| Course | FIN 431 Financial Risk Management and Insurance |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 2 |
| Paper type | Loss measurement paper |
| Length | About 970 words, 4 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Finance and Economics |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for FIN 431 Topic 2
Same Expected Loss, Opposite Treatment: A Frequency and Severity Profile for a Forty-Van Delivery Fleet
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
FIN-431: Financial Risk Management and Insurance
Topic 2 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Same Expected Loss, Opposite Treatment: A Frequency and Severity Profile for a Forty-Van Delivery Fleet
The Fleet and the Question
Northline Parcel, a composite last-mile delivery company, runs forty vans in a metropolitan area and has equity of about 1,500,000 dollars. After identifying its loss exposures, it now needs to measure them. This paper profiles three exposures by frequency, how often losses occur, and severity, how large they are when they do, and shows why expected loss alone is a poor guide to how each should be handled. All figures are illustrative.
Collision Damage: Frequent and Predictable
Northline's records show collision claims on its own vans over five years: 14, 18, 11, 16 and 16. The mean is 15 claims a year. The sample standard deviation, which measures how much the yearly count varies around that mean, is about 2.6 claims. Average severity is about 2,400 dollars a claim, so the expected annual collision loss is 15 times 2,400, or 36,000 dollars.
The important feature is stability. In the worst of the five years, 18 claims, losses would have been about 43,200 dollars; in the best, about 26,400. A swing of that size is a budget variance, not a threat to the firm. Rejda et al. (2020) note that when losses are frequent and individually small, a large firm can predict them well from its own experience, which makes them suitable for retention.
Cargo Theft: Moderate
Cargo theft from vans runs about two claims a year, averaging about 6,000 dollars each, for an expected annual loss of 12,000 dollars. The yearly figure varies more in proportion than collisions, since a year might bring zero or four thefts, but even a bad year of four, about 24,000 dollars, is manageable.
Serious Injury Liability: Rare and Catastrophic
Northline has never had a serious injury liability claim, in which one of its vans badly injures a pedestrian or another driver and a court awards large damages. Its own history therefore cannot measure the exposure. The profile borrows experience from the industry table supplied with the case, which suggests an illustrative 2 percent annual chance that a fleet of this size faces a judgment of about 2,000,000 dollars. The expected annual loss is 0.02 times 2,000,000, or 40,000 dollars.
This expected figure is almost meaningless as a planning number. In 98 years out of 100, Northline would pay nothing; in the remaining two, it would owe 2,000,000 dollars, more than its entire 1,500,000 dollars of equity. The loss would not be a variance from budget but the end of the company.
The Profile
Table 1
Frequency and Severity Profile for Three Fleet Exposures, Illustrative
| Exposure | Frequency | Severity | Expected annual loss | Worst plausible year |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Collision damage | About 15 a year | About $2,400 | $36,000 | About $43,000 |
| Cargo theft | About 2 a year | About $6,000 | $12,000 | About $24,000 |
| Serious injury liability | About 2% chance a year | About $2,000,000 | $40,000 | $2,000,000 |
Table 1 collects the three exposures.
How Reliable the Numbers Are
The three measurements rest on very different evidence. The collision figure comes from five years of Northline's own claims, a modest but real record; with about 75 claims behind it, the mean is a reasonable guide to next year, though a change in routes, drivers or vehicles could shift it. The theft figure rests on about ten claims, enough to give an order of magnitude but not much more. The liability figure rests on no Northline experience at all. The industry table reflects many fleets, but they may differ in size, routes and driver quality, and a 2,000,000-dollar severity is a rough central figure for a loss that could be smaller or several times larger. For this reason the liability estimate should be read as a range: the chance might be 1 percent or 4 percent, and the judgment might be 500,000 or 5,000,000 dollars. Across most of that range the conclusion holds, since even a 500,000-dollar judgment would take a third of the firm's equity and anything above 1,500,000 would exceed it, which is why the profile can still guide the decision despite its uncertainty.
Placing the Exposures in the Matrix
Risk managers often place exposures in a matrix with frequency on one axis and severity on the other, because each cell suggests a different treatment. Collision damage is high frequency and low severity: losses are predictable and the firm can retain them, budgeting about 36,000 dollars a year and investing in driver training and telematics to reduce them. Serious injury liability is low frequency and high severity: the firm cannot absorb a single loss, so it must transfer the risk, through liability insurance with limits well above 2,000,000 dollars. Cargo theft falls between, suited to a moderate deductible.
The two largest expected losses, collision at 36,000 and liability at 40,000, differ by only 4,000 dollars, yet they belong in opposite cells of the matrix. One is a budget line; the other could end the company. Mayers and Smith (1982) argue that firms buy insurance largely to avoid the costs of financial distress, and only the liability exposure carries that risk here.
A Caution About Insuring the Small Losses
Firms and households often do the reverse of what the profile suggests, buying low deductibles to avoid small, predictable losses while carrying too little protection against rare, large ones. Sydnor (2010) found that homeowners frequently paid substantially more in premiums for low deductibles than they could expect to save in claims. For Northline, insuring collision damage at first dollar would mean paying an insurer's expenses and profit on top of the 36,000 dollars of losses it can predict, money better spent on higher liability limits. The profile's purpose is to point the firm's premium dollars toward the exposure that could actually threaten its survival, and to show the owners that a quiet claims history in one exposure says nothing about the size of the loss it could still produce.
