| Course | FIN 432 Real Estate |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 7 |
| Paper type | Acquisition memo |
| Length | About 820 words, 3 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Finance and Economics |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for FIN 432 Topic 7
Memorandum
To: Investment Committee
From: Acquisitions Analyst
Date: [Date]
Re: Westgate Commons: underwriting at the asking price and recommended bid
Recommendation in Brief
We should decline Westgate Commons at the 3,400,000-dollar asking price and offer about 3,050,000 dollars. At the asking price, the center fails the lender's coverage test and returns about 5.6 percent on our equity against our 12 percent target. At 3,050,000 dollars, on the same assumptions, it returns about 12.3 percent and passes the coverage test. The reasoning follows. All figures are illustrative.
Correcting the Seller's Income
Table 1
Seller's Income Compared With Our Underwriting, Illustrative
| Line | Seller | Our underwriting |
|---|---|---|
| Potential gross income | $300,000 | $300,000 |
| Vacancy and credit loss | $0 | -$21,000 (7%) |
| Operating expenses | -$62,000 | -$62,000 |
| Reserves for replacement | $0 | -$12,000 |
| Net operating income | $238,000 | $205,000 |
| Yield at $3,400,000 | 7.0% | About 6.03% |
The listing reports net operating income of 238,000 dollars, a 7.0 percent capitalization rate at the asking price. That figure assumes all twelve retail bays are leased and sets nothing aside for roof and paving replacement. Neither assumption holds for underwriting. The center's history and the local market support a 7 percent vacancy and credit loss allowance on potential gross income of about 300,000 dollars, or 21,000 dollars a year, and a property of this age needs reserves of about 12,000 dollars a year for roofs, paving and parking lot lighting. Restoring both brings net operating income to 205,000 dollars, a 6.03 percent yield at the asking price. Ling and Archer (2021) note that listings routinely present stabilized or best-case income, which a buyer must rebuild before pricing.
The Loan at the Asking Price
Our lender offers 65 percent of the price at an illustrative 6.25 percent, amortized over twenty-five years. At 3,400,000 dollars that is a 2,210,000-dollar loan with annual payments of about 174,944 dollars. Debt service coverage on our income is 205,000 divided by 174,944, about 1.17, short of the 1.25 the lender requires, which means the loan would be cut or refused. Even if it were made, cash flow after debt service would be about 30,000 dollars on 1,190,000 of equity, a cash yield of about 2.5 percent. Brueggeman and Fisher (2018) describe this as the unfavorable case: the loan constant, about 7.9 percent, exceeds the property's 6.0 percent yield, so borrowing lowers the return on equity.
The Five-Year Return
We project income growing 2.5 percent a year and a sale at the end of year five, priced at a 6.75 percent capitalization rate on year-six income, less 3 percent selling costs, with the remaining loan balance repaid from the proceeds. At the asking price, the internal rate of return on our equity is about 5.6 percent, less than half our 12 percent target. The sale contributes most of the return, so Geltner et al. (2014) would caution that the result depends heavily on the exit rate; but even a more generous exit would not bring the return near 12 percent at this price.
The Price That Meets Our Target
Table 2
The Investment at the Asking Price and at Our Bid, Illustrative
| Measure | At $3,400,000 | At $3,050,000 |
|---|---|---|
| Loan (65%) | $2,210,000 | About $1,982,500 |
| Annual debt service | About $174,944 | About $156,935 |
| Debt service coverage | About 1.17 (fails) | About 1.31 (passes) |
| First-year cash yield | About 2.5% | About 4.5% |
| Five-year equity IRR | About 5.6% | About 12.3% |
Holding every assumption fixed, income, growth, loan terms, exit rate and selling costs, we solved for the purchase price at which our equity return reaches our target. At about 3,050,000 dollars, the return is about 12.3 percent. At that price the loan is about 1,982,500 dollars, debt service about 156,935 a year, coverage about 1.31 and the first-year cash yield about 4.5 percent.
What the Seller's Figures Would Imply
It is worth checking what the asking price requires us to believe. On the seller's own income of 238,000 dollars, with full occupancy and no reserves, the yield is 7.0 percent, coverage on the same loan would be about 1.36 and the project would look acceptable. The difference between the seller's case and ours is therefore not the market or the loan but two underwriting assumptions about the building itself. Full occupancy for five years in a twelve-bay strip center would be unusual; the center has had at least one empty bay in each of the past four years. And roofs and paving are certain costs, not optional ones. Pricing the center on the seller's figures would mean paying today for income that our own records say will not arrive.
Risks and Next Steps
The bid rests on three judgments the seller may dispute: the 7 percent vacancy allowance, the 12,000 dollars of reserves and the 6.75 percent exit rate. We should support each with evidence in the offer letter, including the center's own vacancy history and the property condition report. If the seller can show signed leases that justify lower vacancy, we could raise the bid modestly. We should not raise it simply to close the gap, since at the asking price the investment fails both our return target and the lender's test.
References
Brueggeman, W. B., & Fisher, J. D. (2018). Real estate finance and investments (16th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.
Geltner, D. M., Miller, N. G., Clayton, J., & Eichholtz, P. (2014). Commercial real estate analysis and investments (3rd ed.). OnCourse Learning.
Ling, D. C., & Archer, W. R. (2021). Real estate principles: A value approach (6th ed.). McGraw Hill.
