About $1.53 |
| Year 3 dividend | About $2.00 | 1 / 1.09^3 | About $1.54 |
| Terminal value at year 3 | About $41.53 | 1 / 1.09^3 | About $32.07 |
| Total | | | About $36.65 |
The model assumes dividends grow 10 percent a year for three years and then 4 percent a year indefinitely, and discounts them at a required return of 9 percent. The first stage is computed year by year. Dividends will be 1.65 dollars in year one, about 1.82 in year two and about 2.00 in year three.
The second stage uses the constant-growth model (Gordon, 1959) at the end of year three. The dividend in year four is about 2.00 times 1.04, or about 2.08 dollars, and the value at year three of all dividends from year four on is 2.08 divided by the required return minus the long-run growth rate, 0.09 minus 0.04, or about 41.53 dollars. That terminal value is located at year three, so it is discounted three years.
Where the Value Comes From
About 32.07 of the 36.65 dollars, roughly 87 percent, comes from the terminal value, the dividends after year three. The high-growth period, which drives the company's story, contributes less than 5 dollars. The value therefore depends heavily on the long-run growth rate and the required return, the two inputs in the terminal value's denominator. Damodaran (2012) warns that in most discounted cash flow valuations the terminal value dominates, so its assumptions deserve the closest scrutiny.
How Sensitive the Dividend Value Is
Table 2
Dividend Model Value Under Different Long-Run Assumptions, Illustrative
| Long-run growth | Required return 8.5% | 9.0% | 9.5% |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3.5% | About $36.98 | About $33.59 | About $30.77 |
| 4.0% | About $40.75 | About $36.65 | About $33.30 |
| 4.5% | About $45.46 | About $40.38 | About $36.32 |
Because the terminal value dominates, small changes in its two inputs move the answer a lot. Table 2 recomputes the value for long-run growth of 3.5, 4 and 4.5 percent and required returns of 8.5, 9 and 9.5 percent.
Reading the Sensitivity
Within this grid, values range from about 31 to about 45 dollars. None reaches the multiple's 50 dollars; even the most generous combination, 4.5 percent growth and an 8.5 percent required return, falls about 5 dollars short. That is itself informative: the peer multiple sits outside the range produced by assumptions most analysts would call reasonable for this company, which is why the next section asks what it would take to close the gap rather than treating either figure as the right one.
The Peer Multiple
The comparable-companies approach takes the median price-earnings ratio of a group of similar water technology firms, 20 times trailing earnings, and applies it to Tamarack's 2.50 dollars of earnings per share. The result is 50.00 dollars a share. This method is quick and reflects how the market currently prices similar businesses, but it borrows all of that market's assumptions about growth and risk without stating them.
What the Gap Implies
The two answers differ by more than 13 dollars, about 36 percent of the dividend value. Averaging them would produce a number, about 43 dollars, that answers no question either method asked. A more useful step is to ask what assumptions would make the dividend model agree with the multiple. Holding the required return at 9 percent, the model reaches 50 dollars only if long-run growth is about 5.4 percent rather than 4. Holding long-run growth at 4 percent, it reaches 50 dollars only if the required return is about 7.7 percent rather than 9.
The multiple, in other words, carries either more optimism about long-run growth or less concern about risk than the dividend model's inputs. Either could be right. If the peer companies are expected to keep growing faster than the overall economy for decades, or if investors regard water technology as a low-risk, regulation-driven business, the multiple may be reasonable. If not, the peer group may be overpriced, and Tamarack with it.
Choosing Between Them
Bodie et al. (2021) describe dividend models and multiples as complements: the model makes assumptions explicit, while the multiple reflects current market prices. The useful question for an investor is which set of assumptions is more believable. A long-run growth rate of 5.4 percent forever would mean Tamarack grows faster than the overall economy indefinitely, which is hard to defend for a company in a maturing market. A required return of 7.7 percent would be low for a mid-sized industrial company. On balance, the dividend model's 4 percent and 9 percent seem more reasonable, which suggests the peer multiple is pricing in optimism that Tamarack may not justify. An investor considering the stock at around 50 dollars should ask what she knows about long-run growth that the 4 percent assumption misses. If she cannot name a reason, such as a durable regulatory advantage or a pipeline of new markets, the dividend model suggests that much of the peer group's premium rests on expectations Tamarack would have to exceed, not merely meet, for the investment to pay off.
References
Bodie, Z., Kane, A., & Marcus, A. J. (2021). Investments (12th ed.). McGraw Hill.
Damodaran, A. (2012). Investment valuation: Tools and techniques for determining the value of any asset (3rd ed.). Wiley.
