FIN 451 Topic 6 asset location tax drag analysis example

Investments and Portfolio Management Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This FIN 451 Topic 6 sample paper shows how placing assets in different accounts changes a composite household's taxes and its real allocation. It was completed for GCU FIN 451, Investments and Portfolio Management, catalog code FIN-451, in the Grand Canyon University BS in Finance and Economics. The couple has 500,000 dollars in a taxable account, 400,000 in a traditional IRA and 100,000 in a Roth IRA, with a 60/40 target. Held pro rata, the taxable account generates about 2,835 of tax a year; putting all bonds in the IRA cuts it to 1,125. Valuing the IRA after a 22 percent tax shows the located portfolio is about 66 percent stocks.

CourseFIN 451 Investments and Portfolio Management
TopicTopic 6
Paper typeAsset location analysis
LengthAbout 970 words, 4 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramBS in Finance and Economics
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for FIN 451 Topic 6

1

Same 60/40, Different Accounts: How Asset Location Cuts a Household's Annual Tax by 1,710 Dollars and Changes Its After-Tax Allocation

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

FIN-451: Investments and Portfolio Management

Topic 6 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the saving location produces and the less obvious effect it has on the real allocation. The household and every figure are an illustrative composite; the sources are real.
2

Same 60/40, Different Accounts: How Asset Location Cuts a Household's Annual Tax by 1,710 Dollars and Changes Its After-Tax Allocation

The Household

Ben and Alicia Moreno, a composite couple in their fifties, have 1,000,000 dollars invested across three accounts: 500,000 dollars in a taxable brokerage account, 400,000 in a traditional IRA and 100,000 in a Roth IRA. Their policy is 60 percent stocks and 40 percent bonds, which means 600,000 dollars in a broad stock index fund and 400,000 in a bond index fund. Asset allocation decides how much of each asset to hold; asset location decides which account holds it. The couple has always held the same 60/40 mix in each account, because it seemed simplest and kept every account balanced, but that habit has a tax cost they have never measured. This paper shows how location changes their taxes and why it also changes what their allocation really is. All figures are illustrative, and tax rules are described in general terms.

Tax on Each Asset in a Taxable Account

The two funds are taxed differently when held in a taxable account. The stock fund yields about 1.5 percent a year in qualified dividends, taxed at the couple's 15 percent rate. Most of its return comes as price growth, which is not taxed until the shares are sold. The bond fund yields about 4.5 percent a year in interest, taxed as ordinary income at the couple's 24 percent rate. Bonds therefore generate much more tax per dollar held each year. In the traditional IRA and the Roth IRA, neither fund's income is taxed as it is earned.

Pro Rata Versus Located

Table 1

Annual Tax Under Two Arrangements, Illustrative

ArrangementTaxable account holdsAnnual tax in taxable account
Pro rata (60/40 in each account)$300,000 stocks, $200,000 bondsAbout $2,835
Located (bonds in traditional IRA)$500,000 stocksAbout $1,125
Annual saving| About $1,710

If the couple held 60 percent stocks and 40 percent bonds in every account, the taxable account would hold 300,000 dollars of stocks and 200,000 of bonds. Each year it would generate 4,500 dollars of dividends, costing 675 dollars of tax, and 9,000 of interest, costing 2,160, a total of about 2,835 dollars.

If instead they placed all 400,000 dollars of bonds in the traditional IRA and held stocks in the taxable account and the Roth IRA, the taxable account would hold 500,000 of stocks and no bonds. It would generate 7,500 dollars of dividends, costing 1,125 dollars of tax a year. Location saves about 1,710 dollars a year before any growth, without changing the 60/40 mix in dollar terms.