The FIN-432 Topic 7 assignment instructions
Topic 7 in FIN-432 asks students to evaluate an acquisition and recommend a price. The brief rewards rebuilding the seller's income to underwriting standards, testing the proposed loan against the lender's coverage requirement and projecting the investor's return on equity over a holding period. Strong work explains why borrowing lowers the return when the loan constant exceeds the property's yield, solves for the price at which the investment meets the target return with all other assumptions fixed, and states the evidence behind each judgment the seller might dispute. The memo should lead with its recommendation and be usable by an investment committee.
How the FIN-432 Topic 7 example is put together
The memo starts by correcting the seller's figures. The listing shows 238,000 of net operating income, a 7.0 percent capitalization rate at the asking price, but assumes every bay leased and sets nothing aside for roofs and paving. Restoring 7 percent vacancy and 12,000 of reserves brings income to 205,000, a 6.03 percent yield at 3,400,000. Financed at 65 percent with an illustrative 6.25 percent, twenty-five-year loan, the asking price leaves debt coverage near 1.17, below the lender's 1.25, and a cash yield of about 2.5 percent. With income growing 2.5 percent a year and a sale after five years at a 6.75 percent capitalization rate, the buyer's return on equity is about 5.6 percent against a 12 percent target. The memo declines at the asking price and bids about 3,050,000, where the same assumptions return about 12.3 percent.
Reading the FIN 432 Topic 7 rubric
An Excellent memo earns its marks by turning underwriting into a price. The rubric rewards a table that rebuilds the seller's income with vacancy and reserves, and a loan test showing coverage and cash yield at the asking price. Credit goes to explaining the unfavorable effect of debt through the loan constant. Faculty look for a five-year equity return compared with the target, and for a bid solved from the same assumptions rather than guessed. Strong memos show what the seller's figures would require the buyer to believe. Top marks go to naming the disputed assumptions, the evidence for each and the conditions for raising the bid.
FIN 432 Topic 7 help before you submit
Accepting the seller's net operating income without rebuilding it draws the heaviest deduction, because a full-occupancy, no-reserve statement overstates this building's income by 33,000 and every figure downstream inherits the error. Papers that judge the price on a capitalization rate alone, with no loan attached, miss that the asking price fails the lender's coverage test and leaves a cash yield near 2.5 percent. Net operating income computed after debt service counts as an outright error, because it mixes the buyer's financing into the property's income. A return reported with no target beside it gives the decision nothing to meet. Declining without naming a price that would work ends the analysis early. Recommendations that omit the downside case present a bid as safe without showing what a flat market would do to it.
Get a FIN-432 Topic 7 example written to your instructions
Send the FIN-432 Topic 7 instructions and the rubric attached in your classroom, with the case your section assigns. We write a custom example to them, with the seller's income rebuilt, the price tested with financing attached, the equity return set against a target, a supportable bid located and a downside case run, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More FIN 432 papers and BS in Finance and Economics samples
- FIN 432 Topic 1: Property Asset Distinction Paper
- FIN 432 Topic 2: Three-approach Value Reconciliation
- FIN 432 Topic 3: Loan Structure Financing Test
- FIN 432 Topic 4: Holding Period Cash Flow Projection
- FIN 432 Topic 5: Market Turn Dq Post
- FIN 432 Topic 6: Ground Lease Interest Valuation
- FIN 432 Topic 8: Lease Versus Own Analysis
- FIN 431 Topic 7: Risk Treatment Program Design
- FIN 375 Topic 7: Horizon-matched Fund Selection
- FIN 355 Topic 7: Decumulation Stress Projection
- FIN 210 Topic 7: Retirement Savings Projection
FIN 432 Topic 7 questions, answered
Why rebuild the seller's net operating income?
Because a listing's income figure is prepared to sell the property. It often assumes full occupancy, omits reserves for roofs, paving and systems, or understates management costs. A buyer who capitalizes that figure pays for income the building is unlikely to produce. In the example, restoring vacancy and reserves lowers income by 33,000, which at a 7 percent capitalization rate is worth about 471,000 of price.
How does the memo find the bid price?
By holding every assumption fixed, income growth, loan terms, exit rate and selling costs, and solving for the purchase price at which the equity return reaches the buyer's 12 percent target. In the example that price is a little above 3,060,000, and the memo rounds down to about 3,050,000 to leave a small margin. The bid is only as reliable as those assumptions, which is why the downside case sits beside it.
Is the memo a recommendation about a real property?
No. The building, its income, the loan terms and the buyer's target are all composites built to show how FIN-432 wants an acquisition decided. Real acquisitions turn on verified leases, inspections, environmental reports, market evidence and current lending terms, and decisions about them belong with the buyer's qualified advisers. The memo is coursework and carries no investment advice.
Where can I find a free FIN 432 Topic 7 sample paper?
The strip center acquisition memo is printed here in full: the recommendation, the income correction, the loan test, the five-year return, the price that meets the target, what the seller's figures imply and the next steps. Send the listing in your case and a free memo can be underwritten.
How is the bid of 3,050,000 found in FIN 432 Topic 7?
By holding income, growth, loan terms, exit rate and selling costs fixed and solving for the price at which the equity return reaches the 12 percent target. At 3,050,000 it is about 12.3 percent and coverage about 1.31.