FIN 432 Topic 8 lease versus own analysis example

Real Estate Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This FIN 432 Topic 8 sample paper compares leasing and owning 20,000 square feet of industrial space for a composite device maker over ten years. It answers the final prompt of GCU FIN 432, Real Estate, catalog code FIN-432, in the university's BS in Finance and Economics. The lease starts at 480,000 dollars and rises 2.5 percent a year; owning means 6,000,000 up front, 60,000 a year of repairs and a sale after ten years less 5 percent costs. At a 9 percent cost of capital, leasing costs about 3,697,000 in present value. Owning costs about 3,450,000 at 2 percent value growth, and the break-even is about 1.1 percent a year.

CourseFIN 432 Real Estate
TopicTopic 8
Paper typeLease versus own analysis
LengthAbout 950 words, 3 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramBS in Finance and Economics
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for FIN 432 Topic 8

1

Lease or Own the Building? A Present-Value Comparison That Turns on About 1.1 Percent a Year of Property Growth

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

FIN-432: Real Estate

Topic 8 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the decision and the single assumption the answer depends on. The firm, the building and every figure are an illustrative composite; the sources are real.
2

Lease or Own the Building? A Present-Value Comparison That Turns on About 1.1 Percent a Year of Property Growth

The Decision

Brightline Medical Devices, a composite maker of diagnostic equipment, needs about 20,000 square feet of light industrial space for the next ten years. It can lease a building or buy a comparable one. This paper prices both paths in present value and identifies the assumption on which the answer turns. All figures are illustrative, and taxes are set aside to keep the comparison on the property economics; they are discussed briefly at the end.

The Two Paths

Leasing costs 24 dollars a square foot in the first year, 480,000 dollars, rising 2.5 percent a year and paid at the start of each year. The landlord bears structural repairs. Owning means paying 6,000,000 dollars for the building now, carrying about 60,000 dollars a year of structural and roof repairs that a tenant would not bear, and selling the building after ten years, paying 5 percent in selling costs. Operating costs such as utilities, cleaning and property taxes are assumed to be similar under both paths, since the lease is net of those items, and are left out of the comparison.

The Discount Rate

Both paths are discounted at Brightline's 9 percent cost of capital. Buying the building would commit 6,000,000 dollars that could otherwise fund inventory, equipment or product development, so the building must earn at least what the firm's other uses of capital earn. Brealey et al. (2020) note that lease-versus-buy analysis is a financing as well as an investment decision, and that the appropriate discount rate depends on the risk of the cash flows being compared. Using the firm's overall cost of capital is a reasonable simplification here, since the largest uncertain flow is the building's resale value.

Present Value of Leasing

The ten lease payments, growing 2.5 percent a year and paid at the start of each year, have a present value at 9 percent of about 3,697,000 dollars. This figure does not depend on what happens to property values, since the lease cost is fixed by contract.

Present Value of Owning

Table 1

Present Cost of Owning at Three Growth Rates Against Leasing at About $3,697,000, Illustrative

Annual growth in building valueValue after 10 yearsNet sale proceeds (after 5%)Present value of owningOwning minus leasing
0%$6,000,000$5,700,000About $3,977,000About +$280,000 (lease cheaper)
1%About $6,628,000About $6,296,000About $3,725,000About +$29,000 (lease cheaper)
2%About $7,314,000About $6,948,000About $3,450,000About -$247,000 (own cheaper)

The cost of owning is the purchase price plus the present value of the repairs, minus the present value of the net sale proceeds after ten years. The sale proceeds depend on how much the building's value grows, which is the uncertain part.

The repairs add about 385,000 dollars in present value, since 60,000 dollars a year for ten years at 9 percent is worth about 6.42 times the annual amount. The sale is far in the future, so its value is heavily discounted: at 2 percent growth, net proceeds of about 6,948,000 dollars received in year ten are worth about 2,935,000 today, less than half the purchase price. That discounting is what makes owning more expensive than it first appears. A buyer who thinks of the building as an asset that holds its value is right in nominal terms but overlooks that the 6,000,000 dollars paid now could have earned 9 percent a year in the business for ten years.

What this page is doingOwning's cost moves with the growth assumption while leasing's does not, which is why the decision turns on that one number.
3

The Break-Even

At 2 percent annual growth, owning costs about 3,450,000 dollars in present value against about 3,697,000 for leasing, so owning is cheaper by about 247,000. At 1 percent growth, leasing is cheaper by about 29,000, and with no growth by about 280,000. Solving for the growth rate at which the two paths cost the same gives about 1.1 percent a year. Above that rate, owning wins; below it, leasing does.

The decision therefore turns on a forecast of local industrial property values over ten years. Geltner et al. (2014) observe that property values tend to rise roughly with inflation over long periods but with wide variation by market and period, and that buildings also depreciate as they age. A 1.1 percent nominal break-even is below typical long-run inflation, which tilts the comparison toward owning, but it is close enough that a weak local market or a period of rising capitalization rates could easily leave the building worth less in real terms after ten years.

What the Numbers Leave Out

Several considerations fall outside the present-value comparison. Taxes matter: lease payments are generally deductible, while an owner deducts depreciation and interest, and the sale may produce a taxable gain; a full analysis would compare after-tax flows. Flexibility matters too: Ling and Archer (2021) note that leasing preserves the ability to move or resize, while owning ties the firm to one location and one size. If Brightline's growth might require 30,000 square feet within five years, leasing's flexibility has value the table does not capture. And owning concentrates 6,000,000 dollars in a single real estate asset outside the firm's core business, a bet on one local property market that its shareholders did not ask it to make.

