| Course | FIN 375 Introduction to Investments |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 8 |
| Paper type | Allocation defense paper |
| Length | About 980 words, 4 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Finance and Economics |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for FIN 375 Topic 8
An Allocation He Will Actually Hold: Defending a 35-55-10 Portfolio Against the Constraint That Decides Whether Any Plan Survives a Bad Year
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
FIN-375: Introduction to Investments
Topic 8 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
An Allocation He Will Actually Hold: Defending a 35-55-10 Portfolio Against the Constraint That Decides Whether Any Plan Survives a Bad Year
The Constraints Come First
Walter Kim, a composite 60-year-old regional sales director, has about 900,000 dollars across three accounts and asks for an allocation for the next five years. Before any allocation is proposed, five constraints are stated, because an allocation that ignores any of them will fail in practice.
First, his daughter's wedding will cost about 30,000 dollars in eighteen months. Second, he plans to retire in five years. Third, 270,000 dollars, nearly a third of his wealth, is in his employer's stock inside the workplace plan. Fourth, his taxable brokerage account holds shares bought decades ago with large unrealized gains. Fifth, in the last major market decline he sold most of his stocks near the bottom, and he says plainly that a one-year loss above 100,000 dollars would make him sell again.
The First Proposal and Its Stress Test
A conventional first proposal for someone five years from retirement is 45 percent diversified stocks, 45 percent bonds and 10 percent cash. To test it against the fifth constraint, the portfolio is run through an illustrative bad year: stocks fall 35 percent, bonds gain 3 percent and cash earns 2 percent. On 900,000 dollars, the stock holding of 405,000 loses about 141,750, the bonds gain about 12,150 and the cash earns about 1,800, a net loss of about 127,800 dollars. That exceeds Walter's own limit by almost 28,000 dollars.
By his own account, an allocation that loses that much in a bad year would be sold near the bottom, locking in the loss. Its expected return is irrelevant if he will not hold it. The first proposal fails the constraint that decides whether any plan survives contact with a bad year.
The Revised Allocation
Table 1
Stress Test of Two Allocations on 900,000 Dollars, Illustrative
| Allocation | Stocks | Bonds | Cash | Loss in stress year (stocks -35%, bonds +3%, cash +2%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| First proposal | 45% | 45% | 10% | About $127,800 |
| Revised | 35% | 55% | 10% | About $93,600 |
The revised allocation is 35 percent diversified stocks, 55 percent bonds and 10 percent cash. In the same stress test, stocks lose about 110,250, bonds gain about 14,850 and cash earns about 1,800, a net loss of about 93,600 dollars, within his limit.
What the Revision Costs
Holding less in stocks lowers expected return. With illustrative long-run assumptions of 7 percent for stocks and 4 percent for bonds, moving 10 percentage points from stocks to bonds costs about 0.3 percentage points of expected return a year, roughly 2,700 dollars a year on 900,000. Over five years that is real money, but it is small compared with the cost of selling after a 128,000-dollar loss and missing the recovery. Barber and Odean (2000) found that individual investors who traded most actively earned substantially lower net returns than those who traded least, a reminder that the behavior an allocation provokes can matter more than its design.
The Employer Stock
The 270,000 dollars in employer stock is the most dangerous holding. It ties Walter's savings to the same company that pays his salary, so a bad year for the company could cost him his job and a large share of his wealth at once. Benartzi (2001) found that employees tend to allocate heavily to company stock, especially after it has performed well, and that those allocations did not predict better future returns. The plan is to sell all but a small amount and reinvest in diversified stock and bond funds. Because the shares sit inside the tax-deferred workplace plan, selling them triggers no tax, which makes this the cheapest step in the whole plan. Markowitz (1952) showed that concentrated holdings carry risk that diversification could remove at no cost in expected return; here, it can also be removed at no cost in tax.
The Wedding, the Taxable Gains and Where Each Asset Sits
The 10 percent cash allocation, about 90,000 dollars, easily covers the 30,000-dollar wedding in eighteen months, so that money is held in Treasury bills and is not exposed to the stock market. The low-basis shares in the taxable account are a constraint on where changes are made rather than on the allocation: selling them would realize large capital gains, so they are kept, and the rest of the portfolio is adjusted around them. Most of the bonds are placed in the workplace plan and IRA, where their interest is tax-deferred, while the taxable account holds the existing stocks. The overall mix is 35, 55 and 10 across all accounts combined.
Rebalancing Rules Set in Advance
Because Walter's history shows he acts under pressure, the plan sets its rebalancing rules now, while markets are calm. The allocation will be checked every six months and restored to 35, 55 and 10 whenever any part drifts more than 5 percentage points from its target. After a fall in stocks, that means buying stocks with bond money, the opposite of what he did last time. Writing the rule down, and agreeing that changes outside it require a week's wait and a conversation, turns rebalancing from a decision made in fear into a routine. If Walter cannot accept buying after a decline, the stock share should be lowered further rather than left to be sold at the worst moment.
The Defense
The revised allocation is not the one with the highest expected return. It is the one Walter is most likely to hold through a bad year, which is the condition for earning any return at all. It respects every stated constraint: the wedding is funded, the employer concentration is removed without tax, the low-basis gains are left untouched, and a severe decline would cost less than his own limit. It should be reviewed each year and as retirement approaches, and if Walter's tolerance for losses grows with experience, the stock share can be raised gradually.
