| Course | FIN 451 Investments and Portfolio Management |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 3 |
| Paper type | Active versus passive review |
| Length | About 950 words, 4 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Finance and Economics |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for FIN 451 Topic 3
A 1.46-Point Hurdle and a Style in Disguise: Reviewing Whether Two Active Funds Earn Their Costs
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
FIN-451: Investments and Portfolio Management
Topic 3 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
A 1.46-Point Hurdle and a Style in Disguise: Reviewing Whether Two Active Funds Earn Their Costs
The Question
An investor holds 400,000 dollars of her taxable account in two actively managed U.S. stock funds that have beaten the broad market index over the past ten years. She asks whether to keep them or move the money to an index fund. This review measures what the active funds must earn to justify their costs, how long it would take to tell skill from luck, and whether their past success came from skill or from a style. All figures are illustrative.
The Hurdle
Table 1
The Annual Hurdle Active Funds Must Clear, Illustrative
| Cost | Active funds | Index fund | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Expense ratio | 0.80% | 0.04% | 0.76 |
| Trading costs from turnover | About 0.25% | Near zero | 0.25 |
| Added tax drag from distributed gains (taxable account) | About 0.45% | Near zero | 0.45 |
| Total hurdle | | | About 1.46 points a year |
Before costs, active managers as a group must earn the market return, because together they hold the market; once fees and trading are paid, the typical actively managed dollar has to fall behind the index dollar (Sharpe, 1991). The question for any particular fund is how much it must beat the index to overcome its costs. Against an index fund costing 0.04 percent a year, the active funds' costs are higher in three ways.
What the Hurdle Means
The active funds must beat the index by about 1.46 percentage points a year just to tie. On 400,000 dollars, that is about 5,840 dollars a year that must be earned back through skill before the investor gains anything. The hurdle is larger than many investors realize because trading costs and tax drag do not appear in the expense ratio, which is the only cost most fund comparisons show, and because the investor pays all three costs every year whether or not the managers outperform; in a taxable account, funds that distribute capital gains frequently impose tax that an index fund mostly defers.
What the Hurdle Costs Over Time
A hurdle of 1.46 points a year compounds. If the market earned an illustrative 7 percent a year for twenty years and the active funds merely matched it before their extra costs, the 400,000 dollars would grow to about 1,548,000 dollars in an index fund and about 1,176,000 in the active funds, a difference of about 372,000 dollars. The active managers would have to add enough value to close that gap before the investor came out ahead. Put another way, the investor is paying roughly a quarter of her eventual wealth for the chance that her managers are among the minority who beat their benchmark by more than their costs over two decades. That price is worth paying only with strong evidence of skill, which leads to the question of how such evidence could be obtained.
How Long It Takes to Tell Skill From Luck
A manager's skill is measured by the information ratio: active return, the fund's return minus its benchmark's, divided by tracking error, the volatility of that difference (Grinold & Kahn, 2000). These funds have tracking error of about 4.5 percent a year. To break even after the 1.46-point hurdle, a manager needs an information ratio of about 0.32, that is, 1.46 divided by 4.5.
Statistical evidence of skill accumulates slowly. The t-statistic for a manager's record grows with the information ratio times the square root of the number of years. A manager with a true information ratio of 0.32 would need about 38 years for the record to reach a t-statistic of 2, the conventional threshold for confidence that the result is not luck. Ten years of a manager exactly at break-even would produce a t-statistic of only about 1.0, which is the kind of result chance produces regularly among many funds. Ten years of outperformance, however impressive it looks, says little on its own about whether it will continue. Carhart (1997) found little evidence that winning mutual funds keep winning once costs and common factors are accounted for.
A Style, Not Skill
The funds' strong decade against the broad index has a simpler explanation. Both funds lean heavily toward smaller companies with low prices relative to their book value, a small-value style. Fama and French (1993) showed that small-company and value stocks have historically earned returns different from the broad market, so a fund leaning toward them will beat a broad index in periods when those stocks do well, without any stock-picking skill. Compared with a small-value index matched to their actual style, the funds' ten-year advantage shrinks from about 1.8 points a year against the broad index to about 0.2 points, far below the 1.46-point hurdle. Most of the apparent edge was the style, which the investor could buy in an index fund for a fraction of the cost.
Recommendation
The investor should replace the two active funds with low-cost index funds. If she wants the small-value tilt the active funds gave her, she can buy it directly through a small-value index fund at a cost far below 0.80 percent. Because the funds are held in a taxable account, she should sell them gradually or in years when her income is lower, and harvest any losses, so that the tax cost of switching does not offset the savings. The review does not say active management can never succeed; it says these funds have not shown the skill needed to overcome a 1.46-point hurdle, and a decade of returns could not show it in any case. If she still prefers some active management, she could limit it to a small share of the account and choose funds with low costs and a clear, consistent process, judging them against a style-matched benchmark rather than the broad index.
References
Carhart, M. M. (1997). On persistence in mutual fund performance. Journal of Finance, 52(1), 57-82. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6261.1997.tb03808.x
Fama, E. F., & French, K. R. (1993). Common risk factors in the returns on stocks and bonds. Journal of Financial Economics, 33(1), 3-56. https://doi.org/10.1016/0304-405X(93)90023-5
Grinold, R. C., & Kahn, R. N. (2000). Active portfolio management: A quantitative approach for producing superior returns and controlling risk (2nd ed.). McGraw-Hill.
