| Course | FIN 450 Intermediate Finance |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 2 |
| Paper type | Cost of capital computation |
| Length | About 990 words, 4 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Finance and Economics |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for FIN 450 Topic 2
Market Weights or Book Weights? Computing a Weighted Average Cost of Capital and Showing How the Choice Decides an 8.5 Percent Project
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
FIN-450: Intermediate Finance
Topic 2 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Market Weights or Book Weights? Computing a Weighted Average Cost of Capital and Showing How the Choice Decides an 8.5 Percent Project
The Firm and the Question
Thornbury Controls, a composite maker of building automation systems, is evaluating a new product line expected to return 8.5 percent on its investment. The finance team must estimate the company's weighted average cost of capital, the return investors require on the firm as a whole, to decide whether the project clears the bar. Every input below is illustrative and dated to the case; none is a current market figure. Amounts are in millions of dollars.
Market Value Weights
The weights should reflect what investors would pay for the firm's securities today, not what the accounts record. Thornbury has 50 million shares trading at 24 dollars, a market value of equity of 1,200, against book equity of 700. Its debt consists of bonds with a face value of 500, paying a 5 percent coupon semiannually and maturing in five and a half years, which trade at 92 percent of face value. The market value of debt is therefore 460. Total market value is 1,660, so equity is about 72 percent and debt about 28 percent.
The Cost of Debt
The cost of debt is the return investors require on the firm's bonds today, which is their yield to maturity, not the coupon rate set when the bonds were issued. A bond paying 2.50 every six months for eleven periods and 100 at maturity, priced at 92, has a yield to maturity of about 6.8 percent a year. Interest reduces taxable income, so at Thornbury's 25 percent marginal rate each dollar of interest costs only 75 cents after tax, and the 6.8 percent yield becomes about 5.1 percent.
The Cost of Equity
The cost of equity cannot be observed directly. The capital asset pricing model builds it from three inputs: a risk-free return, the stock's beta and the extra return investors demand for holding the market. The case gives a ten-year Treasury yield of 4.2 percent as the risk-free rate, a beta of 1.15 from the case's data provider, measuring how Thornbury's shares move with the market, and a premium of 5.5 points for bearing market risk, within the range the course text supports. The cost of equity is 4.2 plus 1.15 times 5.5, about 10.5 percent. The model is an approximation; Fama and French (2004) review evidence that beta alone explains average returns imperfectly, so the estimate should be treated as a reasonable central figure rather than a precise one.
The WACC
Table 1
Weighted Average Cost of Capital at Market Weights, Illustrative
| Component | Market value | Weight | Cost | Weighted cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Equity | 1,200 | About 72% | About 10.5% | About 7.6% |
| Debt (after tax) | 460 | About 28% | About 5.1% | About 1.4% |
| Total | 1,660 | 100% | | About 9.0% |
The weighted average cost of capital combines the two costs in proportion to their market weights: 0.72 times 10.5 percent plus 0.28 times 5.1 percent, which gives about 9.0 percent.
What Book Weights Would Show
If the team had used book values instead, equity of 700 and debt of 500, the weights would be about 58 percent equity and 42 percent debt. Because debt is the cheaper source, giving it more weight lowers the average: the book-weighted WACC is about 8.3 percent. The difference matters for the decision. The new product line's expected return of 8.5 percent exceeds the book-weighted cost of 8.3 percent but falls short of the market-weighted 9.0 percent. Under book weights the project would be accepted; under market weights it would be rejected.
Market weights are the right choice. Investors who could buy Thornbury's shares and bonds today would pay market prices, and the return they require is measured on those prices. Book equity of 700 reflects historical accounting, not what shareholders could sell their stake for. Brealey et al. (2020) recommend market weights for exactly this reason, noting that book values describe past transactions rather than the opportunity cost of capital.
How Sensitive the Answer Is
The cost of equity carries most of the weight, so its inputs deserve a test. If Thornbury's beta were 1.0 rather than 1.15, the cost of equity would be about 9.7 percent and the WACC about 8.4 percent, low enough for the 8.5 percent project to pass. If the market risk premium were 6.0 percent instead of 5.5, equity would cost roughly 11.1 percent and the blended rate would climb to about 9.4 percent. At a premium of 5.0 percent, the WACC would be about 8.6 percent, still just above the project's return. The decision is therefore close, and it depends on judgments about beta and the premium that reasonable analysts could make differently. The finance team should report the WACC as a range, roughly 8.4 to 9.4 percent, and recognize that the project's 8.5 percent return falls near the bottom of it. A project whose return sits inside the range of reasonable hurdle rates needs a closer look at its own risk before it is approved or rejected. If the product line is closer in risk to Thornbury's mature controls business than to the company as a whole, a lower project rate could be justified; if it is a new market for the firm, a higher one would be.
Conclusion and Caveats
Thornbury's hurdle rate comes out near 9.0 percent, and the 8.5 percent product line should not be accepted on these figures unless it is less risky than the firm's average business, in which case a lower project-specific rate might apply. The estimate rests on inputs that change: the share price, the bond price, Treasury yields and the market risk premium all move, so the WACC should be recalculated whenever a major investment is evaluated. Graham and Harvey (2001) found that most large firms use the capital asset pricing model to estimate the cost of equity but that many apply a single company-wide rate to all projects, which can lead them to accept risky projects and reject safe ones.
References
Brealey, R. A., Myers, S. C., & Allen, F. (2020). Principles of corporate finance (13th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.
