| Course | FIN 440 Estate Planning and Special Topics |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 6 |
| Paper type | Business succession plan |
| Length | About 970 words, 4 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Finance and Economics |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for FIN 440 Topic 6
Equal Value, Unequal Ownership: A Succession Plan That Leaves the Company to the Child Who Runs It and Equalizes the Others
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
FIN-440: Estate Planning and Special Topics
Topic 6 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Equal Value, Unequal Ownership: A Succession Plan That Leaves the Company to the Child Who Runs It and Equalizes the Others
The Family and the Business
Walter Brennan, a composite 66-year-old widower, owns all of Brennan Mechanical, a commercial plumbing and heating contractor appraised for this case at 3,000,000 dollars. He has three adult children. His son Michael has worked in the company for fifteen years and runs its operations; his daughters, a teacher and a nurse, have no role in it. Walter's other assets, his home, savings and retirement accounts, total about 1,000,000 dollars. He wants to treat his children equally and wants the company to survive him. All figures are illustrative.
Why Equal Thirds Would Fail
The simplest plan, leaving everything in equal thirds, would give each child a third of the company. Michael would own a third of the business he runs, and his sisters together would own two thirds. Their interests would differ sharply. Michael would want to reinvest profits in equipment and staff; his sisters, with no salary from the company, would want dividends. Together they could outvote him on any decision, including selling the company. Family firms face this problem often, and research suggests succession choices matter for performance: Bennedsen et al. (2007) found that Danish family firms passing control to a family heir rather than an outside chief executive saw significantly lower profitability afterward, a reminder that how control passes, not just to whom, affects whether the business survives.
The Plan
Table 1
Equalizing Shares of a 5,000,000-Dollar Pool, Illustrative
| Child | Receives | Less | Net value |
|---|---|---|---|
| Michael | Company, $3,000,000 | Note owed to estate, $1,333,333 | About $1,666,667 |
| Each daughter | Half of other assets ($500,000), half of insurance ($500,000), half of note ($666,667) | | About $1,666,667 | |
| Total | | | $5,000,000 |
The plan separates equal value from equal ownership. Michael inherits the entire company. In return, he signs a promissory note to Walter's estate for 1,333,333 dollars, the amount by which the company's value exceeds his equal share. To fund the daughters' shares without depending entirely on Michael's payments, Walter buys a 1,000,000-dollar life insurance policy, owned by an irrevocable trust for the daughters' benefit so the proceeds are available promptly at his death.
The value is then shared equally. The total pool is 5,000,000 dollars: the 3,000,000-dollar company, the 1,000,000 of other assets and the 1,000,000 of insurance. Each child's equal share is about 1,666,667 dollars. Michael receives the company, worth 3,000,000, less his 1,333,333 note, a net of about 1,666,667. The daughters together receive the 1,000,000 of other assets, the 1,000,000 of insurance and the 1,333,333 note, a total of 3,333,333, or about 1,666,667 each.
Can the Company Carry the Note?
A plan that equalizes on paper can still fail if the note cannot be paid. At an illustrative 6 percent interest over ten years with level annual payments, the 1,333,333-dollar note requires about 181,000 dollars a year. Brennan Mechanical generates about 350,000 dollars a year of free cash flow, the cash left after operating costs and the capital spending needed to keep the business running. The note would take a little over half of it. That is feasible but tight: in a weak year, or if Michael needs to buy new vehicles, the payments could strain the company. Brealey et al. (2020) stress that the capacity to service debt depends on the stability of cash flow, and a contractor's cash flow can swing with construction activity.
Two features reduce the risk. The note can allow Michael to defer a payment in a year when free cash flow falls below a stated level, with interest accruing, so a bad year does not force a default. And because the insurance pays the daughters 1,000,000 dollars at once, they do not depend on the note for most of their inheritance.
Alternatives Considered
Three other approaches were weighed. Walter could sell the company now, to Michael or an outsider, and leave cash to all three children equally. That would solve the governance problem but might force Michael to borrow heavily or lose the business to a buyer, and a sale now would be taxable to Walter. Walter could instead recapitalize the company into voting and nonvoting shares, leaving the voting shares to Michael and nonvoting shares to his sisters. That keeps control with Michael, but the sisters would still own most of the value in a company that pays them little, the same conflict in a quieter form. Finally, Walter could leave equal shares but bind all three children to a buy-sell agreement requiring Michael to buy his sisters' shares at an appraised price. That reaches a result similar to the note, but it gives the sisters a period as co-owners before the sale closes. The chosen plan avoids co-ownership altogether, which is why it was preferred.
Valuation and Fairness
The plan's fairness rests on the 3,000,000-dollar appraisal. If the company is really worth more, Michael receives a bargain; if less, he overpays through the note. The plan therefore calls for an independent appraisal at Walter's death, with the note's amount adjusted to the appraised value, and a written explanation to the daughters of how the figure was reached. Sitkoff and Dukeminier (2022) note that unequal distributions of specific assets are a frequent source of family disputes, which clear terms and a neutral valuation help prevent.
Conclusion
Leaving the company to Michael and equalizing his sisters through insurance and a note gives each child about 1,666,667 dollars of value while keeping control with the child who runs the business. The note's payments take about half of the company's free cash flow, so the plan includes a deferral provision. Prepared for a class, the plan offers the Brennans no legal or tax opinion and would need review by the family's own attorney, accountant and an independent business appraiser before any document is signed or any policy bought.
