| Course | FIN 451 Investments and Portfolio Management |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 7 |
| Paper type | Performance evaluation report |
| Length | About 970 words, 4 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Finance and Economics |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for FIN 451 Topic 7
A 0.10-Point Shortfall That Hides a Wider Gap: Attributing a Portfolio's Return and Measuring It Against Risk
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
FIN-451: Investments and Portfolio Management
Topic 7 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
A 0.10-Point Shortfall That Hides a Wider Gap: Attributing a Portfolio's Return and Measuring It Against Risk
The Portfolio and Its Benchmark
This report evaluates a balanced portfolio managed for a composite family foundation against its policy benchmark, 60 percent in a broad stock index and 40 percent in a broad bond index. Over the period, the manager held 65 percent equities and 35 percent bonds. The portfolio's equities returned 9.0 percent annualized against the stock index's 10.0, and its bonds returned 3.0 percent against the bond index's 2.5. All figures are illustrative.
The Raw Comparison
The portfolio earned 0.65 times 9.0 plus 0.35 times 3.0, or 6.90 percent. The benchmark earned 0.60 times 10.0 plus 0.40 times 2.5, or 7.00 percent. The shortfall is 0.10 percentage points, small enough that a trustee might dismiss it. The report breaks it into its sources and then adjusts it for risk.
Attribution
Table 1
Attribution of the 0.10-Point Shortfall, Illustrative (percentage points)
| Effect | Equities | Bonds | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Allocation | +0.500 | -0.125 | +0.375 |
| Selection | -0.600 | +0.200 | -0.400 |
| Interaction | -0.050 | -0.025 | -0.075 |
| Total difference | | | -0.100 |
Return attribution separates what the manager gained or lost by weighting asset classes differently from the benchmark, the allocation effect, from what was gained or lost by choosing different securities within each class, the selection effect, with an interaction term for the combination. The approach follows the framework Brinson et al. (1986) used to separate policy, timing and selection in pension plan returns.
The allocation effect is the difference in weights times the benchmark return of each class: 5 points extra in equities times 10.0 percent, plus 5 points less in bonds times 2.5 percent, a net of plus 0.375 points. The overweight in equities, which outperformed bonds, helped.
The selection effect is the benchmark weight times the difference in returns within each class: 0.60 times minus 1.0 for equities, or minus 0.60, plus 0.40 times plus 0.5 for bonds, or plus 0.20, a net of minus 0.40 points. The manager's stock picks lagged the index by a full point, which bond selection only partly offset.
The interaction effect is the difference in weights times the difference in returns: 0.05 times minus 1.0, plus minus 0.05 times plus 0.5, a net of minus 0.075 points. The manager overweighted the class where his selection was weakest.
Reading the Attribution
The attribution tells two different stories about the manager. The decision to hold more stocks than the benchmark paid off in this period, because stocks outperformed bonds by 7.5 points. That decision is a bet on the direction of markets, and in a period when stocks lagged bonds, the same overweight would have cost the portfolio. Whether it reflects skill or luck cannot be judged from one period. The selection result is more troubling, because it reflects the manager's core work, choosing stocks, and it lost a full point against the index in the asset class where the manager held the most money. A committee reviewing the manager should ask what produced the shortfall: a style tilt away from the index's largest companies, high turnover, or concentrated bets that did not work. Each has different implications for whether the result is likely to persist.
Adjusting for Risk
Table 2
Risk-Adjusted Performance, Illustrative
| Measure | Portfolio | Benchmark |
|---|---|---|
| Annualized return | 6.90% | 7.00% |
| Volatility | 11.0% | 10.0% |
| Beta | 1.08 | 1.00 |
| Sharpe ratio | About 0.35 | 0.40 |
| Treynor measure | About 3.61 | 4.00 |
| Jensen's alpha | About -0.42% | 0.00% |
The raw return ignores how much risk the manager took, and a manager who beats a benchmark only by taking more market risk has not shown any skill the foundation could not buy more cheaply through an index fund. The portfolio's volatility was 11.0 percent against the benchmark's 10.0, and its beta against the benchmark was 1.08. With a risk-free rate of 3.0 percent, three standard measures follow.