References
Barber, B. M., & Odean, T. (2000). Trading is hazardous to your wealth: The common stock investment performance of individual investors. Journal of Finance, 55(2), 773-806. https://doi.org/10.1111/0022-1082.00226
Benartzi, S. (2001). Excessive extrapolation and the allocation of 401(k) accounts to company stock. Journal of Finance, 56(5), 1747-1764. https://doi.org/10.1111/0022-1082.00388
Markowitz, H. (1952). Portfolio selection. Journal of Finance, 7(1), 77-91. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6261.1952.tb01525.x
What the FIN 375 Topic 8 instructions ask for
FIN-375 closes with Topic 8, where students recommend and defend an asset allocation for a specific investor. The brief rewards starting from constraints rather than from a standard model portfolio. Students should list the investor's goals, horizon, concentrations, tax situation and behavioral limits, then stress-test a proposed allocation against a severe but plausible year and revise it if it breaks a constraint. Strong work prices what the revision costs in expected return, addresses concentrated employer stock with research, considers taxes in deciding what to sell and where to hold each asset, and sets rebalancing rules in advance for an investor who has acted under pressure before.
How this FIN 375 Topic 8 example is built
The finished defense states five constraints before any allocation: a 30,000 wedding cost in eighteen months, retirement in five years, 270,000 of employer stock inside the workplace plan, low-basis holdings in the taxable account, and a record of selling after the last market fall, with his own statement that a one-year loss above 100,000 would make him sell again. The first proposal, 45 percent diversified stocks, 45 percent bonds and 10 percent cash, is stress-tested with an illustrative 35 percent stock decline, a 3 percent bond gain and 2 percent on cash, and loses about 127,800. It fails the constraint that decides whether any plan survives contact with a bad year. The revised allocation, 35, 55 and 10, loses about 93,600 in the same test, at a cost of about 0.3 points of assumed expected return a year.
Where the marks sit in the FIN 375 Topic 8 rubric
Faculty reward a defense built on the investor's own constraints. An Excellent paper states the constraints first, stress-tests the first proposal in dollars and revises it when it breaches the investor's stated loss limit. Credit goes to pricing the revision in expected return and comparing that cost with the cost of panic selling. The rubric values removing employer stock concentration inside the tax-deferred plan, with research cited, and leaving low-basis taxable holdings in place. Strong papers fund near-term needs from cash and place assets by account. Top marks go to rebalancing rules written down in advance and a defense that explains why the investor will hold the allocation.
Common FIN 375 Topic 8 mistakes, and how to avoid them
The heaviest deductions go to allocations sized to a return target with the investor's record of selling left unexamined, since a portfolio he dumps during a slump delivers none of the return that justified it. Papers that express risk tolerance as a label, moderate or aggressive, and never convert it into a dollar loss cannot show whether the allocation fits. Leaving the employer stock in place, or counting it as diversified equity, keeps the investor's largest single risk inside a plan that claims to spread risk. Selling low-basis taxable holdings to rebalance, when the same change could be made inside the tax-deferred account, creates needless tax. A defense that tests some constraints and not others, often skipping the near-term cash need, is incomplete. Revising for caution without pricing what it costs leaves the investor unable to judge the trade.
Get a FIN-375 Topic 8 example written to your instructions
Send the FIN-375 Topic 8 instructions and your classroom rubric, with the investor case and constraints your section provides. We write a custom example to them, with constraints listed before any allocation, a stress test run in dollars, the allocation revised where it fails and the cost of the revision priced, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More FIN 375 papers and BS in Finance and Economics samples
- FIN 375 Topic 1: Trade Execution Walkthrough
- FIN 375 Topic 2: Realized Return Statistics
- FIN 375 Topic 3: Diversification Limit Demonstration
- FIN 375 Topic 4: Two-method Equity Valuation
- FIN 375 Topic 5: Market Efficiency Dq Post
- FIN 375 Topic 6: Bond Duration Exercise
- FIN 375 Topic 7: Horizon-matched Fund Selection
- FIN 355 Topic 8: Lump Sum Election Review
- FIN 350 Topic 8: Capital Investment Recommendation
- FIN 210 Topic 8: Personal Financial Plan
FIN 375 Topic 8 questions, answered
Why does the investor's past selling outweigh a higher expected return?
Because an allocation earns its expected return only if it is held. An investor who sells after a large loss realizes that loss and often misses the recovery, which can leave him worse off than a more cautious allocation held throughout. His record is evidence about his real tolerance, so the example sizes the stock allocation to a loss he has said he could live with.
Why sell the employer stock inside the workplace plan?
Because trades inside a tax-deferred account trigger no tax when they happen, so the concentration can be reduced without a tax bill, while selling appreciated shares in the taxable account would realize gains. Some plans allow special tax treatment for employer stock taken out in kind, so the plan documents deserve a check before any sale, since that choice matters for some participants.
Is this allocation advice for my own retirement?
No. The investor, his accounts and every return assumption are composites chosen to show how an allocation is defended against constraints. Your allocation depends on your own accounts, taxes, plan rules, horizon and tolerance for loss. The example demonstrates the reasoning FIN-375 marks at the close of the course and should not be read as investment advice; your actual situation calls for a licensed professional.
Where can I find a free FIN 375 Topic 8 sample paper?
The allocation defense is shown in full here: the five constraints, the first proposal and its stress test, the revision, its cost, the employer stock, the wedding and taxable gains, the rebalancing rules and the defense. Tell us about the investor in your case and a free defense can be built on those facts.
Why does the first allocation fail in FIN 375 Topic 8?
In a stress year with stocks down 35 percent, bonds up 3 and cash up 2, the 45-45-10 mix loses about 127,800 dollars, beyond the 100,000 loss the investor says would make him sell again.