Fama, E. F., & French, K. R. (2004). The capital asset pricing model: Theory and evidence. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 18(3), 25-46. https://doi.org/10.1257/0895330042162430
Graham, J. R., & Harvey, C. R. (2001). The theory and practice of corporate finance: Evidence from the field. Journal of Financial Economics, 60(2-3), 187-243. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0304-405X(01)00044-7
FIN 450 Topic 2 instructions, in plain terms
The Topic 2 assignment in FIN-450 asks students to estimate a firm's weighted average cost of capital from market data. Students should compute market values of equity and debt, find the cost of debt as the bonds' yield to maturity rather than the coupon, apply the tax deduction, estimate the cost of equity with the capital asset pricing model using stated and dated inputs, and combine the costs at market weights. Strong work explains why market weights are preferred, shows how book weights would change the answer and a project decision, tests sensitivity to beta and the market premium, and acknowledges the model's limits with research.
How the FIN-450 Topic 2 example is put together
Every figure in the finished computation is illustrative and dated. Equity is 50 million shares at 24, a market value of 1,200 million, against book equity of 700. The firm's semiannual 5 percent bonds, 500 at face with five and a half years to run, trade at 92, so debt is worth 460 and yields about 6.8 percent. The cost of equity uses a 4.2 percent ten-year Treasury yield, a beta of 1.15 from the case's data provider and a 5.5 percent market premium supported by the course text, giving about 10.5 percent. After tax at the 25 percent marginal rate, debt costs 5.1 percent. Market weights of about 72 and 28 percent give a WACC near 9.0 percent. Book weights give about 8.3 percent, and a project returning 8.5 percent passes one test and fails the other.
Reading the FIN 450 Topic 2 rubric
Instructors grading the computation reward correct inputs and a defended choice of weights. An Excellent paper prices the bonds to find their yield, applies the tax rate to the cost of debt and builds the cost of equity from labeled inputs. Credit goes to market-value weights and a clear WACC table. The rubric values showing that book weights would accept a project that market weights reject. Strong papers test beta and the premium and report the WACC as a range, citing evidence on the CAPM's limits. Top marks go to noting when a project-specific rate should replace the company-wide figure.
Common FIN 450 Topic 2 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Book weights used without a word of justification are marked wrong outright on this topic, since owners and lenders require returns on what their claims are worth today, not on historical balances. Taking the coupon as the cost of debt is the second common error, and here it would understate debt's cost by 1.8 points before tax. Papers that quote a beta or a market premium with no source leave the reader unable to check the largest input. Applying an effective tax rate to interest misstates what the deduction is worth at the margin. Carrying the result to three decimals claims a precision no premium estimate supports. A WACC computed and never applied to a decision leaves the work as arithmetic, which is why the 8.5 percent project is in the example.
Get a FIN-450 Topic 2 example written to your instructions
Send the FIN-450 Topic 2 instructions and your classroom rubric, with the firm and market data your section supplies. We write a custom example to them, with every input sourced and dated, debt costed at yield rather than coupon, market and book weights compared and the result tested on a real decision, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More FIN 450 papers and BS in Finance and Economics samples
- FIN 450 Topic 1: Discounted Cash Flow Firm Valuation
- FIN 450 Topic 3: Debt Capacity Analysis
- FIN 450 Topic 4: Dividend Versus Repurchase Analysis
- FIN 450 Topic 5: Corporate Cash Holdings Dq Post
- FIN 450 Topic 6: Trade Credit and Terms Analysis
- FIN 450 Topic 7: Standalone and Synergy Valuation
- FIN 450 Topic 8: Board Financing Recommendation
- FIN 440 Topic 2: Instrument and Purpose Matrix
- FIN 432 Topic 2: Three-approach Value Reconciliation
- FIN 210 Topic 2: Personal Time Value Worksheet
- FIN 431 Topic 2: Frequency and Severity Profile
FIN 450 Topic 2 questions, answered
When are book weights acceptable?
When market values are unavailable or would barely differ, and the paper says so. Privately held firms have no share price, and debt that trades near par has a market value close to its book value. The example uses book weights only as a comparison, because this firm's shares trade well above book equity and its bonds sit below par. Stating the reason for the weighting choice is what separates a judgment from a shortcut.
Why use yield to maturity instead of the coupon rate?
Because the coupon reflects market conditions when the bond was issued, while yield to maturity reflects what lenders require now. A 5 percent coupon bond trading at 92 shows that investors want about 6.8 percent to hold the firm's debt today. A new issue would have to offer something close to that, so the yield, adjusted for tax, is the cost the firm actually faces.
Is this the cost of capital for a real company?
No. The share price, bond terms, Treasury yield, beta and premium are illustrative figures dated to a case, not current market data. A real computation needs prices observed on a stated date, a beta estimate whose method is known and a defended market premium, and it goes stale as markets move. The example shows how FIN-450 expects each component sourced and combined, as coursework rather than investment advice.
Where can I find a free FIN 450 Topic 2 sample paper?
The WACC computation is printed here in full: market weights, the cost of debt from the bond's yield, the cost of equity, the WACC table, the book-weight comparison, the sensitivity and the conclusion. Share the prices and rates from your case for a free computation.
Why does the choice of weights matter in FIN 450 Topic 2?
Book weights give debt more weight and produce a WACC of about 8.3 percent, so the 8.5 percent project passes. Market weights give about 9.0 percent, and the same project fails.