| Course | FIN 432 Real Estate |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 1 |
| Paper type | Real estate characteristics paper |
| Length | About 970 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Finance and Economics |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for FIN 432 Topic 1
A Building or a Fund? Six Features That Make Direct Real Estate Different From a Listed REIT, Each With Its Consequence
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
FIN-432: Real Estate
Topic 1 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
A Building or a Fund? Six Features That Make Direct Real Estate Different From a Listed REIT, Each With Its Consequence
The Choice
Elaine Morrow, a composite retired teacher, has 1,200,000 dollars from the sale of a family business and wants real estate income. Her broker has shown her a small office building priced at 1,200,000 dollars; her financial adviser suggests a listed real estate investment trust fund instead, which owns hundreds of properties and trades on a stock exchange. Both give her an interest in income-producing property. This paper explains six features that make the building a different kind of asset from the fund, and what each means for her. All figures are illustrative.
Unique and Without a Quoted Price
Every building is different in location, size, condition and tenants. There is no market price for Elaine's building in the way there is a price for a share of the fund, which is quoted every second the exchange is open. The building's value must be estimated, usually by an appraiser comparing it with sales of other buildings, adjusting for differences, or by capitalizing its income. Ling and Archer (2021) describe this heterogeneity as a basic characteristic of real estate. The consequence for Elaine is that she will never know exactly what her building is worth until she sells it, and two honest appraisers may disagree by several percent.
Immobile and Tied to One Market
A building cannot move. Its income depends on the local economy, the local supply of competing space and decisions by the local government, such as zoning. If the largest employer in town closes, Elaine's tenants may leave and her rents fall, and nothing she does with the building can change that. The fund owns properties in many cities and sectors, so a downturn in one market affects only a small part of it.
Indivisible
Elaine cannot buy a tenth of the building. Buying it puts 1,200,000 dollars, all her capital, into a single asset. If the building has a problem, such as a major tenant leaving or a roof failing, her whole investment is affected. The fund lets her divide her money among many properties and, if she wishes, hold only part of her capital in real estate. Indivisibility makes diversification within real estate impossible at her level of wealth without a pooled vehicle.
Slow and Costly to Trade
Table 1
Transaction Costs Spread Over the Holding Period, Illustrative
| Holding period | Round-trip cost | Cost per year | As a share of value each year |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 years | $108,000 | $36,000 | About 3.0% |
| 5 years | $108,000 | About $21,600 | About 1.8% |
| 10 years | $108,000 | $10,800 | About 0.9% |
Buying and selling a building takes months and costs a great deal. At illustrative rates of 3 percent to buy, for legal work, inspections and financing fees, and 6 percent to sell, mainly brokerage, a round trip on a 1,200,000-dollar building costs about 108,000 dollars. How much that matters depends on how long she holds it.
Needs Management
A building must be managed: leases negotiated, rents collected, repairs made, taxes and insurance paid. Elaine can do this herself or hire a property manager for a share of the rent. A fund's management is done by the trust's professional staff and is reflected in its expenses. Geltner et al. (2014) note that direct property returns depend partly on the owner's management skill, which makes them in part a return to effort as well as to capital.
Divisible Rights
Ownership of real estate is a bundle of legal rights that can be separated and sold apart: the right to use the property, to lease it, to sell it, to borrow against it, and in some cases rights to minerals or air above it. Elaine could sell an easement to a utility or lease part of the land while keeping the rest. A fund share carries no such rights; it is a claim on the trust's earnings and assets. This flexibility can add value for an active owner but also creates complexity, since title must be examined for rights others already hold.
What Each Would Pay Her
The income looks different too. The building's seller reports net operating income of about 84,000 dollars a year, a 7 percent return on the price, but that figure assumes the current tenants stay and leaves out a manager's fee of perhaps 5 percent of rents and reserves for future repairs. After those, Elaine might expect about 70,000 dollars in a normal year, and much less in a year when a tenant leaves and the space sits empty while she looks for another. The fund pays dividends from the rents of hundreds of buildings, so a single vacancy barely affects it, though its illustrative dividend yield of about 4 percent is lower and its share price can swing. Neither figure is a promise, but the building's income is lumpier, depending on a handful of leases, while the fund's is smoother and lower.
The Fund by Contrast, and the Choice
The fund trades daily at low cost and offers wide diversification, but its price moves with the stock market in the short run, sometimes falling sharply when property values have barely changed. Research comparing public and private real estate finds that, after adjusting for debt levels and property type, long-run returns are broadly similar, while short-run behavior differs considerably (Pagliari et al., 2005). For Elaine, the building offers control and income but concentrates her entire capital in one asset, requires management and is costly to sell. If she expects to hold for ten years or more and wants to manage it, the building may suit her; if she may need her money sooner or values diversification, the fund is the better choice. Given that this is her whole capital and she is retired, a fund, or a building held alongside other assets, is the more prudent path.
References
Geltner, D. M., Miller, N. G., Clayton, J., & Eichholtz, P. (2014). Commercial real estate analysis and investments (3rd ed.). OnCourse Learning.
Ling, D. C., & Archer, W. R. (2021). Real estate principles: A value approach (6th ed.). McGraw Hill.
