| Course | FIN 490 Financial Planning Capstone |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 5 |
| Paper type | Discussion post and reply |
| Length | About 460 words, 3 pages |
| Format | Discussion post, APA 7 citations |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Finance and Economics |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for FIN 490 Topic 5
Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post and Reply
The Recommendation They Will Not Follow Is the One That Asks for a Decision Every Day
Initial Post
My prediction: of the five recommendations in my composite couple's plan, the one they will not follow is the 450-dollar monthly cut to dining out and subscriptions.
The reason is how often each recommendation asks them to act. Raising the husband's 401(k) deferral to capture the full match is one form, signed once, after which it happens automatically every paycheck. Buying term life insurance is an application and a medical exam, then an automatic premium. Signing wills takes two meetings with an attorney. Opening a 529 account with an automatic monthly transfer is one afternoon. Each of these needs a single decision and then runs on its own.
The spending cut is different. It asks the couple to make a fresh decision every time they are tired on a Tuesday night and could order takeout, every time a streaming service they forgot about renews, and every weekend when friends suggest dinner out. Each choice is small, the reward is invisible and far away, and the cost of saying yes is immediate and pleasant. Recommendations that rely on repeated willpower tend to fail, while those that require one decision and then default to the right behavior tend to stick, which is why automatic enrollment raises participation so sharply (Madrian & Shea, 2001).
So I would redesign the recommendation rather than repeat it more forcefully. Instead of asking the couple to spend 450 dollars less each month, set up an automatic transfer of 150 dollars on payday into a separate savings account, so the money is gone before it can be spent. Then commit in advance that each future raise adds 100 dollars to the transfer until it reaches 450. That is the logic of Save More Tomorrow, the program Thaler and Benartzi (2004) designed, in which employees committed to raise their saving rate with future pay increases; participants' saving rates rose substantially over several raises, largely because the increases were automatic and timed so take-home pay never fell.
My question for the class: is it honest for a planner to design recommendations around a client's weaknesses, or does that treat clients as less capable than they are?
Reply to Owen
Owen, you argued that if the planner explains clearly why the 450 dollars matters, the couple will follow through. I agree that explanation helps, and the couple should understand what the money is for. But understanding is rarely the problem; most people already know they should spend less. The difficulty is acting on that knowledge thirty times a month. Would you be willing to pair the explanation with an automatic transfer, so the couple's good intentions do not have to win every evening?
References
Madrian, B. C., & Shea, D. F. (2001). The power of suggestion: Inertia in 401(k) participation and savings behavior. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 116(4), 1149-1187. https://doi.org/10.1162/003355301753265543
Thaler, R. H., & Benartzi, S. (2004). Save More Tomorrow: Using behavioral economics to increase employee saving. Journal of Political Economy, 112(S1), S164-S187. https://doi.org/10.1086/380085
The FIN-490 Topic 5 assignment instructions
The Topic 5 discussion question in FIN-490 asks why clients fail to follow financial advice and how planners can respond. Learners post first and respond to classmates afterward. Strong posts make a specific prediction, explain it by the kind of action each recommendation requires, and redesign the weak recommendation using a behavioral mechanism rather than repeating it more forcefully. Good posts draw accurately on the evidence about defaults and commitment devices and close with a question that raises an ethical or practical issue. Replies should respond to a classmate's argument and propose a way to combine it with the post's approach.
How the FIN-490 Topic 5 example is put together
Its prediction comes first: of five recommendations made to a composite couple, the one they will not follow is the 450 a month cut to dining and subscriptions. It explains the choice by how often each recommendation asks the couple to act. Raising a 401(k) deferral is one form signed once; a term policy is an application and a medical exam; wills are two meetings. The spending cut asks for a fresh decision every day, with no visible reward. The post then redesigns it. An automatic transfer of 150 a month on payday removes the money before it can be spent, and each future raise adds 100 until the full 450 is reached, the commitment device behind the Save More Tomorrow program Thaler and Benartzi designed. A reply answers a classmate who argued that clear explanation is enough.
