FIN 451 Topic 4 rebalancing rule cost study example

Investments and Portfolio Management Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This FIN 451 Topic 4 sample paper follows a 1,000,000-dollar 60/40 portfolio through five illustrative years under three rebalancing rules. It forms part of GCU FIN 451, Investments and Portfolio Management, catalog code FIN-451, in the Grand Canyon University BS in Finance and Economics. Never rebalancing lets stocks reach about 67.3 percent before a 20 percent fall that costs about 155,900. Annual rebalancing loses about 132,800 with five trades and 202,700 of turnover; a 55 to 65 percent band loses about 133,500 with two trades and 167,300. Trading costs are trivial; taxable sales would realize about 7,700 of tax under the annual rule and 5,600 under the band.

CourseFIN 451 Investments and Portfolio Management
TopicTopic 4
Paper typeRebalancing study
LengthAbout 960 words, 4 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramBS in Finance and Economics
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for FIN 451 Topic 4

1

Never, Every Year or Only When It Drifts: A Five-Year Rebalancing Study of a 60/40 Portfolio and What Each Rule Costs in Turnover and Tax

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

FIN-451: Investments and Portfolio Management

Topic 4 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title names the three rules compared and the two costs that separate them. The portfolio and every return are illustrative; the sources are real.
2

Never, Every Year or Only When It Drifts: A Five-Year Rebalancing Study of a 60/40 Portfolio and What Each Rule Costs in Turnover and Tax

The Setup

A 1,000,000-dollar portfolio starts at a policy target of 60 percent stocks and 40 percent bonds. This study follows it through five illustrative years under three rules: never rebalancing, rebalancing to 60/40 at the end of every year, and rebalancing only when the stock weight drifts outside a band of 55 to 65 percent. Stocks return 22, 18, minus 20, 12 and 8 percent over the five years; bonds return 3, 2, 4, 3 and 3. The question is how each rule controls risk and what it costs.

Never Rebalancing

Left alone, the portfolio drifts toward stocks during the two strong early years. By the start of year three, just before the bad year, it holds about 67.3 percent stocks instead of 60. When stocks fall 20 percent that year, the portfolio loses about 155,900 dollars. The drift has quietly turned a 60/40 portfolio into a riskier one at exactly the wrong moment. The investor's policy said 60 percent, but the portfolio's actual risk was set by recent returns.

Rebalancing Every Year

The annual rule restores 60/40 at the end of each year. It sells stock after the first two strong years, buys stock after the fall, and sells again after the recovery years. The portfolio enters year three at 60 percent stocks and loses about 132,800 in the bad year, about 23,000 less than the drifting portfolio. The rule trades five times and moves about 202,700 dollars in total over the five years.

Rebalancing Only Outside a Band

Table 1

Three Rebalancing Rules Over Five Illustrative Years

RuleStock weight entering year 3Loss in year 3Trades in 5 yearsTurnover
Never rebalanceAbout 67.3%About $155,9000$0
Annual60.0%About $132,8005About $202,700
Band (55-65%)60.0%About $133,5002About $167,300

The band rule acts only when the stock weight leaves the 55 to 65 percent range. After year one, stocks are at about 64.0 percent, just inside the band, so nothing happens. After year two, at about 67.3 percent, the rule sells about 93,400 dollars of stock to return to 60 percent. After the fall, stocks are at about 53.6 percent, below the band, and the rule buys about 74,000 dollars of stock. The portfolio loses about 133,500 in the bad year, almost the same as the annual rule, with only two trades and about 167,300 dollars of turnover.

What this page is doingThe band rule matches the annual rule's protection in the bad year with fewer trades and less turnover.
3

What Each Rule Costs

Table 2

Trading and Tax Costs of the Two Rebalancing Rules, Illustrative

RuleStock soldEstimated tax if sold in taxable accountTrading cost at 0.10%
AnnualAbout $129,100About $7,700About $203
Band (55-65%)About $93,400About $5,600About $167

Trading costs are small for liquid index funds, and they are the cost most often overstated when investors argue against rebalancing. At an assumed 0.10 percent per trade, the annual rule costs about 203 dollars over five years and the band rule about 167; the difference is trivial.

Taxes are not trivial. If the stock sales happen in a taxable account, each sale realizes capital gains. Assuming that about 40 percent of each sale is gain, taxed at 15 percent, the annual rule's stock sales of about 129,100 dollars would realize about 7,700 dollars of tax over five years, while the band rule's single sale of about 93,400 would realize about 5,600. Each dollar of tax paid is a dollar no longer invested.

What this page is doingTaxes, not trading costs, are what separate the rules, which points to where rebalancing should happen.
4

What the Study Does Not Show

Five years with one sharp fall is a single illustrative path, chosen to show how drift and rebalancing interact. In a long period of steadily rising stock prices, never rebalancing would end with more money, because the portfolio would hold more of the asset that kept rising; the price of that outcome is a portfolio whose risk no longer matches the policy. Rebalancing is not designed to raise returns. Its purpose is to keep the risk the investor chose, and the study's bad year shows what happens when that risk quietly grows.

Where to Rebalance

The tax result points to a practical rule: rebalance inside tax-deferred accounts, such as IRAs and workplace plans, wherever possible, since sales there trigger no tax when they happen. If the household holds both stocks and bonds in its retirement accounts, it can move between them there and leave taxable holdings alone. New contributions and withdrawals can also be directed toward the underweight asset, rebalancing without any sale. Jaconetti et al. (2010), in Vanguard's research on rebalancing, conclude that the choice of rule matters less than having one, and that annual or semiannual monitoring with thresholds of about 5 percentage points is a reasonable balance between risk control and cost.

