| Course | FIN 440 Estate Planning and Special Topics |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 3 |
| Paper type | Transfer route comparison |
| Length | About 980 words, 4 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Finance and Economics |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for FIN 440 Topic 3
Give the Stock Now or Let It Pass Later? Comparing a Lifetime Gift, Probate and a Revocable Trust on Basis, Cost and a Second-State Property
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
FIN-440: Estate Planning and Special Topics
Topic 3 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Give the Stock Now or Let It Pass Later? Comparing a Lifetime Gift, Probate and a Revocable Trust on Basis, Cost and a Second-State Property
The Widow and Her Daughter's Suggestion
Margaret Olsen, a composite 79-year-old widow, owns about 1,600,000 dollars: a 550,000-dollar house, 350,000 dollars in cash and certificates of deposit, a 250,000-dollar rental condominium in another state and shares of a utility company she bought decades ago for 50,000 dollars, now worth 450,000. Her daughter, her only child, has suggested that Margaret give her the stock now, to save probate costs and simplify things later. This paper compares three routes for the stock and the estate as a whole, a lifetime gift, passing through probate under her will, and a revocable trust, using the case's illustrative figures.
The Gift and Its Hidden Tax Cost
A gift during life carries the donor's tax basis with it. Under the federal rule for gifts, the daughter's basis in the shares would generally be Margaret's original 50,000 dollars (Basis of property acquired by gifts and transfers in trust, 2018). If the daughter later sold the shares for 450,000 dollars, she would realize a gain of 400,000 dollars. At the case's illustrative 15 percent capital gains rate, the tax would be about 60,000 dollars.
Property that passes at death is treated differently. Its basis is generally reset to its value at the date of death (Basis of property acquired from a decedent, 2018). If the daughter inherited the shares when they were worth 450,000 dollars and sold them soon after, she would have little or no gain and little or no tax. The gift would therefore cost the family about 60,000 dollars in tax that inheritance would largely avoid. The gift would also generally require Margaret to file a gift tax return, since it exceeds the annual exclusion, although on the case's facts no gift tax would be due because her lifetime exemption would absorb it.
What Probate Would Cost
The daughter's concern about probate is reasonable but should be measured. Using the case's illustrative estimate of 3 percent of the estate for court costs, attorney and executor fees, probate on the whole 1,600,000-dollar estate would cost about 48,000 dollars. The stock's share of that, at 3 percent of 450,000 dollars, is about 13,500 dollars. Giving away the stock to save 13,500 dollars of probate costs would trigger about 60,000 dollars of potential tax: a poor trade.
Probate has another cost in Margaret's case. Real estate is governed by the law of the state where it sits, so the condominium in the second state would require a separate ancillary probate proceeding there, with its own court, its own attorney and its own delay (Sitkoff & Dukeminier, 2022). That second proceeding is often more burdensome than its share of value suggests.
The Revocable Trust
Table 1
Three Routes for Margaret's Estate, Illustrative
| Route | Tax on later sale of stock | Probate cost | Second-state proceeding | Cost to set up |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lifetime gift of stock | About $60,000 (carryover basis) | About $34,500 on remaining estate | Still needed for condo | Gift tax return |
| Probate under will | Little or none (reset basis) | About $48,000 | Needed for condo | None |
| Revocable trust | Little or none (reset basis) | Little or none for trust assets | Avoided if condo is retitled | About $5,000 |
A revocable trust offers a third route. Margaret would transfer her assets, including the stock and the condominium, into a trust during her life, keeping full control as trustee and the right to change or revoke it. At her death, a successor trustee, her daughter, would distribute the assets without probate. Because the trust is revocable, the assets are still treated as Margaret's for tax purposes, so they receive the reset basis at her death, preserving the tax advantage of inheritance. The case estimates the cost of drafting the trust and retitling the assets at about 5,000 dollars.
Weighing the Routes
The revocable trust combines the advantages of the other two routes: it avoids probate, including the second-state proceeding, as the gift would for the stock alone, while preserving the reset basis that inheritance provides. Its cost, about 5,000 dollars, is far below either the probate costs or the tax the gift would create. The trust also helps if Margaret becomes incapacitated, since a successor trustee could manage the assets without a court-appointed conservator. Its disadvantages are modest: assets must actually be retitled into the trust to be covered, and a trust does not avoid every cost of settling an estate.
The gift has one advantage the other routes lack: it removes the stock from Margaret's control now, which matters only if she wants her daughter to have it immediately or if the estate were large enough to face estate tax, neither of which applies on the case's facts.
One practical step decides whether the trust works: funding it. A trust that is signed but never receives the assets accomplishes nothing, and the assets left outside it pass through probate as before. The stock and cash accounts can be retitled by the custodians with a short form. The condominium requires a new deed recorded in the second state, which is the step most often skipped and the one that avoids the ancillary proceeding. The house can be deeded to the trust as well. Margaret should keep a checklist of each asset and confirm each change in writing.
Recommendation
Margaret should not give the stock away now. She should instead create a revocable trust, retitle the stock, the condominium and her investment accounts into it, name her daughter as successor trustee and beneficiary, and keep her will as a backstop for any assets left outside the trust. This preserves the basis reset on the stock, avoids probate in both states and costs about 5,000 dollars. As a class exercise, the analysis offers Margaret no tax or legal opinion; her own attorney and tax preparer should confirm each step.
References
Basis of property acquired by gifts and transfers in trust, 26 U.S.C. § 1015 (2018).