FIN 490 Topic 5 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Instructors grading the post reward a prediction explained by mechanism. An Excellent post sorts recommendations by how often they require action and identifies the daily-decision spending cut as the likely failure. Credit goes to redesigning it as an automatic transfer with escalation tied to raises, citing Save More Tomorrow accurately. The rubric values evidence on inertia and defaults. Replies earn marks by granting a classmate's point about explanation and showing why it does not solve repeated decisions. A closing question about the ethics of designing around clients' habits, clear citations and a respectful tone complete the expectations.
FIN 490 Topic 5 help before you submit
Posts that name a recommendation without saying why it will fail earn the least, because the prompt asks for a prediction someone could test against the household. Choosing the most expensive recommendation rather than the most demanding behavior confuses cost with difficulty. Papers that treat noncompliance as the client's fault, rather than as something the plan can anticipate, miss the point of the question. Citing commitment research with invented participation rates or savings figures draws a sharp deduction in FIN 490 threads. A redesign that simply repeats the original cut more firmly changes nothing about the behavior involved. Replies that agree with a classmate's faith in explanation, without asking what the client must do every day afterward, leave the discussion where it began.
Get a FIN-490 Topic 5 example written to your instructions
Send the FIN-490 Topic 5 discussion question and your classroom rubric, with any assigned case or readings. We write a custom example to that prompt, with the likely unfollowed recommendation predicted and defended, the plan's recommendations ranked by the behavior they require, a redesign that fits the household and a reply to a classmate, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More FIN 490 papers and BS in Finance and Economics samples
- FIN 490 Topic 1: Planning Relationship Memo
- FIN 490 Topic 2: Household Discovery Profile
- FIN 490 Topic 3: Integrated Household Analysis
- FIN 490 Topic 4: Competing Goals Trade-off Analysis
- FIN 490 Topic 6: Multi-year Implementation Schedule
- FIN 490 Topic 7: Plan Consistency Review
- FIN 490 Topic 8: Household Plan Presentation
- FIN 210 Topic 5: Debt or Invest Dq Post
- FIN 451 Topic 5: Drawdown Response Dq Post
- FIN 350 Topic 5: Required Return Dq Post
- FIN 450 Topic 5: Corporate Cash Holdings Dq Post
FIN 490 Topic 5 questions, answered
What is Save More Tomorrow?
A program designed by Richard Thaler and Shlomo Benartzi in which employees commit in advance to raising their retirement saving rate when they receive future pay increases. Because the increase arrives with a raise, take-home pay does not fall, and because the commitment is made ahead of time, inertia works for the saver rather than against. The post borrows the design idea and does not cite results from it.
Why not simply recommend a smaller spending cut?
A smaller cut still asks for daily decisions, so it fails for the same reason, only less visibly. What changes the outcome is removing the decision: an automatic transfer on payday means the money is gone before spending choices are made. The post keeps the full 450 as the target and changes how it is reached rather than lowering the goal itself.
Can the post predict which advice my household will ignore?
No. The couple and their five recommendations are composites, and the post argues a general pattern for a FIN-490 discussion question. Which recommendation a real household will skip depends on its habits, values and circumstances, which only the household and its planner can judge. The post models the discussion reasoning the capstone rewards and offers no financial advice to any reader.
Where can I find a free FIN 490 Topic 5 sample paper?
The follow-through post and the reply to Owen are both on this page, with the prediction, the sorting of five recommendations, the redesign and the ethical question. If your prompt asks about a different client, describe it and a no-cost post with a peer response can be written.
How is the spending cut redesigned in FIN 490 Topic 5?
As an automatic transfer of 150 dollars on payday, rising by 100 with each raise until it reaches 450, so the money leaves before it can be spent and take-home pay never falls.