Sharpe, W. F. (1991). The arithmetic of active management. Financial Analysts Journal, 47(1), 7-9. https://doi.org/10.2469/faj.v47.n1.7
The FIN-451 Topic 3 assignment instructions
Topic 3 of FIN-451 asks students to evaluate active management for a specific investor. Students should build the full cost hurdle, including expense ratios, trading costs and tax drag in a taxable account, and convert it into dollars and over time. Strong work uses the information ratio to show what skill is required to break even, computes how many years of results would be needed to distinguish that skill from luck, and checks whether past outperformance reflects a style tilt by comparing the funds with a style-matched benchmark. Students should cite the arithmetic of active management and persistence research and recommend a course of action that accounts for taxes on switching.
How this FIN 451 Topic 3 example is built
The finished review builds the hurdle first. Against an index sleeve costing 0.04 percent, the active funds carry illustrative expense ratios averaging 0.80, trading costs from turnover near 0.25 and about 0.45 of added tax drag from distributed gains in a taxable account, so they must beat the index by 1.46 points a year just to tie. On 400,000 that is 5,840 a year. With tracking error of 4.5 percent, breaking even requires an information ratio of about 0.32. At that ratio, a record would need roughly 38 years to reach a t-statistic of 2, and ten years of a manager exactly at break-even would show about 1.0. The funds' strong decade against the broad index is then rechecked against a small-value benchmark matching their style, and most of the edge disappears.
FIN 451 Topic 3 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Faculty marking the review reward a complete hurdle and an honest test of evidence. An Excellent paper adds trading costs and tax drag to the expense ratio and shows the hurdle compounding over two decades. Credit goes to the information ratio needed to break even and the years required for statistical confidence. The rubric values rechecking the funds against a style-matched benchmark and citing the factor research that explains style returns. Strong papers cite persistence evidence accurately and avoid claiming active management never works. Top marks go to a recommendation that manages the tax cost of switching.
FIN 451 Topic 3 help before you submit
The largest deduction goes to reviews that compare the active funds' past returns with the index and stop, because a gross return comparison ignores every cost the investor would actually pay. Counting the expense ratio while leaving out trading and tax drag understates the hurdle by nearly half in a taxable account. Papers that call a ten-year record proof of skill have not asked how noisy excess returns are, and the arithmetic shows a decade barely separates a break-even manager from luck. Alpha measured against the broad index credits the managers with returns their style tilt delivered. Selection judged fund by fund, rather than by what it adds to the whole portfolio, overstates its weight beside allocation. A recommendation with no evaluation rule leaves the next underperforming year to be judged in the moment.
Get a FIN-451 Topic 3 example written to your instructions
Send the FIN-451 Topic 3 instructions and the rubric attached in your classroom, with the fund data or case your section assigns. We write a custom example to them, with every cost layer stacked into one hurdle, that hurdle expressed as an information ratio, style checked against a matching benchmark and the active sleeve sized, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More FIN 451 papers and BS in Finance and Economics samples
- FIN 451 Topic 1: Investment Policy Statement
- FIN 451 Topic 2: Mean-variance Allocation Memo
- FIN 451 Topic 4: Rebalancing Rule Cost Study
- FIN 451 Topic 5: Drawdown Response Dq Post
- FIN 451 Topic 6: Asset Location Tax Drag Analysis
- FIN 451 Topic 7: Risk-adjusted Attribution Report
- FIN 451 Topic 8: Portfolio Change Request Response
- FIN 450 Topic 3: Debt Capacity Analysis
- FIN 210 Topic 3: Debt Repayment Order Comparison
- FIN 440 Topic 3: Probate and Transfer Cost Comparison
- FIN 350 Topic 3: Annuity Problem Set
FIN 451 Topic 3 questions, answered
What is an information ratio?
Active return, the portfolio's return minus its benchmark's, divided by tracking error, the volatility of that difference. It measures how much excess return a manager delivers per unit of deviation from the benchmark. Because tracking error is often several points a year, even a sizable true edge produces a modest ratio, which is why short records say so little about whether a manager's excess return reflected skill.
Why would a style tilt look like skill?
Because a fund leaning toward smaller or cheaper companies will beat a broad index whenever those companies do well, whether or not its manager picks well among them. Factor research associated with Eugene Fama and Kenneth French showed how much of the return difference between portfolios such tilts explain. Measuring the fund against an index with the same tilt separates what the style delivered from what selection added.
Does the review say active funds are never worth owning?
No. It says what a particular set of illustrative funds would have to add, after their costs, to justify a place in one composite portfolio, and how hard that is to confirm. Real funds, costs and tax situations differ, and some investors hold active funds for reasons the review does not model. It is FIN-451 coursework, and nothing in it recommends or rejects any actual fund.
Where can I find a free FIN 451 Topic 3 sample paper?
The active fund review is shown in full: the question, the hurdle table, what it means, its cost over twenty years, how long skill takes to prove, the style explanation and the recommendation. If your case funds have other costs, send them and a free review can be prepared.
Why does a decade of outperformance prove little in FIN 451 Topic 3?
A manager at the break-even information ratio of about 0.32 would need roughly 38 years for a t-statistic of 2. Ten years at that level gives about 1.0, a result chance produces often among many funds.