Basis of property acquired from a decedent, 26 U.S.C. § 1014 (2018).
Sitkoff, R. H., & Dukeminier, J. (2022). Wills, trusts, and estates (11th ed.). Aspen Publishing.
The FIN-440 Topic 3 assignment instructions
Topic 3 of FIN-440 asks students to compare ways of passing property, weighing tax, cost and administration. Students should explain the carryover basis rule for gifts and the basis reset at death with the governing statutes, estimate probate costs and identify when real estate in another state requires a separate proceeding. Strong work sets the routes side by side in one table, shows why a gift can cost more in tax than it saves in probate, explains how a revocable trust preserves the basis reset while avoiding probate, and addresses funding the trust, the step most often skipped. The recommendation should fit the client's age, assets and goals.
Inside the FIN 440 Topic 3 example
Illustrative figures carry the whole comparison. A composite widow, 79, holds 1,600,000: a 550,000 house, 350,000 in cash and certificates, a 250,000 rental condo in a second state and stock bought for 50,000 that is now worth 450,000. Her daughter suggests taking the stock as a gift now. As a gift it keeps the mother's 50,000 basis, so a later sale realizes 400,000 of gain, about 60,000 of tax at the case's 15 percent rate. Inherited, its basis would generally adjust to value at death and that tax largely disappears. Probate on the whole estate at the case's 3 percent costs about 48,000, only 13,500 of it on the stock, and the condo needs a second proceeding in its own state. Drafting and funding a revocable trust costs about 5,000.
FIN 440 Topic 3 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Faculty marking the comparison reward tax and cost figures computed from the case. An Excellent paper shows the 400,000 gain a gift would carry and the roughly 60,000 tax, compared with the 13,500 of probate cost on the stock. Credit goes to identifying the ancillary probate for the second-state condominium. The rubric values a table comparing the three routes and explaining that a revocable trust keeps the basis reset because its assets remain the owner's for tax purposes. Strong papers stress retitling assets into the trust. Top marks go to a recommendation that reverses the daughter's intuition with numbers.
FIN 440 Topic 3 help before you submit
A comparison that stops at probate fees earns the fewest marks, since the cost that decides this case is income tax on a gift, which no fee table shows. Papers treating a lifetime gift as an inheritance delivered early miss the basis rule entirely. Stating the federal estate and gift tax exemption or the annual exclusion as a fixed dollar figure dates the paper, because both are set by statute and adjusted. Claiming that a revocable trust saves estate tax confuses avoiding probate with shrinking a taxable estate. A trust recommended with no account of retitling leaves the condo exposed to the very proceeding the trust was meant to avoid. Omitting what would change the answer, such as a later need to qualify for long-term care benefits, leaves the timing question unexamined.
Get a FIN-440 Topic 3 example written to your instructions
Send the FIN-440 Topic 3 instructions and the rubric your classroom provides, with the estate facts or case your section assigns. We write a custom example to them, with each transfer path priced, basis on gifts and at death distinguished, probate and retitling costs counted and no exemption stated as a fixed figure, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More FIN 440 papers and BS in Finance and Economics samples
- FIN 440 Topic 1: Estate Plan Objectives Memo
- FIN 440 Topic 2: Instrument and Purpose Matrix
- FIN 440 Topic 4: Blended Family Trust Design
- FIN 440 Topic 5: Stale Estate Plan Dq Post
- FIN 440 Topic 6: Family Business Transfer Plan
- FIN 440 Topic 7: Death Sequence Stress Test
- FIN 440 Topic 8: Family Plan Explanation Letter
- FIN 432 Topic 3: Loan Structure Financing Test
- FIN 431 Topic 3: Total Cost of Risk Comparison
- FIN 375 Topic 3: Diversification Limit Demonstration
- FIN 210 Topic 3: Debt Repayment Order Comparison
FIN 440 Topic 3 questions, answered
What is a step-up in basis?
When property passes at death, its tax basis is generally reset to what the property was worth when the owner died, so gain that built up during the owner's life is not taxed to the heir who later sells. A lifetime gift works differently: the recipient usually takes the donor's original basis. The rule has exceptions and proposals to change it recur, so the example describes it without treating it as permanent.
Does a gift over the annual exclusion mean gift tax is owed?
Not usually. A gift above the annual exclusion generally requires a gift tax return, and the excess is counted against the donor's lifetime exemption, which is shared with the estate tax. Tax falls due only once cumulative taxable gifts and the estate exceed that exemption. Both the exclusion and the exemption are set by statute and adjusted periodically, which is why neither amount appears in the example.
Should my parent gift assets now or leave them in a trust?
No example can settle that for a real family. The widow, her assets, their basis and the fee and tax rates are illustrative, chosen so the timing effect shows clearly. Real decisions depend on the actual assets, state probate rules, health and care needs and current tax law, and they belong with an estate planning attorney and a tax professional. This is FIN-440 coursework, not legal or tax advice.
Where can I find a free FIN 440 Topic 3 sample paper?
The gift, probate and trust comparison is shown in full here: the widow's assets, the gift's tax cost, probate costs, the second-state proceeding, the revocable trust, the comparison table, funding and the recommendation. Share your case figures and a free comparison can be prepared.
Why not give the stock now in FIN 440 Topic 3?
Because a gift carries the 50,000 basis, so a later sale realizes about 400,000 of gain and roughly 60,000 of tax, while saving only about 13,500 of probate cost. Inherited stock generally gets a basis reset, and a revocable trust avoids probate anyway.