| Course | FIN 431 Financial Risk Management and Insurance |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 3 |
| Paper type | Retention comparison paper |
| Length | About 950 words, 4 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Finance and Economics |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for FIN 431 Topic 3
Cheapest Before Capital, Not After: Comparing a 1,000 Deductible, a 5,000 Deductible and Full Retention by Total Cost of Risk
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
FIN-431: Financial Risk Management and Insurance
Topic 3 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Cheapest Before Capital, Not After: Comparing a 1,000 Deductible, a 5,000 Deductible and Full Retention by Total Cost of Risk
The Decision
Cascade Grounds Maintenance, a composite commercial landscaping firm with about forty crews, insures physical damage to its trucks, trailers and mowing equipment. Its broker has offered two policies, one with a 1,000-dollar deductible per claim and one with a 5,000-dollar deductible. The owner has also asked whether the firm should drop the coverage and pay all such losses itself. This paper compares the three options by total cost of risk: retained losses, premiums, claims handling and the cost of the capital the firm must hold against a bad year. All figures are illustrative.
The Loss Distribution
Cascade's claims history suggests about ten physical damage claims a year. About 60 percent are small, averaging 600 dollars, such as a damaged mower deck; about 30 percent are moderate, averaging 2,800 dollars; and about 10 percent are large, averaging 9,000 dollars, such as a trailer accident. Expected annual losses are 10 times the weighted average severity: 10 times (0.6 x 600 + 0.3 x 2,800 + 0.1 x 9,000), or 10 times 2,100, which is 21,000 dollars.
What Each Option Retains and Costs
Under the 1,000-dollar deductible, Cascade pays the first 1,000 of each claim. It keeps all of each small claim, 600, and 1,000 of each moderate and large claim, so its expected retained losses are 10 times (0.6 x 600 + 0.3 x 1,000 + 0.1 x 1,000), or 7,600 dollars. The insurer expects to pay the remaining 13,400 dollars but charges a 20,000-dollar premium, 6,600 more than it expects to pay out. Under the 5,000-dollar deductible, Cascade keeps all small and moderate claims and 5,000 of each large one, about 17,000 dollars of expected retained losses, and pays a 7,000-dollar premium for the insurer's expected 4,000 of payments. Under full retention, Cascade keeps all 21,000 dollars of expected losses and pays an estimated 2,500 dollars a year to handle claims itself, such as adjusting and arranging repairs, work the insurer would otherwise do.
The Comparison Before Capital
Adding retained losses, premiums and handling costs gives the first comparison: about 27,600 dollars a year for the 1,000 deductible, 24,000 for the 5,000 deductible and 23,500 for full retention. Before considering capital, full retention looks cheapest, because it avoids paying the insurer's expenses and profit. The low deductible looks most expensive, because Cascade pays 6,600 dollars a year above the insurer's expected claims to transfer losses it could easily absorb. Sydnor (2010) found the same pattern among homeowners, who often paid far more for low deductibles than the claims they could expect to recover.
Adding the Cost of Capital
Table 1
Total Cost of Risk Under Three Options, Illustrative
| Cost component | $1,000 deductible | $5,000 deductible | Full retention |
|---|---|---|---|
| Expected retained losses | $7,600 | $17,000 | $21,000 |
| Premium | $20,000 | $7,000 | $0 |
| Claims handling | $0 | $0 | $2,500 |
| Total before capital | $27,600 | $24,000 | $23,500 |
| Reserve for a bad year | $12,000 | $28,000 | $42,000 |
| Cost of reserve at 10% | $1,200 | $2,800 | $4,200 |
| Total cost of risk | $28,800 | $26,800 | $27,700 |
The comparison is incomplete, because retained losses are not always average. In a bad year Cascade might have twice the usual number of large claims, and it must hold cash or credit in reserve to pay them without disrupting operations. The case sets the reserve needed for a bad year at 12,000 dollars under the 1,000 deductible, 28,000 under the 5,000 deductible and 42,000 under full retention. Money held in reserve cannot be used to buy equipment or win contracts, so it has an opportunity cost. At Cascade's cost of capital of 10 percent, the annual cost of each reserve is 1,200, 2,800 and 4,200 dollars.