What this page is doingMoving the high-yield, ordinary-income asset into the tax-deferred account produces the saving without changing the dollar mix.
3

Why Bonds Go in the Traditional IRA

The principle is to hold tax-inefficient assets, those producing income taxed at high ordinary rates each year, in tax-deferred accounts, and tax-efficient assets, such as broad stock index funds whose returns come mostly from unrealized growth taxed at lower rates, in taxable accounts. Dammon et al. (2004) found that under most conditions investors should hold taxable bonds in tax-deferred accounts and equities in taxable accounts, a result that follows from the different tax treatment of interest and equity returns. The Roth IRA, whose growth is never taxed if withdrawals qualify, is best used for the assets expected to grow most, here stocks. The rule has exceptions. When bond yields are very low, bonds produce little taxable income and the advantage of sheltering them shrinks. Actively managed stock funds that distribute large capital gains each year are tax-inefficient and may belong in the IRA themselves. And holding stocks in the taxable account preserves a benefit an IRA cannot offer: if shares are held until death, their basis is generally reset, so the unrealized gains may never be taxed.

The After-Tax Allocation

Table 2

Pre-Tax and After-Tax Allocation of the Located Portfolio, Illustrative

AccountHoldsPre-tax valueAfter-tax value
TaxableStocks$500,000$500,000
Roth IRAStocks$100,000$100,000
Traditional IRABonds$400,000About $312,000 (after 22% tax)
Total| $1,000,000About $912,000
Stock share| 60%About 66%

Location has a second effect that is easy to miss. A dollar in a traditional IRA is not worth a dollar to the household, because withdrawals will be taxed as ordinary income. If the couple expects to withdraw at an average tax rate of 22 percent, the 400,000-dollar IRA is worth about 312,000 dollars after tax. Reichenstein (2006) argues that asset allocation should be measured on this after-tax basis, since the government effectively owns part of every tax-deferred account.

Measured that way, the located portfolio is no longer 60/40. Its after-tax value is about 912,000 dollars: 500,000 of stocks in the taxable account, 100,000 of stocks in the Roth IRA and 312,000 of bonds in the traditional IRA after tax. Stocks make up about 600,000 of that, or about 66 percent. Placing all the bonds in the traditional IRA has quietly made the household's real allocation more aggressive than its policy.

What this page is doingValuing the traditional IRA after tax shows the located portfolio is about 66 percent stocks, not 60.
4

What the Couple Should Do

The couple should locate bonds in the traditional IRA to capture the 1,710 dollars of annual tax saving, which compounds over time. To keep their real allocation at their policy, they should set the target on an after-tax basis: holding about 539,000 dollars of stocks and 461,000 of bonds in pre-tax terms brings after-tax stocks back near 60 percent. Since the IRA holds only 400,000, the remaining 61,000 of bonds would sit in the taxable account, preferably in a tax-efficient form, giving up a small part of the location saving to keep the risk the couple chose. Bodie et al. (2021) note that tax management is one of the few sources of added return an investor controls with certainty. The arrangement should be reviewed when tax rates or account balances change significantly, and especially before the couple begins withdrawals, since the order in which they draw from taxable, traditional and Roth accounts will change both their tax bill and the location that makes sense from then on.

References

Bodie, Z., Kane, A., & Marcus, A. J. (2021). Investments (12th ed.). McGraw Hill.

Dammon, R. M., Spatt, C. S., & Zhang, H. H. (2004). Optimal asset location and allocation with taxable and tax-deferred investing. Journal of Finance, 59(3), 999-1037. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6261.2004.00655.x

Reichenstein, W. (2006). After-tax asset allocation. Financial Analysts Journal, 62(4), 14-19. https://doi.org/10.2469/faj.v62.n4.4183

Reading the GCU FIN 451 Topic 6 instructions

FIN-451 uses Topic 6 to distinguish asset location from asset allocation. Students should compute the annual tax each asset generates in a taxable account, compare a pro rata arrangement with one that places tax-inefficient assets in tax-deferred accounts, and state the saving. Strong work explains the principle with research, notes its exceptions, and then measures the allocation on an after-tax basis, since a traditional IRA is worth less than its balance. Students should show how location can change the real allocation, adjust the target to restore the intended risk, and describe tax rules generally rather than as fixed figures.