Conclusion

Rebalancing exists to keep the portfolio's risk where the policy put it. Brinson et al. (1986) showed that the policy mix explains most of a portfolio's behavior over time, which is why letting the mix drift undermines the policy itself. In this study, never rebalancing let the stock weight reach about 67 percent before a 20 percent fall and cost about 23,000 dollars more than either rebalancing rule in the bad year. The band rule controlled risk as well as the annual rule with less turnover and less tax. The recommendation is a 5-point band, checked at least annually, with trades made inside tax-deferred accounts first. Bodie et al. (2021) note that rebalancing also imposes a discipline of selling after gains and buying after losses, the opposite of what many investors do on instinct. A written rule makes that discipline easier to follow, because the trade is triggered by the band rather than by the investor's mood after a difficult year, and the decision is made once, in advance, rather than every time markets move.

References

Bodie, Z., Kane, A., & Marcus, A. J. (2021). Investments (12th ed.). McGraw Hill.

Brinson, G. P., Hood, L. R., & Beebower, G. L. (1986). Determinants of portfolio performance. Financial Analysts Journal, 42(4), 39-44. https://doi.org/10.2469/faj.v42.n4.39

Jaconetti, C. M., Kinniry, F. M., Jr., & Zilbering, Y. (2010). Best practices for portfolio rebalancing. Vanguard Research.

Reading the GCU FIN 451 Topic 4 instructions

In Topic 4, FIN-451 asks students to compare rebalancing rules on risk control and cost. Students should follow a portfolio through a sequence of returns under each rule, recording the stock weight before a bad year, the loss in that year, the number of trades and the turnover. Strong work separates trading costs from taxes, shows which matters more for a taxable investor, explains where rebalancing should happen to minimize tax, cites practical research on rebalancing thresholds and states the limits of a single illustrative path. The paper should end with a specific rule and a monitoring schedule.

Inside the FIN 451 Topic 4 example

The finished study follows 1,000,000 at 60 percent stocks through returns of 22, 18, minus 20, 12 and 8 percent on stocks and 3, 2, 4, 3 and 3 on bonds, every figure illustrative. Left alone, the portfolio reaches about 67.3 percent stocks just before the bad year and loses about 155,900 in it, against roughly 133,000 for either rebalanced version. The annual rule trades five times and moves about 202,700. The band rule trades twice, selling about 93,400 of stock after the second year and buying about 74,000 after the fall, for 167,300 of turnover. At an assumed 0.10 percent per trade the dollar cost is trivial either way. Tax is not: if stock sales happen in the taxable account, the annual rule realizes about 7,700 of tax and the band about 5,600.

FIN 451 Topic 4 rubric: what Excellent looks like

Graders award an Excellent study for tracing each rule through the same returns. The rubric rewards showing the drift to about 67 percent stocks before the bad year and the extra loss it caused. Credit goes to counting trades and turnover for each rule and showing that the band rule matched the annual rule's protection with less trading. Faculty look for taxes estimated under a stated gain assumption and the conclusion that rebalancing belongs inside tax-deferred accounts. Strong papers note that rebalancing controls risk rather than raising returns. Top marks go to a clear rule with thresholds and a review schedule.

Common FIN 451 Topic 4 mistakes, and how to avoid them

A rebalancing rule stated without a price is where most marks go, since a rule costed at zero will always look worth following. Papers that compare ending values alone, and crown whichever rule finished highest, mistake one path's luck for a property of the rule. Counting commissions and ignoring tax misses the cost that actually decides between rules in a taxable account. A study with no unrebalanced baseline cannot show what the rule was protecting against, which here is a portfolio drifting more than seven points toward stocks. Leaving the account location of trades unspecified hides the cheapest fix available. Treating a narrower band as automatically safer overlooks that a three-point band trades almost as often as the annual rule and brings the tax bill with it.

Get a FIN-451 Topic 4 example written to your instructions

Send the FIN-451 Topic 4 instructions and the rubric shared in your classroom, with the return path or portfolio your section assigns. We write a custom example to them, with each rule run over the same years, trades and turnover tabled, tax and trading costs estimated, account location considered and an unrebalanced baseline kept, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More FIN 451 papers and BS in Finance and Economics samples

FIN 451 Topic 4 questions, answered

Is a threshold rule always cheaper than a calendar rule?

Not always, but it usually trades less for the same control over drift, because it acts only when the weights have actually moved. On this example's path the five-point band traded twice in five years against five times for the annual rule. A band set too narrow loses that advantage, and on some return paths a calendar rule happens to trade at better moments, so the study reports its result as belonging to its path.

Why does rebalancing inside an IRA avoid tax?

Because sales inside a traditional or Roth IRA are not taxable events when they happen; tax on a traditional IRA arises only when money is withdrawn. A household holding both taxable and tax-deferred accounts can often restore its target mix by trading inside the deferred account alone. The study describes this at a general level and assumes its rates and gains for illustration only, since actual rules and rates change.

Should my portfolio follow the band rule in the study?

The study cannot say. Its portfolio, returns, trading cost and tax assumptions are constructed for a FIN-451 exercise, and the best rule for a real household depends on its accounts, tax position, contributions and the discipline to follow any rule at all. The example shows how the course wants rebalancing rules compared, and a licensed adviser should look at real accounts before any rule is adopted.

Where can I find a free FIN 451 Topic 4 sample paper?

The rebalancing study is printed here in full, covering the setup, never rebalancing, annual and band rules, the comparison table, trading and tax costs, what the study does not show, where to rebalance and the conclusion. Bring your own return path or rule for a free rerun.

Which rebalancing rule wins in FIN 451 Topic 4?

The 5-point band. It protected the portfolio in the bad year almost as well as annual rebalancing, about 133,500 lost against 132,800, with two trades instead of five and less taxable selling.