The Sharpe ratio, excess return divided by volatility (Sharpe, 1966), is 6.90 minus 3.0, divided by 11.0, about 0.35 for the portfolio, against 7.00 minus 3.0 divided by 10.0, or 0.40, for the benchmark. The Treynor measure, excess return divided by beta, is 3.90 divided by 1.08, about 3.61, against 4.00 for the benchmark, whose beta is 1 by definition. Jensen's alpha, the return above what the portfolio's beta would predict (Jensen, 1968), is 6.90 minus the sum of 3.0 and 1.08 times 4.00, or about minus 0.42 percent.
What the Measures Show Together
Every risk-adjusted measure shows the portfolio lagging by more than the raw numbers suggest. The manager took more risk than the benchmark, through the equity overweight, and earned slightly less. Jensen's alpha of about minus 0.42 percent means that, given its beta, the portfolio should have earned about 7.32 percent and earned 6.90. The allocation decision itself was sound in this period, adding about 0.375 points, but the extra risk it involved was not rewarded once poor stock selection is counted. The Sharpe ratio, which uses total volatility, is the most relevant measure if this portfolio is the foundation's entire investment program; the Treynor measure and alpha, which use beta, are more relevant if it is one part of a larger diversified portfolio.
Conclusion
The 0.10-point shortfall understates the manager's underperformance. Attribution shows a sound allocation tilt offset by weak equity selection, and risk adjustment shows a gap of about 0.42 points a year once the extra market risk is counted. The foundation's investment committee should discuss the equity selection process with the manager and consider whether the equity sleeve would be better served by an index fund, while keeping the manager's allocation decisions under review. One period of results is not conclusive; the committee should compare these measures over several periods before acting. A rolling three-year record of attribution and alpha, reported each year, would show whether weak equity selection is persistent or a single bad stretch, and would give the manager a fair chance to explain the process behind the numbers.
References
Brinson, G. P., Hood, L. R., & Beebower, G. L. (1986). Determinants of portfolio performance. Financial Analysts Journal, 42(4), 39-44. https://doi.org/10.2469/faj.v42.n4.39
Jensen, M. C. (1968). The performance of mutual funds in the period 1945-1964. Journal of Finance, 23(2), 389-416. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6261.1968.tb00815.x
Sharpe, W. F. (1966). Mutual fund performance. Journal of Business, 39(1, Part 2), 119-138. https://doi.org/10.1086/294846
Reading the GCU FIN 451 Topic 7 instructions
Topic 7 in FIN-451 asks students to evaluate a manager's performance. Students should compute the portfolio's and benchmark's returns, break the difference into allocation, selection and interaction effects that add up exactly, and then adjust for risk with the Sharpe ratio, the Treynor measure and Jensen's alpha. Strong work explains what each effect and measure means, notes when total volatility or beta is the more relevant risk, cites the original sources accurately and interprets the results for the client, including whether allocation decisions reflect skill or a market bet. The report should recommend questions or actions while noting that one period is not conclusive.
Inside the FIN 451 Topic 7 example
The finished report works from illustrative annualized figures. The portfolio held 65 percent equities and 35 percent bonds against a 60/40 benchmark; its equities returned 9.0 percent against the benchmark's 10.0, its bonds 3.0 against 2.5. The portfolio earned 6.90 percent, the benchmark 7.00. Attribution splits the 0.10 shortfall three ways: the equity overweight added 0.375 points, selection cost 0.40, with equities losing 0.60 and bonds recovering 0.20, and the interaction of the two cost 0.075. Risk comes next, with a 3.0 percent risk-free rate and volatility of 11.0 percent against 10.0. The portfolio's Sharpe ratio is about 0.35 against 0.40; its Treynor measure is about 3.61 against 4.00 at a beta of 1.08; and Jensen's alpha is about minus 0.42, a wider gap than the raw shortfall suggested.