Reading the Result
With the cost of capital included, the 5,000-dollar deductible has the lowest total cost of risk, about 26,800 dollars a year, ahead of full retention at 27,700 and the low deductible at 28,800. The middle option wins because it lets Cascade retain the predictable small and moderate losses, where insurance is expensive relative to the risk transferred, while transferring the large ones, which are less predictable and would require a large reserve. Froot et al. (1993) argue that managing risk creates value when it protects the firm's ability to fund its operations and investments without costly outside financing; the 5,000 deductible achieves that protection at the least total cost. Rejda et al. (2020) describe the same logic as retaining frequent small losses and transferring infrequent large ones.
Recommendation
Cascade should choose the 5,000-dollar deductible. The result depends on the inputs, especially the reserve sizes and the cost of capital: if the firm's cost of capital fell to about 3.6 percent, full retention would tie with the 5,000 deductible, and a lower cost would favor retention. The reserve sizes matter just as much: they come from the case's estimate of a bad year, and a firm with ready access to a credit line might need to hold less cash, which would also narrow the gap. Neither change is likely soon for a firm of Cascade's size, whose bank currently limits its credit line to a modest seasonal amount. The owner should therefore revisit the choice as the firm grows, since a larger fleet makes losses more predictable and reduces the reserve needed per vehicle. For now, the higher deductible saves about 2,000 dollars a year compared with the current low-deductible policy, while keeping the firm protected against the losses it could not comfortably absorb. To make the retained losses easier to carry, the owner should also set aside the expected 17,000 dollars as a monthly budget line for equipment repairs, and track each crew's damage claims so that the savings from the higher deductible are not lost to careless handling of trailers and mowers.
References
Froot, K. A., Scharfstein, D. S., & Stein, J. C. (1993). Risk management: Coordinating corporate investment and financing policies. Journal of Finance, 48(5), 1629-1658. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6261.1993.tb05123.x
Rejda, G. E., McNamara, M. J., & Rabel, W. H. (2020). Principles of risk management and insurance (14th ed.). Pearson.
Sydnor, J. (2010). (Over)insuring modest risks. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 2(4), 177-199. https://doi.org/10.1257/app.2.4.177
What the FIN 431 Topic 3 instructions ask for
Topic 3 of FIN-431 asks students to compare risk financing options by their full cost. Comparing premiums alone misses most of the answer. Students should build a loss distribution, compute the losses retained under each deductible, compare each premium with the losses the insurer expects to pay, include claims handling costs for retention and then add the opportunity cost of the reserve each option requires for a bad year. Strong work presents the components in one table, explains why the ranking changes once capital is counted, tests how sensitive the result is to the cost of capital and reserve size, and recommends an option with its conditions.
How the FIN-431 Topic 3 example is put together
The finished comparison starts from an illustrative loss distribution: about ten physical damage claims a year, 60 percent averaging 600, 30 percent averaging 2,800 and 10 percent averaging 9,000, so expected losses run 21,000 a year. Under the 1,000 deductible the firm keeps about 7,600 of that and pays a 20,000 premium, 6,600 more than the insurer expects to pay out. Under the 5,000 deductible it keeps about 17,000 and pays 7,000. Retaining everything means 21,000 of losses plus 2,500 to handle claims. Before capital, full retention looks cheapest at 23,500, against 24,000 and 27,600. Each option then needs a reserve sized to the case's bad year, 12,000, 28,000 or 42,000, priced at the firm's capital cost of 10 percent. With that line added the 5,000 deductible wins at 26,800, ahead of 27,700 and 28,800.
