| Course | FIN 432 Real Estate |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 3 |
| Paper type | Financing analysis paper |
| Length | About 990 words, 4 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Finance and Economics |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for FIN 432 Topic 3
When Borrowing Helps and When It Hurts: Testing a 70 Percent and an 80 Percent Loan on a 1,000,000-Dollar Property
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
FIN-432: Real Estate
Topic 3 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
When Borrowing Helps and When It Hurts: Testing a 70 Percent and an 80 Percent Loan on a 1,000,000-Dollar Property
The Property and the Two Loans
An investor is buying a small retail building for 1,000,000 dollars. It produces net operating income of 75,000 dollars a year, so an all-cash buyer would earn a 7.5 percent return on the price. A lender offers two loans, both amortized over thirty years with monthly payments: 70 percent of the price, 700,000 dollars, at an illustrative 6 percent, or 80 percent, 800,000 dollars, at 6.5 percent, the higher rate reflecting the lender's greater risk. The lender's minimum coverage is 1.25, which means net operating income must be at least 1.25 times the annual loan payments. This paper tests both loans on that requirement, on the investor's cash return and on how each changes the result when the property's value moves.
The 70 Percent Loan
Monthly payments on 700,000 dollars at 6 percent over thirty years total about 50,362 dollars a year. The debt service coverage ratio is 75,000 divided by 50,362, about 1.49, comfortably above the lender's minimum. After paying the loan, the investor keeps 24,638 dollars a year on 300,000 dollars of equity, a cash yield of about 8.21 percent, higher than the 7.5 percent all-cash return. Borrowing raises the cash return here because the loan's annual payments, about 7.19 percent of the loan amount, cost less than the 7.5 percent the property earns on its price.
The 80 Percent Loan
Table 1
Two Loans Compared With an All-Cash Purchase, Illustrative
| Measure | All cash | 70% loan at 6% | 80% loan at 6.5% |
|---|---|---|---|
| Equity invested | $1,000,000 | $300,000 | $200,000 |
| Annual debt service | $0 | About $50,362 | About $60,679 |
| Debt service coverage | n/a | About 1.49 | About 1.24 (below 1.25) |
| Cash flow after debt | $75,000 | About $24,638 | About $14,321 |
| Cash yield on equity | 7.5% | About 8.21% | About 7.16% |
| Loan constant | n/a | About 7.19% | About 7.58% |
Payments on 800,000 dollars at 6.5 percent total about 60,679 dollars a year. Coverage falls to about 1.24, just below the lender's 1.25 minimum, so the loan would not be approved on these figures. Even if it were, the investor would keep 14,321 dollars on 200,000 dollars of equity, a cash yield of about 7.16 percent, below the all-cash 7.5 percent. The reason is the loan constant, the annual payment as a share of the loan: at about 7.58 percent, it exceeds the property's 7.5 percent return, so each borrowed dollar costs more each year than it earns. Borrowing more at a higher rate has turned the debt from a help into a drag on cash flow.
How Sensitive the Result Is to the Rate
The favorable result on the 70 percent loan depends on its 6 percent rate. If the same 700,000-dollar loan cost 7 percent, annual payments would rise to about 55,885 dollars and the loan constant to about 7.98 percent, above the property's 7.5 percent return. Coverage would still pass at about 1.34, but the investor's cash yield would fall to about 6.37 percent, below the all-cash return. One percentage point on the interest rate is enough to turn the same loan from helpful to harmful for cash flow. This matters because rates are set at closing and, for many commercial loans, reset or must be refinanced within five to ten years. An investor who relies on debt to raise the cash yield should know the rate at which it disappears, which here is a loan constant of 7.5 percent, reached at an interest rate of about 6.4 percent on a thirty-year schedule.
When Value Moves
Table 2
One-Year Return With and Without the 70 Percent Loan, Illustrative
| One-year value change | All-cash return | 70% loan return on equity |
|---|---|---|
| Up 5% | 12.5% | About 27.7% |
| Down 10% | -2.5% | About -22.3% |
Borrowing also magnifies changes in value. Suppose the property's value moves over one year. With the 70 percent loan, the investor's one-year return on equity includes the cash flow, the loan principal repaid during the year, about 8,600 dollars, and the change in value. If the value rises 5 percent, by 50,000 dollars, the return on 300,000 of equity is about 27.7 percent, against 12.5 percent for an all-cash buyer. If the value falls 10 percent, by 100,000 dollars, the return is about negative 22.3 percent, against negative 2.5 percent for the all-cash buyer. A modest fall in value becomes a large loss of equity, because the loan balance does not fall with the property's price.
What the Test Shows
Brueggeman and Fisher (2018) describe the favorable case as the condition in which the property's return exceeds the cost of debt, so that borrowing raises the return on equity, and warn that the condition can reverse when loan terms worsen or property income falls. The 70 percent loan meets it; the 80 percent loan does not, and also fails the lender's coverage test. Even favorable borrowing raises risk: the investor's equity absorbs every change in value, so the same loan that lifts a good year's return to about 28 percent turns a bad year into a loss of more than a fifth of the equity. Geltner et al. (2014) make the point that debt financing increases both the expected return on equity and its volatility, rather than creating value by itself.
Recommendation
The investor should take the 70 percent loan, if he can afford to lose a fifth of his equity in a bad year, and decline the 80 percent loan, which costs more than the property earns and would not pass the lender's test in any case. Before closing, he should check how much net operating income could fall before coverage on the 70 percent loan dropped to 1.25: at 1.25 times 50,362 dollars, income would have to fall to about 62,950, a decline of about 16 percent. That is the margin of safety his tenants' leases must protect, and Ling and Archer (2021) recommend checking it against the lease expiration schedule, since a large tenant leaving in the first few years is the most likely way to use it up.
