| Course | FIN 440 Estate Planning and Special Topics |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 5 |
| Paper type | Discussion post and reply |
| Length | About 480 words, 3 pages |
| Format | Discussion post, APA 7 citations |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Finance and Economics |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for FIN 440 Topic 5
Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post and Reply
Five Changes a Plan Never Saw: Reading a Couple's Documents Against the Family as It Stands Today
Initial Post
My composite couple, the Harrows, signed wills, a trust and powers of attorney eighteen years ago and have not looked at them since. A plan does not expire, but the family it was written for changes, and reading their documents against today's facts turns up five problems.
First, the brother named as executor has died, and the will names no alternate, so a court would have to appoint someone. Second, the guardian clause names an aunt to raise the children, who are now 24 and 27; the clause is harmless but shows how old the plan is, and the children themselves are now the natural choices as executors. Third, Mr. Harrow changed jobs six years ago, and his new 401(k) has no beneficiary on file, so it would pass under the plan's default rules, possibly to his estate and through probate. Fourth, the couple moved to a new state, and their old powers of attorney, valid where signed, may meet hesitation from banks in the new state that prefer their own state's form.
The fifth change matters most. Their wills fund a bypass trust at the first death with the largest amount that can pass free of federal estate tax, a common formula when the exemption was much lower. The federal exemption has since risen substantially (Internal Revenue Service, n.d.). Their combined estate is about 2,200,000 dollars, and under today's law the formula would now send all of the first spouse's share into the bypass trust. The surviving spouse would own none of it outright and would depend on the trustee's discretion for income and principal. Sitkoff and Dukeminier (2022) describe how formula clauses tied to the tax exemption can produce results no one intended when the exemption changes. The trust may also give up the basis reset at the survivor's death for assets that would otherwise have been inherited from the survivor.
So my view is that the Harrows' biggest risk is not a missing document but a working document doing the wrong thing. The fix is simple: review every plan whenever the family, the state or the law changes, and at least every five years. My question: should formula clauses be avoided altogether, or written to cap the bypass trust at a stated share?
Reply to Tamara
Tamara, you suggested the Harrows simply revoke the trust and leave everything outright to the survivor. That would fix the formula problem, and for many couples with estates well under the exemption it is reasonable. But the trust may still serve purposes the formula does not: protecting assets if the survivor remarries, or managing money if the survivor's health declines. Would you keep a trust but make funding it optional, letting the survivor decide after the first death how much to place in it?
References
Internal Revenue Service. (n.d.). Estate tax. Retrieved October 4, 2026, from https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/estate-tax
Sitkoff, R. H., & Dukeminier, J. (2022). Wills, trusts, and estates (11th ed.). Aspen Publishing.
What the FIN 440 Topic 5 instructions ask for
The Topic 5 discussion question in FIN-440 asks students to evaluate whether an existing estate plan still fits a family. Students post and reply to classmates. Good posts read the documents against current facts, list the changes that have overtaken the plan, explain the consequence of each and identify which matters most. Students should explain how a formula clause tied to the federal estate tax exemption can produce unintended results when the exemption changes, without stating a specific exemption figure, and recommend a review schedule. Replies should engage a classmate's proposed fix and ask a question that weighs its trade-offs.
How this FIN 440 Topic 5 example is built
The post reads a composite couple's plan against the family as it stands now, and five changes have overtaken it. The brother named as executor has died and no alternate appears. The guardian clause protects children who are now 24 and 27. A job change left a new 401(k) with no beneficiary on file. The couple moved states, and an older power of attorney may meet hesitation from institutions in the new one. The fifth change gets the most space: a formula clause funding a bypass trust with the largest amount that can pass free of federal estate tax, drafted when the exemption was far lower, would now capture the whole 2,200,000 estate. The surviving spouse would own nothing outright and would rely on whatever the trustee distributes. The post names no exemption amount anywhere.
FIN 440 Topic 5 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Instructors grading the post reward a reading of documents against facts. An Excellent post names each change, from the deceased executor to the missing 401(k) beneficiary, and states what it would cause. Credit goes to explaining the bypass trust formula clearly and why a higher exemption now sends the whole estate into the trust. The rubric values citing a source for the exemption's change without quoting a figure that may become outdated. Replies earn marks by crediting a classmate's simpler fix and asking whether a flexible design would keep the trust's other benefits. Most sections also expect proper citations and a courteous tone.
Common FIN 440 Topic 5 mistakes, and how to avoid them
A general list of life events, with no clause shown failing, gets the least credit, because the prompt asks what happens rather than what might change. Missing the formula clause is what separates adequate posts from strong ones, since it is the change nobody in the family would notice. Stating the current federal exemption as a figure invites correction and dates the post. Papers that claim an old will becomes invalid with time overstate the law, which generally keeps a properly signed will in force until it is revoked. Leaving beneficiary forms out of a review discussion misses where much of this estate would actually move. A reply that simply agrees a review is wise, and never tests the classmate's claim against a clause, contributes agreement and little else.
Get a FIN-440 Topic 5 example written to your instructions
Send the FIN-440 Topic 5 discussion question and your classroom rubric, with any readings or case your section assigns. We write a custom example to that prompt, with each change traced to the clause it breaks, a formula clause explained without exemption figures, reviews tied to events and a reply that tests a classmate's claim, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More FIN 440 papers and BS in Finance and Economics samples
- FIN 440 Topic 1: Estate Plan Objectives Memo
- FIN 440 Topic 2: Instrument and Purpose Matrix
- FIN 440 Topic 3: Probate and Transfer Cost Comparison
- FIN 440 Topic 4: Blended Family Trust Design
- FIN 440 Topic 6: Family Business Transfer Plan
- FIN 440 Topic 7: Death Sequence Stress Test
- FIN 440 Topic 8: Family Plan Explanation Letter
- FIN 432 Topic 5: Market Turn Dq Post
- FIN 431 Topic 5: Uninsurable Risk Dq Post
- FIN 375 Topic 5: Market Efficiency Dq Post
- FIN 210 Topic 5: Debt or Invest Dq Post
FIN 440 Topic 5 questions, answered
Does an estate plan expire?
Generally no. A properly signed will usually stays in force until it is revoked or replaced, and many trusts run for decades. The problem the post identifies is fit rather than validity: named people die or become unsuitable, assets change form, families grow and divide, and tax law moves. Some events, such as divorce, may alter a will's effect under state law, but most leave the document operating exactly as written.
What is a bypass trust formula clause?
Language in many older wills and trusts that funds a trust at the first death with the largest amount that can pass free of federal estate tax, keeping it out of the survivor's taxable estate. The amount it captures moves with the exemption, so when the exemption rises far above the estate's value, the formula can place everything in that trust. Portability, added to federal law later, changed how many couples plan for this.
Can the post tell me whether my family's plan is out of date?
Not for a real family. The couple, their changes and the estate figure are invented, and each kind of staleness appears once by design. Whether an actual plan still works depends on its wording, state law, current tax rules and the family's circumstances, which an estate planning attorney should review. It is a FIN-440 discussion answer written at a general level, not legal, tax or financial advice.
Where can I find a free FIN 440 Topic 5 sample paper?
The plan review post and the reply to Tamara are both here, with the five changes, the formula clause explained and the review schedule. Course prompts on this topic differ, so share yours and we will write a complimentary post and peer reply around it.
What is wrong with the formula clause in FIN 440 Topic 5?
It funds a bypass trust with the largest amount that can pass free of federal estate tax. Written when the exemption was far lower, it would now send the whole first share of a 2,200,000 estate into the trust, leaving the survivor nothing outright.