Where the marks sit in the FIN 431 Topic 3 rubric
Faculty marking the comparison reward a complete total cost of risk. An Excellent paper computes retained losses from the distribution for each option and shows how much each premium exceeds the insurer's expected payout. Credit goes to adding claims handling for retention and a capital charge on each reserve, and to showing that the cheapest option before capital is not the cheapest after. The rubric values a sensitivity check, such as the cost of capital at which retention would tie. Strong papers explain the result with the principle of retaining frequent small losses and transferring large ones. Top marks go to a recommendation that states when it should be revisited.
FIN 431 Topic 3 help before you submit
Premiums compared with premiums, and nothing else, cost the most on this topic, since the question is the total cost of a risk and a premium is only one line of it. A comparison that counts retained losses at their expected value and stops has priced the average year while ignoring the bad one the reserve must survive. Leaving out the capital a reserve ties up makes retention look free, which is how full retention appears cheapest here until that line is added. Deductibles applied to the total annual loss instead of to each claim misstate what the firm keeps. Papers that omit claims handling under full retention forget that someone must investigate and pay each loss. Recommendations with no threshold at which the answer changes present a conclusion resting on a 10 percent assumption as though it were fixed.
Get a FIN-431 Topic 3 example written to your instructions
Send the FIN-431 Topic 3 instructions and the rubric your classroom provides, with the loss data or quotes your section assigns. We write a custom example to them, with retained losses computed under each option, premium loadings shown, the capital behind retention priced and the threshold that would reverse the choice stated, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More FIN 431 papers and BS in Finance and Economics samples
- FIN 431 Topic 1: Loss Exposure Identification
- FIN 431 Topic 2: Frequency and Severity Profile
- FIN 431 Topic 4: Commercial Property Policy Reading
- FIN 431 Topic 5: Uninsurable Risk Dq Post
- FIN 431 Topic 6: Premium Loading Breakdown
- FIN 431 Topic 7: Risk Treatment Program Design
- FIN 431 Topic 8: Cyber Coverage Decision Memo
- FIN 375 Topic 3: Diversification Limit Demonstration
- FIN 355 Topic 3: Contribution Rules Worksheet
- FIN 350 Topic 3: Annuity Problem Set
- FIN 210 Topic 3: Debt Repayment Order Comparison
FIN 431 Topic 3 questions, answered
What is the total cost of risk?
The full annual cost of carrying and transferring a set of exposures: retained losses, premiums paid, the expense of handling claims and administering the program, and the cost of capital held against losses the firm keeps. It is the figure retention and transfer decisions should compare, since a lower premium that raises retained losses and reserves can leave the firm worse off overall.
Why charge a cost of capital on the reserve?
Because money held against possible losses cannot be used elsewhere in the business. A firm that keeps 42,000 available for a bad claims year gives up whatever that money would have earned in operations, a cost the example sets at the case's 10 percent. Without the charge, retention looks costless beyond its expected losses, and full retention wins comparisons it would otherwise lose.
Should my business raise its deductibles?
The example cannot say. Its firm, claim distribution, premiums and cost of capital are illustrative, set up so that the capital line changes the answer. Any actual choice turns on loss history, quoted terms, cash reserves and lender or contract requirements, and deserves review by a licensed insurance professional. What the example shows is the total cost comparison FIN-431 expects at this point.
Where can I find a free FIN 431 Topic 3 sample paper?
The total cost of risk comparison appears in full: the loss distribution, what each option retains and costs, the comparison before capital, the capital charge, the summary table, the reading and the recommendation. Supply your own premiums and loss data and a free comparison can be built.
Why does the 5,000 deductible win in FIN 431 Topic 3?
It keeps predictable small and moderate losses, where insurance is costly, and transfers large ones, so it needs a 28,000-dollar reserve instead of 42,000. With a 10 percent capital charge its total cost is about 26,800, below 27,700 for retention and 28,800 for the low deductible.