References
Bennedsen, M., Nielsen, K. M., Pérez-González, F., & Wolfenzon, D. (2007). Inside the family firm: The role of families in succession decisions and performance. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 122(2), 647-691. https://doi.org/10.1162/qjec.122.2.647
Brealey, R. A., Myers, S. C., & Allen, F. (2020). Principles of corporate finance (13th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.
Sitkoff, R. H., & Dukeminier, J. (2022). Wills, trusts, and estates (11th ed.). Aspen Publishing.
Reading the GCU FIN 440 Topic 6 instructions
FIN-440 uses Topic 6 to address family business succession. Students should explain why dividing ownership equally among children can damage a business, then design a plan that equalizes value without equalizing control. Strong work shows the arithmetic of equalization, tests whether the business can carry any note the successor owes, adds safeguards such as payment deferral in weak years, addresses valuation and fairness, and compares alternatives such as a sale, voting and nonvoting shares or a buy-sell agreement. Research on family firm succession should be cited accurately, and the plan should state what each child receives.
Inside the FIN 440 Topic 6 example
Figures in the finished plan are illustrative throughout. The widower is 66, the company is appraised for the case at 3,000,000 and his other assets total 1,000,000. Dividing the shares in thirds would leave the active child outvoted by siblings who want dividends while the business needs reinvestment. The plan instead leaves the company to the active child, who signs a 1,333,333 note to the estate, and adds a 1,000,000 life insurance policy for the other two. With the note, the policy and the other assets, each child's share comes to about 1,666,667 of a 5,000,000 pool. The note's payments, about 181,000 a year at 6 percent over ten years, are then tested against the company's illustrative 350,000 of annual free cash flow, and they take a little over half of it.
Reading the FIN 440 Topic 6 rubric
Graders award an Excellent plan for separating value from control and proving the numbers. The rubric rewards showing why equal thirds would create a governance conflict, an equalization table in which each child reaches the same value by a different route, and a note payment tested against free cash flow. Credit goes to safeguards such as deferral and insurance that reduces dependence on the note. Faculty look for alternatives considered and reasons for rejecting them. Strong papers cite research on family succession accurately. Top marks go to an independent appraisal provision and a clear explanation to the siblings.
Common FIN 440 Topic 6 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Equal division of the shares, offered as fairness, is where this topic takes the most marks, because equal stock held by heirs with unequal roles tends to wreck what the company is worth. Papers that give the company to the active child and stop there leave two siblings with 500,000 each beside a 3,000,000 business. Equalization proposed without arithmetic cannot show whether the insurance and note amounts actually balance. A note tested against nothing assumes the company can pay for itself, which its cash flow may not support in a weak year. Treating the appraisal as a fact, rather than a figure resting on assumptions about management continuity, overstates certainty. Plans that leave the buy-sell terms to be settled after death invite the dispute they were meant to prevent.
Get a FIN-440 Topic 6 example written to your instructions
Send the FIN-440 Topic 6 instructions and the rubric shared in your classroom, with the business and family case your section provides. We write a custom example to them, with control and value treated separately, equalization solved in figures, note payments tested against cash flow and buy-sell terms named, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More FIN 440 papers and BS in Finance and Economics samples
- FIN 440 Topic 1: Estate Plan Objectives Memo
- FIN 440 Topic 2: Instrument and Purpose Matrix
- FIN 440 Topic 3: Probate and Transfer Cost Comparison
- FIN 440 Topic 4: Blended Family Trust Design
- FIN 440 Topic 5: Stale Estate Plan Dq Post
- FIN 440 Topic 7: Death Sequence Stress Test
- FIN 440 Topic 8: Family Plan Explanation Letter
- FIN 432 Topic 6: Ground Lease Interest Valuation
- FIN 431 Topic 6: Premium Loading Breakdown
- FIN 375 Topic 6: Bond Duration Exercise
- FIN 210 Topic 6: Household Insurance Review
FIN 440 Topic 6 questions, answered
Why not leave the business to all three children equally?
Because ownership brings votes, and two siblings outside the business can outvote the one running it. Their interests also differ: owners who do not work there often want distributions, while the business may need its cash reinvested. Equal shares can therefore produce deadlock, resentment or a forced sale. The plan aims for equal value rather than equal stock, which is a different and usually more workable idea of fairness.
What does a buy-sell agreement do?
It sets in advance who may or must buy an owner's interest when a stated event occurs, such as death, disability or departure, and how the price is determined and paid. Agreements are often funded with life insurance so the buyer has cash when the event arrives. Fixing the valuation method while everyone is alive removes the most common source of dispute among heirs and surviving owners.
Can this plan be used for my family's business?
No. The company, its appraisal, the cash flow and the family are composites, and real succession planning depends on the entity's governing documents, a qualified business valuation, state law, tax consequences and the family's actual relationships. It calls for an estate planning attorney, a tax adviser and often a valuation professional. The plan illustrates how FIN-440 wants a business interest handled and is not legal, tax or financial advice.
Where can I find a free FIN 440 Topic 6 sample paper?
This page holds the complete succession plan: the family, why equal thirds fail, the plan and equalization table, whether the company can carry the note, the alternatives, valuation and fairness, and the conclusion. If your case company is different, send its figures for a free plan.
How are the children equalized in FIN 440 Topic 6?
The son receives the 3,000,000 company but owes the estate a 1,333,333 note. The daughters share the 1,000,000 of other assets, 1,000,000 of insurance and the note, so each child ends with about 1,666,667.