References
Brueggeman, W. B., & Fisher, J. D. (2018). Real estate finance and investments (16th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.
Geltner, D. M., Miller, N. G., Clayton, J., & Eichholtz, P. (2014). Commercial real estate analysis and investments (3rd ed.). OnCourse Learning.
Ling, D. C., & Archer, W. R. (2021). Real estate principles: A value approach (6th ed.). McGraw Hill.
FIN 432 Topic 3 instructions, in plain terms
Topic 3 of FIN-432 asks students to analyze how financing changes a real estate investment's return and risk. Students compute annual debt service, the debt service coverage ratio and the cash yield on equity for each loan, then explain when borrowing raises or lowers the return using the loan constant. Strong work tests each loan against the lender's coverage requirement, shows how a change in property value affects the return on equity with and without debt, including principal repaid, and checks how sensitive the result is to the interest rate. The paper should end with a recommendation and a margin of safety for income.
Inside the FIN 432 Topic 3 example
The finished test holds net operating income at an illustrative 75,000, a 7.5 percent return on the price. The 70 percent loan, 700,000 amortized over thirty years, costs 50,362 a year, a debt service coverage ratio near 1.49, and leaves 24,638 on 300,000 of equity, an 8.21 percent cash yield. The 80 percent loan at 6.5 percent costs 60,679, covers debt only 1.24 times and fails the lender's 1.25 minimum. Its cash yield falls to 7.16 percent, below the all-cash 7.5, because its payments consume 7.58 percent of the loan each year. A one-year value swing then shows the debt working in both directions. With the 70 percent loan, a 5 percent rise lifts the equity's return to about 27.7 percent; a 10 percent fall turns it to about minus 22.3 percent, against 12.5 and minus 2.5 for cash.
Where the marks sit in the FIN 432 Topic 3 rubric
Faculty marking the analysis reward correct loan arithmetic tied to a clear principle. An Excellent paper computes debt service, coverage and cash yield for each loan in one table and explains the results through the loan constant compared with the property's yield. Credit goes to showing that the larger loan both fails the lender's test and lowers the cash return. The rubric values a one-year value swing that includes principal paydown and contrasts the financed and all-cash returns. Strong papers find the interest rate at which the loan stops raising the cash yield. The highest band names how far income could fall before coverage breaches the minimum.
Common FIN 432 Topic 3 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Showing the effect of debt only on the way up draws the sharpest deduction, and a test that reports the 27.7 percent gain without the matching fall describes half of what debt does. Subtracting debt service before computing net operating income is marked wrong, since NOI belongs to the property and financing is a separate layer beneath it. Papers that assume more debt always raises cash yield miss the comparison between the loan constant and the property's return, which reverses the result here. Coverage ratios computed without the lender's minimum cannot say whether a structure is even available. Principal repayment left out of the equity return understates the levered result, while treating it as cash in hand overstates liquidity. A recommendation that names no income decline the structure can withstand leaves its risk unmeasured.
Get a FIN-432 Topic 3 example written to your instructions
Send the FIN-432 Topic 3 instructions and the rubric your classroom posts, with the property and loan terms your section supplies. We write a custom example to them, with debt service computed for each structure, coverage tested against the lender's minimum, cash yield compared with the loan constant and borrowing run in both directions, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More FIN 432 papers and BS in Finance and Economics samples
- FIN 432 Topic 1: Property Asset Distinction Paper
- FIN 432 Topic 2: Three-approach Value Reconciliation
- FIN 432 Topic 4: Holding Period Cash Flow Projection
- FIN 432 Topic 5: Market Turn Dq Post
- FIN 432 Topic 6: Ground Lease Interest Valuation
- FIN 432 Topic 7: Acquisition Bid Recommendation
- FIN 432 Topic 8: Lease Versus Own Analysis
- FIN 431 Topic 3: Total Cost of Risk Comparison
- FIN 375 Topic 3: Diversification Limit Demonstration
- FIN 355 Topic 3: Contribution Rules Worksheet
- FIN 210 Topic 3: Debt Repayment Order Comparison
FIN 432 Topic 3 questions, answered
What is a debt service coverage ratio?
Net operating income divided by the year's loan payments, interest and principal together. A ratio of 1.49 means the property earns about one and a half times what the loan requires. Lenders commonly set a minimum, and the case uses 1.25, so a loan whose payments push the ratio below that is cut to a smaller amount. It measures how far income could fall before the property stops paying its debt.
How can borrowing lower the cash return?
When the loan's annual payments, as a share of the loan, exceed what the property earns on its price. The 80 percent loan's payments take about 7.58 percent of its balance each year, while the building earns 7.5 percent, so each borrowed dollar costs slightly more than it produces in cash. Debt raises cash yield only when the property's return exceeds that loan constant.
Should I finance a property purchase at 70 percent?
The test cannot say. Its building, income and loan terms were set for illustration, with rates chosen to show a mechanism rather than to describe any market. Real financing choices depend on the property, the borrower's finances, current lending terms and the risk the borrower can carry, and they call for a qualified lender or adviser. The example shows the financing analysis FIN-432 grades.
Where can I find a free FIN 432 Topic 3 sample paper?
Here is the full loan test: the two loans, the comparison table, rate sensitivity, the one-year value swing, what the test shows and the recommendation with its margin of safety. Different loan terms in your case can be sent over for a free reworked test.
Why does the 80 percent loan lower the cash yield in FIN 432 Topic 3?
Its annual payments are about 7.58 percent of the loan, more than the 7.5 percent the property earns on its price, so each borrowed dollar costs more than it earns and the cash yield falls to about 7.16 percent.