Pagliari, J. L., Jr., Scherer, K. A., & Monopoli, R. T. (2005). Public versus private real estate equities: A more refined, long-term comparison. Real Estate Economics, 33(1), 147-187. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1080-8620.2005.00115.x
The FIN-432 Topic 1 assignment instructions
Topic 1 in FIN-432 introduces real estate as an asset class by asking what makes it different from financial assets. A list of characteristics is only the start. Strong submissions name each distinguishing feature of direct property, explain its practical consequence for an owner and compare it with an indirect form such as a REIT fund. Students should show at least one consequence with arithmetic, such as transaction costs spread over different holding periods, cite research comparing public and private real estate, and end with a judgment about which form suits the investor described, given her capital, horizon and willingness to manage property.
How this FIN 432 Topic 1 example is built
The finished paper names six features that separate the building from the fund and gives each a consequence. The building is unique, so no quoted price exists and value must be estimated from sales of other buildings. It is immobile, tying its income to one local market. It is indivisible, putting 1,200,000 into a single asset. Its transactions are slow and costly: at illustrative rates of 3 percent to buy and 6 percent to sell, a round trip costs 108,000. Spread over a three-year hold that is 36,000, about 3 percent of value, every year; over ten years, about 0.9 percent. It needs management that a fund does not. And ownership itself divides into separate legal rights that can be sold apart. The fund, by contrast, trades daily at low cost but moves with the stock market.
Reading the FIN 432 Topic 1 rubric
Faculty reward a paper that ties every feature to a consequence. An Excellent paper explains uniqueness through the absence of a quoted price, immobility through dependence on one local market and indivisibility through concentration of capital. Credit goes to computing transaction costs across holding periods and showing why direct property suits long holds. The rubric values describing management needs and the bundle of legal rights accurately. Strong papers compare income patterns and cite evidence that long-run public and private real estate returns are broadly similar after adjustments. Top marks go to a recommendation that fits the investor's whole situation rather than the asset alone.
FIN 432 Topic 1 help: mistakes that cost marks
The lowest marks go to papers that analyze the building as one more security, since the course starts here precisely to show why pricing, trading and analysis work differently for property. Listing features such as illiquidity and uniqueness without saying what each changes produces a set of definitions with nothing attached. Transaction costs mentioned in words but never priced leave out the difference a holding period makes. Papers that describe REITs as identical to owning property overlook that their shares trade with the stock market and can diverge from appraised values for long stretches. Stating the trusts' distribution requirement as a fixed percentage dates the paper, since tax rules change. A conclusion that never links each feature to the valuation and financing tools the course will use leaves the opening topic disconnected from everything after it.
Get a FIN-432 Topic 1 example written to your instructions
Send the FIN-432 Topic 1 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with any case your section assigns. We write a custom example to them, with each feature of property tied to a consequence, a financial asset used as the comparison, transaction costs priced across holding periods and REITs described without fixed tax figures, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More FIN 432 papers and BS in Finance and Economics samples
- FIN 432 Topic 2: Three-approach Value Reconciliation
- FIN 432 Topic 3: Loan Structure Financing Test
- FIN 432 Topic 4: Holding Period Cash Flow Projection
- FIN 432 Topic 5: Market Turn Dq Post
- FIN 432 Topic 6: Ground Lease Interest Valuation
- FIN 432 Topic 7: Acquisition Bid Recommendation
- FIN 432 Topic 8: Lease Versus Own Analysis
- FIN 431 Topic 1: Loss Exposure Identification
- FIN 375 Topic 1: Trade Execution Walkthrough
- FIN 355 Topic 1: Plan Risk Bearer Comparison
- FIN 210 Topic 1: Household Spending Budget
FIN 432 Topic 1 questions, answered
Why does holding period matter so much for property?
Because buying and selling property carries large fixed costs, such as brokerage, legal work, inspections and transfer taxes, that barely change with how long the owner stays. Spread across a short hold, they eat a large share of the return; across a long one, they shrink to a small annual drag. Here the 108,000 round trip costs about 3 percent a year over three years and under 1 percent over ten.
Is a REIT the same as owning property?
Not quite. A REIT owns property, so its income comes from rents, but its shares trade on an exchange and their price moves with investor sentiment and the stock market as well as with the underlying buildings. That brings liquidity and diversification that direct ownership lacks, along with price swings a building owner never sees quoted. The paper describes the trusts at that level and does not rank the two.
Does the paper recommend buying the building or the fund?
No. The investor, the building and the costs are composites, and the paper's task is to show how property differs as an asset, not to choose between investments. A real choice depends on the investor's capital, horizon, taxes and willingness to manage property, along with local market facts the example does not contain. It is FIN-432 coursework and not investment advice.
Where can I find a free FIN 432 Topic 1 sample paper?
The building versus fund paper is on this page in full, covering uniqueness, immobility, indivisibility, transaction costs, management, divisible rights, the income each would pay and the choice. If your investor's situation is different, tell us and we will write a free version for it.
How much do transaction costs matter in FIN 432 Topic 1?
A round trip at 3 percent to buy and 6 to sell costs 108,000 dollars on a 1,200,000-dollar building, about 3 percent of value a year over a three-year hold but only about 0.9 percent a year over ten.