Recommendation

On the property economics alone, owning is modestly favored if the firm expects local industrial values to rise faster than about 1.1 percent a year. Given the uncertainty in that forecast, the firm's possible need for more space and the 6,000,000 dollars of capital that owning would draw from its main business, Brightline should lease, and revisit the question if its space needs stabilize and capital becomes less scarce. A lease with a renewal option at a stated rent, and perhaps a purchase option, would keep both paths open, letting the firm buy later if local values rise faster than the break-even and its space needs prove stable.

References

Brealey, R. A., Myers, S. C., & Allen, F. (2020). Principles of corporate finance (13th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.

Geltner, D. M., Miller, N. G., Clayton, J., & Eichholtz, P. (2014). Commercial real estate analysis and investments (3rd ed.). OnCourse Learning.

Ling, D. C., & Archer, W. R. (2021). Real estate principles: A value approach (6th ed.). McGraw Hill.

The FIN-432 Topic 8 assignment instructions

FIN-432 closes with Topic 8, where students decide whether a business should lease or own its space. The brief asks for both paths to be priced in present value at an appropriate discount rate, with lease payments timed correctly and the owner's costs and eventual sale proceeds included. Strong work shows how the owning cost changes with the assumed growth in property value, solves for the break-even growth rate, and judges whether that rate is likely given long-run evidence. Students should also discuss what the comparison leaves out, including taxes, flexibility and the concentration of capital, and finish with a recommendation tied to the firm's circumstances.

How this FIN 432 Topic 8 example is built

The finished analysis prices two paths with illustrative figures. The lease starts at 24 a square foot, 480,000 a year, rising 2.5 percent annually and paid at the start of each year. Owning means paying 6,000,000 for the building, carrying 60,000 a year of structural repairs a tenant would not bear, and selling after ten years with 5 percent selling costs. Both paths are discounted at the firm's 9 percent cost of capital, since money tied up in a building is money not invested in the business. If the building gains 2 percent a year in value, owning costs about 3,450,000 in present value against about 3,697,000 for leasing. At 1 percent growth leasing wins by about 29,000, and with no growth by about 280,000. The break-even is near 1.1 percent a year.

Reading the FIN 432 Topic 8 rubric

Graders award an Excellent analysis for pricing both paths on the same basis and finding the assumption that decides them. The rubric rewards lease payments discounted from the start of each year, owner costs and net sale proceeds discounted at the firm's cost of capital, and a table of owning costs at several growth rates. Credit goes to the break-even growth rate and a reasoned judgment about it. Faculty look for taxes, flexibility and capital concentration discussed as considerations outside the table. Top marks go to a recommendation that weighs the modest numerical advantage of owning against the firm's need for flexibility and capital.

FIN 432 Topic 8 help before you submit

Comparing total lease payments with the purchase price, both undiscounted, is the error most often marked down, since it ignores timing and the building's value at sale. Discounting at the mortgage rate rather than the firm's cost of capital treats money locked in the building as though it had no better use in the business. Papers that leave out the owner's structural repairs compare a tenant's full cost with an incomplete owner's cost. An exit value asserted with no sensitivity hides the input that decides the result, since the answer reverses between 2 and 1 percent growth. Analyses that assume the firm stays ten years without testing an earlier move ignore the flexibility a lease provides. Stating depreciation or deduction rules as fixed figures, rather than as current law described generally, dates the analysis.

Get a FIN-432 Topic 8 example written to your instructions

Send the FIN-432 Topic 8 instructions and your classroom rubric, with the lease terms or case your section provides. We write a custom example to them, with both paths discounted at a defended rate, owner-only costs included, the exit value tested across growth rates, an early move modeled and tax treatment described generally, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More FIN 432 papers and BS in Finance and Economics samples

FIN 432 Topic 8 questions, answered

Why discount at the firm's cost of capital?

Because buying the building commits 6,000,000 that could otherwise fund inventory, equipment or expansion, and the firm's cost of capital measures what that money is expected to earn in the business. Discounting at a mortgage rate would treat the purchase as costless beyond its interest. The lease, meanwhile, is itself a fixed obligation much like debt, and the analysis notes that the two paths carry different risks as well as costs.

How do taxes change a lease versus own decision?

Lease payments on business property are generally deductible as an expense, while an owner generally deducts depreciation, interest and operating costs and may owe tax on gain at sale. The value of each depends on the firm's tax position and rules that change over time, so the example describes them in general terms and compares the paths before tax, leaving specific treatment to the assignment or a tax professional.

Does the analysis say my company should lease its building?

No. Every figure here, from the rent to the growth rates, was invented, and the result was built to show how one input can decide the answer. Any real choice rests on actual terms, local property values, the firm's growth plans and tax position, and deserves review by qualified real estate, legal and tax advisers. The example is FIN-432 coursework demonstrating the discounted comparison the topic asks for.

Where can I find a free FIN 432 Topic 8 sample paper?

The lease versus own analysis appears here in full: the decision, both paths, the discount rate, the present values, the growth table, the break-even, what the numbers leave out and the recommendation. Share the rent and price in your case and a free comparison can be run on them.

What decides lease versus own in FIN 432 Topic 8?

The growth in the building's value. Owning is cheaper in present value if values rise faster than about 1.1 percent a year and leasing is cheaper below that, so the choice rests on a ten-year forecast of local industrial property values.