How the FIN-451 Topic 6 example is put together

The household holds 500,000 in a taxable account, 400,000 in a traditional IRA and 100,000 in a Roth IRA, with a 60/40 target, every figure illustrative. The stock fund yields 1.5 percent in qualified dividends taxed at 15 percent, and the bond fund 4.5 percent taxed as ordinary income at 24. Held pro rata, the taxable account generates about 2,835 of tax a year. Placing all 400,000 of bonds in the traditional IRA and stocks in the other two accounts cuts that to 1,125, a saving of 1,710 a year before growth. The analysis then values the IRA after the tax still owed on it: at an assumed 22 percent withdrawal rate it is worth about 312,000, so the located portfolio is closer to 66 percent stocks after tax.

Reading the FIN 451 Topic 6 rubric

Faculty reward location analysis that goes beyond the tax saving. An Excellent paper computes the annual tax on dividends and interest under both arrangements and shows the 1,710-dollar saving. Credit goes to explaining why bonds belong in the traditional IRA and stocks in the taxable and Roth accounts, with exceptions noted. The rubric values valuing the IRA after tax and showing the after-tax allocation drifting to about 66 percent stocks. Strong papers cite asset location research accurately. Top marks go to an adjusted target that restores the intended risk while keeping most of the tax saving.

Common FIN 451 Topic 6 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Analyses that report the tax saving and never ask what location did to risk lose the most, because a dollar in a traditional IRA is not a dollar the household owns outright. Placing bonds in the taxable account and stocks in the IRA, on the theory that growth should always be sheltered, reverses the drag arithmetic under the case's assumptions. Papers that quote current brackets or dividend rates as fixed date the work and ignore that the household's own rates will change. Treating the Roth and the traditional IRA as interchangeable misses the difference in what each owes at withdrawal. Location recommended without a rebalancing plan can force taxable sales of appreciated stock the first time weights drift. Tax savings projected over decades, with no word on assumptions, present a guess as a result.

Get a FIN-451 Topic 6 example written to your instructions

Send the FIN-451 Topic 6 instructions and the rubric listed in your classroom, with the household accounts your section provides. We write a custom example to them, with tax drag estimated by asset class, pro rata and located arrangements compared, the traditional IRA valued after its embedded tax and the effect on risk stated, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More FIN 451 papers and BS in Finance and Economics samples

FIN 451 Topic 6 questions, answered

What is asset location?

Deciding which accounts hold which assets, as distinct from asset allocation, which decides how much of each to hold. Because taxable, tax-deferred and tax-free accounts treat income differently, placing heavily taxed assets such as bond funds in deferred accounts can lower the household's yearly tax without changing its overall mix. The saving depends on tax rates, yields and the household's future withdrawal rate, all of which change.

Why does the IRA count for less after tax?

Because withdrawals from a traditional IRA are generally taxed as ordinary income, so part of its balance will go to tax eventually. Valuing it at the withdrawal rate the case assumes, 400,000 becomes about 312,000 of spendable money. Measured that way, the located portfolio holds more stock relative to bonds than its nominal balances suggest, which is why the analysis restates the allocation on an after-tax basis.

Should I move my own bonds into my IRA?

The analysis cannot answer that for a real household. Its balances, yields and tax rates were set for illustration, so that the drag and the risk shift would both be visible, and actual rules, brackets and account options change. Location decisions depend on current tax law, future withdrawal plans and state taxes. It is FIN-451 coursework describing tax effects at a general level; real accounts deserve a tax professional's review.

Where can I find a free FIN 451 Topic 6 sample paper?

The asset location analysis appears in full here: the household, the tax on each asset, pro rata versus located, why bonds go in the IRA, the after-tax allocation and what the couple should do. Households in other cases hold different accounts; list yours and the location test will be rerun free.

How much does location save in FIN 451 Topic 6?

About 1,710 dollars a year. Holding bonds in the traditional IRA and stocks in the taxable and Roth accounts cuts annual tax in the taxable account from about 2,835 to about 1,125 dollars.