Gordon, M. J. (1959). Dividends, earnings, and stock prices. Review of Economics and Statistics, 41(2), 99-105. https://doi.org/10.2307/1927792
The FIN-375 Topic 4 assignment instructions
In Topic 4, FIN-375 asks students to value common stock with more than one method and to reconcile the results. Students build a two-stage dividend discount model with the high-growth dividends computed year by year and a terminal value discounted from the right date, then apply a peer multiple. Strong work reports the terminal value's share of the total, tests the model's sensitivity to long-run growth and the required return, and refuses to average conflicting answers. Instead, students should solve for the growth rate or required return that would make the model match the multiple and judge which assumptions are more believable for the company described.
Inside the FIN 375 Topic 4 example
The finished valuation works from illustrative figures. The company has just paid a dividend of 1.50, and the dividend model assumes 10 percent growth for three years, then 4 percent indefinitely, discounted at a 9 percent required return. Dividends of 1.65, about 1.82 and about 2.00 lead to a terminal value of about 41.53 at year three, and the present value comes to about 36.65. The multiples approach takes earnings of 2.50 and a peer median price-earnings ratio of 20, giving 50.00. The example does not average the two. It backs out what the multiple implies: the dividend model reaches 50 only if long-run growth is about 5.4 percent rather than 4, or if the required return is about 7.7 percent rather than 9. The multiple, in other words, carries more optimism about growth or less concern about risk.
Where the marks sit in the FIN 375 Topic 4 rubric
Faculty reward a valuation that explains disagreement rather than splitting it. An Excellent paper computes each dividend and the terminal value with correct timing, presents them in a table and notes the terminal value's share of the total. Credit goes to a sensitivity grid on long-run growth and the required return. The rubric values backing out the growth rate and required return implied by the peer multiple. Strong papers cite the constant-growth model's source and discuss when its assumptions hold. Top marks go to a judgment about which set of assumptions is more plausible for the company and what an investor would need to believe to pay the higher price.
FIN 375 Topic 4 help: mistakes that cost marks
Averaging the two values and reporting the midpoint is the error marked hardest here, because it buries the input the two methods disagree about and yields a figure neither supports. Terminal values discounted one period too far, or computed from the third year's dividend instead of the fourth, understate the dividend model by a visible amount. A peer multiple applied without saying which peers, or why, assumes the target shares their growth and risk. Papers that report both values and pick one offer no reason a reader could test. Saying nothing about how much of the total comes from the terminal value hides the answer's dependence on growth after year three, which here supplies most of it. Treating either value as a buy signal, with no market price beside it, turns a valuation into a recommendation it cannot support.
Get a FIN-375 Topic 4 example written to your instructions
Send the FIN-375 Topic 4 problems and the rubric your classroom provides, with the company data or case your section assigned. We write a custom example to them, with a dividend value and a multiples value built independently, the terminal value dated correctly, the gap solved for its cause and implied multiples compared, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More FIN 375 papers and BS in Finance and Economics samples
- FIN 375 Topic 1: Trade Execution Walkthrough
- FIN 375 Topic 2: Realized Return Statistics
- FIN 375 Topic 3: Diversification Limit Demonstration
- FIN 375 Topic 5: Market Efficiency Dq Post
- FIN 375 Topic 6: Bond Duration Exercise
- FIN 375 Topic 7: Horizon-matched Fund Selection
- FIN 375 Topic 8: Constrained Allocation Defense
- FIN 355 Topic 4: Payout Option Comparison
- FIN 350 Topic 4: Bond and Share Pricing
- FIN 210 Topic 4: Credit Score Factor Analysis
FIN 375 Topic 4 questions, answered
Why not average the two valuations?
Because a midpoint answers no question anyone asked. The dividend model and the peer multiple encode different beliefs about growth and risk, and a gap of more than 13 a share measures how far apart those beliefs are. The example keeps both figures and solves for the growth rate and required return that would bring them together, which turns the disagreement into two claims an analyst can test.
Why does most of the dividend value come from the terminal value?
Because the high-growth period lasts only three years, and everything after it is compressed into one figure. In the example the discounted terminal value is about 32 of the 36.65 total, nearly nine-tenths. That makes the long-run growth rate the most consequential input, which is why the reconciliation tests it first and why small changes to it move the answer so far.
Does the example say the stock is worth buying?
No. The company is a composite and every input is illustrative, chosen to show how two approaches can disagree and how the gap is explained. Whether any real share is worth buying depends on its actual price, prospects and risks, and on your own circumstances. The example shows the reasoning FIN-375 marks; it is coursework, not investment advice.
Where can I find a free FIN 375 Topic 4 sample paper?
This page holds the complete valuation paper: the two-stage dividend table, the terminal value's share, the sensitivity grid, the peer multiple, the implied growth and return, and the judgment between them. Different dividends or peer multiples in your assignment? Share them and we will rebuild both values at no cost.
What does the multiple imply in FIN 375 Topic 4?
That long-run growth would have to be about 5.4 percent instead of 4, or the required return about 7.7 percent instead of 9, for the dividend model to reach the peer value of 50 dollars.