References
Mayers, D., & Smith, C. W., Jr. (1982). On the corporate demand for insurance. Journal of Business, 55(2), 281-296. https://doi.org/10.1086/296165
Rejda, G. E., McNamara, M. J., & Rabel, W. H. (2020). Principles of risk management and insurance (14th ed.). Pearson.
Sydnor, J. (2010). (Over)insuring modest risks. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 2(4), 177-199. https://doi.org/10.1257/app.2.4.177
FIN 431 Topic 2 instructions, in plain terms
The Topic 2 assignment in FIN-431 asks students to measure loss exposures before choosing how to treat them. Expected loss alone is not enough. Students should compute frequency and severity separately, use the firm's own claims history where it exists and explain how to estimate exposures the firm has never experienced. Strong work calculates means and standard deviations, shows each exposure's worst plausible year, places exposures in a frequency-severity matrix and explains why the matrix cells call for different treatments. Students should also discuss how reliable each estimate is and compare the largest possible loss with the firm's equity.
Inside the FIN 431 Topic 2 example
The finished profile tables five illustrative years of collision claims for the forty vans: 14, 18, 11, 16 and 16, a mean of 15 a year with a sample standard deviation near 2.6. Average severity is 2,400, so expected annual collision loss is 36,000, and the yearly total stays close enough to budget. Cargo theft runs about two claims a year at 6,000 each, 12,000 expected. Serious injury liability has never occurred in the firm's history, so the profile borrows the case's industry table: an illustrative 2 percent annual chance of a 2,000,000 judgment, or 40,000 expected. The two largest expected losses differ by only 4,000. One is a budget line; the other exceeds the firm's 1,500,000 of equity, and the profile places them in opposite cells of the matrix.
Where the marks sit in the FIN 431 Topic 2 rubric
Instructors grading the profile reward measures that lead to treatment decisions. An Excellent paper computes frequency, severity, expected loss and variability for each exposure and shows the worst plausible year beside the expected one. Credit goes to borrowing industry data, with its limits stated, for an exposure the firm has never had. The rubric values recognizing that two exposures with similar expected losses can differ completely in severity relative to the firm's equity. Strong papers place each exposure in the frequency-severity matrix with a reasoned treatment. Top marks go to warning against spending premium on small, predictable losses while large ones stay underinsured.
FIN 431 Topic 2 help: mistakes that cost marks
Expected loss reported alone, without frequency and severity shown separately, strips out the information treatment depends on, because an average of 40,000 can describe a steady drip or a single catastrophe. Papers that measure liability from the company's own clean record conclude the exposure is zero, when five years without a judgment says almost nothing about a rare event. A frequency figure given with no spread hides whether the count is steady enough to budget. Severity quoted as an average without the worst plausible outcome understates the exposure that decides survival. Placing exposures on the matrix by impression, instead of by the computed figures, turns the grid into decoration. The strongest profiles compare each worst case with the firm's capacity to absorb it, since that comparison is what the retention decision in the next topic uses.
Get a FIN-431 Topic 2 example written to your instructions
Send the FIN-431 Topic 2 instructions and your classroom rubric, with the loss history or case your section provides. We write a custom example to them, with frequency and severity measured separately, expected losses computed, borrowed data labeled where the history is thin and each worst case set against the firm's capacity, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More FIN 431 papers and BS in Finance and Economics samples
- FIN 431 Topic 1: Loss Exposure Identification
- FIN 431 Topic 3: Total Cost of Risk Comparison
- FIN 431 Topic 4: Commercial Property Policy Reading
- FIN 431 Topic 5: Uninsurable Risk Dq Post
- FIN 431 Topic 6: Premium Loading Breakdown
- FIN 431 Topic 7: Risk Treatment Program Design
- FIN 431 Topic 8: Cyber Coverage Decision Memo
- FIN 375 Topic 2: Realized Return Statistics
- FIN 355 Topic 2: Employer Plan Design Memo
- FIN 350 Topic 2: Compounding and Discounting Exercise
- FIN 210 Topic 2: Personal Time Value Worksheet
FIN 431 Topic 2 questions, answered
Why measure frequency and severity separately?
Because they call for different responses. A loss that arrives often and costs little is predictable enough to budget and is usually cheaper to carry than to insure. A loss that arrives rarely and costs a great deal cannot be budgeted, because the average never actually occurs; what occurs is either nothing or the full amount. Multiplying the two into one expected figure erases that difference.
How can a firm measure a loss it has never had?
By borrowing experience from a larger group. Industry loss data, insurer rating tables and published claim studies cover many similar firms, so a rare event shows up often enough to estimate. Here the case supplies an illustrative industry frequency, labeled as such. A firm's own clean record is weak evidence about rare losses, since a five-year window would miss most of them.
Can the profile tell my company what to insure?
No. The fleet, its claims and the industry figure are composites built for a FIN-431 exercise. Real measurement depends on actual loss runs, exposure data and the judgment of underwriters and risk professionals, and treatment decisions follow from facts the example does not have. It shows how the course wants exposures measured before any decision is made, and it is not insurance advice.
Where can I find a free FIN 431 Topic 2 sample paper?
The fleet frequency and severity profile is shown in full here, from collision damage and cargo theft through the liability estimate, the profile table and the reliability of each figure to the matrix and the caution on small losses. Share your claims data and a free profile can be worked.
Why treat collision and liability differently in FIN 431 Topic 2?
Their expected losses are close, 36,000 and 40,000 dollars, but collision losses are frequent and small while the liability loss is rare and could reach 2,000,000, more than the firm's 1,500,000 of equity. One is retained; the other must be transferred.