Where the marks sit in the FIN 451 Topic 7 rubric
Graders award an Excellent report for attribution that reconciles and risk measures that are interpreted. The rubric rewards computing allocation, selection and interaction effects in a table that sums to the raw shortfall. Credit goes to the Sharpe ratio, Treynor measure and Jensen's alpha computed correctly with sources cited. Faculty look for the insight that the risk-adjusted gap is wider than the raw one, and for the right measure chosen for a whole portfolio versus a part of one. Strong papers question whether the allocation result was skill or a market bet. Top marks go to recommendations based on several periods.
FIN 451 Topic 7 help: mistakes that cost marks
Reports that give the portfolio's return beside the benchmark's and stop earn the least here, since a shortfall of a tenth of a point says nothing about which decision caused it. Attribution that mixes methods, measuring allocation against segment returns in one line and against the total benchmark in another, produces effects that do not add to the active return. Folding interaction into selection without saying so hides a real effect. Papers that praise the portfolio for nearly matching the benchmark miss that it took more risk to do so, which the risk-adjusted measures expose. Using Treynor for a portfolio that is the investor's entire wealth applies a measure built for a diversified component. Drawing firm conclusions about manager skill from one period claims more than the record can carry.
Get a FIN-451 Topic 7 example written to your instructions
Send the FIN-451 Topic 7 instructions and your classroom rubric, with the portfolio and benchmark data your section supplies. We write a custom example to them, with the active return split into allocation, selection and interaction effects that sum correctly, Sharpe, Treynor and alpha computed and explained, and conclusions sized to the record, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More FIN 451 papers and BS in Finance and Economics samples
- FIN 451 Topic 1: Investment Policy Statement
- FIN 451 Topic 2: Mean-variance Allocation Memo
- FIN 451 Topic 3: Net-of-cost Selection Review
- FIN 451 Topic 4: Rebalancing Rule Cost Study
- FIN 451 Topic 5: Drawdown Response Dq Post
- FIN 451 Topic 6: Asset Location Tax Drag Analysis
- FIN 451 Topic 8: Portfolio Change Request Response
- FIN 450 Topic 7: Standalone and Synergy Valuation
- FIN 210 Topic 7: Retirement Savings Projection
- FIN 440 Topic 7: Death Sequence Stress Test
- FIN 350 Topic 7: Project Criteria Comparison
FIN 451 Topic 7 questions, answered
What is the difference between allocation and selection effects?
The allocation effect measures what the portfolio gained or lost by weighting segments differently from the benchmark, judged by how those segments performed within the benchmark. The selection effect measures what it gained or lost by holding different securities inside each segment. An interaction term captures the two acting together. Reported separately, they show whether a shortfall came from the mix, the holdings or both.
When is Treynor more useful than Sharpe?
Treynor divides excess return by beta, the risk that remains in a diversified portfolio, so it suits a portfolio that is one piece of a larger diversified whole. Sharpe divides by total volatility, so it suits a portfolio representing the investor's entire holdings, where every kind of risk is borne. Jensen's alpha adds a third view: return above what beta alone would predict under the capital asset pricing model.
Can the report evaluate my own portfolio's performance?
Not directly. The weights, returns, risk-free rate and beta are illustrative, arranged so each effect and measure shows clearly and the arithmetic can be checked. Evaluating a real portfolio needs its actual holdings, a benchmark agreed in advance and a long enough record. The report demonstrates FIN-451 attribution work and offers no opinion on any real manager, fund or account.
Where can I find a free FIN 451 Topic 7 sample paper?
This page holds the complete performance report: the portfolio and benchmark, the raw comparison, the attribution table and its reading, the risk-adjusted measures, what they show together and the conclusion. Send the weights and returns from your case and a free report can be prepared.
Why is the gap wider after risk in FIN 451 Topic 7?
The manager took more market risk, a beta of 1.08 and volatility of 11 percent, but earned slightly less. Given its beta, the portfolio should have earned about 7.32 percent, so Jensen's alpha is about minus 0.42.