| Course | FIN 450 Intermediate Finance |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 8 |
| Paper type | Financing decision memo |
| Length | About 900 words, 3 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Finance and Economics |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for FIN 450 Topic 8
Memorandum
To: Board of Directors, Finance Committee
From: Chief Financial Officer
Date: [Date]
Re: Financing the new plant: debt, equity or a mix
Recommendation and Summary
We recommend financing the new plant with a mix of 150 million of debt and 6 million new shares. All-debt financing gives the highest earnings per share in a normal year but would push the company past the debt level consistent with its current credit rating in a downturn like the last one. The analysis follows. The numbers are illustrative, in millions of dollars, with per-share figures marked as such.
The Starting Point
Operating profit, earnings before interest and taxes, is 150 million today and is expected to rise to 190 million once the plant is running. The company has 200 million of existing debt at 6 percent, costing 12 million a year in interest, and 60 million shares trading at 25 dollars. The plant costs 300 million. The tax rate is 25 percent.
Three Financing Options and Earnings per Share
Table 1
Earnings per Share Under Three Financing Options at Operating Profit of 190, Illustrative
| Option | Total interest | Profit before tax | Net income (75%) | Shares | Earnings per share |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A: all debt | 33.0 | 157.0 | 117.75 | 60 | About $1.96 |
| B: all equity | 12.0 | 178.0 | 133.50 | 72 | About $1.85 |
| C: mix | 22.5 | 167.5 | About 125.63 | 66 | About $1.90 |
Option A borrows all 300 million at 7 percent, adding 21 million of interest. Option B issues 12 million new shares at 25 dollars. Option C borrows 150 million at 7 percent and issues 6 million shares. At operating profit of 190, the options produce the following earnings per share.
The Break-Even
Debt gives the highest earnings per share at 190 of operating profit, but that ranking depends on the level of profit. Setting the earnings per share of all-debt and all-equity financing equal and solving for operating profit gives a break-even of 138 million: below that level, the fixed interest of the all-debt option outweighs its smaller share count, and equity gives higher earnings per share. The mix shares the same break-even point with both, since it lies between them. At the expected 190, all three options are above the break-even, so debt looks best.
The Downturn Test
Table 2
Each Option in a Repeat of the Last Downturn, Illustrative
| Option | Total debt | Interest coverage in downturn (EBIT 120) | Debt to EBITDA in downturn (170) | Within 2.5 limit? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A: all debt | 500 | About 3.6 times | About 2.94 | No |
| B: all equity | 200 | 10.0 times | About 1.18 | Yes |
| C: mix | 350 | About 5.3 times | About 2.06 | Yes |
Earnings per share in a normal year is not the only consideration. In the company's last downturn, operating profit fell by about 37 percent. A repeat after the plant opens would cut operating profit to about 120 million and EBITDA, operating profit before depreciation and amortization, to about 170 million. The case treats total debt of 2.5 times EBITDA as the limit consistent with the company's current investment-grade rating.
Reading the Test
In a downturn, the all-debt option would still cover its interest 3.6 times, so default is not the immediate risk. But debt would reach about 2.94 times EBITDA, past the 2.5 limit, which would likely lead to a rating downgrade, higher borrowing costs on future debt and possibly covenant pressure. The mix stays at about 2.06 times, within the limit, while giving up only about 6 cents of earnings per share in a normal year compared with all debt. All-equity financing is the safest but gives the lowest earnings per share and issues the most new shares.
What the Extra Debt Is Worth in a Normal Year
It is fair to ask what the company gives up by choosing the mix. Compared with all debt, the mix lowers earnings per share by about 6 cents in a normal year, about 3 percent. At the company's current price-earnings ratio, that difference would matter only if investors valued the shares purely on next year's earnings and ignored the added risk. In practice, a firm carrying more debt is riskier, so investors would apply a lower multiple to its earnings; the higher earnings per share from all-debt financing would be partly or wholly offset by a lower price per dollar of earnings. The mix trades a small, visible reduction in earnings per share for a large reduction in the chance of a downgrade.
Why Directors Hesitate to Issue Shares
Directors often resist issuing equity, and the research explains why. Myers and Majluf (1984) showed that because managers know more about the firm's value than outside investors, investors tend to interpret a share issue as a sign that managers think the shares are overpriced, so announcing an issue can lower the price. Myers (1984) described the resulting pecking order: firms prefer internal funds, then debt, and issue equity last. The mix limits this cost by issuing only 6 million shares, half as many as the all-equity option. Graham and Harvey (2001) found that chief financial officers rank financial flexibility and credit ratings among the most important factors in debt decisions, which is the concern the downturn test addresses.
Conclusion
The mix of 150 million in debt and 6 million shares gives earnings per share of about 1.90 in a normal year, keeps debt within the rating limit in a repeat of the last downturn and limits the signaling cost of a share issue. We recommend it. If the board prefers more debt, it should first confirm with the rating agencies how they would treat a temporary rise above 2.5 times EBITDA.
References
Graham, J. R., & Harvey, C. R. (2001). The theory and practice of corporate finance: Evidence from the field. Journal of Financial Economics, 60(2-3), 187-243. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0304-405X(01)00044-7
Myers, S. C. (1984). The capital structure puzzle. Journal of Finance, 39(3), 574-592. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6261.1984.tb03646.x
Myers, S. C., & Majluf, N. S. (1984). Corporate financing and investment decisions when firms have information that investors do not have. Journal of Financial Economics, 13(2), 187-221. https://doi.org/10.1016/0304-405X(84)90023-0
What the FIN 450 Topic 8 instructions ask for
FIN-450 closes with Topic 8, where students recommend how to finance a major investment. The brief asks for the earnings per share under each option, the break-even level of operating profit between them, and a test of each option in a downturn against coverage and debt limits such as a rating threshold. Strong work explains why the option with the highest normal-year earnings per share may not be best, discusses why investors read share issues as a signal, cites research on financing choices and credit ratings, and ends with a recommendation that weighs earnings, risk and flexibility.
Inside the FIN 450 Topic 8 example
The finished memo works with illustrative figures in millions. Operating profit is 150 before the plant and 190 with it, existing debt is 200 at 6 percent, and 60 million shares trade at 25. Borrowing all 300 at 7 percent gives earnings per share of about 1.96; issuing 12 million shares gives about 1.85; a mix of 150 in debt and 6 million new shares gives about 1.90. All three break even at operating profit of 138. The memo then tests a repeat of the last downturn, which would cut operating profit to about 120 and EBITDA to 170. All-debt financing would leave interest covered 3.6 times and debt at 2.94 times EBITDA, past the 2.5 the case treats as the limit for the current rating. The mix stays near 2.06, and the memo recommends it.
Where the marks sit in the FIN 450 Topic 8 rubric
An Excellent memo earns its marks by testing each option in a bad year as well as a normal one. The rubric rewards an earnings per share table built from interest, tax and share count, and a correctly computed break-even. Credit goes to a downturn table showing coverage and debt to EBITDA against the rating limit. Faculty look for the signaling cost of equity explained with Myers and Majluf and the pecking order. Strong memos weigh the small earnings sacrifice of the mix against the risk of a downgrade. Top marks go to a recommendation with a clear next step for the board.
FIN 450 Topic 8 help before you submit
The commonest error here is choosing the option with the highest earnings per share at expected profit and stopping, which ignores the year when profit falls. Debt measured only at expected profit overstates what the firm can carry in exactly the year it matters. Papers sometimes compute the break-even incorrectly by leaving out existing interest, which shifts it noticeably. Treating interest coverage as the only constraint misses rating thresholds based on debt to EBITDA. Ignoring the signaling cost of issuing shares makes all-equity look free of drawbacks. A recommendation without a downturn test, or without saying what the board should confirm next, leaves the committee with a ranking instead of a decision.
Get a FIN-450 Topic 8 example written to your instructions
Send the FIN-450 Topic 8 instructions and your classroom rubric, with the firm and project case your section provides. We write a custom example to them, with the recommendation stated first, earnings per share and break-even computed, each option tested in a downturn, rating limits applied and directors' objections answered, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More FIN 450 papers and BS in Finance and Economics samples
- FIN 450 Topic 1: Discounted Cash Flow Firm Valuation
- FIN 450 Topic 2: Sourced Wacc Computation
- FIN 450 Topic 3: Debt Capacity Analysis
- FIN 450 Topic 4: Dividend Versus Repurchase Analysis
- FIN 450 Topic 5: Corporate Cash Holdings Dq Post
- FIN 450 Topic 6: Trade Credit and Terms Analysis
- FIN 450 Topic 7: Standalone and Synergy Valuation
- FIN 440 Topic 8: Family Plan Explanation Letter
- FIN 432 Topic 8: Lease Versus Own Analysis
- FIN 210 Topic 8: Personal Financial Plan
- FIN 431 Topic 8: Cyber Coverage Decision Memo
FIN 450 Topic 8 questions, answered
What is an EBIT-EPS break-even point?
The level of operating profit at which two financing options give the same earnings per share. Above it, the option with more debt gives higher earnings per share because fixed interest is spread over fewer shares; below it, the equity option does better. In the example all three options break even at 138. Knowing that level tells a board how far profit could fall before the debt-heavy choice stops paying off.
Why does issuing equity worry directors?
Partly because outside investors know managers issue shares more willingly when they think the price is high, so an announcement can push the price down. Issuing also spreads future earnings across more shares. The memo addresses both: it states management's own estimate of value relative to 25 and argues that the capacity preserved in a downturn is worth more than the small reduction in earnings per share.
Can the memo guide a real company's financing decision?
No. The firm, the plant, the downturn and the rating threshold are illustrative, chosen so the trade between earnings per share and flexibility is visible. A real financing decision depends on audited results, actual market terms, rating agency analysis and the board's risk tolerance, and it involves qualified financial advisers. The memo demonstrates the board-ready recommendation FIN-450 closes on, as coursework rather than investment advice.
Where can I find a free FIN 450 Topic 8 sample paper?
The financing memo is shown in full here, with the starting point, three options and earnings per share, the break-even, the downturn test, the value of the extra debt, the signaling discussion and the conclusion. For a different plant or balance sheet, tell us the figures and the options will be rerun in a complimentary memo.
Why choose the mix in FIN 450 Topic 8?
In a repeat of the last downturn, all-debt financing would reach about 2.94 times EBITDA, past the 2.5 rating limit, while the mix stays near 2.06 and gives up only about 6 cents of earnings per share in a normal year.